Teachers Pass Out Treats In Pill Bottle to Calm Test Anxiety
Filed under: In The News, Weird But True
Two teachers gave their students candy in a pill bottle and at least one caregiver says that sends a bad message. Credit: Charles Williams, Flickr
Sandy Young tells the Tampa Tribune she was shocked to walk into her grandson's Westchase Elementary School classroom and spot a pill bottle sitting on his desk. Teacher Beth Watson assured her that the contents of the bottle were just candy, but Young is still upset about the message being sent.
"She said it was nothing but some mints; it was just something special for the kids, for the [Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test] to mellow them out," Young tells the newspaper. "We turn around and we have our teachers giving them drugs. I don't care if it's mints or not. ... If it's in a prescription bottle, it's a drug."
The "drug" in question was a bottle of candies made to resemble prescription medication. Young tells the Tribune that the bottle reads in part: "Watson's Whiz Kid Pharmacy. Take 1 tablet by mouth EVERY 5 MINUTES to cure FCAT jitters. Repeated use may cause craft to spontaneously ooze from pores. No refills. Ms. (Deborah) Falcon's authorization required."
District spokeswoman Linda Cobbe tells the newspaper there has been only one complaint about the incident thus far and that Watson and her co-teacher Deborah Falcon have met with the principal. No disciplinary action is pending at this time.
"Elementary teachers do creative things to make learning fun," Cobbe says. The teachers won't be disciplined, and it wasn't their intention to promote drug use, she adds.
She adds that the idea for the pill bottle came from a book the students read recently. In "George's Marvelous Medicine" by Roald Dahl, a boy concocts potions to change the mood of his grumpy grandmother.
But Young isn't buying it. Even pretending to take drugs is a serious matter, she says.
"We as parents and grandparents have to drill it into them that this is unacceptable and hope and pray that they don't accept drugs from someone else," Young tells the Tribune.
Other parents, however, don't feel the same way and are backing up the two teachers. Jenny McMurray's son is in the same class, and she says Falcon and Watson "go above and beyond."
They are fantastic and wonderful teachers," McMurray tells the Tribune in a follow-up story. "I spend a lot of time in the class and am constantly amazed by their energy and creativity. They genuinely care for all of these kids. They do wonderful engaging activities with the kids. They've been doing it all year."
Does this send the wrong message to kids about drugs or was it just a harmless treat?
Related: Anti-Drug PSA Plays on Our Worst Fear -- Not Having PizzaYour<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS AS TO THE ANSWER BY DEFENDANTS ______________________________. Plaintiff, ________________________ h...
- D. hickman v. intel, microsoft et.al federal district court dc (bill gates deposition part 1 you tube?) are you a owner of a company?
- Why should anyone listen to a _____, what makes her an expert? Harpo is jus an actress, all she does is sit on her tush & claim she knows it all. ...











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 6)
2-11-2010 @ 10:47AM
Katrina said...There will always be a Devils Advocate.. This is not a Motion to Say that Pills will always help to solve a Problem. The teachers I'm sure were just saying Take a Chill Pill.. and helping the Kids relax.. and have something to smile and refocus on .. Surely The Parents and Teachers and Students have helped to understand that REAL Meds are for Medical Use only... Some parents need to get a grip!! Seriously people are ALWAYS looking to be Contrary!
Reply
3-02-2010 @ 11:32AM
dg1 said...get lives, all of you. who cares about this nonsense. GO GET LIVES
2-11-2010 @ 11:00PM
JONIE71561 said...GET OVER IT . ITS A MINT IN A BOTTLE . ITS NOT THE END OF THE WORLD
2-12-2010 @ 6:34AM
Eileen said...I am a teacher and have been for over twenty years. Creativity is part of the craft of a good teacher and creative motivating activities abound in my classroom. However, I strongly feel that this "creative" endeavor sends a very bad message to young children. I think the teachers should have used a more appropriate way to have the students engage fully in the test. Testing demands are high and it sometimes causes teachers to resort to tactics such as this. The idea is not a good one and next time, perhaps, the teachers will think of another less controversal way to motivate students. How about telling the students how great they will feel when they have done their best and this feeling of accomplishment will live in their hearts and make them proud!!! Teachers need to instill good feelings that come naturally.
