Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Maria Lianos-Carbone: 8 Simple Things to Do on Valentine's Day
Jodee Blanco: Schools That Stonewall: What to Do If Your Child Is…
Children's Health Insurance Program's Future Uncertain
Filed under: In The News
Sen. John Rockefeller (D-W.Va) has fought to keep the Children's Health Insurance Program in the Senate's Health Care Reform Bill. Credit: Alex Wong, Getty Images
The biggest questions revolve around the Children's Health Insurance Program. CHIP covers more than nine million children and pregnant women. However, it may be a square peg that doesn't fit any of health care reform's round holes.
The House version of the health care bill kills CHIP. It puts children on Medicare or directs their families to buy them private insurance with financial assistance from the federal government.
This concerns organizations such as the Urban Institute, a Washington-based public interest research group, The New York Times reports.
"Attention must be paid to the possibility that some children who lose CHIP coverage could fall through the cracks and become uninsured," Genevieve M. Kenney and Allison Cook wrote last month in a brief prepared for the group.
Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Calif., tells the Times it's hard to justify government footing the bill for children once families have access to subsidies.
But it's not that simple, Jocelyn A. Guyer tells the Times. She's the co-executive director of the Center for Children and Families at Georgetown University.
Between CHIP and Medicaid, the United States has made huge strides in providing health coverage for low-income children, she tells the newspaper.
"It would be a major problem if health reform undercut these gains by shutting CHIP down too abruptly or by moving kids into coverage that isn't as affordable and as well-designed to get them the care they need to develop and grow," she adds.
Then there is the problem of immigrant children. Some have a parent who is in the country illegally. Both the Senate and House versions of the bill refuse subsidies for illegal immigrants.
The Times reports that this could eliminate health insurance for 14 percent of the children now getting help. The Senate and House bills provide for child-only insurance policies, but it's unclear how those policies would work in the face of immigration issues, the Times reports.
The House and Senate bills also push people to buy employer-sponsored health insurance, except when it would be too expensive for low-income workers. But then that's why CHIP was created. Many workers already enroll their children in the program because private coverage is too costly.
Democratic Sens. John Rockefeller of West Virginia and Robert Casey of Pennsylvania are pushing Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid of Nevada to extend CHIP funding for two more years to make sure there are no rude surprises for children currently in the program.
Rockefeller tells the Times he's willing to go to war with his colleagues to preserve CHIP.
"I am not going to drop kids," he tells the paper.












ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
1-05-2010 @ 10:22AM
LS said...I see a couple of issues that need addressing in this situation.
First, governmental health insurance. We like to couch this issue in language like “healthcare”. It is NOT health CARE. It is health INSURANCE. There is a massive difference, but we have allowed the language to confuse us. Health CARE – and excellent health care – is available to every single person who walks into an emergency room, regardless of ability to pay. Will they receive a private room and a personal nurse? No. Will they receive life-saving treatment? Yes. Will they receive assistance in figuring out how much they should/can pay? Yes. I’ve lived it.
Health INSURANCE is NOT a right. It is a privilege. Not everybody can have, nor should they need, insurance. And to that end, the very best thing that the government can do is to back the hell off. Get OUT of the situation altogether.
It is ridiculous governmental interference that has landed us in this deplorable situation in the first place. In the misguided effort to “help the children” and then the elderly, the government created the debacles known as Medicaid and Medicare. Those institutions pay ridiculously low reimbursements to doctors, hospitals, etc. The insurance companies then follow suit. If Dr. Jones is going to take only $20 from the government, then why should the insurance company pay him $30 for the same service? So they only pay $20. Dr. Jones can’t refuse the government – in many places, that is illegal – so he MUST accept that ridiculously low amount. But he can’t run his business on that either, so he has to charge the guy without insurance ridiculous fees. It’s a massive catch-22, because then that guy won’t go to the doctor, because he can’t afford it, and he can’t afford insurance. So he goes without, and an emergency happens, he goes to the hospital, takes advantage of that free care available, and is now a further burden on the system.
If the government got OUT of the insurance business, and allowed the market to reset itself, I submit that perhaps it would be more affordable. Would people be able to have *anything* they wanted? Would they be able to walk in and have breast implants and birth control for free? No. Why should they? But, would they be able to see their doctor for a reasonable fee? Yes. Would the prices for hospital care, drugs, etc. come down? The rules of economics state that they will.
