Oh, how the mighty have fallen

As the Internet seethes with stories of Britney Spears losing her mind, losing control, and losing custody of her kids, it reminds me of a more personal parenting defeat I've suffered recently. 'Twas the final battle in a war waged over four long years -- began by my younger, more energetic, self-righteous self, who, much like the chart-topping, schoolgirl-outfit-wearing, virginity-declaring Spears of yore, was fond of making dubious yet plausible statements of personal infallibility. I was pure of heart. I was a rock. I was the center of the universe, 'round which the planets did spin.
It was this version of myself that knew, for a fact, that Disney, and their band of weak-minded, romance-hungry princess characters were, more or less, evil. I believed, in all seriousness, that by refusing to acknowledge the existence of these spineless saps, that I could somehow hold back the tidal wave of sexism in pop culture, and keep it from my daughter.
And let's be clear. I still hate that Cinderella (who's pretty, because she's good) just sits there and takes it from her nasty step-sisters (who are ugly, because they're bad), waiting around for magic to sweep her off her feet and into the arms of some hunky dude who will solve all her problems and make her life complete. Just shut up and look pretty and you'll win -- with a man! Hooray! No more problems!
But from the very beginning, the world has been chipping away at my defenses -- as if the desire to know these fictional, idyllically-figured airheads was transmitted to our children through their mothers' amniotic fluid. Edan was infatuated with Barbie before she'd ever seen that impossibly chesty hussy, and started calling herself Sleeping Beauty, Ariel and Cinderella almost compulsively around age two. So, through unflinching diligence, she eventually found the kinks in our armor, and saw Sleeping Beauty, then Cinderella, then Beauty and the Beast (and loved them all -- more than any other movie she'd seen up to that point).
So, when she scraped her knee on the playground last week, and we stopped in the drug store to pick up some Band-Aids, she was strong, and I was weak. She was bruised, and crabby, and just wanted her daddy to make her feel better, while I was tired, lost, and unable to defend my moral high ground in that moment of crisis. I pointed to bandages adorned with Poo Bear, Snoopy, Toy Story, Cars and Chicken Little -- to which she instantly whimpered "no." My daughter refused these lesser animated characters because she had already spotted the Disney Princess set, and I, in order to heal my aching child, sullenly purchased the packet, even though it cost nearly two dollars more than the plain kind (an inflation so egregious that I nearly pulled a Steve Martin ala Father of the Bride, ripping apart the package in the middle of the store, demanding that the confused teenage clerk tell me why I have to go broke making my daughter happy -- all the while complaining that those thieving bastards also insist on selling hot dogs in packages of six and buns in packages of eight). Oh, the humanity!
How did we get here, when only four years earlier, I was a passionate college student, fervently debating with Edan's mother about the virtues of raising a vegetarian baby and condemning the consumerist, sexist, classist, blah blah culture from which we should try and shield our child?
Because Edan's mother was, and is, along with her future husband, a little less off the rails than I am (or was). It's in their home that Edan sleeps most nights, it's where she has dinner, it's where she wakes up in the morning -- it's her home -- and it influences her life just as much as I do. And, while it's not like her mother and stepfather are buying those slutty Bratz dolls, they also don't run their house like the fascist anti-Barbie and/or Disney regime I probably would've attempted to construct if Edan only lived with me.
This is a good thing.
I've written before about how incredibly frustrating it can be to give up even partial control over how your child is raised. Even the smallest and most superficial decisions that you're not involved in only remind you of what you're missing. It's taken an enormous amount of effort not to pick fights over any number of day-to-day things that, when it's all said and done, probably don't make much difference to the person Edan is, and is becoming.
However, there's something to be said about tempering the fiery resolve of of a 21-year-old, before he inflicts his uncompromising world view on a baby -- only to breed neurosis as he compromises those beliefs, little by little while he gains a more nuanced perspective of the world.
Because hopefully, if we do our jobs right, Edan will be smarter than all of her parents -- able to see past whatever toy, movie or musician -- princesses or otherwise -- that's telling her who she's supposed to be.
