Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Zoe Armstrong: Five Ways to Fake a Break and Avoid Parenting Burnout
How To Help Victims Of The Tornado
Losing a Breast in a Body-Obsessed Culture
Filed under: Medical Conditions, Fashion, Opinions, Development Health
As her tween embarks into womanhood, this breast-cancer surviving mom contemplates the feminine figure. Illustration by Dori Hartley
As my 12-year old daughter and I cuddled up together on the couch for our TV-viewing evening, we had the opportunity to see the controversial cleavage that had all of America buzzing: Lane Bryant's commercial for its new line of undies. The ad got me thinking about breasts.
Every few years, corporate America pats itself on the back for embracing the women who brazenly defy the size-zero standards. It's a trend that dies a quick, unnoticeable death and ensures an equally speedy return to the safe, though impossibly unattainable, skin-and-bones associated with the slithering hotties that sell Victoria's Secret lingerie. The buzz on the naturally bodacious Lane Bryant model was that she was a tad too luscious for mainstream America's prime-time viewers.
Truth be told, America loves breasts. And when we get a chance to see them in a television commercial, it's like a dirty little secret disguised as a fashion show to which we want an invitation. Like apple pie and baseball, breasts are a significant part of American culture.
Three years after my daughter was born, I developed breast cancer. I had a mastectomy and a partial reconstruction. I did not perceive my body as ugly and I never felt sorry for myself. As a mother, it was up to me to make sure my child grew up knowing that we have to make the best with what we've got, and that we're all perfectly beautiful as we are, without need for commercial approval. My single breast was just as worthy as a solo player over my heart.
Shortly after I came home from the hospital, my baby girl noticed that my chest appeared somewhat different than it had in the past. No longer a breast, but a "breast-mound," as the doctor called it.
"Mama, where is your nipple?" she asked.
I had the choice of answering in one of two ways. I could burden her with fearsome thoughts of surgical procedures and a life nearly lost, or I could show her by example that even though life may alter us, it doesn't define who we are.
I chose the latter.
"It went to nipple heaven, honey."
Satisfied, she went on her way. After all, I was Mama, and if Mama was OK, then all was right with the world. My child never knew that her father found me so repulsive in my post-operative state that it was as good a reason as any to end our already decayed marriage. To him, my lack of a second breast somehow made me hideous and unlovable. It was a hard pill to swallow, but an inner voice kept reminding me that this was a clear case of "that's your problem, bud."
Together, he and I kept the drama to a minimum, explaining to our young daughter that it would be better if Mom and Dad lived separately, yet promising "to marinate her with love," which became our divorced-parent mantra. I didn't want her to resent her father or to grow up perceiving all men as ruthless judges of women's bodies. I was up against dispelling the idea that the scarred and imperfect get left behind, while the flawless and beautiful are celebrated and coveted.
In order to do this, I downplayed my so-called flaws and let her become an eye-witness over the years to the woman I really am, scars and all. What she saw was an intelligent and confident person who worked hard and laughed harder. What she came to know was that her mother is a well-loved and respected person who moved through the world as if the word "flawed" didn't exist.
Now, as a preteen, my daughter is hyper aware of the attention paid to women's breasts, as well as the rest of our bodies. These days, during the Victoria's Secret commercials, we acknowledge that we don't actually know anybody who looks like these models, but rather many who look more like the Lane Bryant gals.
We talk about how the promotion of unnaturally skinny is a key player in the selling of procedures, bras and diets. We continue to come to the conclusion – yes, after two minutes of commercials -- that if you're happy with what you've got, you really can't be affected by what someone else thinks you should be.
So, when I recently held my girl to my side and asked her what she wanted for her upcoming birthday, I had to smile. Knowing the days of dolls and games were long gone, I anticipated her response would have something to do with fashion.
"I think I want to get some stuff from Victoria's Secret," she said.
There's no argument that even with all our talks, advertising works. My daughter is a healthy adolescent, about to embrace a world of feminine possibility. Having discovered my own sense of real versus fake as a result of a war-wound isn't going to make me stop her from experiencing life's offerings, even if that consists of lacy underthings draped on impossible-to-attain thinness.
Maybe I'll even get myself something black and lacy while I'm there.
Related: Pregnancy Safe for Breast Cancer Survivors, Study Shows











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 11)
6-02-2010 @ 10:14AM
Kim Roche said...Thank you Dori for sharing your life so that others might benefit from your insights. What a well written article that I will show my pre-teen daughter when she gets home from school.
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 8:44PM
stephen said...I think your hubby didn't know how to handle the situation for one and maybe he needed to grow up and be a partner. I think we all have beauty and gifts and they are not always body parts. I find yo a very beautiful woman and no I'm not looking for a GF. Just paying a compliment to you.
6-06-2010 @ 10:16PM
Lynn said...Beauty lives within us. The most "beautiful" people can be ugly and the "ugliest" people can be quite beautiful. It is the metaphysical beauty that is most important. Peace be with you , Lynn
6-06-2010 @ 10:28PM
marlene said...well i just had a masectomey March 30,10,,and waiting for reconstructive surgey .but my husband of 28 years says if i want it fine if i dont that is fine too he loves me anyway. there is just two many people out that that is just plain vain. my children and grandchildren are fine with it also.but yours was a good story
6-06-2010 @ 11:11PM
Dennis Peters said...well as a man all i can say is her ex is a loser , for her to survive and keep going i would love her all the more. And men like that should be shot!
