Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Charlotte Robinson: LISTEN: How Gay And Lesbian Couples Become…
New Turnaround Teacher 'Trying To Get It Right' In Tough School
Losing a Breast in a Body-Obsessed Culture
Filed under: Medical Conditions, Fashion, Opinions, Development Health
As her tween embarks into womanhood, this breast-cancer surviving mom contemplates the feminine figure. Illustration by Dori Hartley
As my 12-year old daughter and I cuddled up together on the couch for our TV-viewing evening, we had the opportunity to see the controversial cleavage that had all of America buzzing: Lane Bryant's commercial for its new line of undies. The ad got me thinking about breasts.
Every few years, corporate America pats itself on the back for embracing the women who brazenly defy the size-zero standards. It's a trend that dies a quick, unnoticeable death and ensures an equally speedy return to the safe, though impossibly unattainable, skin-and-bones associated with the slithering hotties that sell Victoria's Secret lingerie. The buzz on the naturally bodacious Lane Bryant model was that she was a tad too luscious for mainstream America's prime-time viewers.
Truth be told, America loves breasts. And when we get a chance to see them in a television commercial, it's like a dirty little secret disguised as a fashion show to which we want an invitation. Like apple pie and baseball, breasts are a significant part of American culture.
Three years after my daughter was born, I developed breast cancer. I had a mastectomy and a partial reconstruction. I did not perceive my body as ugly and I never felt sorry for myself. As a mother, it was up to me to make sure my child grew up knowing that we have to make the best with what we've got, and that we're all perfectly beautiful as we are, without need for commercial approval. My single breast was just as worthy as a solo player over my heart.
Shortly after I came home from the hospital, my baby girl noticed that my chest appeared somewhat different than it had in the past. No longer a breast, but a "breast-mound," as the doctor called it.
"Mama, where is your nipple?" she asked.
I had the choice of answering in one of two ways. I could burden her with fearsome thoughts of surgical procedures and a life nearly lost, or I could show her by example that even though life may alter us, it doesn't define who we are.
I chose the latter.
"It went to nipple heaven, honey."
Satisfied, she went on her way. After all, I was Mama, and if Mama was OK, then all was right with the world. My child never knew that her father found me so repulsive in my post-operative state that it was as good a reason as any to end our already decayed marriage. To him, my lack of a second breast somehow made me hideous and unlovable. It was a hard pill to swallow, but an inner voice kept reminding me that this was a clear case of "that's your problem, bud."
Together, he and I kept the drama to a minimum, explaining to our young daughter that it would be better if Mom and Dad lived separately, yet promising "to marinate her with love," which became our divorced-parent mantra. I didn't want her to resent her father or to grow up perceiving all men as ruthless judges of women's bodies. I was up against dispelling the idea that the scarred and imperfect get left behind, while the flawless and beautiful are celebrated and coveted.
In order to do this, I downplayed my so-called flaws and let her become an eye-witness over the years to the woman I really am, scars and all. What she saw was an intelligent and confident person who worked hard and laughed harder. What she came to know was that her mother is a well-loved and respected person who moved through the world as if the word "flawed" didn't exist.
Now, as a preteen, my daughter is hyper aware of the attention paid to women's breasts, as well as the rest of our bodies. These days, during the Victoria's Secret commercials, we acknowledge that we don't actually know anybody who looks like these models, but rather many who look more like the Lane Bryant gals.
We talk about how the promotion of unnaturally skinny is a key player in the selling of procedures, bras and diets. We continue to come to the conclusion – yes, after two minutes of commercials -- that if you're happy with what you've got, you really can't be affected by what someone else thinks you should be.
So, when I recently held my girl to my side and asked her what she wanted for her upcoming birthday, I had to smile. Knowing the days of dolls and games were long gone, I anticipated her response would have something to do with fashion.
"I think I want to get some stuff from Victoria's Secret," she said.
There's no argument that even with all our talks, advertising works. My daughter is a healthy adolescent, about to embrace a world of feminine possibility. Having discovered my own sense of real versus fake as a result of a war-wound isn't going to make me stop her from experiencing life's offerings, even if that consists of lacy underthings draped on impossible-to-attain thinness.
Maybe I'll even get myself something black and lacy while I'm there.
Related: Pregnancy Safe for Breast Cancer Survivors, Study Shows












ReaderComments (Page 5 of 11)
6-06-2010 @ 9:14PM
evelyn said...Good for you. I too had bilateral mastectomy and did not feel less of a woman or was unhappy about it . It was my choice to remove both breasts even if only one was diseased.
I still look good inside and outside. Any man who find us repulsive because some parts are missing is --shallow!!! He only cares about himself!!! What if he loses his testicles ---will we(women ) find him repulsive too???
To heck with those men!!! We do not need them!!!
