A Parent's Dilemma: How to Handle a College Football Scholarship for a Seventh-Grader
Filed under: Sports
Put yourself in the shoes of David and Denise Sills. Fair warning, this will take some doing.
For the most part, the Sillses are a typical family. They live in Wilmington, Delaware. They have three children, all teenagers.
The two oldest are girls. The youngest is 13-year-old David. He's in the seventh grade and plays quarterback on the middle school football team at the Red Lion Christian Academy.
Apparently, David is pretty good at football because something unheard of happened last week. The University of Southern California, a college football power, offered him a sports scholarship. Trojan coach Lane Kiffin made the proposal and, with his parents' blessing, David accepted.
There are a few strings, of course. First, David has to graduate from high school. Before that, he has to graduate from the seventh grade. If all goes as planned, David's first game in a USC uniform will be in 2015.
Granted, it's hard to imagine your 13-year-old getting home from school, slamming down his backpack and asking permission to accept a USC football scholarship. (When my sons were that age, the big sports questions at our kitchen table were: "Where's my uniform?" Followed by, "Is it washed?" )
But if it happened in your family, what would you do?
David and Denise Sills have taken some heat over their decision to let David become the Trojans quarterback of the (somewhat distant) future. As the story has been picked up by national media, they've been skewered for being pushy sports parents. One writer, Mark Saxon of ESPN Los Angeles quipped: "I was feeling as though I needed to take a shower after mulling Sills' verbal commitment."
David Sills III, the quarterback's dad, hasn't seemed bothered by the criticism. Recently he told ESPN.com: "For the people that don't like kids getting recruited early, if it was their kid what would they do?...The way I look at it if David was a phenomenal mathemetician and I held him back, wouldn't that be wrong?"
Maybe. But what if David were doing math problems at the Rose Bowl in front of 100,000 screaming fans? And Brent Musburger was barking out play-by-play? Isn't that a fairer comparison?
Experts in child development and youth sports say they worry how Sills will handle the spotlight. Even more troubling to some is what the story of a 13-year-old playing footsie with a college football coach says about the state of youth sports in general.
"We're robbing children of their childhood," warns Richard Ginsburg, a sport psychologist who treats youth athletes and their families at Boston's Massachusetts General Hospital, in an interview with ParentDish.
"The sports industry has become tailored to giving children the hope that they have a chance to be scouted and picked. There are so many things that can go wrong: Overuse injuries, burnout, stress. Putting young bodies and minds into that kind of situation, they're just not ready for it.," says Ginsburg, co-author of Whose Game is It, Anyway? a book that helps parents navigate youth sports.
Much of the medical establishment agrees about those risks. This month, the American Academy of Pediatrics sent out its latest warning. AAP's Committee on Sports Medicine and Fitness reissued a caution first published in 2000: It reads: "Children involved in sports should be encouraged to participate in a variety of different activities and develop a wide range of skills. Young athletes who specialize in just one sport may be denied the benefits of varied activity while facing additional demands from intense training and competition."
Time will tell how David Sills deals with the challenges ahead of him. Not everyone in youth sports sees what's he's doing as a disaster. Some think it actually might work out.
Linda Petlichkoff, a sport psychology consultant and professor of Kinesiology at Boise State University, says her only reservation is whether David's dream truly belongs to him.
"Are these goals actually his goals or his dad's goals?" she says in an interview with ParentDish. "If they're his, I don't think anybody should say yay, nay or put up roadblocks. That's what life's about. Set your goals ands strive for them."
Ginsburg is more skeptical. "Five years from now, maybe it's a success story. Maybe all the stars align. But he's a superstar at 13. I'm afraid the only way to go is down."
ParentDish sports reporter Mark Hyman is the author of Until It Hurts: America's Obsession With Youth Sports and How It Harms our Kids (Beacon Press). Have a suggestion for an article on youth sports? Contact Mark at pdyouthsports@aol.com.
Related: Couple Changes Wedding Plans for High School Football Game
Your<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- Derian d hickman v. Internal revenue service superior court dc 2012
- Why should anyone listen to a _____, what makes her an expert? Harpo is jus an actress, all she does is sit on her tush & claim she knows it all. ...
