Hot Topic: Parent Sportsmanship Worse Than Ever?
Filed under: Opinions
Is parent sportsmanship at our kids' games in a steep decline?
That's an easy one to answer, since examples of adults behaving badly on youth sports sidelines are about as easy to find as the games themselves.
Today we heard about former Oakland Raiders player Jeremy Brigham, who went to blows with Alameda County supervisor Scott Haggerty. According to the San Francisco Chronicle, Brigham accused Haggerty - "whom he had just fired as the assistant coach of his Pleasanton squad of 10- and 11-year-old boys" - of leaking plays to an opposing pee-wee football team. This scuffle is under investigation.
And just last month, a football practice near Boston abruptly turned into a bizarre boxing match between a father of a young player and the team's coach. Pop Warner is the largest national youth football league for kids not yet in high school. The Boston Globe reported that the father suffered serious injuries, the coach was suspended and the small community of Wilmington was thrown off-balance by the incident.
Michael VonKahle was escorting his 12-year-old-son Tyler to football practice. The VonKahles arrived 10 minutes late whereupon the coach, William Reynolds, instructed Tyler to run some laps to make up for missing the start of the workout.
Tyler's father objected, saying that he was responsible for the mistake, not his son, according to an account in the Globe.
The two men moved their argument away from the practice. Then punches flew. According to the police report cited by the Globe, each man accused the other of throwing the first punch. VonKahle's injuries included a broken nose, a concussion and a damaged eye socket. Reynolds has been charged with aggravated assault and battery, The Globe reported.
It isn't the only alleged example of really bad behavior at youth sports events of late. In Monaca, Penn., the father of a high school football player got into an argument with a referee at halftime. Before it was over, police had subdued the football dad, Thomas Phillips, with a Taser, according to Pennsylvania's Beaver County Times.
These incidents contribute to the perception that adults are poor role models for good sportsmanship. In fact, when adults were asked about modern sportsmanship behavior, 80 percent of those older than 60 remember their earlier days as more civil.
Could it be that we simply hear more about rude, overbearing sports parents than we did in years past, thanks to CNN, ESPN and Web sites like this one? Is it possible that though parent behavior at youth sports games can be rude, even loutish, that their parents were just as obnoxious and vulgar back in the day?
Related: More on Sports
ParentDish sports reporter Mark Hyman is the author of Until It Hurts: America's Obsession With Youth Sports and How It Harms Our Kids (Beacon Press) Have a suggestion for an article on youth sports? Contact Mark at pdyouthsports@aol.com.











ReaderComments (Page 4 of 4)
11-06-2009 @ 5:04AM
Sparkina said...I think that these parents have to stop thinking that their little athletes are going to grow up to be the next Joe DiMaggio or something. Most kids who play youth sports grow up to be plain old "normal" adults with "normal" jobs and lives, and the main point of youth sports is for kids to have fun, get exercise, learn how to function in a group, and learn how to behave in society.
Reply
11-06-2009 @ 5:22AM
Gary said...I could see this trend starting 30 years ago, which is exactly why I didn't go into coaching. When I was playing sports in the 70s most parents let the coaches handle the kids and things on the field, and for the most part coaches back then were fair, although a few always favored their sons over other more talented players. As time went on more and more parents were beginning to act out verbally and physically toward coaches when they thought their sons weren't getting a fair shake. It should also be noted that there appears to be an obvious correlation between the number of spoiled brats and their parents who exhibit this aggressive behavior. In my opinion parents have become too protective of their kids and therefore lose control when they think something isn't going their way. These parents, themselves, were likely spoiled brats back in the 70s, which could explain their tendency to 'act out' aggressively today.
Reply
11-06-2009 @ 5:25AM
Bige128 said...My husband has been coaching our boys in football and baseball for the past 6 years. The lack of commitment and common sense of the parents has been the biggest obstacle. Parents all think that their kid should be the most played stars of the teams, instead of just allowing the kid to have fun and be part of a team. They don't cheer on for the entire team, just sit in the stands and bitch about how much time their kid is on the field. They overlook any errors that their kids make when they are playing, but loudly complain about other kids mistakes (not even realizing that the parents or family members are within listening range). They also make it clear what they think the coaches are doing wrong. Coaches are not perfect, and there are some that are better than others, and some that should not be out there. Regardless, they are volunteering their time. Many parents drop their kids off at practices and show up 20 minutes late to pick them up. They are not babysitters, and deserve a little more respect than they get from most parents that want to complain instead of do something to help the team, or even spend extra time practicing with their kid so they are better on the field. They also can't be expected to make exceptions for kids that are involved in other activites that interfere with practices or games. That wouldn't be fair to the other kids that are always there, because they made a choice to be.
Reply
11-07-2010 @ 1:17PM
Allison said...I am the mother of a 13 year old girl who plays ice hockey. I view sports as a life lesson....you sign up, you attend practice, you attend games...on time. You work hard you are rewarded, you goof off you ride the pines. As far as the dad getting mad his son had to run laps, that shouldn't be deemed as punishment...warming up is to prevent injury. And parents need to stop living vicariously through their children. I was given great advice when she started playing hockey...ask your kids 2 things when they get off the ice...did you have fun? where do you want to eat? (my daughter actually told me once that when I told her to skate harder it made her want to slow down...I immediately resumed spectating). Our children's lives are their own and whatever sport they choose should be for their enjoyment, not to fulfill some unrealized dream of the parent. Leave the ref's alone, leave the coaches alone and leave your kid alone. Unless something illegal, immoral, or unsafe is happening on the field/gym...just sit back, let the coaches coach, the ref's ref and let your kid play the game. If they win great..if they lose too bad, that's life! Best get used to it at some point.
Reply