PD*Poll: Students vote autistic 5-year-old out of class
Categories: Kids 5-7, In The News, Education, Special Needs
It sounds like somebody has been watching too many reality shows. Namely, Wendy Portillo, a teacher at Morningside Elementary in Port St. Lucie, Florida. She turned her kindergarten classroom into a cruel version of Survivor by allowing her students to vote a fellow student out of the class.The banished child is 5-year-old Alex Barton, who is in the process of being diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome, a high-functioning type of autism. Not uncommon to his condition, Alex has had some behavioral issues and as a result, spends a lot of time in the principal's office.
After returning to Ms. Portillo's classroom after a recent visit with the principal, his teacher decided to punish him with humiliation. She had Alex stand at the front of the class while his fellow students listed off what they didn't like about him. After informing him that they found him "disgusting" and "annoying", the class was instructed to vote on whether or not Alex should be allowed to stay in the class. By a 14 to 2 margin, they voted him out.
Alex hasn't been back to school since then, but his mother, Melissa Barton, says he is still reliving the incident. The night after it happened, she says she overheard him saying "I'm not special" over and over.
Incredibly, an investigation by the state attorney's office concluded that Alex's treatment did not meet the criteria for emotional child abuse and no charges have been filed. I don't know what the criteria for emotional abuse is, but if this doesn't meet it, what does? My heart breaks for all the children involved in this incident.
Recent Posts
- Report Cites 220 Cases of D.C. Teachers Abusing Students (2/09/2010)
- Chicago Candidate Drops Out of Race With Tearful Child On Display (2/09/2010)
- Juicy, But Not Juice (2/09/2010)
- Carrie Underwood Worms Her Way Onto 'Sesame Street' (2/09/2010)
- Heart-Shaped Valentine's Day Crafts (2/09/2010)






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 72)
sarah gilbert 5-27-2008 @ 5:10PM
Umm, can I start throwing things now? this is beyond disgusting. I ache for Melissa.
Reply
the goddess anna 5-27-2008 @ 7:39PM
Wow, we haven't seen you around here in a very long time! I miss your posts from way back when.
romy 5-29-2008 @ 7:00AM
My child has Aspergers and behavior is rarely an issue when they are in the proper educational program, with teachers and staff who know how to deal with it. Clearly this child wasn't and that teacher should be fired.
Michelle 5-29-2008 @ 11:09PM
With the growing cases of various degrees of autisium in our society today, I have to wonder where or even IF this so called teacher has gotten educated in child developement. Ms Wendy totally needs a refresher course. I find this disturbing for many reasons.
Pat 5-29-2008 @ 8:09AM
We too have an Asperger's child. People are ALWAYS cruel to her - in church, school, neighbors. She has some ticks (nervous habits) and anxiety but otherwise does well. The few "abnormal" things she may do are enough to set other kids on her like wolves. Our society stinks.
quantmdi2 5-29-2008 @ 8:27AM
Abuse? Of course, and specifically it's called BULLYING! Most schools of any merit have in place a policy to deal with bullying issues. I wonder if any of them address bullying by a TEACHER! Pull her license....
rmwtaw30 5-29-2008 @ 8:39AM
Ditto
Parents with special children of a handicap nature have a rough time as it is they don't need idiots like that teacher adding to the distress.
Theresa Ashline 5-29-2008 @ 8:50AM
This teacher needs to go. As an educator and an aunt to an autistic boy I am completely disgusted. Children should not be subjected to humiliation regardless. What is it with Florida???????Teachers get fired for practicing witchcraft when actually trying to stimulate the students minds in a science room. Teachers sleeping with students. And now teachers allowing cruelty into the classroom and acting as ringleaders in a disgusting display of bullying.
Yevette 5-30-2008 @ 8:50AM
Do they not know that Einstein had Asperger's Syndrome?
If Florida doesn't consider what happened to this child as abuse, Florida's lawmakers need more education!
whatagurlneeds 5-29-2008 @ 9:19AM
This makes me sick to my stomach. Absolutley disgusting that this grown woman would teach a class of children to single someone out and savagely demean him. Autistic or not this is reprehensible. I hope this teacher loses her teaching license and comes into a solid beating someday over this. She deserves much worse.
chars 5-29-2008 @ 9:20AM
This is just a reply-
So where is Wendy's picture? I think she deserves some exposure for her teaching method.
melissa 6-02-2008 @ 10:38AM
To the Barton family. You can tell Alex that I think he is special. That he is a very handsome young man. For the teacher in the other hand she shouldn't have a job. This is horrific and she should not be teaching.
