Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Caron Gremont: Obesity's Officially a Disease, So How Come My Child…
Karri-Leigh P. Mastrangelo: Am I Going to Hell For My Position on…
Parents Keep 2-Year-Old's Gender a Secret
Filed under: In The News

Swedish couple avoid stereotypes by refusing to reveal their child's gender. Photo: Dominik Gwarek/sxc.hu
But even if you can't tell the gender of someone's child just by looking, you can always come out and ask the parents, right? Usually, yes. But in the case of a two-and-a-half-year-old Swedish child, the answer would be "none of your business."
Aside from the parents and few other people, nobody knows if the child they call Pop is a boy or a girl. Pop's parents subscribe to a feminist philosophy in which the idea of gender is an unnecessary and potentially harmful social construction. They believe that by keeping Pop's gender a secret from the world, their child will be allowed to grow up without preconceived notions of how he or she should be treated based on his or her gender.
Pop is allowed to choose what to wear from a collection of both girl's and boy's clothing and has ever-changing hairstyles. According to the parents, Pop understands the physical differences between boys and girls but they avoid using gender specific personal pronouns when referring to their child. Pop is just Pop.
"We want Pop to grow up more freely and avoid being forced into a specific gender mold from the outset," Pop's mother said. "It's cruel to bring a child into the world with a blue or pink stamp on their forehead."
At least one expert believes that Pop's parents might be on to something with this gender-free experiment. Swedish gender equality consultant Kristina Henkel believes that by removing the preconceived notions about gender, a child like Pop can develop character as an individual rather than as a boy or a girl. "I think that can make these kids stronger," Henkel says.
Pop may be living without the so-called burden of gender stereotypes, but could there also be a down side? Pediatric endocrinologist Anna Nordenström believes that, at the very least, Pop will grow up feeling different than other children. "It will affect the child, but it's hard to say if it will hurt the child," she says. "I don't know what they are trying to achieve. It's going to make the child different, make them very special."
She is probably right, but I suspect that "different" is exactly what Pop's parents are hoping for.
Your<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- My daughter (14 yrs) was just kicked out of her Girl Scout Cadettes troop. Her offense? Having ADD (not hyperactive) and she wasn't picking up on a tr...
- Copyright royaly board understanding building a radio or tv (song sound good got your own radio)?
- (department of defense)? hey can you build me a super duper all protector? yea what you want on it $$$$$











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 2)
6-30-2009 @ 4:48PM
chrisz said...These parents are complete morons. They are turning into their child into a genderless freak. Instead of teaching their child that they can be whatever they want no matter what gender, they are teaching their child that hiding who they truly are is the right way to go through life. This poor kid will end up in therapy with an identity disorder.
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 9:31AM
Kayla said...WHERE WILL THE CHILD GO TO THE BATHROOM?!?!
7-01-2009 @ 1:52PM
sxybstevr said...i agree with you. my parents always said to me tht who you are defines you not the way you look. this kid is going to be in and out of identy disorder therepy classes untill the end of time. wht in gods name are these people thinking when they say they dont want their child classified? the second they decieded not to reveal their childs sex she/he was automatically placed in a group of people most of us have never evn meet. she/he is still a kid but do they want their kid to commit suicide? because he/she doesnt know who to be or wht to think?
6-30-2009 @ 5:16PM
Patrice said...I agree that the lesson of being whatever you want to be, despite what others say, is what should be taught. It could even be argued that they have some preconceived ideas, as well. I mean, what is a "boy" or "girl" to them? If it doesn't matter, if it's not important, what's the harm in disclosing Pop's gender?
What happens when this child has to venture out into the public arena (e.g. school)? It's easy for them to allow Pop to dress in whatever clothing he/she wants now, but will they also allow him/her to use whatever public restroom he/she wants (should it ever be necessary)?
Unless this child is homeschooled and sheltered from society all the days of his/her life, there's no way this is going to remain undisclosed for much longer.
Reply
6-30-2009 @ 9:25PM
SKL said...I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought: the kid is being raised to be a freak.
First of all, s/he is not going to be sheilded from gender identity unless s/he's kept blindfolded, wears ear plugs, and never learns to read. Children are extremely observant. Most likely the child already has most of the stereotypes his parents are trying to avoid.
