Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Charlotte Robinson: LISTEN: How Gay And Lesbian Couples Become…
New Turnaround Teacher 'Trying To Get It Right' In Tough School
My Favorite Baby Names Don't Work Together
Filed under: Baby Names
Dear Name Lady:
I have always loved the names Vesper (for a girl) and Kaspar (for a boy) ... but people laugh when I say them together, and I can see why. They are rare names and they have similar structures. I came upon them at different times but adore them both equally! I've thought of variations but in the end I wouldn't use them, it would take away from what I love about these names. Will I have to wait to see which gender comes first and then say goodbye to the other name?
- V or K?
Vesper and Kaspar are an unusual pair, but your basic dilemma is more common than you might think. Lots of parents fall in love with incompatible names. Choosing Charlie for a boy means you can't name a future girl Charlotte. Tyler means no Taylor, Jack means no Jill, Houston means no Whitney. You may yearn for both, but you have to pick one.It sounds like you've already accepted this reality, which is half the battle. Giving up on a favorite name requires a little grieving process, complete with the "bargaining" stage. ("If I'm careful to introduce them as Jill and Jack instead of Jack and Jill, maybe nobody will notice?") Now you have to decide how to proceed.
Here's the first step. Quick, if you had to choose just one of the two names right now, which would it be?
If you froze in panic at that question, your answer is simple. First come, first served. Life is unpredictable. There's no guarantee that you'll be blessed with a second child -- or that you'll have both boys and girls. If you go with whichever name the ultrasound points to, you know at least that you'll be able to name a child one of your favorite names.
Perhaps, though, you read the question and knew immediately that you'd choose Vesper. Not all "first choices" are created equal, after all. In that case, it's time to look for an alternative to Kaspar to keep the possibility of Vesper alive. This approach is riskier; you could end up with neither. But when one name alone is dearest to your heart, I think it's worth giving yourself the best chance of bestowing that name on a child.
Have you hit sibling name dilemmas? Share your experiences! And if you have your own question to Ask the Name Lady, drop her a line!
Related: Sibling Names Require Individual Thought
I have always loved the names Vesper (for a girl) and Kaspar (for a boy) ... but people laugh when I say them together, and I can see why. They are rare names and they have similar structures. I came upon them at different times but adore them both equally! I've thought of variations but in the end I wouldn't use them, it would take away from what I love about these names. Will I have to wait to see which gender comes first and then say goodbye to the other name?
- V or K?
Vesper and Kaspar are an unusual pair, but your basic dilemma is more common than you might think. Lots of parents fall in love with incompatible names. Choosing Charlie for a boy means you can't name a future girl Charlotte. Tyler means no Taylor, Jack means no Jill, Houston means no Whitney. You may yearn for both, but you have to pick one.It sounds like you've already accepted this reality, which is half the battle. Giving up on a favorite name requires a little grieving process, complete with the "bargaining" stage. ("If I'm careful to introduce them as Jill and Jack instead of Jack and Jill, maybe nobody will notice?") Now you have to decide how to proceed.
Here's the first step. Quick, if you had to choose just one of the two names right now, which would it be?
If you froze in panic at that question, your answer is simple. First come, first served. Life is unpredictable. There's no guarantee that you'll be blessed with a second child -- or that you'll have both boys and girls. If you go with whichever name the ultrasound points to, you know at least that you'll be able to name a child one of your favorite names.
Perhaps, though, you read the question and knew immediately that you'd choose Vesper. Not all "first choices" are created equal, after all. In that case, it's time to look for an alternative to Kaspar to keep the possibility of Vesper alive. This approach is riskier; you could end up with neither. But when one name alone is dearest to your heart, I think it's worth giving yourself the best chance of bestowing that name on a child.
Have you hit sibling name dilemmas? Share your experiences! And if you have your own question to Ask the Name Lady, drop her a line!
Related: Sibling Names Require Individual Thought












ReaderComments (Page 5 of 7)
12-02-2009 @ 1:01AM
misty said...my first name is misty which i like but... my middle name is rojeania. took me years to learn how to spell that. & i have twin sisters named candy jolene & sandy colene. boy they rhyme. my parents had too much time on their hands. lol
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:54AM
Theresa Hartman said...My parents named my sister Marguerite (nickname: Gretchen), then my brother Hansel. My sister used to get so mad when people would call her "Gretel". Not only that, but they bought my brother lederhosen, and put Gretchen's hair in braids daily! They lived through it, and now live thousands of miles apart.
I also know a family where they had a daughter named Christina, then when they had twins, they named them Christian and Christine. They also have a daughter named. . . you guessed it! . . . Vesper!
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 12:59AM
goodbuddy said...Possibly the worst name was that of my high school principle... Jackson Goff, yup that is right Jack Goff!
Or there is my friend who's daughters name is Lily and her sisters kids names Leif and Autum
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:54AM
Theresa Hartman said...I went to school with a girl named Rose Theresa, and her sister, Theresa Theresa, who used to title her math papers Theresa squared (only she'd put the little numeral 2). Her nickname? Tootie. (Get it? Two T) Was she the inspiration for the boarding school character on TV? The world may never know!
