Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Linda Bloom LCSW and Charlie Bloom MSW: Overwhelmed Parents: A…
Allison Tate: What I Would Like to Tell My Son's 5th Grade Teacher Now
Getting Real About Body Image
Filed under: Development: Tweens
Is maintaining a positive body image even possible anymore? Image: sxc.hu
This made me feel only slightly better. Is her displeasure truly only temporary and something that will vanish along with the deep purple spots on her shins? Or is this the beginning of the end of her acceptance and love of herself the way she is?
In a world where skinny, photo-shopped models scream "This is how you should look!", what is a mother to do to help her daughter maintain a positive body image? According to writer Donna Fish, you can't do anything. The message that happiness belongs to those with skinny thighs and perfect breasts is insidious and even girls who don't watch television or read magazines are hearing it loud and clear.
Fish, a mother of a tween and two teens herself, believes that expecting your daughter to maintain a positive body image is unrealistic and advises parents to rid themselves of that goal. Self-loathing is normal. But while there may be no stopping that train of discontent, she says there are things you can do to prevent being run over by it. She gives advice on dealing with self-critical girls that mostly consists of tips on how not to get sucked into their body drama:
"They will try to 'off load' the 'bad feelings' about themselves onto you. This is done by telling you things like: "I hate my thighs", or: "I always look terrible". They need to 'off load' the intensity of their feelings and unfortunately or fortunately depending on how you think about it, you are their target. That way, they get to relieve the pressure. Oh, the joys of motherhood!"
I get where she is coming from and recognize that so much of parenting teens is about staying out of the line of fire. But the idea that it is normal for girls to feel intensely bad about themselves makes me incredibly sad. And it also makes me angry. Girls comparing themselves to other girls is normal and has been happening forever. What has changed is the girls they are comparing themselves to. Where we used to eye our classmates and measure ourselves against those we found most beautiful, girls today are being trained to measure themselves against unreal girls. Fake and airbrushed and impossibly thin, they in no way depict the average female.
Fish may be right -- there may be no way to protect our daughters from the onslaught of this twisted popular culture. But I am not quite ready to throw in the towel. I will continue to boycott the magazines, I will praise my girl for her efforts and accomplishments and not her looks and, most importantly, I will set a good example by loving my own self just the way I am.
How are you helping your daughters maintain their self-esteem and love themselves they way they are?











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
6-09-2009 @ 10:33AM
SKL said...First of all, I disagree with the part of premise you highlight. I do agree that it's normal for pubescent and teen girls to be self-critical, but I don't agree that there's nothing we can do to counter the unhealthy messages they receive. Kids absolutely internalize what their parents say - especially if they practice what they preach.
I recall my mom using the word "ugly" to describe the gaunt and bony frames of the popular female "idols," and "ridiculous" to describe the combination of bleached hair and darkly tanned skin. I have always felt the same way. Even as a young teen, when I saw a peer who was trying to copy that image, I felt sorry for them. Did I sometimes obsess about my zits and the softness of my thighs? Absolutely, but my ideal was a naturally attractive body/complexion.
With my daughters, I focus on health and also speak positively about people's natural differences. When anyone comments on their physical features (positively or negatively), I say that they are the way God made them, and therefore they are perfect. As they get old enough to understand the difference between natural beauty and extreme body engineering, I'll do the same thing my mom did - pass down my honest distaste for the "popular" body image. I'll teach them that make-up is optional and help them find healthy, positive ways to deal with reasonable concerns such as excess acne and overweight. Yes, they will be critical of themselves, but hopefully not because they don't look like an ugly, trampy drug addict whom the media has decided to idolize.
Reply
6-09-2009 @ 11:57AM
jesse said...http://www.jakapatwood.com/
NICE POST.
Reply
6-09-2009 @ 1:41PM
Nikki Thomas said...It's hard to control the social messages about identity that society brainwashes children with, but I guess the best thing parents can do is reverse the brainwashing by telling them to have a mind of thier own and be happy with who they are.
-Nikki-
http://freeonlineadvertising.yolasite.com
http://sellingphotography101.yolasite.com
http://1dollarebooks.yolasite.com
Reply
6-10-2009 @ 4:46AM
damoki said...You go SKL… of course there is something to be done. Kids are inoculated (the statistics are scary) with virtually constant media messages about what and how they should do, behave, think, and of course, spend money.
Parents are in the unique position to model, “in front of their children”, reactions to those same messages and influences. Kids are in the unique position, especially in the early years, to believe in the “rightness” of parental behavior. Kids in China speak Chinese because their parents do, not because it is the official tongue; the same is true for so many behaviors in all families.
Equally important is parental focus on guiding their children toward the development of internal rather than external motivation and valuation. An example: when you tell your child, “I’m so proud of you”, for something they do well, you are supporting the development of external valuation; if instead you address the accomplishment by saying, “You should be proud of yourself!”, internal, valuation is supported.
Remember what you want; it should be to help your children become fully functional adults, sporting characteristics like high self-esteem, self-confidence, and self-image, with which they can more easily resist the barrage of media messages. If you believe simply telling children they should have these characteristics really works, you are living in the land of “just say no”; it does not work. In the vast majority of cases, “Preach’n ain’t Teach’n”.
The most influential action you can take is to be the best human you can be. Set the example. If you complain all the time about others, your kids are likely to complain too; if you react with anger and accusatory tones to minor transgressions, your kids will copy that behavior on the playground; and if you speak Chinese around the house… guess what.
To improve most of society’s ills improve the family unit: it all starts with you, the parent. You should do something, you can do something, you must do something!
DaMoKi
Reply