L.A. to Focus More On Protecting Kids, Less On Reuniting Families
Filed under: In The News
Angel Montiel was reunited with his parents after they enrolled in parenting classes and agreed to drug testing and other services.
Now his mother is spending 15 years in prison. She pleaded no contest to beating the toddler to death.
Angel is one reason the Department of Children and Family Services in Los Angles County is readjusting its thinking.
The overarching goal of many state and county agencies designed to protect children is to reunite and preserve troubled families.
Not in Los Angeles County. Not anymore.
In a major policy shift, the Los Angeles Times reports, county officials say their number one priority will now be protecting children from unsafe parents. Reuniting families and reducing the number of children in foster care are distant seconds.
This is a big change, the Times reports.
Department administrators once boasted about how they got children out of foster care. There were of 52,000 kids in foster care in Los Angeles County in 1997. Last year, there were 19,900.
"I do want these numbers to start going down again, but only when I can assure everyone that the work we are doing results in safety for that child who is going home," Trish Ploehn, the department's director, tells the Times.
"I don't know how much more we can go down in the numbers, though," she adds. "We are a very large county, and it's possible that we are already at the level where we are supposed to be."
The change in attitude comes on the heels of a Los Angeles Times report that detailed how at least 17 children died last year from abuse and neglect, even though the department was aware of their dangerous family situations. In 2008, the paper reports, 14 children died under similar circumstances. (Montiel was among the children who died in 2007.)
One of the children who died last year was Isabel Garcia. The child starved to death, the Times reports, two months after child-welfare officials decided she and her parents and five siblings were doing well.
"These cases had a very deep effect on the department," Ploehn tells the Times.
Not everyone likes the effect. Critics charge that department officials already break up too many families. Sabreen Shabazz, 56, of Los Angeles tells the Times that she cares for her 11-year-old granddaughter on $845 per month. She worries her granddaughter will be taken into foster care, she tells the paper.
Shabazz is a member of a group called DCFS Give Us Back Our Children. Members often demonstrate outside Edelman Children's Court in Monterey Park, Calif.
"DCFS has a family preservation unit and they need to focus on that work more, not less," Shabazz's friend Janet Mitchell tells the Times. "Look at Sabreen. She's a loving grandmother who just needs help. They live in poverty, but the child is happy because she is loved."
Related: Adoption / Foster Care Helpline












ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
2-06-2010 @ 5:48PM
Richard Wexler said...The LA Times got the story wrong, and has run a "clarification" and a follow up story. More generally, for the overwhelming majority of children family preservation is *safer* than foster care. There is indeed a retreat from reform in LA, though not to the extent the Times says, and that actually is making the county's children less safe.
Details are on my organization's Blog at www.nccpr.blogspot.com
Richard Wexler
Executive Director
National Coalition for Child Protection Reform
www.nccpr.org
Reply
2-21-2010 @ 8:59PM
upurs said...sounds to me like 1 of these clever tactics to bring back slave labor...i hate what the rich have been doing to this country...they are responsible for this country going to hell..!
2-13-2010 @ 2:55PM
joe said...for information about foster care in the UK search simplyfostering.co.uk
Reply
2-21-2010 @ 7:59PM
Soojin Yeh said...I grew up in foster care, and I think they're doing the right thing. Too many times, the system is too concerned with reuniting kids with unsafe parents (they want to return the kids to the same parents who beat and raped them) because that's the easiest permanancy plan, and it's easier than working to get the kids adopted (foster care is different from adoption, it's temporary care done by people that are trained and receive salaries), into kinship care (care with relatives-not easy because then the relatives have to go to training and all that) or independence.
Then you gotta work on not randomly abandoning the kids as soon as they turn 18...
Reply
2-21-2010 @ 8:07PM
Freddie said...Whoa, wait a minute. Did I just read that this woman BEAT A 2 YEAR OLD BABY TO DEATH, and got 15 years for it? She beat her son to death, she'll be out in 15 years at what...35, 37..so she can GET WASTED, GET PREGNANT, AND KILL MORE CHILDREN? THIS is what's wrong with this country. I don't give a damn what color she is or where she came from: YOU MURDER A CHILD AND YOU SHOULD GET A NEEDLE IN THE ARM. Watch how fast the infant murder rate drops after we trot a dozen of these bitches to the death chamber and broadcast it on television. This makes me sick.
Reply
2-21-2010 @ 8:18PM
dlite said...Terry, you arw an embarassment to this country. shame on you! go back to your homeland, you idiot!
Reply
2-21-2010 @ 9:05PM
upurs said...terry..i am also racial..but i like the fact that these people have flooded america and overwhelmed the system,because what it has done is;it has shown us how badly we have been robbed ..by the powers that own this country...they have stolen everything we have and our job security too..and then they turn around and tell us that we need to wise up..!...it's time for all of us poor/common people to realize who the real perpertrators are...THEY ARE THE RICH FAMILIES WHO CONTROL AMERICA...AND THEIR BOOT LICKING GOVERNMENT..!..good luck to all of us poor/common americans..!..it's not the poor immigrants..!
Reply
2-21-2010 @ 10:43PM
John said...Yea!!!!!!!!! And let's also kill the white trash littering our welfare system, creating trailer park trash, and creating mix breed babies everywhere. Let's "Repatriated" them back to Europe where they belong and let the real natives have their land back. Let's teach the blacks, mexican, and peckwoods a lesson!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yeeeeee, Haaaawwww!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply
2-22-2010 @ 5:05AM
Amy Rosenberg said...All of this hate? Many people are not capable of raising children. Other people make wonderful parents. Color, race, religion or gender is not the issue. It is the mental capacity, emotional maturity, and the sobriety of the parent. We need to allow the innocent children to live to grow up.
We also need to get back to the welfare system as we knew it. Some families need a welfare worker looking in on them daily or weekly. We also need to have young women stay in the hospital for a few days after giving birth and to be followed up for a period of time. This will allow new parents to be assessed and helped if necessary.
Reply