My Favorite Baby Names Don't Work Together
Filed under: Baby Names
Dear Name Lady:
I have always loved the names Vesper (for a girl) and Kaspar (for a boy) ... but people laugh when I say them together, and I can see why. They are rare names and they have similar structures. I came upon them at different times but adore them both equally! I've thought of variations but in the end I wouldn't use them, it would take away from what I love about these names. Will I have to wait to see which gender comes first and then say goodbye to the other name?
- V or K?
Vesper and Kaspar are an unusual pair, but your basic dilemma is more common than you might think. Lots of parents fall in love with incompatible names. Choosing Charlie for a boy means you can't name a future girl Charlotte. Tyler means no Taylor, Jack means no Jill, Houston means no Whitney. You may yearn for both, but you have to pick one.It sounds like you've already accepted this reality, which is half the battle. Giving up on a favorite name requires a little grieving process, complete with the "bargaining" stage. ("If I'm careful to introduce them as Jill and Jack instead of Jack and Jill, maybe nobody will notice?") Now you have to decide how to proceed.
Here's the first step. Quick, if you had to choose just one of the two names right now, which would it be?
If you froze in panic at that question, your answer is simple. First come, first served. Life is unpredictable. There's no guarantee that you'll be blessed with a second child -- or that you'll have both boys and girls. If you go with whichever name the ultrasound points to, you know at least that you'll be able to name a child one of your favorite names.
Perhaps, though, you read the question and knew immediately that you'd choose Vesper. Not all "first choices" are created equal, after all. In that case, it's time to look for an alternative to Kaspar to keep the possibility of Vesper alive. This approach is riskier; you could end up with neither. But when one name alone is dearest to your heart, I think it's worth giving yourself the best chance of bestowing that name on a child.
Have you hit sibling name dilemmas? Share your experiences! And if you have your own question to Ask the Name Lady, drop her a line!
Related: Sibling Names Require Individual Thought
I have always loved the names Vesper (for a girl) and Kaspar (for a boy) ... but people laugh when I say them together, and I can see why. They are rare names and they have similar structures. I came upon them at different times but adore them both equally! I've thought of variations but in the end I wouldn't use them, it would take away from what I love about these names. Will I have to wait to see which gender comes first and then say goodbye to the other name?
- V or K?
Vesper and Kaspar are an unusual pair, but your basic dilemma is more common than you might think. Lots of parents fall in love with incompatible names. Choosing Charlie for a boy means you can't name a future girl Charlotte. Tyler means no Taylor, Jack means no Jill, Houston means no Whitney. You may yearn for both, but you have to pick one.It sounds like you've already accepted this reality, which is half the battle. Giving up on a favorite name requires a little grieving process, complete with the "bargaining" stage. ("If I'm careful to introduce them as Jill and Jack instead of Jack and Jill, maybe nobody will notice?") Now you have to decide how to proceed.
Here's the first step. Quick, if you had to choose just one of the two names right now, which would it be?
If you froze in panic at that question, your answer is simple. First come, first served. Life is unpredictable. There's no guarantee that you'll be blessed with a second child -- or that you'll have both boys and girls. If you go with whichever name the ultrasound points to, you know at least that you'll be able to name a child one of your favorite names.
Perhaps, though, you read the question and knew immediately that you'd choose Vesper. Not all "first choices" are created equal, after all. In that case, it's time to look for an alternative to Kaspar to keep the possibility of Vesper alive. This approach is riskier; you could end up with neither. But when one name alone is dearest to your heart, I think it's worth giving yourself the best chance of bestowing that name on a child.
Have you hit sibling name dilemmas? Share your experiences! And if you have your own question to Ask the Name Lady, drop her a line!
Related: Sibling Names Require Individual Thought












ReaderComments (Page 1 of 7)
12-01-2009 @ 9:10PM
jen106 said...Aside from the religious overtones, Vesper to me sounds like a redneck trying to say "Vespa", as in "Hey, ya'll, didja see that Vesper motorscooter?"
Which is too bad, because it could be a pretty name.
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 12:07AM
karen said...jen106 12-01-2009 @ 9:10PM
Aside from the religious overtones, Vesper to me sounds like a redneck trying to say "Vespa", as in "Hey, ya'll, didja see that Vesper motorscooter?"
Which is too bad, because it could be a pretty name.
***
FYI, the only "rednecks" that might say ves-PER trying to get out the word Vespa....probably are from New England. They are the ones that put ER on words that never had them. In Oklahoma there are some that screw up vowel sounds, and some might use double or even, on occasion, TRIPLE negatives, but NEVER would anyone I've ever met here add "ER" on the end of a word that ends in "A". For that you'd have to go to the ultimate "redneck", Teddy Kennedy. He probably had a 'vesper' when he was a kid for tooling around in the compound...
12-02-2009 @ 2:06AM
Clint said...Karen's right Jen. And how the hell can you degrade ANYONE and then in the same breath say that "Vesper" is a pretty name. And for your info, "rednecks" aren't TRYING to pronounce anything. WE say the words exactly the way we want to. I'm from the deep south, lady and I'm as redneck as they get. I also got a perfect score in the english comp. section of the S.A.T., which I took in the 7th grade, have a clinically tested I.Q. of 146 and will talk like a "redneck" 'til I die. What you got, darlin'?
12-02-2009 @ 2:30AM
Jennifer said...Karen - I'm from New England, near Boston. You have it backwards, we usually chop off the R in words. Instead of Gloucester, we might say Glostah. My name is Jennifer, I'm always hearing Jennifah, or even Gin-if-ah. My son even has a t-shirt poking fun at it, it reads "Wicked Smaht". People often "Pahk the Cah in Havad Yad"
12-02-2009 @ 2:35AM
Boricua said...Well Karen, using the word 'probably" to prove a point isn't the way to go. Unless you know for a fact that New Englanders say that then you shouldn't comment.
