Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Dr. Peggy Drexler: The Breadwinner Complex: Are Women Apologizing For…
Guideposts : Meet The Canine Minister To A Man With Alzheimer's
The impossibility of finding a birthday gift

Our daily routine goes more or less like this: I pick Edan up from daycare, then we run around the park, go swimming, explore the Botanical Gardens, or whatever, and then I drop her off at her mom's office. Because Austin's roads get obnoxiously congested by 4pm every afternoon, and daycare, my house, and the office are all in different parts of the city, it's a real pain in the butt to go to the house between pick-up and drop-off.
So we're almost never at home.
Plus, I'm from Cleveland, where the weather is dreary, wet and cold for 8 months out of the year. Whenever the weather is halfway decent, you go outside -- no matter what -- or risk feeling guilty for "wasting" what could be the last sunny day the city will ever see. Now that I live in the sunniest place on the planet, it means I spend nearly every waking moment outdoors, just to ward off a resurgence of my weather-associated guilt from childhood.
Subsequently, Edan hardly spends any time in her room, and rarely gets to play with her toys. She has plenty -- stockpiled from Christmas, birthdays, and all the times my mom saw something that was too cute to pass up. (So many, in fact, I think they're breeding.) The toys are cool, and, because she gets to play with them so infrequently, Edan actually likes being couped-up inside, just because it means she can finally use all her stuff.
On a lazy Saturday -- instead of going to the zoo, or some family-friendly hippie music performance (of which, at least in Austin, there are plenty) -- she'd rather spend hours rummaging through her stuff, finding awesome distractions that'd she otherwise forgotten about.
And then her birthday comes around, and I feel compelled to add to the pile of brightly-colored plastic. However, because most of the time we spend together is either at a public place, in the car, or outside, I never know what to get her.
I'd love to hear your gift ideas. However, please keep in mind the following:
1. I'm not rich. This means no revolutionary, multi-media educational uber-fun devices that teach children to play Mozart concertos while learning to read (in English, French and Mandarin) and/or to recite the capitals of every nation on the planet.
2. I don't live in a mansion (see #1). So no toys that deserve their own mailing address, please. I was actually forced to donate a supremely awesome system of miniatures tents and tunnels to Edan's daycare, because they have a fenced-in backyard, storage, and an additional 1,000 sq feet.
3. It has to be really good. Mostly, because this is the first birthday Edan will remember, so -- essentially -- playtime is over, and it's time for my parenting "game face." Inevitably she will have to deal with disappointment throughout childhood, which is a normal and important part of growing up. However, I'd like for someone else to be the source of that disappointment as often as possible. I only see her part-time, so I feel this is a realistic expectation. Plus, there must be some benefit to being the non-custodial parent, and I'm hoping this is it.
But also, because this is the first year we're trying to do a birthday party with everyone. Everyone. Dad, mom, step-dad, step-mom, grandma, pops, aunts, uncles, cousins, friends, et al -- most of whom I haven't spoken with since Edan was 2 or 3 months-old (and at that time, we weren't exactly fond of each other).
Hence -- while I know it shouldn't matter -- I want the gifts from my girlfriend and I to at least compete with those brought by the other guests. Before you skip ahead to reprimand me in the comments, I'm well aware that this kind of thinking is immature, petty, and will only lead to frustration and disappointment. But if we could overlook that for just a second, I think we could come up with some really solid ideas.
Because, in all honesty, it's not because I have something to prove. I don't know most of these people, and -- chances are -- our paths won't cross again for at least another year. And, in spite of my insecurities, I know that Edan won't love me any less if other people buy her better presents. But once in awhile, I'm superficial, and I want to know that I guessed right, and found the thing she really wanted.











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 2)
6-05-2007 @ 1:02PM
Amy said...How about starting a savings account? Then, when other relatives are feeling spendy, they can deposit money for her future, when she will really appreciate it. But I can't get over the fact that you are having a birthday party with ALL the parents and relatives! Congratulations on that! That would be totally impossible in my family. You are setting a great example for your daughter.
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 1:06PM
kate said...Well, the advantage you have over those other people is that you know her better than they do, so you can get just the right thing without having to fork over a bunch of money. Here are some suggestions (although I don't know how old she is, I'm guessing 3?): her own backpack full of arts and crafts supplies (markers/crayons, coloring books, sticker/activivity books). This is something she'll love (as it has the "big kid" factor of being her own backpack) and can take anywhere (car, park etc.) Encourage her to draw things she sees. Also you could get the backpack and fill it with "nature" type stuff like inexpensive binoculars, a bug-catching kit (net, jar, magnifying glass) and some "field guides" aimed at kids for identifying birds, bugs, reptiles, etc. Then the two of you could spend your time in the park learning about that stuff together. In the end, THAT is what she'll remember, the quality time with you.
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 1:18PM
Liz said...Just go to Terra Toys on W. Anderson Lane. They have the coolest collection of toys for any budget. Good luck!
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 1:15PM
Jonathon said...the bug-catching kit is a genius idea. and i love terra toys -- have only been there a couple times, though. thanks for the reminder!
