Are You Jealous of Your Nanny?
Categories: Playground Bureau, Childcare
We want our kids to love their babysitters, so why are we so jealous when they do? Photo courtesy of sxc.hu.
Having a full-time sitter or nanny in your home is different from sending your child to daycare. The person taking care of your precious babies is in your home, every day or nearly so, and interacts with your children in a very intimate setting. Making this choice can also sometimes mean that the relationship your kids form with their caregivers is extremely close. Sometimes, it can be too close for our comfort.
Nannies4Hire recently conducted a survey on so-called "nanny envy," and lots of moms said they are jealous of the relationships their kids have with their caregivers. "My greatest fear was that after being with [my kids] all day, that the kids would be closer to the nanny than they are to me," says one respondent. "[During] the little time I get to spend with them on the weekends, they call me Shantel, the nanny's name, instead of mommy. I hate that."
Another woman says: "Our youngest, they baby, practically jumps out of my arms to get to the nanny. I am glad my kids like her and that she is so good to them, but as a mother you can't help but feel jealous."
Just ask Jane (not her real name), a Bellevue, Wash. mom who found herself confronting the Green Monster when her two boys were toddlers. Her first nanny had been an older woman; when the boys became more active, she hired a 22-year-old to tend to them. While the young lady was "marvelous" with her boys, Jane found herself facing the fact that "at 45 [years old], I was aging."
The nanny's energy and enthusiasm for her job was a double-edged sword; Jane was thrilled to have her caring for her children, but was envious of her ability to do so with such gusto. So how did she resolve the issue? Did she leave notes for her kids during the day, or arrange for a day out with just her and her boys, as Momlogic suggested recently?
"I just let it ride," Jane says. "And by doing that, I came to see that with two little boys less than a year apart, and given my age and my husband's age, that having a young person in their lives to wear them out was good for all of us. I had the energy to do my parts of the day because of her."
Jane's nanny sensed that something was amiss. "She knew I was struggling with the demands of the children after working a full day," says Jane. "I was lucky that she did her job the best she could and let it ride too."
In fact, the two women are still close, and her now-retired nanny drops by now and then to chat with Jane and see the two boys, now ages 6 and 7. " We still are very dear friends, and although she has not been my nanny for the last couple of years, she occasionally comes to sit on the weekends, attends the boys birthday parties, and she is really a member of our extended family."
A few weeks ago, my 8-month-old son gave me a high-five. At first, I thought he was a genius -- then it dawned on me that our babysitter must have taught him how to do it. He looked up at me with his bright-blue eyes, laughing. I smiled back, and tried hard to swallow the jealousy rising in my throat.
My kids have had babysitter since they were born, but it was different when my daughter was a baby. I wasn't working, and she was also the only little person in the house, so I could focus on her. Now, with a demanding freelance career and two kids to care for, the baby sees the babysitter more than he sees me some days -- and that was never my plan.
When he gave me that sweet high-five, I felt displaced. Worse, I felt like I wasn't doing my job. I felt like our sweet sitter was doing a better job being his mom than I was. Now, I know that isn't the case. But for that minute? It totally felt that way. Motherhood finds new and interesting ways to make me feel guilty -- and now jealous -- all the time.
Are you jealous of your babysitter or nanny, and how do you deal it? Or do you?
Recent Posts
- 3 Reasons to Stop Skipping Breakfast (3/19/2010)
- Puppies Used in Latest Advance-Payment Scam (3/18/2010)
- Opinion: Parents' Attitudes Contribute More to Autism Than Vaccines (3/18/2010)
- Why Do Sandra Bullock and Jesse James' Alleged Marriage Problems Make Us So Sad? (3/18/2010)
- Quebec Government Will Fund IVF Treatments (3/18/2010)










Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
SKL 5-05-2009 @ 3:36PM
I don't feel jealous. My kids have never preferred the nanny over me.
I think it's a good idea to have a "division of labor" between parent(s) and nanny. I build on my nanny's strengths. She is a bilingual artist. Hence her main foci are to give my kids art experiences and teach them Spanish. She uses the Spanish-language books and toys, I use the English-language ones. She uses the play-doh and sidewalk chalk, I teach them music and take them out on the town. I think this is one reason why the girls always look forward to spending time with me, even though they have lots of fun with their nanny. The other reason is the unconditional love I have for them (they sense the difference), and the fact that when things get really bad, I nearly always take charge of making things better.
Reply
Herbal Remedies 5-05-2009 @ 6:15PM
This demonstrated that the babysitter can become a woman close to her children but also demonstrated that they understand the long l apposition of the nanny and the position of his mother, so jealousy by giving more are unfounded in such cases it is important to build trust in our Father, let us not forget that in the end they take the example of their parents.
Herbal Remedies
http://www.naturals-products.com
Reply
CLM 5-05-2009 @ 7:19PM
The first time one of my twin boys gave a caregiver a big hug, I must confess to a twinge. However, I reminded myself that it was a positive indication of socialization and let it go. Who really wants their child screaming or disconsolate when the nanny or sitter arrives?
Reply
bromac 5-06-2009 @ 11:17AM
I don't understand how someone could hand over childrearing of their child and then be jealous of the person to whom they gave the responsibility. It is a natural consequence of whoever raises the child. If you want your child to love you more than the nanny, then don't get a nanny.
Reply
G 6-15-2009 @ 12:05AM
A nanny can never replace a parent. It takes a very strong woman to allow someone else to love their child. Allowing someone else to love your child is not easy but learning to love someone beyond your immediate circle is an important part of sociailization for children. Regardless of whether it is Grandma or Auntie or nanny.
We no longer live in a world where Grandma lives across the street, she is more likely to live across the country.
As mothers you should all support each other's choices whether they are the same or different. Raising children is a tough job.....we are all on the same team.
And for the record: Nanny and Babysitter are not interchangeable terms. The definitions are defined at www.nanny.org