6-07-2010 @ 12:05AM
Giles said...Folks have a potential to project their own feelings onto others, sometimes. Cancer is scary. Both my parents had it, Dad died of complications of it. Each man is different. But chances are both of you, the writer of the article, and your husband, feared you might die, and both of you had feelings about your masectomy. The usual models are not impossibly skinny. It is very normal for them. And some of the probably wish they were as voluptuous as the plus sized model, with him slim waist. But folks come in several varieties, each as possible and as natural as the next. Apparently you haven`t had any reoccurrance of you cancer, something I`m sure both you and your husband may have feared. When Mom was dying, every night when I left the nursing home, she`d order me not to come back. Every day when I came back, she`d thank GOD I`d returned. Eventually she was released home and died here. She was terrified I`d desert her, but I told her I wouldn`t, that she`d desert me, would die on me. And, of course, she did. I hope you have a nice day.
6-07-2010 @ 3:39AM
Anne said...Learn to read gretchen Lieff: "My child never knew that her father found me so repulsive in my post-operative state that it was as good a reason as any to end our already decayed marriage."
You're the one that's repulsive
6-07-2010 @ 11:10AM
Cheryl Meisel said...You go girl, you sound ALL WOMAN to me. Beautiful in and OUT it doesn't get any better then that. Sounds to me like your a wonderful mother too. Ahhhhh women, they kill me lol. They do it all and do it like no other. God really out did himself when he made WOMAN!
6-02-2010 @ 10:29AM
Craig Sargent said...Thank you for this Dori. I hope this touches as many others as it did us. My wife Cindy's mom had a double mastectomy some years ago, so your thoughts are close to home here. If your daughter grows into a shining star, as we're sure she will, we can see where she gets her Light. Thank you sincerely.
Reply
6-07-2010 @ 12:15AM
Dana said...My wife went through a Lumpectomy last year. We seriously thought that it was going to be a Mastectomy possibly a double one. I told my beautiful bride of 25 wonderful years that I did not care what they did as long as I could love her for another 25 years ! I cried for 2 days . I was so worried that I thought that I would just die without her. It has been a year since the operation and she is doing well. I love her more each day and I pray that she NEVER has to go through that again. I will say that women need to check themselves frequently and not be afraid to let your husband in on what you find out. My wife waited 3 years and if she had waited 6 more monthe we would have lost her. It had spread into 11 lymphnodes and was 2cm+.
6-02-2010 @ 10:41AM
Dean said...wonderful piece,full of humour,honesty and intelligence
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:38PM
angelface said...i could'nt have said it any better dean, im so sorry what she had to go through with her jerk of a husband finding her unattractive after a serious procedure! she is a very beautiful woman and will defenitly find a great man someday,she is a wonderfull mom and i wish her the best of luck in the future.
6-06-2010 @ 11:25PM
Isabella said...An absolutely beautifully, thoughtfully, carefully crafted piece of excellent writing. It moved me and made me cringe. My own husband left me and our two wonderful chilren after severe stretch marks made me repulsive to him. We all have stories to tell. It's wonderful when someone is brave enough to share theirs with no self-pity, only grace, humility and strength. Even compassion. I'm in awe of this beautiful woman and wish her and her daughter every happiness and good health always. As time goes by and we become wise, it does get easier to tell those who are deep from those who are unable to handle challenges, or their own insecurities. Life is painful and hard, but being able to share and inspire as the writer has done, makes it worthwhile. Thank you.
6-02-2010 @ 10:44AM
Cyndi Jolly said...Thanks Dori for this insightful, important comment on women, the life we lead and the struggles that we all go through on a day to day basis. It's my hope that many others all over the world are raising their daughters the way that you are, to become women in all the glory that word holds and to see it as glory and not less than or having to be model perfect. Brilliant article!
Reply
6-02-2010 @ 10:47AM
Maritza Espinal said...Dori,
Great article!...it is very moving and thought-provoking.
I remain flabbergasted when I hear about spouses that turn their backs on wives when their support is so needed. And I commend you for "keeping it real" for your daughter. She has her own road to travel; yet, no doubt she will carry your example with her.
Thanks!
Reply
6-02-2010 @ 10:49AM
Amy Leech said...A very thought provoking article, it's a damn shame that women like you aren't thought of as role models for the younger generation. You have dealt with surviving cancer and the mastectomy with dignity and grace, showing your daughter that being a strong woman isn't about following the trends, that it comes from within. xx
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 11:14PM
harry said...What makes you think Dori isn't already a role model for younger girls? I'm sure she is ....or will be very soon.
I think it's funny that angelface would call the hubby a "jerk" even though the author didn't.....obviously he wasn't the right person but it's not her place to call him names. What purpose did it serve?
6-02-2010 @ 11:04AM
Sandra said...Dori awesome article
Enjoyed it alot.
hope to read more
thanks
Sandy
Reply
6-02-2010 @ 3:42PM
Darius said...Great article! In regards to those skinny Victoria Secret models, Rosie O'donnell put it best," Meat is for the man, bone is for the dog!"
I think it is horrible the way Madison Ave. pushes this impossible to reach ideal, your daughter is extraordinarily lucky to have such an intelligent mom to provide her with the insight to put things in perspective.
Reply
6-02-2010 @ 11:50AM
Joe said...Dori, This speaks volumes about you and your inner strength, even though those who know you personally not virtually should know about this already. With having two family members come through some form of Cancer I can understand this. I am lucky that I don't have to mourn anyone that has passed directly from this, but my heart really goes out to my friends who have lost someone either from Cancer or another disease.
Please keep writing these thought provoking articles.
Reply