The Story of Stuff Makes Moms - And Kids - Think
Categories: Teens & tweens, Environment, Media, Education, Resources
Annie Leonard explains how stuff is made, and soon tossed. Image via storyofstuff.com.
Last night, I talked a handful of my girlfriends into watching it with me so we could see why teachers everywhere are using it get teens talking about the plague of our consumer culture. Seems that if we buy less, we might just save the world.
Here's why: Annie Leonard, a former Greenpeace employee, wrote the film after spending years investigating the travels of trash across the globe. Leonard also narrates the story of "stuff" (depicted as line-drawn cartoons); she's clear and often funny, the way people who really know what they're talking about often are. It doesn't hurt that the film was produced by Free Range Studios, the group behind socially minded, web-based films like "The Meatrix" and "Grocery Store Wars." (The project was bankrolled by The Sustainability Funders and Tides Foundation.)
Huddled around a laptop, we listened. We laughed. We gasped. I marveled at the simplicity of the medium, and the complexity of the message. Leonard outlines in very clear language how the global materials economy works. Or doesn't. I love a good picture, so I was delighted when the pie charts appeared to illustrate how one-third of the world's natural resources have burned up in the past 20 years. Of course, then I was horrified. Leonard went on to explain that even though America accounts for just 5 percent of the world's population, we use 30 percent of the world's resources-and generate 30 percent of its waste.
Maybe it was the comfy couches, or the red wine. But, when it was all over, we couldn't help but feel a sisterhood of complicity. One mom admitted she lusts after handbags. Another wants to redecorate her home. We all collect shoes. And we love our children-as well as the environment. Leonard contends that our current state of consumer mania (of which we're a part, no matter how disciplined we try to be) was designed after World War II and ratcheted our of control by economic and media manipulation. Many sexy new products are designed for the dump-and consumers feel terrible if they aren't constantly upgrading.
Gretchen Giumarro, 38, is a landscape architect and mother of two boys. Even so, she somehow recalled being told by a five-year-old visitor that "washing the dishes kills the polar bears." True. But, after watching "The Story of Stuff," she suggested that you have to teach kids to love the environment before you can teach them to heal it. "I'd love to have another video with the next installment," she said. "I could really use the "what you can do" chapter of the story." Me, too.
Until then, here's a good start.
What are you doing to teach your kids about stuff? Or are your kids the ones schooling you?
Victoria Scanlan Stefanakos is editor of Project Homestead.
Recent Posts
- Reviews: What's New This Week (11/06/2009)
- Jim Carrey's "A Christmas Carol" Creepy in a Good Way (11/06/2009)
- Twitter Follow Friday on ParentDish! (11/06/2009)
- Babies Pick Up Mothers' Accents In The Womb (11/06/2009)
- Recall: Adventure Playsets (11/06/2009)

.jpg)
















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
LS 5-13-2009 @ 7:09PM
I was a little skeptical of all those stats that were thrown around in the beginning of the video, and I wrote them down to research later. But then she got to the part about Externalized Cost and said,
"I was walking to work the other day, and I wanted to listen to the news. So I popped inot Radio Shack to buy myself a radio. I found a cute little green one for $4.99..."
WHAT???? The WHOLE POINT of this video is to discuss how we evil Americans (because it doesn't discuss anyone else) are raping the planet for our own gratification, and she's stopping off to buy a radio so she can listen to the news on the way to work, where she will be able to read the paper, or turn on the internet and get it all.
She COMPLETELY defeated her own argument, right there.
Reply
ED 5-14-2009 @ 2:23PM
LS, did you stop watching the video at that point? Because she goes on to illustrate the implications of the impulse to buy a $4.99 radio and how that plays out in the global economy.
You're trying to hold her to a standard she doesn't even espouse; she's not saying people shouldn't buy anything; she's educating people as to the implications of our choices.
Talk about missing the point.
LS 5-14-2009 @ 3:27PM
No, Ed, I did not miss the point. And yes, I did watch the whole thing.
She stated that she was thinking about this stuff, *while she stood in line, waiting to pay for her purchase.* Never once did she say that she put it back. And how hard would that have been, really? A simple insertion of, "So you know what I did? I put that crappy radio right back on the shelf, and walked out of Radio Shack. I could wait another ten minutes to get to work and read the news." Maybe it's splitting hairs, but to me, it's just one more person preaching "do as I say, not as I do." We're just supposed to nod, and swallow all of this crap without asking questions, because when we do ask questions, we're shouted down.
I am tired of being preached at by the sanctimonious "environmentalists". The ones who yell the loudest are the worst offenders. Reference their king, Al Gore, living in a massive mansion, on a massive estate, and flying to "environmental concerts" in a private jet. While he's telling us little people to ride our bikes to work. Oh, yeah, and pay into his little hedge fund by buying farcical "carbon offsets".
It's just so much hypocrisy, and until they start practicing what they preach, all it is, is hot air and noise pollution.
Reply
Brian 5-20-2009 @ 4:24PM
The definitive critique to the Story of Stuff:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c5uJgG05xUY
Reply