Clint, where to start with you? First off, she was going by the stereotypical redneck language. It's well known that redneck's language isn't proper.Alot of the words are often misplaced with one word, misspelled, and there are many incomplete sentences. As for your 7th grade english section on the SAT..lol that was when you were in 7th grade and your not the first redneck to have some education. I'm not saying all of you rednecks are dumb. Just the majority. Also, another thing that bothered me, even though it was a small mistake....Jen did not degrade anyone and then say it was a pretty name in one breath because first of all :it was typed so she literally didn't say anything, and there was a period at the end of her "degrading" remark, so if anything it would be counted as a new sentence, meaning she would have to stop and take another breath to say, but your a redneck and you aced your 7th grade english section on your SAT and you have a high IQ so I'm pretty sure you knew that. LOL
12-01-2009 @ 9:12PM
Rin said...I have a nephew-in-law Jack, and a niece-in-law Jill.... and yes, they are brother and sister...... Thankfully, Jill is quite a few years older than Jack, and they have two other siblings... (also "J" names) But I could never do that to my kids!!!! Other names that don't gel: Daniel & Danielle. Michael & Michelle. All those rhyme-y "twin" names that twins should never have to put up with!!
Reply
12-01-2009 @ 10:48PM
PhilG said...There was a hospital where my mother-in-law once worked; the new mother was looking at a medical book and was trying to decide baby names between 'Syphallis' and 'Gonrea'.
12-02-2009 @ 10:29PM
Pam Morgan said...My husband's name is Jack and his sister's is Jill. I laughed when I first heard it and asked if he got teased a lot. He said, "No." That ended that conversation. lol I asked my mother-in-law why she did that and she said his dad wanted a Jr. therefore the name Jack and she always loved Jill since she was a little girl so she named her first daughter that. Well to each his own!
12-04-2009 @ 8:19PM
feistycat said...That stuff about people using medical terms as baby names is an urban legend. I've heard it a thousand times from "people who know someone who works in a hospital". Nobody has named their baby placenta or meconium either.
12-01-2009 @ 9:18PM
blackpox said...i once knew a police officer who's last name was Crook. she named her son 'Chase"
Reply
12-01-2009 @ 9:18PM
NewEnglandBonnie said...hmmm...Pepper ot Taser....Taser or Pepper....hmmmmm
(You've gotta be kidding me that the only response so far is an ad).
I had a girl's name picked and had a boy. Took two weeks for this family to finally name our "Jake". A bit of an accelerator was his 8 & 10 y/o brothers referring to him as "it" after a lot of non gender specific talk about "the baby".
Reply
12-01-2009 @ 9:21PM
Karen said...Siblings are a set for only a short while. I say go for both names, if you end up with a boy and a girl. Or you could put the name of the gender that comes second in the middle. e.g. Anne Vesper Lastname. That's what we ended up doing with my favorite boy's name to make our 2 sons' names work.
Reply
12-01-2009 @ 9:38PM
robert said...My last name is Wood and if I have a girl her name will be Holly! If she becomes a stripper she's all set!
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:35AM
Marian said...My daughter went to school with a girl whose name was Holly. She got married to a classmate whose last name was Wood. She took a lot of ribbing when she got pregnant and the entire school was trying to help her name the baby. She vetoed names like Dolly, Woody and even Holly Two Wood. I wish I could remember what she named the baby!
12-28-2009 @ 11:48PM
Good Grief said...My name is Holly and I dated a guy with the last name Day. That was short-lived.
12-01-2009 @ 9:48PM
Nancy W said...My cousins are Kiethie and Craigie and Paulie - which were cutesy names when they were 3, but now they are in their 40s and they just sound stupid. When you name your kids, don't just think of how the names will sound together, but, how that name will fit a middle-aged man or someone's grandmother, because that is what your cute little baby will oneday be.
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 10:54AM
Thithee said...Nancy, you are so right. I worked for a college once and there was the most adorable student there named Bambi. Yep, Bambi. She was in Hotel management and imagine trying to have people (especially men) take you seriously in meetings! Why didn't her parents name her Barbara or something and just call their sweet little baby Bambi. Then she'd have a choice! She could be the CEO of some big company and be Barbara, or maybe run a daycare and go by Bambi, or whatever. I really feel sorry for those kids that are stuck with the one (cutsie) name!
12-01-2009 @ 9:46PM
Crystal said...Hey, it would be YOUR childrens' names, not any other person's opinion (other than hubby or s/o's) business! You might forever regret not naming the child your "dream" name. And as for other children potentially teasing your children-to-be, kids will ALWAYS find a reason to pick on other kids for any reason! Follow your heart! No regrets!
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:50AM
toomanysox said...Offspring are not dolls placed before you to enact your long held fantasies, they are human beings in their own right. It is perfectly reasonable to consider the consequences of a name choice.
12-01-2009 @ 9:59PM
nikki vee said...As someone (originally) given a "distinctive" name at birth, please, let me urge prospective parents to give up their selfish need to appear clever, chic, or whatever among THEIR peers. Their children's peers won't find strange names nearly as smart or stylish. Even if your child might, ultimately, grow fond of his or her peculiar name, that fondness won't be more powerful than the years of childhood teasing s/he had to suffer for it. Perhaps if you earn milions-upon-millions of dollars and provide a social atmoshere in which other kids are named Brooklyn, Phinnaeus, or Pilot Inspektor, your kid might survive being called "Apple", but otherwise? Not so much. YOU grow up!
Reply