Hot on HuffPost Parents:
HPV Vaccine Slashes Rate Of Infected Teen Girls
WATCH: Dad's Homosexuality Blamed For Son's Tragic Death
Mom Says Get Out, Drives Off
Filed under: Opinions
How frustrated do you have to be to drive off and leave your children behind on a street corner? One mom found out.Madlyn Primoff, a 45-year-old partner in a Manhattan law firm, did what many parents -- myself included -- often threaten: she pulled her car over, told her kids to get out, and drove off, leaving them behind. She is now facing a charge of endangering a child after leaving her 10- and 12-year-old daughters in a White Plains, New York business district. Apparently, the girls had been arguing and Primoff couldn't take it anymore.
What kind of mother would do that? According to her lawyer, Primoff "is a great mother connected with a great family." The lawyer also noted that Primoff "is grateful for the outpouring of support from friends and family." Nonetheless, police say she abandoned her daughters about three miles from their house; her older daughter made it home while the younger daughter was picked up by a "Good Samaritan."
Primoff called police to report her 10-year-old as missing, but was told to go to the police headquarters in White Plains. When she did, she was arrested. She is now barred from contact with her kids, at least temporarily. Primoff pleaded not guilty to the charges.
Now, we've all felt the way Primoff must have; I know that "I'll let you out and you can walk home!" is heard at least once a trip when I'm driving the kids. I've even gone so far as to pull over and open the van door. Actually letting them out, however is a whole other matter. And driving off, well, that's just plain criminal. The White Plains police apparently agree.
Would you ever kick your kids out of the car? Would you let your pre-teens find their own way home? Was this a case of a mother pushed past her limit or criminal negligence?











ReaderComments (Page 3 of 3)
4-30-2009 @ 10:01AM
Uly said...Tammy, I'm not so sure she *did* break the law. My understanding is that she put the children out in an area where pedestrians are allowed to be. In NY State, children are allowed to travel alone before the age of 10 and 12 - for example, you only have to be 8 to ride the MTA unaccompanied - and while three miles is a far way to walk it's not *that* far.
Of course, I'm not a lawyer. If you can point me to the relevant law in question...?
4-30-2009 @ 2:54AM
Anne said...Do not because you are angry at, on the way to treat your child.
http://www.000health.com
Reply
4-30-2009 @ 12:28PM
Charice said...Come on, these are American kids, the mom shouldn't have expected them to walk a whole 3 miles much less 3 feet. :-)
Reply
4-30-2009 @ 12:17PM
steff hartman said...SKL...have fun with it all! My kids are now 17, 23, and 25 and all very independent. I doubt that anyone would be too happy being dropped off on an interstate with no phone! She is fortunately out of the relationship, has completed college, and gainfully employed. Enjoy, enjoy, enjoy, your little ones! As a teacher in a childcare center, and now age 55, I realize there are things I missed with my kids, and I was home with them 20 years! It is really true what you hear while raising your kids...."Little children, little problems...big children, big problems!" The point I was trying to make is don't do something rash, all in the name of discipline, that you might regret for the rest of your life. The "National Association for the Education of Young Children" offers a wealth of information as does "Better Kid Care" (Univ.of Penn State). Once again, enjoy each day with your little ones because they really do grow up quickly.....
Reply
4-30-2009 @ 12:33PM
Tammy said...Our boys are all three self sufficient, well rounded individuals each with their own special personality. The truth of the matter is we all have an opinion and are entitled to it, what someone else thinks is not going to change our minds. Yesterday afternoon as I was reading new post on this subject our oldest son who is 14 came into the room and asked what I was doing. He read the article himself and without giving him my own opinion I asked him what he thought. Without hesitation his response was why would any mother do that, why not just punish the girls when they got home? Then he said, "You love us too much to ever do anything like that." What if something had happened to the girls, the mom would never forgive herself he said. I then told him that sometimes moms and dads get caught up in the moment and do really stupid things that they later regret and that this mom I'm sure regretted what she had done. As far as did she break the law, if the article is accurate she is an associate at a law firm and should have known that she might be breaking the law when she put the girls out. If the charges do stick she has no one to blame but herself after all she was the only adult in the situation, the girls won't be held accountable for her actions. All of us view things differently, what I see as possible dangers obviously others do not, and seem to have the statistics to back it up and that's fine, I just don't want one of my boys to be that obviously rare case according to statistics of," How could this have happened", and it have happened all because I didn't think before I acted. For me this subject is closed.