2-15-2010 @ 6:46AM
paula said...I have to say this is total wrong and if the teacher wanted to do something like this she should have called all parents frist . And if they agree then ok, but your a teacher not the parent. I would also be upset. So what the school is saying its ok because there good teachers. Ok thats like saying a kid who maybe did same thing would be ok too because he/she gets good grades. This is wrong we teach kids not to take pill enless a doctor fives then to you or your parents know about it, At are school you cant give asprin enless its given by a nurse and the parent has given the ok. Maybe you all should get a GRIP.. WE teach kids not to take drugs and know teacher can its ok wait becasue it was candy... So next time your kids at the park and someone says want some candy its ok to take because lets how it is only candy , lets hope these kids dont realy bring pills to school/park and give them out , beacuse this will relax you,,, Your all asses at this school the one who made a concern your not you are smart and I feel sorry that the school could care less... WOW . SAD. This is why kids do bad thing because look this is a teacher who did something wrong and nothing happen to her. They blame the parents when a kid does something bad, will maybe it not the parents like we think its the teacher .. Its realy sad that people feel this was ok .... The world has gone to hell.....
2-15-2010 @ 9:43PM
weeboys2 said...I think some people over analyze. I'm 48 years old and remember as a kid when my siblings and I had to do household chores we would say "let's take an energy pill" and we would pop a Sweetart or a Redhot in our mouth ,and then get to work! We didn't have anyone in our life popping amphedimines or anything,it was just play,and made a dreaded chore more fun and less painful. Lighten up. If you are concerned about the message,speak to your child about it. Don't try to made a big issue,and threaten a teachers career.
2-11-2010 @ 8:25PM
Sammi said...Hilarious! Slightly inappropriate but hilarious!!
Reply
2-11-2010 @ 8:35PM
EllieB said...First we read about a school over-reacting about a kid taking a 2" action figure's gun to school. Now we've got parents freaking about mints in a medicine bottle. Why not lighten up on this trivial stuff and concentrate on education.That's where the focus should be.
Reply
2-11-2010 @ 8:36PM
Dan Stuart said...the teachers should be commended for creativity and the woman that complained should shut up and apologize to the teachers that tried to get the students to relax and not freak out.
Reply
2-11-2010 @ 9:16PM
Lisa said...I am a fourth grade teacher in Florida and think the idea was cute. The kids get so stressed over the writing test and if it helps...great!! I am sure the teachers read the label aloud and of course used it as a teachable moment.
2-12-2010 @ 6:00AM
Timmo said...Lisa, your a moron!! your whats wrong with the education system today.
2-11-2010 @ 8:58PM
bnbncb said...Likely these teachers paid for this fun moment out of their own pocket and likely the kids enjoyed the moment and felt less pressure and anziety... Sounds like this granny needs a bunch of CHILL pills. Good Job Teachers!
Reply
2-13-2010 @ 1:30AM
Tommy Miller said...The teachers were only trying to help the students do better on the test. Doctors give out sugar pills for the same reson, to make someone think they are now "Better". I think the teachers were creative thinkers who should be rewarded and not persacuted. Had they actully given the students Valium or any other "Real" drug then it would be a different story. They gave the kids candy! Name them teachers of the year for tryig to HELP students instead of the teacher who only shows up to work to collect a apy check!
2-11-2010 @ 9:02PM
Tom B said...Sounds like they had one bottle to few... Chill out woman. Maybe inapropriate but harmless still...