- Alot of .gov when submitting a program or proposal for government agency (be sure you personally can provide for the agency)











ReaderComments (Page 6 of 10)
2-17-2010 @ 12:17AM
rwt said...Just one more reason why Lane Kiffin and his ilk should be run out of athletics. I understand that I'm in the minority - but just like in the movie "Meatballs" - it just doesn't matter. At the most basic level - sports are a means of expression physically, mentally, and even spiritually for some. Beyond that it's entertainment for the masses and should be treated as such. If you live and die by who wins the Super Bowl or World Series you need to get a life. It just doesn't matter that he much the day after. If these misguided (in my opinion) parents want to sell their soul to Lane Kiffin and mortgage their kid's childhood years, it is really none of our business. Sounds like the kid may have a shot at being something big someday. Good for him. But if its not him, there will be another star to take center stage. Who really cares folks? Just as long they keep playing. Right?
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 1:28AM
Dean said...One thing to remember here is that Lane Kiffin is a real low life.
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 7:59AM
mxmom said...Please remember that Lane Kiffin is loyal to no one but himself...this young man is bound to get his heart & spirit broken by this liar just like the entire University of Tennessee football team did!
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 9:07AM
RT said...Seventh and eighth graders are not considered "recruitable student athletes" in football yet so the NCAA rules don't apply (college basketball rules have declared 7th and 8th graders recruitable because of this very problem).
This commitment will speed up the NCAA's urgency to make it a violation to recruit these kids in football too.
I've been involved in offering two eighth graders, one going back to the early 2000s and the other 4 years ago. It's rare but not new, the commitment is new.
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 11:26AM
bkeegs said...Ironic how the media is worried about the kid's' well-being, yet, they're the ones sloshing him around in the public eye. Isn't it a parents dream that their child succeeds and becomes pro at something? Whether it's sports, playing the violin, guitar, or anything a child does, you, as a parent want that kid to be successful. The boy is 13, and 5 years goes by fast. But, in that 5 years so much can change. Stop the media frenzy and let the kid...be a kid
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:07AM
rdwyer111 said...Would people be criticizing the parents if they had allowed their son to accept an Academic scholarship to USC at age 13?
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:13AM
Pat said...Kim In China the child is taken from the parent at 3 years old, at least for gymnastics, and train their entire childhood. They consider it an honor, we consider it barbaric.
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 10:19AM
Alexalon9 said...Most of the concerns addressed in this article are retarded. People are mainly causing a fuss because they are jealous, otherwise why the hell is it their business anyway.
A scholarship IS any parents dream for their child. Regardless of just pushing sports most colleges have academic standards that you must meet to stay in competitive teams. This is a SCHOLARSHIP so that this kid can get AN EDUCATION.
He first has to finish middle school and then high school. It's not like he's being asked to quarterback for the college team itself... right now! I think that fact that people are sticking their noses in it to such a degree is ridiculous.
Besides, it's just a verbal agreement. If the child decides to go into medicine, I doubt his parents will stop him AND A COLLEGE SCHOLARSHIP will STILL help him get there. Lord knows Grad school is expensive enough who wants to be paying off loans for undergrad?
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:19AM
LESLI said...This backlash is only occuring because its football. Look at how old some of these Olympians are and how driven they are to succeed in their sports. I don't hear anything about their parents being pushy. And we know that some of those coaches are just as harsh and demanding as any college football coach. Face it, if the kid were brilliant in another sport and successful, no one would say a word.
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:20AM
Tigarick said...Please people get real...this happens all the time , the only reason this recieved any attention was that it was USC and Lane Kiffin. The latter is a snake in at any level but that is another blog. Each year dozens of kids get scholarship offers in several sports and at this age. I can think of one kid from my hometown who was offered a full ride at 13 and that was Chris Leak, who went on the graduate with honors and was the starting QB for the then National Championship Fla Gators. Another who was recruited at this age was current USC starting QB Matt Barkley! You folk who say you feel ill about the Sill's are just jealous , and if your kid had chance to recieve a full sports scholarship most of you would be doing back flips and running out to spend that college fund right now ! Please! As to the writer who said he felt as if he needed to take a shower maybe he did as most sport's writer's are full of that stinky stuff anyway. Also someone wrote that either side could withdraw at any time and that is NOT true ..the young man can rescind his verbal at any time and not so fast on the granting insitution unless for cause , such as criminal activity , grades etc...if young Mr Sills got into an accident ( God forbid) and could not play a down for USC that scholarship offer is good . So mama's and daddy's go out and get on the field and maybe your kid can be the next one to save YOU oh about 250K in college fees..the rest of you so called sports experts and therapist's it is YOU that need the most help. Play on Mr Sills ..and parents of Matt, congrats and DO NOT listen nor justify your actions. Archie Manning once said he had people calling to offer him serious dollars as a sperm donor , hmmm wonder why? LMAO!
