Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Zoe Armstrong: Five Ways to Fake a Break and Avoid Parenting Burnout
How To Help Victims Of The Tornado
Parents Outraged Over Drunk Bus Driver's Punishment
Filed under: In The News
A school bus driver who drove 37 students while intoxicated was sentenced to five years probation and jail time, but some parents of her terrified passengers say the punishment is not nearly harsh enough.
According to the "CBS Early Show," bus driver Martha Thompson, 56, of Almond, N.Y. pleaded guilty Nov. 2, 2009, to 37 counts of child endangerment and driving while intoxicated on May 8, 2009, while students screamed and begged her to stop. On Jan. 4, the Allegany County Court sentenced her to six months of electronic home monitoring, five years of probation, 12 weekends in jail and mandatory alcohol counseling. She was also fined $1,000.
A video captured the frightening ride, during which several students beg Thompson to pull over. The "Early Show" reports that her blood alcohol level was .15, almost twice the New York state legal limit of .08 percent.
Grace Scherzer, 16, and Chelsey Pierce, 15, were on board that day and were instrumental in helping their fellow passengers off the bus through the back exit while Thompson ranted for them to stay on board. Scherzer tells the "Early Show" that she approached Thompson after noticing the bus was swerving all over the road.
"I went up to talk to her and asked if she was OK to drive," she tells the "Early Show."
The teen says Thompson said she was fine, yet continued to drive erratically. Later, the girl managed to get the bus's back gate open and helped usher her fellow students off the vehicle.
Pierce tells the news program that she called her mother during the scary ride. Her mom, Lori Loomis, says Thompson's punishment is less than satisfactory.
"I am outraged. I am very upset with what she received," Loomis tells the "Early Show." "And I just don't think it's a harsh enough punishment for this woman. She put all these children's lives in danger. She could have killed them all. I'm very upset with the outcome."
Thompson's attorney, Thomas D. Trbovich, tells the "Early Show" that his client is "embarrassed."
"She's very sorry to the children," he says. "She never, ever would intentionally put any of those children ... in any type of risk."
Does Thompson deserve a harsher sentence, or does her punishment fit the crime?
Related: Alcohol Abuse and Dependence











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 13)
1-06-2010 @ 4:24PM
Greg said...I grew up in that area of Upstate NY and it does not suprise me with the punishment. Just two years ago a young man was murdered at Alfred University. There was no arrest, trial or conviction ever sought by the State Police or District Attorney.
This was just another of a handful of deaths in a college town swept under the rug.
I am glad I no longer live in Allegany County and will never move back!!
Reply
1-06-2010 @ 11:59PM
Jon Lucero said...So an NFL football player goes to jail for years for shooting himself in the leg at a night club but a bus drivers who drive intoxictated and endagers the life of innocent children only get 90 days. Why does not someone stand up and make an example out of her!!! FREE PLAXICO!
1-08-2010 @ 8:30PM
AnnieB said...She wouldn't "intentionally" do this? Did someone force her to drink?
Kudos to the teenagers who confronted her and got the little kids off the bus.
1-08-2010 @ 9:00PM
Simzee said...Gee, liquid courage never gave you the ability to drive. How funny drunks are.
1-08-2010 @ 9:18PM
Amarie said...I am 30 years old, but this brought back horrible memories for me. When I was a young teenager my father or one of his friends would come and pick me up on a Friday night from my mom's from a bar or a club and be drunk out of there minds. It scared me to death. I remember one time my dad pulling up next to a cop in his big old box style suburban with the black tinted windows, got the cops attention and then pretended to take a swig of a closed beer that he had in his center consul. He laughed and said that the cop wouldn't do anything because he was afraid. Said the cop wouldn't stop someone when he couldn't see in their back windows. He was right the cop didn't do a thing. I don't know if I should be upset that the cop didn't stop him and take me out of his custody or relieved that the cop showed common sense and did not get himself into a position where he potentially could have gotten himself killed.
1-08-2010 @ 9:34PM
Binky said...Typical Blue State
1-08-2010 @ 11:08PM
elizabeth said...and to think my son got 1 to 3 yrs for 100.00 this girl shouldhave lived in niagra county i assure u she would be doing time thank god the judge did this or who knows what woulfd have become of him this was 16 yrs ago he now has 3 kids and a great dad and husband ,there is more to this but i dont want to go there of course it had something to do with drugs.
