Students suspended for anti-drunk-driving shirts

I agree it was inappropriate because, unless the drinking age there is unusually low, it's illegal for high school seniors to have .08 or .0anything (unless they are with their parents). By saying this logo is a positive message to teens, you are saying teen drinking is OK, which is contradictory to the law. If that is OK, why not also allow shirts that say "drink Miller beer"? Just adding "oh, but not to many cans" doesn't negate the message.

I'm sure there are other messages that the teens could have chosen that don't indicate that illegal drinking in moderation is OK.

If teens continue to raise a big stink over every banned t-shirt, the schools will simply ban all t-shirts and all logos. Some restraint would be advisable on the students' part, in my opinion.

Reply

the drinking age varys from state to state and some of them it is as low as 16 years of age. So I dont see anything wrong with the shirt if that is one of the places where the legal age is young. Any shirt that says drinking and driving is bad should be praised. I believe there should be no bars alloud to be open because you obviously drink and drive everytime you step out of the bar. Yea the shirt can be read as differnt things but what it means to you might not be what it really means. This is something that they should be encouraging their students to participate in stuff like this at a young age to get the message acrossed. If you find the shirt offensive then you must not of lost a loved one to a drunk driver. It is ignorant to say they did something wrong when they were doing something for the good of their friends dieing. maybe more people do need to see it. My cousin who was only 28 was killed almost 2 years ago by a drunk driver at 5:45 in the morning. She was on her way to the hospital she worked at to get a pregnancy test done to confirm what she already knew that she was pregnant. This was no ordinary pregnacy either. She had suffered from endomitriosis her whole life and was told she would never be able to get pregnant. She had to get a life saving operation when a large tumor ruptured in her overie and the specialist did such a great job she was given the go ahead that she possibly could get pregnant now. A child is all she ever wanted. Since we were little she knew she wanted kids. We were only 8 months apart and pretty much lived beside each other and were like sisters our whole life. You couldnt get any closer than we were. Any ways the point is on her way to the hospital 5:45 AM she was hit and forced into oncoming traffic lane by this woman and an innocent lady on her way to work hit and killed my cousin. The lady was 3X over the limit! My cousin was dead, her baby was dead and an innocent woman has to now live with this for the rest of her life. all because this woman was drinking and driving. Going to the cemetary at 5:45 in the morn and drunk off her ass. I lost someone and so did those kids and if that is how they want to show respect and try to keep it from happening again then good for them. That school should be ashamed of themselves. I have a shirt that has my cousins picture on it and under it it says Killed by a drunk driver. That is why they make billboards with the same thing on it so people can see it. everybody reads shirts. I just hope these kids dont give up and continue the fight against drinking and driving. They are worried about saving lives when the school is worried about fashion.

Reply

Roger, the decision whether to allow a shirt promoting illegal activity should not turn on whether or not some percentage of the kids are going to break the law anyway.

I like the idea of the T-shirt mentioned by Michele W - e.g., Killed by Drunk Driving. This in no way implies that it's OK for high school seniors to drink any amount; yet it gets the point across about the consequences of irresponsible drinking and driving. I am sure kids could come up with hundreds of equally acceptable logos.

Furthermore, I'm sure that if the school endorsed the shirts, there would be a lot of parents up in arms about their kids getting the message at school that underage drinking is fine as long as they limit the number of drinks.

Finally, how many high school kids are both (a) irresponsible enough to illegally drink and (b) responsibile enough to know which drink will put them over .08? Is this message really likely to save any lives? I think not.

I am inclined to believe that the kids involved had good intentions. However, once it was brought to their attention that their shirt was not acceptable to the school administration, they should have complied with the rules. I have no sympathy regarding their punishment, and I am rather tired of hearing about these constant fights between unruly children and their frustrated educators.

Reply