My Mother Hates My Baby Name
Filed under: Relatives, Baby Names
My husband and I love the name Agnes for our little girl. I made the huge mistake the other day telling my mother about "our" name and she made a big deal about how much she doesn't like it, and how my dad will "hate" it. I still love it. However, I have spent the last two days on the Internet trying to find alternatives. Nothing like the words from a mother to cause guilt and anxiety. Help!
- C
When you choose a name that goes against the fashion tide, you can expect mixed reactions. How should you react to nasty comments? You can take them to heart and reconsider your name choice. You can ignore them and hold fast to your own opinion. Or you can try to understand where they come from, to prepare an effective response. Let's try to understand your mom's reaction to Agnes.
We like the names we like partly because of the associations they bring to mind. In your parents' baby naming days Heather and Melissa sounded like fresh, youthful names for girls. To you and your friends, those names sound more like moms than babies. The same thing happens at the other end of the age spectrum. We hear names from our grandparents' generation as dowdy because the people we know with those names are, well, old. (When was the last time you heard an expectant mom trying to choose between the names Norma and Doris?)
Meanwhile, our great-grandparents' names ring forth with a sweet freshness. Agnes has been out of fashion long enough that you may never have met anyone with the name. To you, it is association-free. The trick is that your great-grandparents are your mother's grandparents. To your mom, Agnes probably summons powerful associations of blue hair and dentures.
Because of these different associations, naming clashes are common. Keeping a controversial choce a secret is one way to avoid an assault on your favorite name. Introduce the name when you introduce the baby. Who can make nasty comments to the face of a loveable newborn babe?
Since you already have told them, and gotten an earful of their "true" feelings, try to make your peace with it. If you can get past your hurt and just accept your parents' generational viewpoint, they're likely to come around in time ... thanks to their new grandbaby. That adorable infant will give your parents a sparkling new generation of associations to make Agnes youthful again.
Have you battled with family over baby names? Share your experiences! And if you have your own question to Ask the Name Lady, drop her a line!
Related: Getting Pregnant in the Spring? Take Caution











ReaderComments (Page 6 of 34)
1-18-2010 @ 8:19PM
Charity said...His name has nothing to do with vampires. We chose the name before the movies came out. He was named after a friend of ours who was killed by a drunk driver.
1-16-2010 @ 8:44PM
lilpoohbearie00 said...my mom got over it as soon as she held her granddaughter. My daughter is her name she was supposed to be Caitlyn, katie ect. But I named her Jade. she is a jem and I would never have changed it. My mom cried when I told her but now 16 years later she loves the name! So do not let you mom dictate what you should name your child. Agnes is beautiful and once she sees her she will agree!
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 8:47PM
Judy said...My mother's name is Agnes and yes she was called Aggie- it rhimes with Maggie. If she were alive she would be 101 yrs old. It is so true what was said about the old generation names. The old names are new to the young mommies. Don't tell anyone what you plan on naming a child. My mother-in law refused to come and see my baby if I named her Natalie.....Because her x-husband....my father-in-law's name was Natalino...........This was after she was born and we came home with her without a name......
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 8:50PM
mrskrashski said...My husband and I picked out names that had meaning (not just names we liked). My daughter is Margaret Irene, her first name comes from the bible, and her middle name is after my grandmother. Our son is Russell Thomas, after a man who was very much like a father to my husband, and his middle name after his best friend who passed away several years ago.
Who's going to say anything about names that have such great meaning behind them? Anyone who's ever questioned why I've chosen the names for my children has always backed down when I've told them the meaning.
Furthermore, I believe giving children names with special meaning behind them helps them "accept" their name if they go through a stage of not liking it. I know I did as a kid, and I've come to really love my name, especially knowing the meaning behind it.
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 8:50PM
Teresa said...I think you should keep the name Agnes. It is your daughter. My Mother wanted me to change the my daughter's name, Audrey, because she thought it was too old fashioned. And now that she is 4, her name is the only name in the school, and when we shop in the grocery store....all the old ladies love to here a good old-fashioned name. So, keep your baby name, and let your mother deal with her her grand-daughter's name. I always think about the kids when they get older, when they pick their occupations, when they meet their soul-mates, and how their name impacts them. Agnes is a great name!
Reply
1-18-2010 @ 6:16PM
Heather said...Audrey is a very pretty name. Unlike Agnes its timeless b/c its beautiful.
