ParentDish Editor Debates on American Girl's Homeless Doll
Categories: In The News, Weird But True, Media, Toys & Games, Single Parenting, Extreme Childhood, Opinions
Who knew a doll could cause so much controversy? On this morning's "Fox & Friends," I had the chance to enter into a debate on the appropriateness of Gwen, the American Girl doll whose story includes time spent in a homeless shelter. Take a listen.
In watching the clip again, it seems to me that one of the biggest bones of contention for my formidable opponent, Dr. Janet Rose Wojtalik, was the doll's $95 price tag. Granted, it's expensive, so I called American Girl and found out that the company donates millions of dollars in clothing and books every year to help kids in distressed situations.
And finally, as our ParentDish writer Gary Drevitch wrote to me in an e-mail, "Why would we want to send the message that girls have nothing to learn from a homeless girl? What's admirable about the A.G. series is that it gives voice to girls from all over the American experience ... telling girls they should avoid the story of a girl who was briefly homeless -- that's really the wrong message."
Recent Posts
- G.I. Joe, My Little Pony Invading TV With New Children's Network (2/09/2010)
- Movies May Influence Children's Food Choices, Study Shows (2/09/2010)
- Report Cites 220 Cases of D.C. Teachers Abusing Students (2/09/2010)
- Chicago Candidate Drops Out of Race With Tearful Child On Display (2/09/2010)
- Juicy, But Not Juice (2/09/2010)
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Karen 9-25-2009 @ 5:18PM
Dear God, the headline should read "White doll has brown eyes"! I think that's the first one I've seen. Too bad that even if I could afford a $95 doll for my child, I would never buy one. Also, I would be slightly more impressed with the company's charitable efforts if they just donated millions of dollars, not millions of dollars' worth of dolls and books. I don't know; the homeless theme seems exploited for an overpriced status symbol, but American Girl can and should cover the breadth of girls' experiences, which does sadly include homelessness.
Reply
Lia 9-26-2009 @ 5:54AM
As a woman who was in a shelter for a brief time while growing up, I think that the controversy over the doll is, to put it bluntly, stupid. I didn't grow up to be 'dependant' or 'submissive' just because I was in a homeless shelter. If anything it taught me to be more responsible and independant. I don't agree with that woman's opinion at all, and I lived through a similar experience (My father abandoning my mother)
I applaud AG for making the doll.
Reply
Michelle 9-26-2009 @ 8:35AM
Clearly, Dr. Rose's point is that a "doll" itself isn't going to teach young women about the very complex problem of homelessness. (I've read Dr. Janet Rose book, "The 7 Secrets of Parenting Girls", and it's amazing.)This is an issue that would require mature conversation in the home and frankly, most parents would buy the doll and never discuss it.. Parents who engage with their daughters don't need the doll in the first place to talk about this issue. The real issue here is are the parents capable of the skill set to talk to their daughters about homelessness in a real, meaningful way -- as it certainly isn't going to happen as the result of a doll.
And also -- this is Fox, so I'm sure they just asked these women to each pick a side to stir things up a bit -- they are both very intelligent and could have each made an argument for either side.
hindlist 9-26-2009 @ 6:49AM
Yes i do think in the same way. Dear editor you are right.
http://www.hindlist.com
Reply
david Perez 9-27-2009 @ 5:41PM
If you would like a job in sales; please contact us at : www.gogetitcheaper.com
This is a new start up company with a lot of potential for those with ambition.
TYPE IN :33351 IN BROWSE THE DIRECTORY AND LOOK AT THE LISTINGS.
Your City can be the next to have newest and greatest way to shop.
Become an Independent Client representative in your community.
Reply