Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Charlotte Robinson: LISTEN: How Gay And Lesbian Couples Become…
New Turnaround Teacher 'Trying To Get It Right' In Tough School
Child's Tantrums Wearing Us Out!
Filed under: Expert Advice: Babies, Development: Toddlers & Preschoolers, Behavior: Toddlers & Preschoolers, Expert Advice: Toddlers & Preschoolers, Development: Big Kids, Expert Advice: Big Kids
Dear AdviceMama,
Our 4-year-old great grandson has yelling, screaming tantrums if he does not get his way. He has been like this from the time he crawled. His 2-year-old brother is very calm and quiet. How can we get him to stop acting this way?
Signed,
Tired of Tantrums
Dear Tired of Tantrums,
I'm sorry to hear about your great grandson's upsets. A child's temper tantrums can wear down even the hardiest caregiver; no doubt, it's especially difficult to manage when the behavior happens regularly, disrupting the peace of the household whenever he doesn't get his way.
Children have tantrums when they feel overwhelmed by frustration, disappointment, sadness or anger. In a sense, your great grandson becomes caught in a "storm" of emotions, losing his anchor and finding himself adrift on a sea of feelings too big for him to manage.
In addition, your great grandsons may have the same parents, but that doesn't mean they have the same temperaments. Some children are born with placid, easygoing personalities while others arrive with a fiery disposition and intense nature. Rather than trying to make him more like his brother, focus on how you can help prevent his emotional storms so he can learn how to cope with frustration when he doesn't get what he wants.
1. A child who is tired, hungry or over-stimulated is much more vulnerable to falling apart when life isn't going his way. Make sure your great grandson is well nourished and rested, particularly at difficult times of day like preparing meals or getting everyone out of the house in the morning, when there's a lot going on.
2. Give your great grandson the sense that you're on his side, and you understand his distress. Put words to what you suspect is going on for him: "It's so hard when the blocks don't stay where you want them," or "You really wanted another cookie ... " without trying to talk him out of his feelings, or caving in to his demands. It's deeply comforting to a child when a calm and loving caregiver acknowledges the enormity of his disappointment or anger, and gently helps him move toward the sadness and tears that help him feel better again.
3. Avoid explaining why he can't have what he wants while he's in the midst of being flooded with powerful feelings. A child who's having a tantrum is incapable of processing words, logic or the rational explanations that you may think will get him to calm down. Instead, stay nearby, offer your lap -- if he'll take it -- and wait out the storm with him, helping him find his tears so he can adapt to his world not working the way he would like.
By accepting your great grandson's temperament rather than comparing him to his brother, providing him with the rest and nourishment that will better help him cope with disappointment, and remaining calm while he struggles, you'll help this little boy develop the coping skills and resilience that will help him adjust to life's inevitable ups and downs.
Yours in parenting support,
AdviceMama
AdviceMama, Susan Stiffelman, is a licensed and practicing psychotherapist and marriage and family therapist. She holds a Bachelor of Arts in developmental psychology and a Master of Arts in clinical psychology. Her book, Parenting Without Power Struggles, is available on Amazon. Sign up to get Susan's free parenting newsletter.
Have a question for AdviceMama? Submit your question here.












ReaderComments (Page 5 of 15)
5-17-2010 @ 9:29PM
Greenemachine said...Our sixth child had horrible crying fits, and tantrums. He was our hardest child by far. After extensive testing (of the brain, nervous system, hearing, neurological responses, and I don't even know what else), we took him to a chiropractor who practiced Applied kinesiology, and he discovered that eight of the plates (bones) in his skull were out of place. After just two treatments there was incredible improvement. He is also chronically allergic to cows milk, and formula, even organic formula. Just for you information the chiropractor was Dr Martin in KC
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 10:44PM
Fabricio said...A brief/constructive suggestion:
Do not intoxicate kids with Religion.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:31PM
politicallycorrect said...Great idea ;) seriously but Robert Smith has it all wrong...it's sniveling liberals that cry & whine like a toddler w/ crap is his nappy
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:30PM
Roger said...What if he has Asberger's ?
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:31PM
Lin said...Sorry...but "AdviceMama" hasn't a clue! Children respond to what they are taught, despite their natural tendencies toward certain personality traits. She really needs a degree in psychologiy...and a little "learning up", as they say in Colorado!
This little boy needs what all children need...parameters. When he throws a tantrum, take him gently but firmly by the shoulders, look him in the eye, and say "This behavior is NOT acceptable!" If he continues to scream, walk him into an unoccupied room, say "When you are finished screaming, you are welcome to re-join us", and gently but firmly shut the door. If he continues screaming as he comes out, repeat the procedure...as often as necessary until he "gets it"! When he finally comes out and rejoins the family quietly, lavish him with love and snuggles...offering a favorite treat isn't a bad idea, either, but isn't really necessary.
If you do this consistently, it shouldn't take but an incident or two for him to learn that good behavior gets him what he wants, and negative behavior doesn't. His tantrums are a plea for guidelines...do all of you the favor of giving them to him!
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:31PM
jmgodsey said...Perhaps they should whip his little ass. a coulple of times is all that it takes.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:33PM
Retta said...This is how I got my four year old daughter to stop her tantrums. While she was having a tantrum, I threw one too, only I kept getting louder and stomping my feet. She stopped her tantrum and stood and stared at me. She never did it again. I think it scared her. She is grown now.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:53PM
Shelly said...I'm replying to Retta about how you threw a "fake" tantrum during your child's tantrum ... that's a classic! I actually only tried that once with my son when he was about 5 and he thought I was going crazy?? I think he finally realized how stupid, silly and kind of crazy he was acting when he saw a grown up do it.
He stopped his tantrum and said "Mom, can we just go relax now?"