Secondly, the child is going to learn that s/he is different from everyone else, and isn't going to understand whether that's a good or bad thing. Usually kids conclude that not being up on what ALL the other kids are up on is bad.
Thirdly, the parents are focusing on the superficial. Why do they think their child's identity is so affected by clothes and toddler toys (which are basically unisex anyway)? Do you think Venus and Serena Williams ever wore lace or ruffles as toddlers?
These people are mental and I feel sorry for their kid. Even if s/he isn't "scarred for life," they aren't creating a "superior being" as they seem to believe.
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 12:10AM
Maureen said...I don't know... I think it is potentially harmful to raise a child as gender-neutral. There are two sexes. Men and Women both have something to bring to the table and what they bring can be equally beneficial to mankind. I try not to push stereotypes on my kids -- my son seems to gravitate towards building things and my daughter likes to do whatever feels right in the moment whether it is playing with a tool-set or trains, or making paper dolls.
I just think the whole notion that men and women are the same is bizarre. If a girl child knows she is different from a boy child, how is that harmful. Being different doesn't mean one is better than the other.
Reply
7-02-2009 @ 10:50AM
Estefania said...I`m think you are absolutely right, those parents must be in jail, how stupid can someone be????
7-01-2009 @ 9:43AM
JW said...I'm curious as to what the parents (or child) are going to enter on various forms, i.e. ids, school forms, government forms, etc., for the sex of this person? Even if this child is home schooled, eventually he/she will go out into the public, and the public can be pretty harsh. We do not live in a unisex world, and the parents may be doing more psychological damage to this child as he grows and becomes aware he/she was an experiment at the whim of his parents.
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 5:43PM
April said...The saddest part of this is that they're expecting ANOTHER baby! Having a child shouldn't be considered some kind of sociological experiment. These doofi (plural of "doofus") should both be sterilized, and have the kids taken away. The psychololgical damage that's being done just boggles my mind!
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 1:12PM
damoki said...At the end of the "source" for this post, there is an example of how messing with nature can lead to less than planned or hoped for results... in that case, suicide.
An attempt to alter an individual’s social inclination by masking the genetic imperative is at best foolhardy, and at worst disastrous. Mars and Venus… there are differences.
That case, the result of a horrible accident, was an attempt to alter reality, and the reverse of this one. Here the parents are avoiding reality, but the potentials for a sad end are still there. This parenting style is not effective, because they are not being mentors, and guides... just keepers.
When parents are ineffective in raising their kids to develop positive characteristics - confidence, charity, empathy, patience, et al. - the problems this couple is trying to address are evident. The solution is not to socially neuter the child, it is to be better parents. Understanding the differences not only between genders, but also within each, and helping a child develop appropriate characteristics would be a great start.
DaMoKi
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 1:46PM
Karen said...The kid's going to be screwed up not because s/he doesn't have a social gender construct, but because her/his parents are verging on sociopathic. I do want to clarify that the term for whether a person has indoor or outdoor plumbing is "sex" -- the parents are keeping the kid's sex a secret. By doing so, they are hoping to prevent a sex-specific gender identity. This is just stupid. My mother allowed me to have dolls, wear ruffled everything, and even, on special occasions, paint my nails. Now I am a career-woman head of household whose husband stays home with the baby. Ruffled big-girl panties did not keep me from actualizing my strong self. I agree with those who point out that kids should be taught they can do whatever they enjoy and are good at, not that in order to do or be something, they have to hide themselves.
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 4:03PM
Peyton said...These parents are completely ignorant. They have completely ignored the consequenses of their actions. First, Pop will feel left out and will feel as though s/he doesn't belong in a group. In school, they sometimes separate classrooms for group activities into boys and girls. What is s/he to do? What about using the bathroom? Or when she fills out a form, and they ask her/his sex? This 'experiment' will only last as long as the child isn't in school. her/his gender will be revealed soon enough, so I don't think any psycological side-effects will ensue.
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 4:30PM
Ppixie2 said...My sister recently had a daughter. We knew her gender before we were able to know her name. And I am very happy that she will know she is a girl. And that anything a guy can do she can do also. As long as the parents don't let their children think one sex is better then the other. The child should have no problem.
