
Too Much Sugar - How Bad?
Categories: Mealtime
Well, okay, maybe just one... Photo courtesy of Stockexpert.com.
I used to think of our home as a "low sugar" household. Then recently, we had visitors -- dear friends from the other coast who apparently truly do have a low sugar household. I know this because their kids were downright giddy at all the snacks and treats I'd convinced myself were okay, like organic fruit leather and 100% fruit juice. Their visit really highlighted for me how much sugar our kids are sucking down every day, and it's a lot.
Lunch dessert, dinner dessert...and did I mention the occasional "I'll give you a cookie if you get in the car quickly" bribe? I called Mommy Advisor Christine M. Palumbo, R.D., a nutritionist in private practice in a Chicago suburb who is an adjunct faculty member at Benedictine University, to find out how bad all this sugarification is for my kids. How much is too much? How bad?
"It's bad," she said. "All that dessert is setting them up for bad food habits throughout their lives. And where there's sugar, there's fat," she added, before pointing out that I probably was unaware of all the sugar I was giving my kids that's hiding in foods we usually don't think of as "treats" like bread, and spaghetti sauce.
While we were talking, I drifted into the kitchen and squinted at the label on my bread. There it was: High Fructose Corn Syrup. Ach--stress! Here are Palumbo's tips for keeping the sugar-level lower in your home, for real:
Redefine dessert. Apparently having your children peer into the freezer and forage for treats after dinner is not ideal. Palumbo suggests we instead serve a dessert of our choosing, like yogurt with fruit, a pretty bowl of berries, a poached pear -- basically fruit instead of anything from the chocolate food group, at least for lunch. "Try berries and a tiny dollop of whipped cream in a beautiful plastic cocktail glass. A lot of the thrill of dessert is in the packaging," she points out.
Be aware of portions. Palumbo points out that cookies used to be small and now are often "the size of a baby's head." (I recently asked a bakery for a cookie after lunch and felt rather mortified when they brought over a cookie the size of my head). A kid-size portion of ice-cream is a quarter-cup. Cookies should be small.
If you can, make your own. If you're baking your own cookies you can reduce the sugar and add nutritional value by adding in nuts (if your child can eat them) or oat flour which slows the absorption of sugar.
Make water fun. Palumbo recommends no more than one serving of juice a day. To make water fun, float strawberry or cucumber slices in it, or have a fun water bottle that's only allowed to hold water.
Beware of hiding sugar. Look at the labels for hidden sugars, which Palumbo tells me can be disguised as: "high fructose corn syrup, beet sugar, brown sugar, cane sugar, corn syrup, dextrose, evaporated cane juice, honey, maltodextrin,molasass, sucrose, turbinado sugar, agave nectar..." I have to say I was surprised at some of the items in my pantry that contained these.
Don't use treats as a reward. Oh c'mon! Please? No says Palumbo. Don't go there. "It sets them up for reaching for "comfort foods" when they feel like they need comfort throughout their lives. This is why I'm not big on having dessert with every meal because you don't want to punish by withholding dessert and you don't want to reward by offering dessert." (Note to self: bad!)
So, answer the question: Too much sugar -- how bad? "It's bad," Palumbo says. "I would say, too much sugar during the day is a 7 or an 8 out of 10 because it leads to dental issues and because sugar usually comes packaged with fat, you're setting up your kids for bad habits." Making some changes in the kitchen...
If you've committed a parenting crime and you want to know, How Bad? Send it to PrincessLvsPink@Gmail.com and you might find out.
Sabrina Weill is editor-in-chief of PrincessLovesPink.com.
