You Can't Hold Back Nicknames
Filed under: Baby Names
My column on parents who loved the name Edmund but cringed at nicknames Eddie and Ned spurred a flood of reader letters. One message came through loud and clear: Parents, if you think you'll get to control your child's nickname forever, think again. In the long run, it's his name and he and his friends will determine what he's going to be called. Here's a sampling of tales from the nickname trenches:
"Our son is named Christopher and we have always called him that. Always. I found out this week that his friends at school call him Chris, except when they call and ask for him. And -- he prefers Chris. Who knew?"
"Have you noticed that it seems to be the child's friends who dictate the nickname? I named my son Daniel, which turned into Dan or Danny, but most often he is called Murph -- his last name is Murphy."
"We have a beautiful daughter we named Cassidy. Cute, huh? As she got older her auburn hair became the focal point of conversation everywhere we went. She is a lovely 15-year-old whose friends now call her 'REDD.'"
"When my daughter was born 20 years ago we chose the name Elizabeth, partly because it lent itself to so many nicknames that we were sure to find one that suited her. What we found, though, is she prefers the full, formal Elizabeth."
"My son's name is Nicholas and I tried very hard for it to stay at Nicholas, but my son, friends, teachers, coaches and just about everyone but me decided to shorten to Nick, which I can't stand. So I call him Nicholas and the rest call him Nick."
"At least Eddie is somewhat close to the full first name. Me, I've been called Mr. Spock and The Jolly Fisherman in high school and, for some reason, Sunshine while serving in the Marine Corps."
Have a question of your own to Ask the Name Lady? Drop her a line!
Related: More from The Name Lady
Your<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- 50 million people vote and 25% do not vote for you =12.5 million would you really want your image on tv after position ended(you r your entity
- Do I report my friend's kid to the police?
- Alot of .gov when submitting a program or proposal for government agency (be sure you personally can provide for the agency)











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
12-31-2009 @ 7:26PM
mb said...o.m.g...funny...I agree, friends nickname friends!!! Im a firm believer of "nicknames"...and actually, i've said recently I cant recall their real names...I have a brother we call scully, my b.f.f.is squirrel..fuzzy face is my boss..and the other day they said what is ugly cousins real name?? hmm idk..p.s..im harry, and im female..im sure we make our parents proud...because what is in a name???
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 9:39PM
Shannon said...My 14 month-old daughter is Penelope Jane. I HATE the nicknames Penny and I hate P.J.
My husband has called her P.J. since birth (or maybe in the womb) and some others do too. My sister calls her "Pen". Hate it. She is also called "Miss P" by friends at church which cracks me up.
I call her Penelope Jane and always will. I have resigned myself to the fact that others may have nicknames for her that make me cringe. Sigh.
Reply
12-07-2010 @ 8:36AM
Debra Hathaway said...I would never think of giving my baby that name ...it it aweful ?
But I would go with Penny...it is girly and dainty ...............
By the way" MERRY CHRISTMAS"