Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Dr. Peggy Drexler: The Breadwinner Complex: Are Women Apologizing For…
Guideposts : Meet The Canine Minister To A Man With Alzheimer's
Do child rapists deserve the death penalty?
In 2003, a Louisiana jury found Patrick Kennedy guilty of raping his 8-year-old stepdaughter and sentenced him to death. The law states in Louisiana that aggravated rape of a child younger than 12 is punishable by "death or life imprisonment ... without parole." It is one of five states that allows juries to sentence convicted rapists to death. In May, 2007, the Louisiana Supreme Court upheld this sentence.
Patrick Kennedy is appealing this sentence because his attorneys claim that the Louisiana law conflicts with a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that "a sentence of death is grossly disproportionate and excessive punishment for the crime of rape."
Kennedy's claim is that he is the only person on death row in Louisiana for rape. However, Kennedy did not rape an adult, he raped an 8-year-old child. In fact, Dr. Scott Benton of Children's Hospital testified during the trial that the child's injuries from the rape were the worst he had ever seen in a sexual assault of a child. Kennedy also refused to plead guilty to a lesser charge, which would have reduced his sentence and removed the death penalty possibility from his sentence.
Kennedy's petition will be considered on January 4 by the Supreme Court Justices in a private conference.
Do you think Kennedy's conviction should be overturned as cruel and unusual? Do child rapists deserve the death penalty?
Patrick Kennedy is appealing this sentence because his attorneys claim that the Louisiana law conflicts with a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that "a sentence of death is grossly disproportionate and excessive punishment for the crime of rape."
Kennedy's claim is that he is the only person on death row in Louisiana for rape. However, Kennedy did not rape an adult, he raped an 8-year-old child. In fact, Dr. Scott Benton of Children's Hospital testified during the trial that the child's injuries from the rape were the worst he had ever seen in a sexual assault of a child. Kennedy also refused to plead guilty to a lesser charge, which would have reduced his sentence and removed the death penalty possibility from his sentence.
Kennedy's petition will be considered on January 4 by the Supreme Court Justices in a private conference.
Do you think Kennedy's conviction should be overturned as cruel and unusual? Do child rapists deserve the death penalty?











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 2)
1-24-2008 @ 2:23PM
Kira said...When I learned my best friend was raped twice by two separate Child Rapists I couldn't help but cry. I think that through out the USA that all Child Rapists should recieve the death penalty and should actually be executed instead of just sitting around on death row. But because we are a more civilized country I have a better idea. All Child Rapists who have raped a child under the age of 14 should be executed and a $10,000 fine should be given to the family of the victim. All Child Rapists that have raped a child under the age of 18 should be imprisoned for more then 60 years and should give $10,000 to the family of the victim, if the Child Rapists does not have $10,000 then his/her property should be sold and the money given to the family of the victim or his property should be given to the family of the victim. Also a Child Rapist should recieve no contact from the outside world and should be isolated as much as possible. Thats what should happen to Child Rapists who rape or molest our children, this is what we SHOULD do. We can not allow these people to walk our streets any more and we should NEVER let them hurt our little girls or young boys. And for the Supreme Court to tell us that their deaths is cruel, tell that to the children who didn't know what was happening to them. I want them look into that little girl's eyes, who begged for some one to save her, and tell her just because she was raped in a cruel and unusual fashion it doesn't give her the chance to receive justice.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 9:39AM
Emily said...Of course they deserve the death penalty. There is no defense for raping a child. There can be defenses for committing murder (self-defense, defense of another), but not raping a child.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 9:41AM
kris said...This is a really simple answer for me-Yes. But if I had my way, I would inflict a more cruel punishment and let the general population torture him. I hope its slow and painful.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 10:06AM
Monica said...I'm not a big believer in the death penalty, but in this case I would support it 100%.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 10:38AM
Ethel said...I have heard of men raping toddlers and killing them. And I have to say that man is beyond redemption. But for me to support the death penalty for raping an 8 year old means I'd support the death of the fellow who attempted rape on me when I was 6 years old. Its not that he was 15 at the time, its that I can't accept that would be an appropriate reaction to what happened to me.
I do however think we need a better solution to letting pedophiles back into the population after they serve their time, because there is no fixing a pedophile - they're broken and will forever be broken. Death for rape of a child is too much, but there sure as heck should never come back to society.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 10:39AM
sandy said...yes, he deserves the death penalty, that is much less cruel than what he did to the child I personally think they should shove an axe handle up his rear end right before they execute him
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 10:41AM
Dorisanne Cardwell said...They should death penelty!! I also believe a child molester should get life or the death penelty. The damage they do to a child is FOREVER! I know this for a fact.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 10:48AM
lisa said...yes they should execute him...there is no excuse for what he did...period...and if it were me i would want to castrate him while fully awake before killing him....or as a previous post said an axe handle would work too..the way they are gonna execute him is far more humane than the rape of an 8 year old child....but try telling that to the aclu and other liberals out there who are trying to do away with the death penalty...i wonder what they would say if it was their daughter or son?