Recent Posts
- G.I. Joe, My Little Pony Invading TV With New Children's Network (2/09/2010)
- Movies May Influence Children's Food Choices, Study Shows (2/09/2010)
- Report Cites 220 Cases of D.C. Teachers Abusing Students (2/09/2010)
- Chicago Candidate Drops Out of Race With Tearful Child On Display (2/09/2010)
- Juicy, But Not Juice (2/09/2010)






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Baron 5-07-2009 @ 10:41AM
I think folks get a little overboard on the sugar (and fat, etc) issue these days. You sort of need to look at the overall life style of your kids. I know when I was a kid, which, in retrospect, wasn't all that long ago, I ate things that would make your visitors eyes pop. I was a very picky eater, but I had a really strong sweet tooth. A common snack would be to grab a spoon and get a couple of spoon fulls of sugar out of the canister to just eat. Cool whip mixed with 7up was a favorite drink. So was homemade whip cream, I would eat it all day long. Suffice to say, I could go on about all the really, really bad things I ate (outside of raw carrots, you could cram a vegetable, nor barely a fruit, down my mouth if you tried). BUT, I never stopped moving (that might have been the sugar now that I think about it ;) ). I didn't hit above a 10% body fat until my second year of college, which is when I started actually eating a wider variety of foods and less sugar. I'm still on the fit side of things and I typically eat what I want. I just make sure to keep myself active too. So again, I think we put to much concern into what we eat. If you are sitting around, doing nothing all day though, that is a different story.
Reply
Melissa 5-07-2009 @ 12:38PM
Thank you, Baron! There is waaaay too much concern over this! I was also a picky eater (for about a year all I wanted to eat was peanut butter sandwiches), and had a sweet tooth....my mom was kind of like, well, at least she's eating SOMETHING, right? I was very active so I didn't have any weight problems until I was in my 20's....I wasn't as active as I was as a child and a teen, therefore, I gained some weight. But it wasn't because I was eating too much sugar, it was because I wasn't moving! Bottom line is, keep them moving!
LS 5-07-2009 @ 2:05PM
I think, also, that we tend to simplify and demonize sugar and fat because they're easy targets. It's easy to pile on, and go with the common attitude that "sugar is bad; fat is bad; they will make you FAT!!!"
But the dirty little secret is that your body NEEDS sugar and fat. They are used as fuel.
And while I don't recommend Baron's diet to everyone (cool whip and 7up? Holy COW!!!), there are worse things than sugar.
Also... I agree that rewarding kids with food is generally a bad practice, what does your expert say about making a certain type of food a forbidden one? What's going to happen if you clear all the sugar out of your house, and never let them have any? You become the Sugar Nazi. Then what?
Now they're going to hide food. They're going to get it, because now it has the lure of the forbidden - can't have it? I WANT it!!! That sets them up for eating disorders later in life.
You're better off considering sugar within the context of everything else they do. Have a cookie, and if it's huge, share a cookie. Have a soda then go outside an play.
And once in a while? Eat dessert first. And put whipped cream on it.
Reply
SKL 5-07-2009 @ 3:21PM
I totally agree with your first sentence, and I would say that about our society in general. It's an example of the "dumbing down" of America. Nutrition is a complex matter, yet it's also simple if you have a foundation of knowledge. The key is not what's "good" and "bad," but how everything should be balanced. Unfortunately most people have never gone beyond naming the "four food groups" or, today, the "food pyramid" (which adds that sugar and fat are bad). Oh, and that fast food is the root of all evil. Billions of government dollars are spent on health education and prevention, and this is the best we can do? My guess is that the junk food / junk ingredient companies are lining the pockets of the politicians. I mean, how hard would it be for the food pyramid to include a statement saying "whole foods should be preferred over processed foods"? But then the processed food companies would take a hit and have less money for political donations. Maybe the government should stay out of this all together if they're not going to do it right - I know, a novel and outrageous thought.
My kids eat tons of sugar - mainly in whole fruits and in milk, sometimes in combination with whole-grain foods. Whole foods provide a balance that enables the body to metabolize the sugar (and fat) in a healthy way. Why is that such a difficult concept?
Oh, and please pass the whipped cream!!
LS 5-07-2009 @ 5:55PM
SKL... Shame on you!!! How DARE you suggest that the government stay out of something!!! The gall!!! ;)
add sprinkles to mine, please!
Todd29 6-21-2009 @ 5:20PM
Stop dieting; keep track of everything that you eat each day. No one wants to be overweight! The most difficult thing to be able to control to keep your weight in check is mindless grazing. It is not always easy to do, but eat to live don’t live to eat. Some type of daily regimen is needed by everyone; but do not diet, your body needs nourishment. Diets and diet aids do not help anyone! The only way to successfully lose weight and get the body that you deserve is by using the right information. This information is in the book Lose Weight Using Four Easy Steps which can be ordered through the website www.bbotw.com Everyone who has gotten a copy of this book has lost weight and become healthier.
Reply