Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Abbie Rumbach: The Confession That Blew My Daughter's Mind
PHOTO: Reese Witherspoon, Ryan Phillipe Reunite
My Mother Hates My Baby Name
Filed under: Relatives, Baby Names
My husband and I love the name Agnes for our little girl. I made the huge mistake the other day telling my mother about "our" name and she made a big deal about how much she doesn't like it, and how my dad will "hate" it. I still love it. However, I have spent the last two days on the Internet trying to find alternatives. Nothing like the words from a mother to cause guilt and anxiety. Help!
- C
When you choose a name that goes against the fashion tide, you can expect mixed reactions. How should you react to nasty comments? You can take them to heart and reconsider your name choice. You can ignore them and hold fast to your own opinion. Or you can try to understand where they come from, to prepare an effective response. Let's try to understand your mom's reaction to Agnes.
We like the names we like partly because of the associations they bring to mind. In your parents' baby naming days Heather and Melissa sounded like fresh, youthful names for girls. To you and your friends, those names sound more like moms than babies. The same thing happens at the other end of the age spectrum. We hear names from our grandparents' generation as dowdy because the people we know with those names are, well, old. (When was the last time you heard an expectant mom trying to choose between the names Norma and Doris?)
Meanwhile, our great-grandparents' names ring forth with a sweet freshness. Agnes has been out of fashion long enough that you may never have met anyone with the name. To you, it is association-free. The trick is that your great-grandparents are your mother's grandparents. To your mom, Agnes probably summons powerful associations of blue hair and dentures.
Because of these different associations, naming clashes are common. Keeping a controversial choce a secret is one way to avoid an assault on your favorite name. Introduce the name when you introduce the baby. Who can make nasty comments to the face of a loveable newborn babe?
Since you already have told them, and gotten an earful of their "true" feelings, try to make your peace with it. If you can get past your hurt and just accept your parents' generational viewpoint, they're likely to come around in time ... thanks to their new grandbaby. That adorable infant will give your parents a sparkling new generation of associations to make Agnes youthful again.
Have you battled with family over baby names? Share your experiences! And if you have your own question to Ask the Name Lady, drop her a line!
Related: Getting Pregnant in the Spring? Take Caution










ReaderComments (Page 1 of 34)
1-14-2010 @ 7:07PM
Elizabeth said...Agnes is a pretty name, meaning lamb of god. It also lends itself to some pretty and unique nicknames--Aggie, Nessie, Nessa. Nevermind what mom or anyone else says about a name, if you like it, use it, and if your mother doesn't like it, let her come up with a special nickname that only she will call the baby.
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 8:36PM
ROLLANDO said...For the most part I agree with what you are saying. As for the nickname, that too should be controlled by the mother not the grandmother.
1-16-2010 @ 8:53PM
Ben said...Agnes certainly does not mean, "lamb of God". It simply means, "lamb". The girl's name Agnes \ag-nes\ is pronounced AG-ness. It is of Greek origin, and its meaning is "pure, holy". Latin form of the Greek name Hagnes, from the feminine form of "hagnos". The popular Saint Agnes (fourth century) was a young Roman virgin martyred by the Roman Emperor Diocletian. Her emblem is a lamb; the Latin word for "lamb" is "agnus". thinkbabynames.com/meaning/0/Agnes
1-16-2010 @ 9:27PM
Annie said...Emily is a good example of a name that was reborn. How many Emilys do you know that are now in their 50s or 60s? NONE!! It was my grandmother's middle name (born 1908) and that was as far as that name went until the 1970s. How many Alices do you know that are in their 30s? Maybe one. (I know two.) The name is very pretty so instead of disappearing, it turned into Allison (now how many Allisons do you know who are in their 30s? Millions.). Alice has made a sudden resurgence this past decade and now it's chic to have a little girl named Alice. Here's a hoot: how about a sweet little girl dressed in Baby Gap clothing named Donna or Linda or Barbara? Ha! How about a woman in a nursing home by the name of Tiffany or Taylor or Kayla? Some day, folks!
1-16-2010 @ 10:39PM
Boston Blackie said...Agnes does not mean Lamb of God. The Catholic hymn, Agnus Dei means lamb of God and it is Greek.
1-17-2010 @ 12:31AM
Never Another Womens Man! said...WHO CARES WHAT IT MEANS!! Think of your little girl, growing up, how mean kids are, and the emotional scares we carry. You would be thoughtless and careless to name a child something that opens them to ridicule. Go ahead and name her the WORSE possible thing you can think of if your going to do that.