Recent Posts
- G.I. Joe, My Little Pony Invading TV With New Children's Network (2/09/2010)
- Movies May Influence Children's Food Choices, Study Shows (2/09/2010)
- Report Cites 220 Cases of D.C. Teachers Abusing Students (2/09/2010)
- Chicago Candidate Drops Out of Race With Tearful Child On Display (2/09/2010)
- Juicy, But Not Juice (2/09/2010)






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Amanda 10-02-2007 @ 11:15AM
wow! you are a bit off the rails today :)
calm down, take a deep breath and just relax. she's going to be a great kid and no matter how much she watches cinderella or beauty and the beast she will not grow up thinking she has to sit on her bohunkus waiting for a man to come sweep her off her feet. ITS JUST A MOVIE and I'll even dare say that, the civil relationship you share with her mother and stepfather are going to be FAR more of an influence on her than any movie or doll, or doll covered bandaid.
relax :)
Reply
mckenna 10-02-2007 @ 11:20AM
I think if the princesses bother you, you're making the right decision not to fight it so hard. Kids always want what they are denied.
If it makes you feel any better, I went through a stage where I loved Barbie and the Disney princesses. My mother simultaneously taught me what fiction was and not to wait around for Prince Charming to sweep me off my feet, as that was "make believe." I became a feminist as a pre-teen, before I really knew what that was (I grew up in MT), and graduated from a top tier law school and am now a practicing attorney. Don't discount the power of your message. Embrace it as an opportunity to discuss. Compare the personalities of the wimpy princesses with the strong successful female images that are out there, and she'll eventually choose your message over the mass media. You're her Daddy, after all.
BTW, (and I know this isn't true for all girls, but...) what intrigued me in all those stories was the magic. I thought it would be great to have such control over the world that I could make anything happen with a flick of my wrist. As I grew up, my focus changed to how I could make an impact via reality. So there are positive twists that can be found in those stories.
Reply
Alice 10-02-2007 @ 12:05PM
It seems to me that at least Belle & Mulan aren't exactly sit-on-their-ass wait-for-a-man-to-do-it slouches.
Reply
Joy 10-02-2007 @ 12:29PM
Do you mean that after all my waiting around, prince charming isn't going to come up my driveway riding a white horse ready to sweep me off my feet?????
Reply
dizietsma 10-02-2007 @ 12:45PM
As a fellow despiser of Disney Princess tat, I have decided to follow a different tack. I will not become the weird parent who refuses to get the tacky crap, but I will give my daughter even better Princesses and stories than pansy-ass Disney could ever dream up.
Like these, for example-
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Tatterhood-Other-Tales-Johnston-Phelps/dp/0912670509/ref=sr_1_1/203-5014286-0243115?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1191343172&sr=8-1
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Paperbag-Princess-Story-Corner/dp/0439010179/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/203-5014286-0243115?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1191343208&sr=8-1
Reply
Jonathon Morgan 10-02-2007 @ 12:47PM
Amanada: you're totally right. I've chilled out on a lot of that stuff since Edan was born.
mckenna: I think it's more about the magic for Edan, too, as she's really not old enough to even care about the boy characters unless they're funny.
Reply
Jonathon Morgan 10-02-2007 @ 12:48PM
Alice, totally true. I hadn't seen Beauty and the Beast in years until recently, and she was definitely better than most.
Reply
Eva 10-02-2007 @ 1:07PM
Awesome post. I try to keep that stuff (and TV in general) away from my kid, but it seeps in. I am trying to chill out about it.
Reply
Julie 10-02-2007 @ 2:10PM
I am also anti-Disney, especially that princess crap, and will try to fight them off as long as possible. I'm perfectly fine with dolls, and actually Barbie doesn't even bother me that much, but that the Disney Princess Mafia is out of control. Viva la revolucion!
Reply
LS 10-02-2007 @ 3:19PM
Apologies if this ends up being a double-post...
Why not go even more with the flow? Watch Cinderella with her, and point out the OTHER side of Cinderella's character - that in the face of adversity, she handled herself with grace. Just because a woman doesn't stand up and thrust a sword in the face of her adversary doesn't mean she's a wimp. Consider: By being nice to those lesser than her (the mice, birds, etc), she had allies during her distress. By trusting her friends, she escaped the tower. By being herself (regardless of how she dressed) - graceful and kind - she is the one who got the guy. Yeah, the generalization of the stories are, "be weak and the guy will save you", but sitting back, I see women who made the best of their less-than-perfect circumstances, learned to be strong, and ended up ok. And isn't that what we want to teach all of our kids?
Reply
Irit H 10-04-2007 @ 3:21PM
Just find her something more interesting than this Disney shit. Also, get her REGULAR Band-Aids.
Reply
GirlsGoneChild 10-03-2007 @ 3:24AM
Loved this post. Feel like singing, "Amen, brother man."
Reply