Hot on HuffPost Parents:
WATCH: 12-Year-Old Piano Prodigy Uses His Music As Medicine
Breaking The Paternity Leave Barrier: The Rest Of The Story
Should My Ex's Fiancee Post Photos of My Daughter on Her Facebook?
Filed under: Divorce & Custody, Media, Single Parenting, Relationships, Expert Advice: Big Kids, Expert Advice: Tweens, Expert Advice: Teens, Expert Advice: Just For You, Expert Advice: Home Base
Dear AdviceMama,
I am a newly divorced mom with custody of my child. My daughter rarely sees her dad, so she was happy to have shared the weekend with his new fiancée and her children. Following the weekend, his fiancée posted pictures of our daughter on her social networking site. This makes me very uncomfortable and I struggle with whether or not this is an issue that should be confronted. Should his future wife have the freedom to post pictures of my child on her social networking sites?
Signed,
Momma Bear
Dear Momma Bear,
You have raised a question that wouldn't have even existed a few short years ago. But nowadays, many parents share your concerns, as we all try to figure out how to safely navigate the world of the Internet that's so rapidly becoming part of our parenting lives.
Social networking has changed the way people make contact with old and new friends, creating complex challenges about what is and isn't appropriate, as matters of privacy get explored and debated.
I have a feeling our ParentDish readers will be divided on this issue, but my opinion is that without your express permission -- and depending on your daughter's age -- your former husband's fiancée shouldn't have added the photographs. It's safe to say that she meant no harm; lots of people post pictures of their children on their Facebook site as a way of offering a visual glimpse into their lives.
The problem is that there are many ways that information on networking sites gets passed around on the Internet, and frankly, I don't think parents exercise nearly enough caution in posting photos of their children.
I don't know whether your daughter's future stepmother has the legal right to upload pictures of her or not; I suspect this aspect of custody law is still a work in progress, as attorneys race to catch up with the many new issues that the Internet has created when it comes to parenting.
But I don't think it would be at all inappropriate to politely express your concerns to your former husband and his fiancée.
Before I go further, however, I should say this: If your concerns are relevant to protecting your daughter from being viewed by strangers -- I'm with you. If, however, you're simply uncomfortable having her future stepmother acknowledge her fiancee's daughter to her online friends, we're talking about a different issue. In that case, you are going to have to do the difficult work of coming to terms with this woman's presence in your child's life.
If you legitimately feel uneasy about the situation because you don't want your daughter's photos displayed online, begin by letting your former husband and his fiancee know that you understand that she might want to share pictures from their weekend together, but that you're not comfortable having your daughter's images on the web.
Explain some of your reasons, and make the request that the photos be removed, at least until you can all come to an agreement.
If worse comes to worse, I suppose you can consult your attorney and find out if the custody terms address this sort of problem. But ultimately, your daughter will best be served if you do all you can to untangle this in a friendly way with her father and future stepmom.
Best of luck!
Yours in parenting support,
AdviceMama
AdviceMama, Susan Stiffelman, is a licensed and practicing psychotherapist and marriage and family therapist. She holds a Bachelor of Arts in developmental psychology and a Master of Arts in clinical psychology. Her book, Parenting Without Power Struggles, is available on Amazon. Sign up to get Susan's free parenting newsletter.
Have a question for AdviceMama? Submit your question here.











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 12)
6-07-2010 @ 11:39AM
TAH said...If you have a problem with you ex's fiance posting pictures of your minor child on a social networking site all three of you (you, your ex and his fiance) should sit down together and have a discussion where you state your concearns and request that neither one post pictures on the internet or compromise by making the posted pictures of the minor child private and accessable only to family and close friends.
Please make sure you keep the conversation positive, so do not accuse her or become upset. Stay calm and on topic, make sure your ex is present during the conversation and be prepared to compromise.
Reply
6-07-2010 @ 1:20PM
Maria said...Our kids have been taught to never, never, never post photos on the internet- by the school, scouts (boy and girl) and us. When someone posts the childs photo on facebook their freinds of freinds of freinds often see them. They know right where to find that child. Given the statistics, each and everyone of us know or are related to at least 3 potential child molesters if we know 100 people. Kids are not stalked by strangers, they are molested by moms boyfreind or some other person who is a freind or relative of the parent. This isn't about parental rights, it is about child saftey.
6-07-2010 @ 3:11PM
Kent said...as a step father I se nothing wrong with it, I have pictures of my biological kids posted and I love my step daughter just like my biological ones so why would it be any different for her than the other two. Treat them differentky and you will have issues sooner or later
6-08-2010 @ 12:11AM
LCason6880 said...This happened to two members of my family. Relatives put pictures of my grandaughter and my niece's daughter on their respective websites. If you are the custodial person for the child and don't want your child's picture online, Contact facebook or whatever social site they are using and tell them that a picture of your minor child has been posted to whatever account and that you want it removed. They will take it down and if that person posts pictures of that child again, they will be kicked off the site. It is illegal.