Reply
4-30-2009 @ 1:41PM
Uly said...So basically, Tammy, this whole comment is defending your right to both be ignorant and judge others on your ignorance. You think that your opinion - based, as near as I can tell, on "making shit up" - is as valid as everybody else's opinion - based on facts and information and knowledge - because you happen to be special enough to think it?
Well, fine, but you don't need to announce to the world that you judge them for what they know and you do not, nor do you need to insult them over that.
5-02-2009 @ 4:34PM
Hollistergurl said...I think that everyone (except for Brittany andEH) is completly stupid. I mean I would never drop my kids off on the side of the rode just because they were arguing. I would take them to my house and hande it then. SLK you don't even get the point. They were 3 miles from home and the mom dropped off her kids and said goobye!! You don't see anything wrong with that?? You are the stupidest person in the world to think that isn't wrong!
I agree with the police that she should have gone to jail. That bitch deserves it.
Those are just my opinions.
Reply
5-08-2009 @ 9:31AM
tanya said...I am the mother of 4 boys ages 16,15,14, and 12 1/2, and step-mother to a 24 year old ,also a boy. Believe me, there have been many times that I have come close to getting into automobile accidents due to the fact that someone keeps hitting someone in the backseat, or someone won't shut their mouth!! all of the bickering back and forth really is a HUGE distraction for the driver of the car!! I have tried pulling over to the side of the road and talking to the boys about their behavior in the car, do we really think they care? The answer is no!!!! The problem with kids today, is the fact that they are afraid of nothing!!! If they feel they are treated unfairly or disciplined the wrong way, they can dial the phone and have some agency all over the parent in a second. I applaud the mother who made the girls walk home!! Bet they will listen to her the next time she tells them to stop doing something! or, perhaps, maybe they will think twice before they act up again! Maybe, after the kids have been taken out of their home, they will appreciate what they have, and learn a valuable lesson ! However, the older daughter should be ashamed of herself for not keeping a watch on her younger sibling! If there is one thing our kids should always be made aware of is, there is safety in numbers. Its a lot easier to be abducted or become a victim of a violent crime if there is only one of you!
Reply
5-05-2009 @ 7:07AM
Jennifer said...In my opinion children should be protected by the law. However nowadays too much power is placed in the hands of children by adults and other authority figures even their own parents.
My daughter is 7-years old and told me one day that she is allowed, according to what she learned in school and daycare, to call the police on her parents.
I responded to her that if she is being physically hurt by her parents, or others that she should dial 911 if she feels in danger. However, she took it to mean if she is not given what she wants when she wants it that in her 7-year old mind that is considered "abuse".
I think an emphasis on children is very important. However I do not believe the Mother was thinking clearly when she let her children walk home. I would never let my child walk home by themselves no matter location or closeness to home.
However, in my opinion the Mother did not do it with malice or criminal intent to hurt her own kids.
I think parents are scared to raise their voices to their own children (myself included). Children understand instant gratification and play the system even put one parent against the other parent
to get what they want.
Also, I think authorities and agencies are so afraid of being sued these days that they sometimes respond way beyond the call of duty in a lot of so-called "abuse" cases.
My daughter is a well-behaved child and I rarely have problems with her. However, when she told me she could call the police on me my eyes opened really wide and I realized what a different world it is today then when I was growing up.
Do not take my comments wrong, I am very happy that educators, law enforcement and even "Good Samaritans" etc.....are doing more to protect children.
But in the process we need to make sure as a society we do not make parent's afraid to raise their own children to become productive well-behaved members of our "society"..
Reply
5-22-2009 @ 6:31PM
freecut4girls said...Free Haircuts For Women & Girls!
Trims Layers Bob cuts Girls Buzz cuts
Correction Haircuts! + * Punishment Haircuts!
(*Very Effective!)
Call 267-407-2342 Now!
(trained non-licensed)
In Northeast Philadelphia, PA.
(not trained in textured hair!)
IMMEDIATE SERVICE!
Wanted : White, Asian or Latino Females Ages 17-30 Who Are Willing To Get All Their Hair Cut Off For A Research Project
There is NO Compensation.
Willing Participants Should Have Hair That is Below Shoulders .
Call 267-407-2342 Now!
Reply