nicole 5-29-2008 @ 10:36AM
what the teacher did was wrong , however , there were obviously problems with the child and he should not have been in a class with regular children , he should be in a special ed class wth other children that can not behave normally, why should she get fired, are there any other complaints? People make mistakes , even teachers, letting the other children in the class tell this problem child what they don't like about his behavior is not wrong , just the way she went about it . Children have feelings and need to know how to express them and stick up for themselves. I think the boy should be in trouble , he has probobly been abusing his other classmates and teachers for years
Kimberly 5-29-2008 @ 9:43AM
I am completely appalled. In no circumstance is it ever acceptable for a teacher to do this to a child, especially a 5 year old!
Beth Gallagher 5-29-2008 @ 10:10AM
oh my god!!! This is repulsive. This has nothing to do with disability. These children are 5 years old...what in the world is the teachers point. 'hey kids, let's band together and learn a lesson about hate'. She absolutely needs to go. Whether he has Asberger's or not is irrelevant to a degree. She is a teacher and her job is to find the gifts within each child and nurture those, not tear kids down and make them feel worthless. The other kids learned a great deal about control and power. Hope she is happy.
Suzanna 5-29-2008 @ 10:48AM
Mrs. Marcia Cully- Principal cullym@stlucie.k12.fl.us
Mrs. Patricia Gascoigne - Assistant Principal
gasgoignep@stlucie.k12.fl.us
http://www.stlucie.k12.fl.us/mse/staff/administration.html
Write to these people and express your horror at the school allowing this to happen to an innocent child.
Nicole 6-01-2008 @ 10:30PM
Hello,
I am the mother of a 4 year old Autistic boy that knows his colors, matches objects, can sign his needs, assit with putting on his clothes and etc... why can he do all of these things when many people said he would not is because he has parents that support and love him and a school environment that is specialized to his condition.
This school system in this story should not only be reprimanded by the Federal Government under the ADA statue and for violations of this childs civil rights as he is not an animal. Moreover,, if I were one of the other parents in this horrible teachers class room what would I think was being done to my own child. Could he be voted out because his hair was blond?
stenbock9 5-29-2008 @ 10:06AM
Anywhere else in the co called civilized World...(?) both the teacher !!! and the person who investigated this incidence !!! would have been FIRED O N T H E S P O T ...---
Katie 5-29-2008 @ 10:01AM
WHAT BOTHERS ME IS THAT THIS WOMAN STILL HAS HER JOB!
I LIVE IN FLORIDA ALSO, A FEW YEARS AGO A MOTHER OF A FELLOW SECOND GRADE STUDENT OF MY DAUGHTER CALLED ME TO SAY HOW UPSET HER CHILD WAS AT HOW MY DAUGHTER WAS BEING TREATED IN THE CLASSROOM. WHEN I WENT TO THE PRINCIPAL IMMEDIATELY WITH THE ALLIGATIONS THAT CHILDREN WERE BEING PUT IN THE CLOSET AS PUNISHMENT, HER FIRST REACTION WAS TO DEFEND THE TEACHER AND SHE EVEN WENT AS FAR AS TO TELL ME THAT THEY RECIEVE SPECIAL TRAINING ON HOW TO USE SUCH METHODS. NEEDLESS TO SAY I CAME UNGLUED. BUT NOTHING WAS DONE, THEY EVEN REFUSED TO MOVE HER TO ANOTHER TEACHER.
REMEMBER THE ARTICLE ABOUT THE MOTHER WHO PUT A TAPE RECORDER IN HER CHILDS BACKPACK AND RECORDED HER ABUSIVE TEACHER? ALOT OF PEOPLE THOUGHT IT WAS SUCH AN OUTRAGE THAT THIS TEACHER'S PRIVACY HAD SOMEHOW BEEN VIOLATED. BUT I ASK, WHAT ABOUT OUR CHILDREN, WHO IS PROTECTING THEM WHEN WE SEND THEM OFF TO SCHOOL THINKING THAT THEY ARE SAFE FROM PEOPLE WHO WOULD DO THEM HARM. AND WHAT CAN BE DONE WHEN YOU FIND OUT THE PERSON YOU TRUSTED THE MOST, THE TEACHER, IS THE ABUSER?
baby 5-29-2008 @ 10:06AM
That teacher should be humiliated in front of her peers to the highest degree and fired on live television. But honestly, will it really hurt her the way it hurt a 5 year old child with a disorder??? My first thought was really... she should be shot.