6-10-2010 @ 8:42PM
Judy said...I agree Http://www.socialnetworkingtipsandsecrets.info when posting pictures of someone elses children, permission should be given by the parents.
6-10-2010 @ 9:52PM
Kim said...Wow, couple of issues going on here as I see it, As a mother and Step-mother I have posted many pictures of my children and my stepdaughter but anyone who uses Facebook knows there are privacy controls. Second, the fact that this women who posted is a future step-mother and being the fiance of the child's father I would wonder if the actual parents share joint legal custody in which case if the father (and some guys do) use his fiance's facebook also, I would think it's perfectly ok for the pictures of the daughter to be posted as long as the privacy control for either Friends or Friends of Friends. It sounds more like the mother has a small jealousy issue that the father did something before she did. In which case as a parent... who is she really concerned with herself or the child. Maybe instead of voicing her concerns online whereby we are all commenting on her life, Maybe she should have directed the concerns to the father and future step mother and dealt with it privately. It sounds again more like a scorn women who is a bit upset because of a divorce and that the father of the child has moved on with his life. As a parent we should all monitor our children's actions and any actions that concern our child, but as a divorced women, You really should deal directly with the childs father and voice your concerns to him and his fiance not look for self satisfaction from people you don't know here online... Just a thought ~
6-10-2010 @ 11:18PM
bellered said...You people are insane. Unless this child is having her photo tagged with, "This girl's name is Jane Doe, she lives with her mother at 124 Paranoid Lane, and will be at our house on 456 Hysteria Way from 2 to 5 pm on July 3rd, and from 3 to 3:15 pm on July 3rd, we adults will be in the back yard playing loud music while Jane rests inside alone. Oh, and we'll keep the front door unlocked." then this is a non-issue.
My children do things with other children. Sometimes we take their pictures. To suggest that a predator is going to surf through their online friends' photo albums to try to find a kid they like, then hunt them down through Facebook contact information is ludicrous. If you'd like to be paranoid and jump at shadows, at *least* do reality the service of fearing reasonable things: Like someone noticing that you're on vacation and robbing you because you're posting photos from the vacation, or your status says you're on vacation, and your profile includes your physical address. That has actually happened, though it hasn't happened much, but this "stranger danger" overkill has fueled a socially erosive fear that harms our society and doesn't reflect reality.
In real life, strangers don't molest your kids -- trusted friends and relatives do. Years of sensationalist journalism has pushed gullible and weak-minded parents to imprison their own children, and suggesting that something as harmless as posting pictures of your family on your Facebook pages is some ghastly threat to your safety sickens and saddens me.
The children of your fiance are part of your family. Posting pictures of your family to Facebook doesn't make you some mindless menace. It makes you normal.
Quit hiding in the shadows. Just because you hang out online in places where fellow voluntary shut-ins dwell doesn't mean you're right. It simply means you've found people as woefully wrong as you are.
6-10-2010 @ 11:32PM
blueyes said...Would you have been as offended if your husband had put them on his face book page?
6-11-2010 @ 8:25AM
Reality Check said...Bellerd - EXACTLY! Americans have been whipped into a stupid frenzy of paranoia when it comes to anything about children these days. This woman is clearly jealous of her ex-husband's relationship and is grasping at some ridiculous straw to demonize her with. How is having a child's photo on Facebook any more dangerous than letting the child play in a park where anyone can see him/her? Obviously playing outside is far more "dangerous" because the child themselves is right there. Not some mysterious photo on a website with no contact information. Yet parents let children run around and play outside, while they freak out about a photo online. How crazy is that?
6-11-2010 @ 1:59AM
Nessa said...I have a very blended family. I have a step daughter and a son. My son spends about 1/2 with me and 1/2 the time with his bio dad, and the same schedule for my step daughter with her bio mom. My children (yes i call them "my children" because I raise them and love them equally) are extrememly close and are only 6 months apart and have been together since they were infants. I have a network page and have pictures of my WHOLE family on there. It wouldn't be complete if my step daughter couldn't be on the family pages. Both of my kids are also on their other parents pages and other step parents pages. I believe it is truely a way to understand and respect the relationship my child have with each parent in their life. we often look at the other parents pages together to see the pictures they updated while they were visiting with the rest of their family, and they love telling me what they were doing when the picture was taken. It has helped to encourage the support and love. My children feel so free to express themselves and share the happy times they have with both sets of parents. They would feel so left out if they couldn't be on the "family page" if one of the parents opposed. Honestly I would't listen if they asked me to remove them, expecially if my husband approved of it (which he does). I completely respect a parents view point about being protective of their children, but there are precautions that can be taken. Additionally, raising a child in a split household requires that each bio parent trusts the judgement of the other parent. meaning i have to trust that my ex has made a good choice in a wife that will love and take care of my son as best as possible and be aware of the safty precations. To respond to the initial post...i think this mom is jealous, sounds like she is snooping around behind everyones back fueling her jealousy. She definetly has the right to speak to ex about being careful, but i think she is looking for an arguement, hoping she will win to trump the new fiance in an atempt to "put her in her place" so to speak. mom needs to realize that is only detrimental to her child. the child will eventually resent he mom for hating the step-mom, if the child has bonded with the step mom.