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 4:59PM
shelah said...I THINK THE PARENTS NEED TO BE INVESTIGATED! THEY THINK THEY ARE HELPING THIS CHILD, BUT WHAT THEIR REALLY DOING IS SETTING THIS CHILD UP FOR A LIFETIME OF CRUELTY AND COMPLETE CONFUSION AS TO WHO OR WHAT THEY REALLY ARE SOME PEOPLE JUST "SHOULD'NT" BE PARENTS, THEY'RE TOO STUPID!!!!!!!!!!
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 7:37PM
Becca said...The child knows who s/he is. The Child knows what sex s/he is as well. The child will not experiance any confusion. The parents are only trying to stop their society from imposing gender stereotypes on their child. They are allowing the child to play with what s/he want, dress in the cloths s/he wants, in general to be who s/he wants to be. There will be a time when it will be impossible for them to hide the child's sex from the public. I think the parents are taking this into concideration, and are ready for that. It's the early influence that they are trying to avoid.
7-01-2009 @ 5:02PM
Panda said...I believe this is a great idea. Studies have shown that those who have cling too much to their specific gender and less healthy than those who have both male and female traits. I believe that raising that raising Pop to not care about gender will be a great tool in teaching Pop to treat everyone the same regardless of gender.
My parents kind of raised me the same way,giving me the chance to pick out my own clothes and play what I wanted to play. I know many people who were so pushed to be one or the other they don't treat everyone fairly and assume that everyone is completely attatched to the fact that boys have to manly and girls have to be girly.
Reply
7-01-2009 @ 8:12PM
quinnly said...Totally agree with the part that "being different doesn't mean one is better than the other", but I have to say that there are more than 2 sexes. 1/100 ppl are born intersex (they have hormone levels, gonads or other sexual characteristics that don't match male or female). For years doctors made parents choose a sex for these babies, performed surgeries to make them look more "normative" & often the children have had identity issues there whole lives by being put into a category that they don't fit in.
I hear many ppl say I'm not going to gender stereotype my child but from the time an intersex child is born they are forced to try to fit into one category or the other. And if a sex is not assigned to that child, ppl will assign them one (and many times treat you differently based on whether they think you are m or f). For some reason its the first thing we have to know when we meet someone: are you male or female?
I'm not saying that a social experiment with a child is going to enlighten ppl or even help children with identity issues. I just want to bring awareness that biological sex and gender are not black and white issues. Maybe Pop's parents could have found a better way to bring awareness to this issue, but maybe Pop is intersex.
Reply
7-02-2009 @ 3:59AM
damoki said...quinnly, please read my comment below...
DaMoKi
7-01-2009 @ 10:04PM
Family Matters said...This might work in Swedish, but not in other languages.
This child is likely to be weird, but only time will tell if it's better weird or completely luney ;)
Reply
7-02-2009 @ 3:56AM
damoki said...quinnly,
You said, “For years doctors made parents choose a sex for these babies, performed surgeries to make them look more "normative"…” It is true that over the years, many have undergone sex assignment surgery, but your comment makes it look as though most or all do. The statistics reflect (when you include all possible situations where gender is in question) that 1 in 100 is born with bodies that do not match the “standard” definition of male or female. In response to that situation, the actual percent to have surgery is quite small (about 1 or 2 per 1000 births).
The old Intersex Society of North America (now the DSD) says in their site, “We work to build a world free of shame, secrecy, and unwanted genital surgeries for anyone born with what someone believes to be non-standard sexual anatomy.” I understand your comment regarding an additional gender category, but the ISNA/DSD states, “…intersex isn’t a discreet or natural category.” Additionally, they state the organization, “… and the majority of its constituency don’t necessarily share the goal of eradicating the very notion of gender.”
The intersex issue seems important to you, and I do not wish to degrade it, but a non-standard anatomy is not the issue for Pop’s parents who want to hide “whatever” gender this two year old is, apparently under the impression that will create an equalizing effect on his/her/its approach to others. My opinion (expanded in my first post on this subject) is they and their child would be better served by simply being great parents who set positive behavioral examples, and maintain an accepting and non-judgmental approach toward the kid’s behaviors; if what you said (Pop may be intersex) is true, he?she will benefit from great parents even more.
DaMoKi
Reply