Perhaps it would reset another problem, as well. We have become such a “gimme” society, we EXPECT that our health care fees should be pathetically low or non-existent. Why? Why shouldn’t we have to pay for the service we receive? Does that doctor not deserve to be paid for his expertise? You willingly shell out $500 to the mechanic who fixes your car, why would you balk at shelling out $500 to the guy who can potentially keep you alive?
What would be so horrible about a society that does not have “co-pay” insurance plans, but plans that will cover the big stuff, but requires people to pay for their basic health upkeep? What’s so horrible about budgeting $300 PER YEAR to have a full physical exam/blood work to stay ahead of any potential health problems. Perhaps, if that was the case, we’d have a much healthier society and those illnesses – heart disease, diabetes – that cost so much could be greatly reduced.
The second issue that needs to be addressed is that of “illegal immigrants”. Everybody wants to make this such a huge issue. Frankly, it’s not. I’m sorry to be callous about this, but if they are in the country ILLEGALLY, they don’t deserve to take advantage of the programs that are set up for citizens. If they need medical attention, fine, go to the ER, get the treatment, then leave the country. Or pay for it. If you want to live here, do it right. We welcome you with open arms, if you’re willing to follow the rules, get a job, pay your taxes. But so often, we are so worried about offending people that we won’t stand up for what’s right. “Illegal immigrants” are just that. Illegal. They are BREAKING THE LAW. Why should they then be allowed to take advantage of programs? Why should they be encouraged to do so?
The likely response is, “but the children…” They are not my children. They are not your children. Again, sorry to sound callous, but those children belong to parents. And those parents are making the CHOICE to break the laws of our country. Why, then, should they be rewarded with governmental money and with citizenship? Because once they have a child here – and don’t kid yourself that many don’t come here to have “anchor babies” – they now have the sympathies of those with soft hearts who don’t want to hurt the children, so they’re allowed to stay.
It’s bankrupting our country. It is time that we stood up and said, “no more.” If you want health care, it’s available. Pay for it. If you don’t have insurance, get a job so you can afford it. If you don’t like the insurance system, do NOT get the government involved – they screw up everything that they touch. Think they don’t? How much fraud is there in the Medicaid/Medicare system? For the love of all that’s holy, that’s one of the things that Congress is relying on to pay for this stupid “healthcare reform” … tracking down all the fraud!! If they can’t stop it now, why should we believe that they can stop it once the bill passes?
Reply
1-05-2010 @ 2:42PM
Emily said...Great comment, LS. Everyone thinks things will be so great once they have this "free" health care, without stopping to think that the government will be deciding what is provided and what isn't. And for all of the things not provided, will supplemental private insurance even be an option? Who knows. Some provinces in Canada did not allow supplemental insurance until it was challenged under their constitution, because the government didn't believe it was "fair" to allow people who worked hard and could afford it to get better care.
Reply
1-05-2010 @ 8:50PM
SKL said...I don't feel healthcare is a right OR a privilege. It's a purchased service (or a charitable act, in some cases). Same thing with health insurance. If you work hard, it's on the list of things you can buy. If not, oh well, choices have consequences. Or has the term "consequence" completely lost its meaning? (I fear it has.)
As for children - yeah - did I just hear this liberal Website admit that these kids have deadbeats for parents, who won't do the right thing even if they could? What??? No way, that must be a typo.
But if it's true, then where is the outrage about this whole health bill? This whole comprehensive debacle, this utter monstrosity? Do you think the children of deadbeats are the only people who are going to be worse off under this plan? Just about everyone will be - other than the bureaucrats and politicians who are guilty of this outrage. So go, march on Washington if you really care about these poor, helpless souls who currently GET FREE CARE in this utterly evil, compassionless society.
Reply
1-06-2010 @ 9:51AM
Emily said...From the lack of comments in favor of government health insurance, it appears that perhaps people are finally becoming enlightened and realizing what a pathetic thing the health care bill really is! Even on this Web site! (If only they could have realized it before electing all of those corrupt politicians to office....)
Reply
1-06-2010 @ 7:07PM
LS said...either that, or they show up here, see those stupid ads, and leave. :/