1-08-2010 @ 11:46PM
hvacdaddy said...Wow, that guy on reply number 9 is an Airforce? I've heard of a guy being a one man Army, but never a one man Airforce tht's incredible. BTW I am an Army veteran and have the greatest respect and gratitude to those serving in the armed forces but this crap that is always showing up under comments is exactly that, CRAP
1-09-2010 @ 12:35AM
Gothic Anger said...Just that for a DRUNK bus driver???!!!! She should be fired and have her drivers liscence revoked and be charged with not only child endargerment but driving while intoxicated. She could have killed those kids as she drove like a mad woman. Where's the harsher punishment for this woman?
1-09-2010 @ 1:35AM
Master Shake said...Once again, WHERE ARE THE SEAT BELTS? This is a great example of the American government's hypocrisy. If YOU don't put your child in a car seat that's strapped down like a NASCAR driver's racing cage, then you can lose your children from endangerment. Oh, but trust them on a bus that doesn't even have seat belts, because the government runs THAT.
1-09-2010 @ 2:20AM
TF104 said...Just to add to your comment, I was pretty close to the story of that student's death two years ago, but calling that incident a murder would be a gross overstatement. His cause of death was due to a "loss of blood flow to the brain," and it was concluded after a grand jury that the cause of death was not from the blow from the person in question. That kid is no murderer. The altercation preceding the student's death was started by the deceased student after he broke a bottle over the other kid's head at a party. The whole incident was a tragedy, possibly manslaughter if the grand jury had concluded a different cause of death, but it was NOT murder.
1-11-2010 @ 1:55AM
Jeannie said...think she should lose her lisense forever and serve time in jail. Hard time. What she did is unforgivable. This should be added to what she has already received. She should NEVER be allowed to drive any vecihle again.
1-09-2010 @ 4:58AM
zytychi said...SOURCE: http://www.kmov.com/video 10-21-09...Hey Greg, did you know that a 7 time DUI Convict has been RELEASED without RESTRICTIONS...."The appearance of impropriety in the prosecution of a DUI case leads to a DUI tragedy" Disbar the RELEASOR. Contact the Il Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission and demand the disbarment of the releasor st clair county states attorney robert haida>
1-06-2010 @ 4:45PM
isthrnhnst1 said...Her attorney said, "She never, ever would intentionally put any of those children ... in any type of risk." ??? What planet is her attorney living on? What is there about a drunk driving a school bus with children aboard that does NOT put those children at risk? Did someone hold the bus driver's arm and force her to get drunk before she drove that bus? If not, she chose to drink, and INTENTIONALLY PUT ALL OF THOSE CHILDREN AT RISK. She should lose her driver's license, pay a hefty fine, serve at least 6 months in jail, and be on probation for at least 10 years. Those kids were lucky there were 2 alert and responsible eens aboard to save them all.
Reply
1-06-2010 @ 5:58PM
dalo70 said...Totally agree with you isthrnhnst 1
1-06-2010 @ 10:34PM
Karen said...I also agree with you isthrnhnst1
1-08-2010 @ 8:20PM
Reinhart said...Actually, she most likely did not intend to put those children and others in jeopardy.
That said, her intentions are not excuses. Despite her intentions, the simple facts in this case were that she was drunk and she was driving an occupied bus on a public roadway.
She ultimately put lives needlessly at risk and, thus, while there are things that may explain why this happened, she still has to be responsible for her mistakes, including paying for them.
But, with regard to how other drunk drivers have been prosecuted, she got off easy.
1-09-2010 @ 12:50PM
jdsmitty007 said...Yes although I think they should take her license for goor there is no way that would of hnappened where I live if that was a kid around here it definately would of been handled diffirent and her Lawyer is a complete Idiot and thats being very generis.
1-09-2010 @ 8:36PM
Jan Whitehead said...If you leave your PET in a car in hot weather without a window or windows rolled down, you are charged with animal endangerment, fined, etc. If a "parent" is DWI with children in the car, they are charged with child endangerment, lose their license, are fined, are required to attend a "drunk driving classes, quite possible have their children taken away from them, etc. Sooooooooo New York laws are basically saying....it's OK; no big deal, for a school bus driver, as long as they are "sorry" to endanger the lives of a bus load of kids! This is total crap! If I were a parent of one of those children on the bus I would put together a class action suit with other parents and sue whoever hired the woman, find out if her driving record was scrutinized prior to being hired, and give the money to "Mothers Against Drunk Driving" or another organization with similiar clout to put the money towards lobbying for much stronger laws and punishments for ANYONE who endangers children while DWI or DWI.
1-08-2010 @ 9:12PM
Judy said...I have twice been the victim of a drunk driver. Neither of them "intentionally" crashed into my vehicle, but that does not make my injuries and loss (I was pg with triplets) any less devastating. Each of them intentionally drove after drinking. My personal feeling is that drunk drivers should be shot on sight - they are operating a dangerous weapon. Since they don't give a rats arse if they live or die, take them out before they hurt someone else.