Worked pretty good. When he gets frustrated he will usually just make a sad face and then we talk about what we call "THE FRUSTRATE." Sometimes even when I've had a hard day ... I'll say, "I'VE HAD THE FRUSTRATE" and he will say what's wrong and we talk about it. He will do the same ... it is mutual respect, LISTENING to each other, RESPECTING each other as loving human beings, and realizing sometimes there are things in life that will be very frustrating.
Then we talk about it, try to figure out solutions and how to make things go better the next time with frustrating situations in life ... and we all know there are ALWAYS going to be frustrating situation in life that just happen. :-)
5-17-2010 @ 9:35PM
yabbi said...he only has tantrums because his parents are so useless. Shoot them!!! give the kid to some normal parents who know how to draw boundaries. he needs that kind of support. his parents are complete idiots.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:36PM
irish11 said...I agree that they should look into if he has ADD or something like that, but only after trying things like a good swat to the behind. both me and my two siblings tried throwing a temper tantrum 1 time "that's 1 time each" and my dad just looked at us and said if we wanted to throw a fit he would give us a reason...we each got our little hind ends busted and that was the end of that. I do like the cold water idea a bit too, it's like using water to break up a cat or dog fight. it shocks them without hurting them and then, with a small child, seeing you walk away makes them go...oh, that's not getting me what I want and mom is ignoring me now. they'll straighten up pretty quick. Children WANT mom and dad's love and approval, and if they think their behavior ISN'T going to get them that then they will "normally" stop the behavior. They exception being if there is a deeper reason for the behavior, like a mental disorder.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:39PM
Susan said...This is the most rediculous thing I have heard in a while. This is how we end up with kids like this little girl in my daughters class that no one wants to be friends with because she is 9 years old and out of control. She has no personal boundaries, and no clue how she should behave because her parents never made her behave for a second in her whole life. Please people, teach your kids from an early age that life isn't fair. You don't always get your way. In fact the majority of the time you don't get your way. You have to roll with the punches and make the best of what you have and sure it's ok to be sad sometimes but it is not ok to have a screaming fit about it! There has to be consistent expectations, and follow through with discipline when the expectation is not met. Lots of praise when it is met. Kids need structure. Give it to them.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:40PM
Vera said...How about when you have an 11 yr. old who does the same exact thing and NEVER STOPS IT till he absolutely gets his way....hmm? My sister's kid does this ALL THE TIME. Spanking is out because it's been done already to no effect whatsoever. Ignoring him doesn't work at all either. It is so bad that I don't want to even be around him anymore. I still love him, but I really don't enjoy him. I see how horrible it is on the whole family EVERY SINGLE TIME I come over the house. Non-stop whining, complaining, yelling, screaming, till my poor sister can't take it anymore and just caves in. There is no other option. Personally, I am so glad I am not a parent in this politically-correct day and age, because I would be a HUGE supporter of spankings. I'm 40 and can totally see the difference between kids of my time and kids of this time....
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:40PM
archerandlion said...Wait till your screamer turns to a teenager. You'll look back on theses days fondly.
In the mean time, one word. Ritalin.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:43PM
etherwele said...When I was growing up in the late 40's and early 50's, my father had a simple solution to misbehavior. He used to say, "If you can't listen, you can feel". His application of that simple line was done with swiftness and without anger. None of the four of us grew up hating him or abusing our own children. Children learn how to manipulate their parents from a very early age. If a parent gives in to that manipulative behavior, be it tantrums or another form of behavior, it becomes more and more difficult to deal with. Children behave pretty much as their parents demonstrate their expectations for behavior. As for books, I always found that Dr. Spock's treatise on child rearing was best, especially when applied to the errant rear end of the misbehaving child. Also several writers were exactly right. Too many parents, beginning in the 60's tried to be friends to their children. My kids had enough friends, what they needed and wanted were parents who set limits and enforced those limits with love and as much toughness as needed. One writer was wrong about the bucket of water being abusive. It is only so if done in anger. Calmly applying such a bucket is effective, but only if you then require the miscreant to clean up the mess.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:43PM
peggy said...My father would say... ''YOU WANT TO CRY... I'LL GIVE YOU SOMETHING TO CRY ABOUT!'' GET THE BELT!
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:46PM
Wayne G. said...The type of discipline is not the key. The key is to administer it consistently, firmly, and fairly. If you tell the child he is going to get a spanking, spank him! If you tell him he is getting a time out, make sure he goes in time out. If you tell him you are sending him to bed early, do it! This aint rocket science folks. Just make sure you tell him why you are doing whatever you are doing, and make sure you tell him at some point that you love him.
Reply
5-18-2010 @ 4:14AM
cj said...any child at a certain age can take advantage of their tantrums.We as parents let it happen,if you nip it in the bud at first you will not get the same results.Now I'm not saying to beat them,but a open hand swat across the ass never hurt any child.Control your kids,your kids don't control you.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:49PM
Usually right said...Children that throw tantrums are products of the parent's failure to be parents and at 4 years old it is too late to blame it on the child's disposition. This idiot Psychotherapist is just playing the "politically correct" game and has no idea what she is talking about. It's really sad when the parents can't even take responsibility for the actions of their own children and clearly their inability to control the child is a reflection of their own lack of control. Can't change some things, just hope I never have to know these people. Too bad for the great grandparents.
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:49PM
blackhawk said...my Grandmother ,God rest her soul, use to say the good Lord put plent of cusion on the tush , so a good swat on the backside to correct a problen doesn't really hurt that much but it sure does get the proper attention, usually for the better, and Oh if I would have told my dad if you spank me I'll call the cops, I would be looking for somewhere else to live or my rear-end would be receiver of my stupidty
Reply
5-17-2010 @ 9:49PM
warren Miller said...Beat the SOB
Reply