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:23PM
KatieCouric'sNemesis said...You simply cannot lose sleep over these immature losers who "stop" loving you because your body isn't pre-baby slim, your breasts aren't large enough, you are aging, or you lose a body part to surgical necessity.
The truth is, they didn't love you before that. It's an EXCUSE. And you are well rid of them.
Life when they walk out is, at first, difficult. Then you find out some incredible things about yourself. You're strong. You love your children. You can survive on your own.
That makes you so much more lovable when the right man comes into your life...and he will. It takes a little time, but he will be there. And he will love you unconditionally and accept your flaws because he is mature enough to be mindful of his own that he expects YOU to love him in spite of.
Love after 60 is so much better than any that came before.
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:22PM
Peggy said...Kudos to you Dori! I am a breast cancer survivor as well having had a mastectomy with no reconstruction. I have a 23 year old daughter who at the time of my surgery, sent me an article with a note that said, "you should do this mom". It was an article with pictures of women who had mastectomies, some double, posing for photographs, proudly showing their beautiful bodies...scars and all. It me feel all the more confident about how I looked, but more importantly, proud that my daughter thought these women were beautiful!! You're a great mom Dori, and your daughter is a very lucky girl!
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:23PM
pam said...I guess I am lucky.I lost my right breast to cancer but my husband stood right by me..I think he wants me to get a new one but don't push..I just don't want anymore surgerys at least not right now..
When you marry as in when you have children something can go wrong and health fail but it is so much easier if the love who loves supportsyou..
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:25PM
pam said...I got so many scras well I look like some one wrote a very large "I" on my body in front..again I am lucky for haveing a good husband of the last 37 years
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:29PM
Randy Doson said...Dori, it's been a long time sense I felt so enambered with anyone so selfless and in tune with the real side of life! I think you are a fine mother and likely you were also a FINE wife! I believe your ex will think about his decision for the rest of his life and find little solice in his choice! I commend you for being such a quality human being, the world could use more as yourself! Good luck with the rest of your life! I hope it proves to leave you with hope and content!
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:34PM
Bea said...Your article hit close to home, I too had trouble dealing with no breast I had a double mastectomy, But after a while I became used to not having them nipple and all. But I have since had reconstruction surgery but no nipples yet. Believe in yourselft you are as beautiful today as before your surgery. Thank you for sharing your story.
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:33PM
Delta007 said...This is a beautifully written article. Thanks Dori for sharing. Too bad you and dad were mismatched in your relationship with each other, but congratulations for being well matched in your relationship with your daughter.
I live in a house full of boys and dad's and my views play a big part in how they view the world and others in it. I hope that we help them have the healthy self image that your daughter seems to have now.
:) Nipple heaven, I love that response.
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:40PM
Dolores said...Good for you!
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:40PM
Michelle said...You go girl! What an inspirational human being!!!
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:44PM
jane said...As a women that underwent a preventative masectomy and the most challenging of recoveries............I have never once regretted the choice for myself, my husband or my girls. Yes, tatooted nipples are unique, especially for one that is opposed to tatoos in general, but I wear mine as a badge of courage for the scars beneath them. Oh, and I am alive to enjoy my family and share my story and to give thanks to God for every day I have been blessed to enjoy.
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 10:09PM
YBSFDriel said...@Dori- @Dori- Thanks for sharing your story with many women around the world. I am a two year survivor and I realize every woman's story is so different. However, all breast cancer patients have experienced some form of stressor. Yes, developing this disease can alter your life as a person, a parent, a spouse, a sister, and or a friend. However, life should not stop after the initial diagnosis. Every person copes differently, but after that initial shock it is very important to become optimistic about the disease.
I had a lumpectomy, but the surgery caused a slight imperfection to my left breast. I know that my procedure is classified as the least type of invasive surgery, but I also notice the difference in my breast. Guess what? To keep a positive attitude and a radiant personality, I purchase sexy colorful bras without the underwire, conservative clothes with a tab of sex appeal, and perfume that will fill the room with a sensational smell. Additionally, I constantly remind myself that God created me in His own image and I am beautifully made by him. Again, thanks for sharing your story!
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:44PM
Eileen said...Dori, thanks for the great article. Your husband was a superficial fool. I am happy that you have survived, and attained the wisdom to know that a breast does not make a woman. I am a 29-year breast cancer survivor. I never had any daughters but when I was diagnosed I had a 2-yr-old son and was 2 months pregnant. The pea-sized tumor that showed negative on 2 mammograms grew to the size of a walnut in those 2 months. Within the first 2 weeks of June 1981 I lost a breast and a baby. The loss of the baby was the harder of the 2 losses. My older sister was diagnosed with breast cancer in 1980 and died in 1982. So I also had to deal with survivor's guilt. My wonderful husband and little boy got me thru the ordeal. Today I am a grandmother to 2 beautiful little girls and one lively little boy. I feel very blessed. To me every thing since 1981 is icing on the cake of life. No one can really understand what we go thru unless they have been there and done that. LOL. I am a hospice nurse and feel I have a special understanding and empathy because of my history. My story is just one of many. We survivors are truly in a sisterhood all its own. God bless and continued good health to you. Eileen
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:47PM
Rhonda said...Thank you for sharing this story! It is very much appreciated by a breast cancer survivor/patient without a left breast and no reconstructive surgery!