Reply
2-11-2010 @ 9:09PM
Rachelvis said...GOOD, FIRE THE TEACHER WHO WOULD DO SUCH A STUPID THING,,,NOW ALL THE DRUG DEALERS IN TOWN CAN COME UP TO THESE KIDS AND SAY "HEY KID WANNA PIECE OF CANDY" STUPID, STUPID,STUPID....FOR A PERSON WHO'S ON NARCOTICS AND WATCH ALL THESE YOUNG PEOPLE IN REHAB, BOY THIS TEACHER IS ONE DUMB COOKIE...NEEDS TO BE FIRED IMMEDIATELY...DON'T YOU HAVE ANY CLUE TO WHAT MESSAGE YOU'VE JUST SENT TO THESE KIDS, WHO SEE PILL COMMERCIALS ALL DAY AND NIGHT ON TV....WOW, YOUR NOT A TEACHER, YOU A PERSON WHO JUST COMMITTED THE BIGGEST CRIME EVER, AND THAT IS TO INFLUENCE A CHILDS MIND, THAT CANDY CAN COME IN A PRESCRIPTION PILL BOTTLE..YOU IDIOT..AGAIN FIRE THIS PERSON BEFORE THEY DO ANY FURTHER HARM TO OUR KIDS....
US ARMY VETERAN
Reply
2-11-2010 @ 9:24PM
jlhart06 said...yes, because every kid in that classroom is now going to take drugs from a stranger on the street. they took candy from their teacher who wanted them not to worry about the test. i think you need to take a step back. just because you are an army vet does not make you an expert on the matter.
3-05-2010 @ 9:34PM
rogers said...To say that a teacher should be fired over this is rather overreactionary.The teacher should explain,if they have not already done so,that children should never take medicine from a pill bottle or from anyone other than a parent or guardian or an authorized person.The teachers can and should explain the difference between these candy "pills" and real medicine and tell them to never take anything from a stranger be it candy or whatever.The idea that local drug dealers are going to go around and give children pills is absurd.The high cost of prescription drugs on the street would make a dealer lose money by giving away pills to a child or an adult.Furthermore children should be taught by the time the are in school about avoiding strangers and especially the danger of taking a gift of anything from someone they don't know.Prescription drug abuse is at high enough levels that drug dealers do not have to find children to "give" them pills to get them addicted as the market is already in a state of high demand and high costs for illicit pharmacueticals enough so that so many people buy pills of variuos types for large sums of money,money that school children would not have.Even if a child had money to buy illegal pills off dealers then they would most like then not have enough money to buy more of the pills,because if so then they have parents that are much more dangerous to there safety than these teachers.
2-11-2010 @ 10:10PM
Alex said...Maybe YOU need the chill pill, man. Besides that, doesn't anyone realize how stupid the grandma sounded? "If it's in a prescription bottle, it's a drug." So, mints are drugs now, eh? That means I'm an addict. Better lock me up, throw me in rehab. Oh wiat, that makes me a dealer too, because I regularly give them to people who ask.
And another thing: isn't this exactly WHY we pay for anti-drug education in schools? Like, if this is a supposed "outrage", then obviously all our "Just Say NO!" campaigns aren't working. Should we pull funding for that?
AND TYPING IN ALL CAPS DOESN'T MAKE YOU LOOK MORE IMPORTANT, IT JUST SAYS "I'M STUPID BECAUSE I LEFT THE CAPS LOCK ON."
2-11-2010 @ 10:24PM
Cal said...WHOA partner...
Granted, what these teachers did was somewhat inappropriate, and may send a mixed message to the kids, but their imagination and intentions were great. Yes, we live in a society today that sends a message that pills can solve most any problem, but these teachers did this in fun and in an attempt to calm the kids taking a huge state exam. I am somewhat ambivalent in my feelings about it, but overall, I do not believe they intended to hurt anyone and maybe didn't think this all the way thru. Definitely they do not need to be fired or even disciplined. The principal counseled them and that is enough.
2-12-2010 @ 12:31AM
Julie said...You were probably ignorant enough to vote for the republicans, too. I'm sure you NEVER EVER EVER EVER made a mistake in your obviously overly long life!! huh! You're just perfect. lololololololololol