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:20AM
Jazz said...Well i have grandaughters named Ocean and Tru. i was just as concerned as some here, but they love their names and can take good-natured ribbings about it.:) and surprisingly.. we have met several other girls who share those names. :)
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 11:35AM
pam payne said...I live in East Texas and worked for a Bank at one time. We had an elderly customer whose real name was "Fannie Smelly".
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:23AM
kwood said...I worked at a private boarding school for teenagers with emotional problems. A very depressed girls was named Hope Leslie.
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:31AM
Lia said...Those poor children will only and forever, in school anyway (and perhaps beyond), be known as "Kaspar the friendly ghost" and "Vesper the motorscooter". Parents who give their children oddball names are selfish, hoping to draw attention to themselves every single day of their childrens' existence. I went to school with a Donald Duckley. His parents laughed heartily every time someone made a joke about it, while poor Donald died a quiet death every time the laughing started.
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:32AM
Brandy said...I went to school with a kid named Grady O'Grady, and another named Fernando Fernandez. Oh, and a girl named Brooke Lynn Bridge. And a boy named Abraham Lincoln.
What were these parents THINKING?!!!!!
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:33AM
tracy said...I knew a boy in school named Terrell. Went from 1st-8th with him, never thought his name was funny. Until one day I was telling a story about him and said his full name..........Terrell Bull. Poor kid, he was always in trouble.
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:36AM
robin said...My brother went to school with a Richard Head. Yes, of course they all called him Dick Head. When I was a teacher in Atlanta, I had a Nick Head. Great kid though. He was the 8th grade quarterback. But, I also had a female student with the name Chittapong Kaysavong. Her first name was pronounced "shit-upon". To save the poor child, I called EVERY child in that class that year by their LAST name so as to never have to call her Chittapong (Shitupon). Her brother had a strange first name as well but he went by Hank.
:-))
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:37AM
Lia said...Angela, please don't name your son Kaydence. The nicknames will be Kay or Dence (dense). If there is a marching band at his school, every time they mention "cadence", Kaydence will be ridiculed. The kids will be sarcastically marching down the hall saying his name.
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:38AM
tracy said...and how could I forget all the twins..........Ann and Jan, Lori and Lorne (boy), Kerry and Kelly, and my personal favorite Mona and Lisa.
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:53AM
lito102366 said...When I was pregnant with my son, my husband wanted to name him after his dad, so we decided to make his middle name Lee (his dads name). I was dead set on my favorite boys name of all time, Brock. Put them together broccolli!! Needless to say my sons name is Brandon Lee!
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:50AM
Karen said...My daughter is an elementary school teacher. At the beginning of the school year, she has a list of her students names and makes folders for each one. I was visiting and told her I would write out the names on all of the folders. One girl was given the name Philomina Peruzzi-Williamson (not real name, but close). Her name did not fit on the tab of the folder. I had to add another tab just so her name would fit. These poor students have to go through their whole lives with some of the unfortunate names their parents have given them. Parents, wake up and don't try to be different or unique. Is the hypen absolutely necessary, or is this your ego? This is your child, be proud. My children thank me all the time for their names. They are not unusual, but how can you go wrong with Sarah, Bridget, and James?
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:51AM
Brandy said...My Geometry teacher's name was Les Jakofsky. Of course, the student's all turned it into "Let's Jack Off".
There was a guy in high school named Jack Frost. Super nice guy, but damn, were his parents HIGH when they named him?!!!
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 1:55AM
Samantha said...I have a dilemma that I am hoping someone on here can help me with. I am pregnant with my first child. We do not know the gender and will not find out until the birth, but at the rate we are going there will be an argument in the delivery room. We have settled on a girl name (Lillie Grace) But for the boy my husband insists on naming him after him, now that's not what bugs me. My husbands name is Richard Scott. He goes by Richard therefore calling the child that is out of the question. I hate the nicknames Richie or Jrm and I had a previous Awful relationship with a guy named Scott. I don't want to think of him everytime someone says my child's name. I tried to get him to compromise with the same first name but different middle and he refused. What to do???
Reply
12-02-2009 @ 2:12AM
Samantha said...If your husband can't recognize the fact that the name Scott bothers you so much, because of an awful past relationship, which is understandable. I would never name my kid Travis for the same reason. I think you have more issues than what to name your kid.
12-02-2009 @ 11:18AM
VW said...my friends brother Richard Jr goes by Ricky. Well. Rick now that he's out of college. My brother Richard has always been Richie Rich. You can call him anything..... R.J. for Richard Jr, , Hardy as in ricHARD, My hubby Tom Jr has always been TC to his family even though his initials are TBW. its short for Top Cat, the nickname he picked up at age 2,
12-02-2009 @ 12:53PM
sam said...Thank you so much! You gave me nicknames we hadn't thought of. I love ricky and RJ so it looks like we have a compromise. You have no idea how much you've helped!