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:50PM
joey said...Dori, Wow! You are truly an amazing woman, thank you for sharing your life with the world. You are an inspiration to us all!
Reply
6-22-2010 @ 10:40PM
gal said...Your article was so true. Sorry that some men cannot see past then end of puberty. We woman are not just a set of mammary glands, but human beings --what makes us beautiful is not what you see on the outside but what is on the inside. Teach your daughter well--I know you will. It's a shame the media is also obsessed with "skinny" instead of healthy. Cleavage or no---we were born this way and it comes with the package ->regarding the hoopla about the plus size woman's undergarments.
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:49PM
Addy said...I have a friend who, even DURING and after pregnancy, has never weighed more than maybe 115, 120 lbs. in her life. She's always been very thin - and she's also had Ensure prescribed to her to GAIN weight because a hyperactive thyroid prevents her from doing that successfully. I have another friend who is *constantly* criticizing herself for being overweight and constantly being criticized FOR it despite struggling with a hypOactive thyroid that works against her every effort to eat right and exercise. I have yet another one who is constantly worried about what the effects of a tumor in her thyroid and having to have hers completely removed will do to her body size and image. I have a friend who doesn't like her body image because she's survived breast cancer AND the chemo that made her sick afterwards.
I have a friend who can't stand seeing himself in the mirror sometimes because he feels like he's the wrong gender. I have a friend who's constantly dealing with being ostracized at school because she's black in a mostly asian school. I myself am bi, Pagan, and slightly plump and until I found the strength to not care what people thought of me and embrace loving myself as a person, I grew up terrified of society and people who hated me for any and every reason they could find.
I love the article, but call me a pessimist if you want... the comments bother me a bit. . It makes me wonder how many people commenting so endearingly, trash other people because of their religion, or because they have scars, or because they're too thin, or because they're too fat, or because they dress or act differently, or over their sexual orientation.
I hate the main principle and problem this article brings to light, and that is that it takes tragedy to bring out the humanity in people and even then it sometimes doesn't.
Breast cancer is a terrible cancer that I hope is someday cured along with so many others - but it disappoints and disgusts me that had this been any other problem out of the woman's control people wouldn't have spared this article a first let alone second glance, and I'm sure half the comments would have gone very differently than they did.
To me the point of this article isn't solely dealing with Breast Cancer, or struggling with the aftereffects of surviving it - as much as it is about the core principle of being yourself, loving and respecting yourself, and teaching our kids to do the same despite what popular belief and advertising may be presenting as "right" or "acceptable" and despite what struggles life throws your way.
You have ONE life to live and it WILL eventually end - sometimes sooner than later and you'll never know which one you are until that day comes - you should make it as meaningful, fulfilling, and happy as you can instead of tearing yourself or others down, or worrying about things that, in the end, won't matter.
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:50PM
Angie said...Regarding your callous husband... honey, good riddance to bad rubbish. If he had really loved you (something about "in sickness and in health" comes to mind) it might have taken an adjustment but he would've still loved you. We all have our crosses to bear, whether physical or emotional.
Kudos to you.. but don't fault your daughter for wanting to go to Vicky's Secret. Boobs are a nice part of the whole package and it sounds like what you've shown her is that women are a WHOLE package. As a woman with larger than average, there's no right answer when it comes to the "girls". All we can be is whole people and hope to find others who appreciate us in the way we want and deserve.
Now get out there and get something lacy! Not for a guy, not for America, but for yourself.
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:55PM
Andrea Rowe said...I have wondered how to handle this with my own daughter. She's just 4 right now and my son is 6. They have asked questions that are made more heart wrenching because we three have Cowden Sydrome and a female's lifetime odds of breast cancer are like 50%. I love your response about it going to Heaven. Since I also had OVCA at the ages of 9 and 15 as well as a lot of benign problems much has been removed froim me---breasts, uterus this past year, thyroid, one kidney, one ovary, etc. I fear them facing something similiar. I hope you don't mind if I use what you said if it does happen to them. It all started at age 9 for me and I was so confused. Thank you so much for the article.
Reply
6-06-2010 @ 9:54PM
HesTNTonPMS said...Shame on that man !
Wait a minute, a real man would never leave you in the midle of a battle , he would fight right along with you , which is what he promised when he said I do.
I suppose I am about to face a similar situation.
My wife was diagnosed with BRCA2 and anyone who knows anything about this diagnosis knows what they do reccomend.
Though we do fight like cats and dogs @ times ,
I could never call myself a man if I left her when she needed me the most.
God bless you Dori
Reply