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 10:49AM
Amy said...I don't think anyone should get the death penalty for anything. Talk about getting the easy way out. Far better, in my opinion, for him to live to be 100 in solitary confinement, so that he has plenty of time to live with what he did. Let him out for 10 minutes a day to see the sun, just so he doesn't forget what he's missing.
On the other hand, if our culture is going to insist on continuing to use the death penalty, I can't imagine anyone more deserving than a man who would rape a child.
Amy @ http://prettybabies.blogspot.com
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 11:20AM
Lil said...Our tax dollars support all these people in our prison systems. To me I'd rather see my money spent somewhere other than on a child molester in solitary confinement until he dies. Please!!! YOU should consider paying for his financial needs while in confinement. I support the death penalty 100%. This child may never have the joy of bringing her own children into the world nor can she really trust another adult. Wow, what a way to growup. What if this were your daughter or niece, would you still feel the same?
1-02-2008 @ 11:48AM
renee said...I'm going to agree with Kris and Sandy. My husband works at a maximum security prison and there are quite a few child molesters there. They are all in segregation for fear of what the other inmates will do to them. I say let them out in general population and let them see what it feels like to be molested. The death penalty is the easy way out. Let them suffer the way the child(ren) the molested will suffer for the rest of their lives!
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 12:15PM
Michael said...The death penalty is pretty harsh, but I'd have to say that there is no greater crime then those against a child, so in that respect I am fully support this idea.
We have a case in my town (Las Vegas) of a guy that raped a 2 year old girl (yes, a 2 year old), and a 6 year old. Apparently videotaped taped it too. Police have the tape, DNA, and other evidence...but the guy is fighting it. This is a case I WISH they had this option in Nevada. As someone said above, he is clearly "broken". Someone that could do that to child and videotape it (what?? and show it to friends??) just needs to be taken out...there's just no fix for that.
http://www.lasvegasnow.com/Global/story.asp?s=7486052
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 12:42PM
ame s said...Absolutely exterminate this vermin. If it were one of my daughters, I couldn't stand knowing the demon was still alive and breathing, even in prison.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 12:48PM
Julia said...Yes, he (and all child rapists) should be put to death. I think all rapists should, but especially ones who rape children.
As for liberals wanting to abolish the death penalty, not this one. I am liberal in all areas, except crime. I believe in the death penalty and I think we are not hard enough on criminals.
As for putting the child molesters and rapists with the general prison population, yes to that as well. Why should they be able to be protected when the children they raped were not.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 12:34PM
courtney said...Yes, I would hate the idea there is a possibility he could ever get out. Crimes against children are a whole different story and deserve different punishments.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 12:39PM
Caelligh said...I think of the priorities of our prisons as two things: rehabilitating criminals or, failing that, protecting the rest of us from them. Assuming the evidence was conclusive in this case, this person should probably not have any possibility of parole. And regardless of the cost to the taxpayer, it would be lawlessness to mix him in with general prison population if that means putting his life in danger.
The purpose of our justice system should not be to kill or, as some of you vigilantes sound eager to do, torture people.
Reply
1-05-2008 @ 3:51PM
lisa said...ummmm.yeppers....i was molested as a child not raped but molested and my daughter was molested at the age of 3....hang em high sister.... i dont want to pay for those losers to get fat and happy on my money...and that is exactly what they do....they cant be rehabilitated and i should not have to live in fear that they will do it again in case our liberal justice systems decides to let them out....when your child is molested i think you will say yep..lets kill him...he isnt gonna get better and he will always be a threat and a cancer on society so lose the liberal mush that is your thinking and realize that the reason this is running rampant are that they arent being punished...they arent afraid of the law....if people were executed for their crimes i.e. murder or rape of children i guarantee you it would be a deterrent...after all you didnt see this stuff 50 years ago....so until it happens to you or your precious child keep it to yourself....walk a mile in someones shoes before you say asinine remarks
1-09-2008 @ 10:58PM
naimodo said...you're an idiot. when the death penalty was removed decades ago, crime hit an all time high. People in our society need to be scared that their actions could get them killed.
1-02-2008 @ 12:48PM
Jennifer said...I'm kind of of the 'eye for an eye' belief. I think the crime and punishment should be similar. I do believe that the death penalty gives them too easy an out.
Yes, leaving them in prison is burdensome on taxpayers...although it does also supply jobs for many who work in prisons...so that's could be argued either way.
I WAS raped as a child and molested for years. Honestly, I think that perps should be tortured emotionally and physically for years as well. Don't give them the easy way out.
Reply
1-02-2008 @ 12:57PM
Joy said...I think he should be put to death.
Reply