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:35AM
Irishmanjtm said...I used to play football in Jr high and high school in Jr high I used to throw the ball real good to make great long ball right into the arms of a WR's but went I got to high school for some reason I just couldn't make the throw like I did in Jr high I end up playing defense and some offense in H/S. So this his only 13 anything can happens from 3 or 4 year from now. He just might be albe to play football anymore I seen that alot.
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:37AM
Anna said...Kiffin is all about himself...this is his way of getting publicity. Do you really think he will be at USC when this child is ready to play football????? NOT!!!!
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:58AM
Angiebaby said...The kid is a football prodigy and is being groomed to excell at football. He is not being robbed of his childhood,,. he's a teenager, not a toddler. He will still have to finish school and go to the prom. He will be able to start dating sometime in the future and will learn many things during his teenage years which will shape the man he is to become. As for his commitment? It is simply a verbal consent for something down the road, like, a COLLEGE SCHOLARSHIP. And as for the media hoopla? Well, that's the media for you.
Leave the kid alone. Don't criticize the parents. A kid earned a college scholarship at 13, when most of our kids don't know what they want to be when they grow up until the last year of college and they have to commit to something to graduate. Don't you imagine things would have turned out differently if Peyton, Eli and Tiger were mouthy 13-year-olds with a sense of entitlement who excelled at video games and considering family chores a form of child labor?
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:41AM
Bill said...Why is everyone getting on the parents. It's USC and the NCAA that deserve the criticisim. The recruiting of someone of this age should not be allowed. The processs should not start until a student athlete is in the eleventh grade.
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:47AM
ray said...same thing happen with my son 11 years ago he was in 8 grade they came and watch him play he was a running back. they talk the talk.we like it. but i know now i push him to hard 9 grade he quit the team. i hope this father can do it better then i did
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 8:55AM
Neil Hohmann said...There is an easier solution to this matter, and one which until now, I thought in force. NO COLLEGE CAN CONTACT A HIGH SCHOOL NOR AN INDIVIDUAL AS A RECRUIT NOR POTENTIAL SCHOLARSHIP RECIPIENT, PERIOD!
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 9:09AM
whispererk said...First off, the punk, Kiffin, is taking advantage of the boy for his own publicity stunt. Offering a seventh grader a scholarship is ridiculous. Secondly, it could give the kid a false sense of himself, inflating his ego to titanic size and in the long run hurt his chances.
Thirdly, it looks like he has some pretty good receivers. Is Kiffin offering them scholarships? Kiffin is the biggest jerk in football.
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 9:24AM
VolMan said...Kiffin is doing this for his own publicity I totally agree.!! Heck I am pretty sure Kiffin & his boys will be long gone to the house before this kid gets out of High school..
2-17-2010 @ 10:18AM
Leslie said...Childhood is fairly new phenomenon...just within the past 80-100 years have kids been "allowed" to have a childhood by not working in factories and on the farm (in the USA and other western coutries)yand, really, do any children have a "childhood" today? The have cable TV, hip hop music, "poptarts". vulgar language everywhere, R-rated movies on TV, absentee parents, the internet and i-Phones. Atleast these parents have insured that their son will receive a top notch education at a great school. This will help insure his future success and happiness. Everyone who criticizes these parents are just experiencing "sour grapes"! Who would not love to have their child insured a free-ride at an early age?
Reply
2-17-2010 @ 9:17AM
Buster said...soo much negativity and jealousy, I think that maybe a lot of people wish it was them !
Reply