1-16-2010 @ 9:05PM
Snookhookr said...Kenneth
My mother didn't want me to name my now 1 year old son Barack.
Sometimes mothers know best.....like when you want to name your child after failed Marxist presidents.
You should have listenend to Mom.
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 11:12PM
Lita said...And you, Snookhookr, are an idiot--as evidenced by some of your mean-spirited comments and your choice of screen name.
1-16-2010 @ 8:53PM
Corene said...Honestly, people need to stop catering to their own wants and those of their parents and grandparents when choosing their child's name. I've seen some children saddled with horrific names because their parents thought is was "different" or "unusual". Parents need to think of the child first and how their name will impact their self image and development.
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 8:59PM
Stephie said...Take comfort in knowing you aren't the first expectant mother who has had to deal with meddling family when it comes to the name game. I am currently pregnant and have decided to name my son "Magnus." Everyone in the family hates the name and says it (ironically enough) sounds too much like Agnes. If you love the name that is all that matters, stick to your guns. Your family should support whatever name you choose and you shouldn't feel compelled to change her name simply because your mother doesn't approve. For myself, I will not be losing any sleep over the fact that no one likes the name I've chosen and you shouldn't either!
Reply
1-17-2010 @ 2:33AM
jEANNE (cuteesmiles) said...I really like that name "Magnus".. It's a very strong, protective sounding name, and I wouldn't hesitate to be proud of it! btw.. congrats on your newest family member! Hope he is healthy and God blesses him with a wonderful character!
1-16-2010 @ 9:02PM
Kaitlin said...Personally, I dislike the name Agnes.
I hate hearing about parents who give their children names that they just love but are actually horrible. They are thinking of themselves, and not their children. This child will have to carry this name for the rest of their life. How would *you* like to introduce yourself to your first grade classmates as Agnes? I know I wouldn't!
Children can be cruel, and I think any child would hate to be saddled with this name.
I agree with an earlier comment that said Agnes sounded "hard". It really does, which is not a positive thing. Remember, mom's almost always know best, and I think she does this time.
Reply
1-17-2010 @ 10:55PM
Jessica said...That is the ugliest name ever it sounds like a fat oaf ... ew! DO NOT NAME HER THAT unless you want her to look like shrek
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 9:22PM
Kathy said...Things could be MUCH worse!At least you want to name your daughter a name that's been heard of! When discussing names,my father wanted to name me Mavourneen! (it's an Irish name).But my mother refused & wanted to name me Kathleen. So my dad gave in to that.
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 9:23PM
daryldad said...I have a friend who's grandchild was just named AVA. I never heard of anyone named AVA before and I love the name. My husband and I planned on naming our son Gabriel, however when we saw him it didn't fit. We named him Patrick. The same thing happened when we had a name picked for our daughter. You'll know when you see your baby. It will be the right name to you. It doesn't matter what others people think. Your the parents, these babies are your and your responsibility. Pray for health and happiness and let the rest roll of you. Best Wishes to You and Yours. Sincerely, Karen
Reply
1-18-2010 @ 4:50PM
GJSly said...You never heard of Ava Gardner?
1-18-2010 @ 10:01PM
Tori said...Heather Locklear's daughter is also named Ava.
1-16-2010 @ 9:27PM
Beth said...I love the name Agnes. It's a beautiful name. If it's the name you and your husband like and want to use, that is all that matters. I don't particularly like the name my step daughter picked out for her daughters name. But you know what? She wasn't mine to name, and just because it's a name I don't like, doesn't mean I love her any less. My husband and I just came up with a nickname that was special to us to call her.
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 9:45PM
Laura said...I believe that if you like the name for your little girl, you should name her Agnes. I personally think it's cute. It's not your mother's choice, it is yours and your husbands. That's all you have to remember. I also think that the names Willow, Windsor, Ocean Coral, and Cricket are good names too. But like I already said, its your choice.
thank you. L J
Reply
1-16-2010 @ 9:28PM
Norma said...Hey, what's wrong with "NORMA?"
THAT'S MY NAME, AND NO ONE EVER FORGETS IT.
I do have a distant cousin with the name...Nancy Catherine Saphronia Passion Flower Ellgiberg Mattie Fort.....and they called her, MAGGIE....
Now, put that one on your passport.
Reply