Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Babble.com: 8 Parenting Lessons To Learn From 'Arrested Development'
Our Favorite Tweets From Parents This Week
Kids Watching TV All Day - How Bad?
Filed under: Opinions
Had any bad-parent moments lately, where you end up looking around for your Worst Parent Award while wondering just how much you've damaged your child? If your answer is no, check out Links We Love for some amazing Mommy Blog links! If you're saying a big YES, then welcome! Read on... On the phone with my friend R., she says she has to go, friends are over and she's going to switch on a show for her kids so the grown-ups can eat a peaceful dinner. "Oh, how bad is this?" she asks. "I've had friends here all afternoon and the kids have watched at least four straight hours of TV. They were just so mellow I didn't want to change their scene. Is that really awful?"
Who among us hasn't taken advantage of our friend the TV-babysitter? A fellow ParentDish blogger confessed that she refused to allow her child to give up the Wii for Lent, because it was the only time her house was quiet. I checked in with Mommy Advisor Rosanne Tobey, Director of Calm and Sense Therapy, to get some insight. The question is: TV all day -- how bad?
"A full day of TV, eh?" she asked. "Well..."
"It's definitely not something you want to do habitually, since essentially you're ignoring your kids and they will start to act out to get your attention, and not in a good way."
Sure, but once in a blue moon: Damaging or not? "If this is a rare occurrence, I don't think the kids will be damaged, as long as they're safe and the shows are age-appropriate." I'm scanning Amazon for videos as we talk...
But of course, there's more: "However, you could probably come up with a better plan for the future, so they're not just staring at the TV. I mean the question is: If the kids are watching TV all day, are you being your best parent?" And the answer, obviously, is: Not so much.
Here's what Tobey suggests for your next get-together with grown-ups when you feel the need to otherwise-occupy the children:
1. If you can, invite a mother's helper over to play with the kids.
2. Pick up some easy-to-supervise activities in advance. (I favor the dollar aisles in Target and Michael's. If other parents are coming, they will thank you big time for this move.)
3. Once the TV is on (you know it will be), take turns so an adult is checking in on the kids every few minutes.
4. Always state and enforce an open-door policy for The Kids Room. "Kids can be cruel to each other and will become mischievous if they know no one is checking on them," says Tobey.
5. Lighten up about how quiet the house is. "These are your friends," says Tobey. "They understand kids are not quiet, and that kids need attention."
"One other thing," adds Tobey, seriously. "Was everyone drinking? Because sometimes when parents have friends over and there's drinking, it can be easy to lose track of who is being the responsible adult. If a child gets hurt or sick or chokes on a snack, is someone sober enough to get immediate help?"
So, to answer the question (how bad?): "If people are checking on the kids and making sure their needs are met and they're not in harm's way, doing this very rarely is not going to damage anyone, so it's a 2. But be honest with yourself, because if the TV is your frequent babysitter, that's not ideal. The caveat here is if there's a lot of drinking and the kids aren't safe, that's always a 10."
(For more advice about how much TV is okay, check out commonsensemedia.org).
Do you have a "parenting crime" and you'd like to find out: How bad? It can be about food, lame parenting behavior, something you said... anything. Email your How Bad? to PrincessLvsPink@gmail.com (use subject: How Bad?) and your question could get answered, or comment below with your thoughts about whether an occasional TV marathon is okay.
Sabrina Weill is editor-in-chief of princesslovespink.com











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
3-13-2009 @ 7:13AM
Marinda said...I have more of a question than a comment. What if the TV is just on all day...with age appropriate shows ? My Daughter is 14 months. She doesn't sit in front of the TV and stare at it all day but from when she gets up until around her nap time at noon we have on either Playhouse Disney or NIck Jr. The shows on those channels seem to teach them things rather than just be mindless. Colors, counting, sharing...etc. I sit on the floor and play with her as well when they are on, it's something we do together. She does know some of the songs and the characters of the shows from watching them so much but I didn't think it was bad for her... is it ?
Reply
3-13-2009 @ 9:49AM
Nicola said...Marinda, to sit and watch a show together is one thing, but to simply have the noise and distraction running all day in the background isn't ideal for her development. The two of you need quiet. You need a conversation together, you need to allow her focus to be on what you are doing, on her particular area of interest at that moment. If you want to watch an ep of Mickey Mouse Clubhouse, by all means, sit and do that together, but then turn it off and simply BE in the moment.
3-30-2009 @ 5:20PM
angelina said...I met with a brain researcher who studies the effects of tv on a growing child's brain- you know the physiological impact, not just psychological and he says nothing over an hour a week over the age of 3. nothing under 3. a lot happens when children watch tv- from the fovial nerve that connects the eyes to the brain to the brain itself. It's not a good idea. we've always done saturday night movie night and it was just right. there's so much more a child could be doing with those hours that sitting in front of a tv.
3-13-2009 @ 9:49PM
Heather said...The tv is on all the time here as well. Usually on Treehouse or the news. We don't watch it all day but it is on as background noise.
Also there are days when ds is at his dad's and I have the house to my self and I will have a movie day. Sometimes the kids join in and we will watch movies all day. It is usually during Christmas break or March break when we have no where to go and all the house work is done. For us it is a treat. We stay in our pj's and eat popcorn and just have a lazy day.
Reply
3-13-2009 @ 12:07PM
Joy said...Marinda, I agree with Nicola. To watch something together is great and it's good to do things together but to just leave it on all day, I don't know? If she's not watching it, why is it on? When I have my grandchildren, I let them watch one or two things and that's it. They can get aggressive depending on what they are watching and it stifles doing something "real." If it's on, they tend to just stand there and if we are doing something else, their attention automatically goes back to the tv. Answer me this, why do they love the commercials more than the shows?? LOL!!!
I've been having a really good time playing the Wii with my grandchildren. The Wii Sports is so fun because it seems like we are really bowling or playing tennis. We high five and talk. It's a lot of fun. I also live in MN and it's a long cold winter here. In the summer we are never in the house when I have them.
I'm not a huge fan of tv but I don't think watching some things are bad. As long as your watching it and it's not just background noise. I think that can lead to bad habits as adults. My husband just walks into a room and turns the tv on for no reason and will then go do something else but he has to have it on.
You'll do the right thing. You'll know when she's had to much tv.
Reply
3-27-2009 @ 5:03AM
Anne said...Children watch more television certainly not good, first of all, the children's eyes there is injury, and secondly, the child will not go to watch TV after the book, on television program content, parents simply can not control.
http://www.000health.com
Reply