6-11-2010 @ 3:07AM
Sara said...Not is only is it unnerving to see that another adult has posted a picture of your child without your permission, but along with facebook pictures quite often comes captions. I had a similar situation and there was an inaccurate and inappropriate caption along with my childs picture.
6-11-2010 @ 6:17AM
Judy said...It sounds to us like the Father has been rail roaded out of his own childs life by this ex-wife person. He needs to get custody of his child right away before his child is exploited again by this so called mom.
6-15-2010 @ 9:44AM
Sally G said...Brava! Well said!
6-19-2010 @ 11:21PM
joeobryan said...What the true problem here is if you post pics of your kids online its ok but the soon tobe stepmother she's not allowed to do anything. HMMM sounds like your not over your ex and your in the 5 year plan and cant move on. But you will say you've moved on but FALSE! Listen kids have to adjust more than you do so get over the pics of your child on his soon to be wife. Really there is bigger issues and toget an attorney involved is the stupidest idea or maybe you can throw CSE into the mix too! Why not its just kids and we all can hide behind the fact that the true problem is you dont want to share your kids. Whats going to happen when you meet a man with his kids act like they dont exist? Never take a picture and put it on facebook. Come on! Ive written a book to help the Stepmothers and fathers dealing with Custody issues and divorce with dysfunctional court systems. Stepmothers can be a huge help for the ex mothers to move on because the kids will need lots of support and not another enemy. Look for STUPID GUY IN THE MIDWEST on facebook. Its been nominated for the book of the year on the Oprah show. Comes out soon.
6-20-2010 @ 8:23PM
Ashkash said...To joeobryan: It's not about issues it's about the fact that this woman probably has friends that the mom doesn't know and therefore doesn't feel comfortable seeing pictures it's not necessarily that she has issues...
6-07-2010 @ 11:41AM
jennaris4 said...I see this situation from both sides, as a mother and as a step-mother. My daughter's step-mother has pictures of my daughter on her Facebook but she only posted them after asking me my opinion and seeking my approval. We have a strong working relationship and consistantly work together to raise a healthy well adjusted child.
However, I do not post pictures of my step-daughter on my Facebook. I know her mother would not approve of it and I respect her authority and do not seek to strain relations between households. Nor do I feel the need to parade her around the internet as my own.
I think you have the final say as the primary parent, but you want to make sure you don't come off as jealous or bitter that your ex has moved forward in his life. At the very least she should restrict the visibility of the pictures to only certain parties.
Reply
6-17-2010 @ 4:15PM
Nan Hahn (thinkingperson) said...I agree completely with your comment. While the woman who posted the picture is the fiance of the child's father, she is not yet family. It is my personal view that the biological parents are the only ones to decide whether it's appropriate to post the child's picture. Frankly, with the large number of pedophiles who exist in our neighborhoods today (and there's a website available which can pinpoint them by address), I feel it's unwise to post ANY minor child's photo online. My husband found out his childrens' schools posted the photos of all students. He had a royal hissy fit because he was not consulted by the school before it was done (and he strongly objects to the practice!).
6-07-2010 @ 2:39PM
amused said...Even after any discussion happens between all Parental figures....Please, Please, Please remember to set your privacy settings to allow ONLY your friends to see your site...it's added protection.
Reply
6-08-2010 @ 8:27PM
Aimee said...I think her profile should be locked if the pictures are up on Facebook. However, her having them up in my opinion is fine. It shows that she is proud to have your child as a future step-child and accepts them. That is a good thing. Tell her to lock her profile so only a select few people are able to see.
Reply
6-10-2010 @ 8:18PM
austriallis said...You shouldn't try to start a fight with your child being the issue. None of the reasons you get divorced have to do with the child therefore the child can post whatever pics she wants to her Facebook. Less jealousy is the answer. If your child has a facebook legally she is to be 18 and if you are allowing her to have a Facebook and she is so young she does not have control over what is posted.. you should deduce that she is to young to even have a facebook in the first place.
Reply