2-01-2010 @ 8:50AM
Theresa said...I also believe that the name should be left to the parents. I also think that the nickname that the grandmother choses to call her grandchild is their choice. That will be special to them throughout their lives. Providing that the nickname is not a name picked only to get back at the parents. The grandmother should not nickname the child something totally silly like a vulgar name, the ex-wife's or ex-girlfriends name or a horrible nickname that will reduce that child's self-esteem.
Examples:
Vulgar - I will not address that issue. Nobody should.
Ex: That explains itself.
Horrible: Fat girl, Dum-Dum etc.
I have a nephew that we call "Blockhead" but he doesn't mind. In public we calll him by his name but some child could be hurt by it. He is now a dad himself but still our blockhead. His dad gave him that name, I just followed along. He really would rather I called him that..LOL, I call his brother by his middle name and no other person does. He knows it is out of love. Both of his grandfathers had the same middle name...so he got it to honor both of them.
R I P Dad and Mr. Frank.
1-18-2010 @ 4:29PM
LINDA said...I know how baby names are with mothers because when i was preg with my daughter my mother in law wanted to name her" sarah jane" and things got changed and named her" desiree lynn"
after awhile she got a granddaughter by her own daughter and she got to name the baby "sarah jane" but now my own daughter wants to name her daughter when she is preg her name is gonna be
" emma sue" that is real country name way back in the old days...
1-18-2010 @ 4:52PM
staber said...My son and daughter in law have a six month old. What they named the child is none of my or my wife's business. Tell your mum to go eff off! Parents MUST learn when to butt out! Sacrificing a relationship with your children is what is at stake here MUM MORON!
1-18-2010 @ 5:41PM
Cara said...Firstly, Agnes just means lamb. Please do not put your own religious connotations on the name. Secondly, I'm in my twenties and even for someone of my generation, Agnes sounds like the name of an old lady. It is not youthful name no matter what your age. Hopefully a nickname will help out.
1-18-2010 @ 5:30PM
Laura said...I LOVE AGNES!! We named our dog Agnes. She is a beautiful girl! We usually call her goosey.
1-18-2010 @ 6:11PM
Marsha said...Mom I am so sorry but it is not any of our business what our children name their children
1-18-2010 @ 6:21PM
kg said...My mother hated the name we chose for my second son. She disliked the first name which was a common name.So for a long time she called him by his middle name which was I thought not very good idea. But eventually, she just started using his name because I told her it was confusing to a young child.
Your mom will come around. Maybe she wanted a name of her choice or her liking. But it comes down to the matter that it's your child. I could see perhaps if you had some very bizarre name that might cause a lot of teasing, but otherwise, everyone has to learn to live with it.
1-20-2010 @ 9:20AM
Bev Rhodes said...I am on the grandmeother's side. I hate that name and can't imagine
a child being happy with it. Think of the child as she grows up.
1-18-2010 @ 9:12PM
Preston said...What a great idea, her own special name. I will have to remember that one. By the way Elizabeth is one of my favorites.
1-18-2010 @ 7:04PM
Marion said...Im sorry to say I agree with your Mom let me just say my name is an old fashioned name and I have lived with it and never ever liked it. I made a point to name my daughter a beautiful name (Jacqueline) and to love the nick name that may go along with it (which is sometimes out of your control when your child gets older) I also love the name Jackie. Please dont just think of yourself think of the child that will have to live with the name......and possibly there is a reason why you dont hear of many girls named Agnes.....is just not that pleasant of a name...(like mine !)
1-18-2010 @ 7:05PM
Ashlie said...my daughters name is alaina brooklyn. my family hated it. my sister made fun of it cuz "its a city" my grandfather said he couldnt pronounce it or spell it. my mom wanted me to name her after her. well now that shes almost 1 no one can see her bein named anythin but her name. so name ur daughter whatever u like. ur family will get used to it.
1-20-2010 @ 10:02AM
Malissa said...I love the name Agnes. My mothers name was Agnes.
1-18-2010 @ 7:57PM
Sarah said...I insisted on Alice Agnes for our daughter's name. But, my husband absolutely refused. We compromised, and I got to keep Alice, and he chose Olivia for the middle name. I love her name, but still regret not holding on to Agnes. If I still feel regret over it if we have another, I'll keep Agnes if it's a girl.
Hang in there for those names you love - you have to use that name a million times in their life, and you don't want to feel regret or disappointment every time you use it.
1-18-2010 @ 8:38PM
Trisha said...PLEASE do not name your child Agnes. It is OLD and she will have to deal with that. Why not make that her middle name?