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 1:34PM
Ginny said...What about something personalized? They have those catalogs FULL of stuff you can get personalized like back packs, sleeping bags, etc etc. (Here's a link to Lillian Vernon) I know my 5 year old daughter LOOVES having stuff with her name on it.
http://www.lillianvernon.com/catalog/category.jsp?parentCatId=2&catId=12&simParentCatId=12&origin=head&PIPELINE_SESSION_ID=f...
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 2:26PM
~Monica said...DEFINITELY a backpack filled with treasures! Not only will she be as cool as Dora but it's something that will become her sidekick throughout childhood as the contents can always change. What a great memory for Daddy to create.
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 1:45PM
Gwen said...Have you thought of a bicycle or tricycle, with lovely streamers on the handlebars and a cool helmet? There are also some really cool scooters with three wheels for younger people. These can be put in the trunk and go where ever you do.
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 2:11PM
shannon said...Hmm, that's a toughie. Would she like a band in a box type thing? I like Sweet Juniper's list or the suggestion of Terra Toys.
http://www.sweet-juniper.com/2006/12/ddutchs-2006-holiday-shopping-guide-for.html
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 2:04PM
S. Kelly said...Have you thought about a puppy?
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 2:05PM
Jonathon said...i would be in big trouble if i bought her a puppy. mostly from my girlfriend, who's said "no" to that request on a number of occasions. ;)
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 3:02PM
phyl said...How about a cd player (simple "boom box" or a kid version) that she can have in her room? There are lots of great story cd's that my kids listen to before bed or during "quiet time" (ah, how I miss naptime for my 5 year old) and having a cd player of their own is "cool."
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 3:42PM
Kathy said...Get. A. Grip.
Seriously! Why do you have to talk about your constant need to compete with the mom/stepdad in EVERY SINGLE post? At first I thought it was kind of nice that you were addressing an issue that probably effects plenty of other people, but now it's just getting old. We get it...You don't think you're as good as them. I have no idea if you are as good as them or not, but I doubt they are constantly measuring themselves to you! Maybe you should actually figure out why you feel so inferior instead of making jokes about it.
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 3:46PM
Karen said...I'm with Poster 1...I could never invite my ex to my kids b-day parties! Even though we are friendly, I just wouldn't feel comfortable being around him for so long. You are very lucky!
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 6:51PM
Desiree said...If she has too many toys, rarely uses them and is sure to get more of the same from the rest of the family- dont cave in!!!
Give her something that is more meaningful than that. I would suggest a yearly membership to say a botanical garden or childrens museum...you can make it a special place for the two of you to go year round and these places could also be where you pack a picnic, bring one of her friends along from time to time. Something to discover together. She will certainly remember the time she spends with you there.
Just my two cents....from cleveland of course!
ps- yes i do belong to natural history museum and botanical gardens with my 2 yo son here in oh
Reply
6-05-2007 @ 9:06PM
Jill said...I was going to suggest a membership too. Pick somewhere you enjoy going to visit with her and make it your special outing place.
Magazine subscriptions go over well with my kids. They have their own "book" and something new in the mail each month.
Reply
6-06-2007 @ 12:09AM
rebecca Biernesser said...I like the bookbag filled with stuff...esp. since ya'll are out and on the go alot. I also liked the idea of personalizing the bag with her name on it. I also like the membership thing. YOu could actually combine the two ideas and get like a membership to a Zoo and fill the bookbag with items about animals and activites to do. Stuff like that.
It's creative and most relatives are going to resort to toys, clothes, or just money. It also shows you took the time to think about your child and what she likes to do. And regradless of what another posters said, you taking the time to do something creative earns BIG points :-)
Reply
6-06-2007 @ 11:01AM
Robyn said...How about a child's digital camera, so she can take her own pictures of all your adventures outside?
Reply
6-06-2007 @ 1:54PM
jen said...Does she have a library card yet? It meets the space and money criteria and will open up new worlds for her.
Reply
6-06-2007 @ 4:37PM
S. Kelly said...I have an idea! WHY NOT give her a lifetime supply of counseling sessions with the above poster, KATHY, who OBVIOUSLY has life all figured out and has NO PROBLEMS of her own.
IF ONLY we could ALL be so confident and sure of ourselves and PERFECT like Kathy!
Gee, I want to be Kathy when I grow up.
Jonathan, as the child of divorce -- and four parents to boot -- I find your HONESTY and HUMANITY refreshing.
Reply
6-06-2007 @ 3:39PM
Kathy said...Geez, S.Kelly...That's more than a bit snarky, isn't it?
At NO point in my comment did I even suggest that I think I'm perfect, or that I don't suffer from my own issues. In fact, I did say that at first I *also* enjoyed his perspective on the topic. I was only commenting on the fact that he makes a point to mention his extreme feelings of inadequacy in comparison to Eden's mom in pretty much EVERY article. When someone refers SO OFTEN to these kind of feelings in such an off handed, joking matter it just makes me wonder WHERE the feelings are coming from and if anythign can be done to address them. He admits himself that this need to compete isn't healthy, and I guess it's a little irritating for me to see someone admit that they have a problem that can have a real effect on their relationship with their kids, and not even try to do anything about it.
It is clear that he loves his child, any reader can see that...it just seems to me that there are some unresolved issues.
So, thanks, S. Kelly, for your intelligent and mature display of sarcastic wit, and while it may (or may not) have made Jonathan feel better, it certainly didn't sway my opinion that this fierce competition he feels with his daughter's main caregivers is nothing but detrimental.
Reply