Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Caron Gremont: Obesity's Officially a Disease, So How Come My Child…
Karri-Leigh P. Mastrangelo: Am I Going to Hell For My Position on…
The van der Sloot Syndrome: When Moms Go Cold
Filed under: In The News
It's been a tough week for Joran van der Sloot -- and not because he seems to have officially come out as a serial killer. No, I'm referring to the fact that his biggest ally the last time he got into a sticky situation with a girl has essentially disowned him in front of an international audience.
As the latest surreal van der Sloot saga unfolded on the news, I was intrigued to see that his mother, Anita, was oddly MIA. Day one passed, followed by two, and then three. After what seemed like weeks, she finally made a statement and it wasn't terribly mother-like: "I will not visit him in his cell. I cannot embrace him."
This is a snub I know all too well -- except that I'm not a serial killer. Although you wouldn't know it based on the relationship (or lack thereof) that I've had with my mother for the past 32 years.
Depending on whom you ask, mine was a typical divorce-generation childhood. By my fifth birthday, Mom and Dad were officially no longer a married couple, and I ended up spending the majority of my upbringing with my grandparents, while being shuttled to this parent or that one on alternating weekends.
When I did see my mother -- which averaged about once a month -- it was typically an exercise in mental anguish because she'd always invent new ways to make me feel guilty about the situation she'd created. If I didn't tell her that I loved her more than my grandmother, who was incidentally raising me, then I was ungrateful. If I dared to say that I loved my father, she'd give me the silent treatment for the remainder of the weekend. A few years back, I stumbled across a box of diaries I'd kept in grade school and practically every entry alludes to the crux of our non-bond: Why does my mother not want me?
In all honesty, I was a good kid, considering the circumstances: a church-going, straight-A student who volunteered at an assisted-living facility after school. The closest I came to pulling a van der Sloot? The summer before I left for college, I received a summons for trespassing on the grounds of an abandoned castle with some friends. That was also around the time my mother basically cut me off entirely, only showing up to ruin whatever major life event she could -- the last one being five years ago, when she threw a fit at my wedding, leaving my bridesmaids utterly speechless.
We've spoken a handful of times since then and only because it was Christmas or because my father died, which she informed me was "a good thing." After that gem of a statement, she wanted to know if I was thinking about giving my dad's beloved Harley to her and my stepfather because they'd both always wanted a motorcycle.
I've obviously had years to deconstruct the situation, and I have two things to say on the matter. The first observation is a realization I had around my 16th birthday, when my dad bought me a car and my mother whined out loud that no one ever bought her one. My mother and I were like sibling rivals. This only intensified as I achieved this goal or received that reward for a job well done. At my graduation party, she stormed out of the room because people were not praising the fact that she, herself, was graduating from nursing school. (Yes, I've often noted the irony of her chosen profession.)
But, to this day, the anecdote most of my friends can't believe is when she announced she was getting married a month after me, and then called me at work to announce she had tried on my gown.
"Would you mind if I got something similar?" she asked. Needless to say, I graciously postponed my wedding, and then agreed to be her maid of honor in order to spend months being berated for all the things I was doing wrong.
In retrospect, I can live with a little competition, but it's the unwarranted alienation that has always hurt the most. As she's cycled in and out of my life over the years, I've come to the painful conclusion that it's a blessing I'm an only child. When my mother once suspected she might be pregnant, I remember thinking it was the worst news I'd ever heard. The thought of another person going through what I'd experienced was unbearable.
I know there are professionals who'll disagree and argue this point with me -- and you're entitled to your opinion -- but my mother is one of those people who was never meant to be a mom. It's harsh, but it's true. She may have had the physical means, but she never possessed what's most important: The mom gene that makes some women nurturing, selfless when it's needed, and just happy to be mothers.
I like to think that I didn't inherit this dysfunctional DNA. My husband assures me that I'm different, especially when we have repeat conversations about when and if we'll have a kid. I know there's no such thing as the perfect mother. I'm practical, not delusional. But the mother-daughter bond is such an integral one, and when you've spent your entire life trying to grab on to a woman who only wants to kick you to the curb, it's hard to be rational.
In the weeks after my father died, I went through a phase of wanting to repair things with my mother, to find some way to cling to her for emotional support. It's only natural, I suppose. I'll wager it lasted about three weeks. I'd call her, and she'd eventually get around to calling me back, leaving a completely evil-spirited voice mail. Then I'd play the messages for my husband, asking what kind of person could do such a thing. My mother, that's who.
One night, as I stared at a bouquet of flowers I'd received as a condolence from my friend's mother -- a woman who called me weekly and sent cards just because -- it occurred to me how futile the charade was for both of us. Maybe her unwarranted alienation was a good thing -- and perhaps that's what Anita van der Sloot has realized herself. That, sometimes, repeat transgressions are so great and unconscionable that you just need to let go.
Jo Parente is the ParentDish nom de plume, a pen name, used by our editorial team when we want to spill our dirty little secrets but still keep our dignity, and families, intact.
Related: Mom Gets Jail Time for Berating Ex-Husband to Kids
Your<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- If i own all or most of the property in dc think the mayor already knows. president and others including Embassies. on my property for 20 +years
- Here in dc since dec, 6 2006 retired FED BOARD GOV,inventor ,writter, FORMER GOVERNOR (founder of the republic of )DERIAN DOUGLAS HICKMAN
- Twitter followers











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 2)
6-25-2010 @ 3:37PM
Elizabeth said...Wow, that sounds intense. I am sending you some mothering from someone who was loved by her mother but still had to raise herself. My mom suffered from mental illness. However, I am doing my best to mother my son. I hope to leave a more positive legacy.
Best to you sister.
Reply
6-25-2010 @ 5:15PM
marji said...I have friends who have similar relationships with their mothers...I often feel that they have a perpetual 'rain cloud' hovering over them. The only thing you can do is to move on...and leave that toxic relationship behind...just going over and over how she has hurt you can only keep those awful feelings happening again and again..You are going to have to cut loose from this negative relationship because you already do know that some people are not cut out to be nurturers, mothers or otherwise..
6-25-2010 @ 3:39PM
Elaine said...How can you possibly compare your mother to Mrs. Van der Sloot? Joran's mom stuck by him through the Holloway thing. Her son has KILLED (yet another) woman. She has two other boys to raise. I'm sorry for what your mother put you through. It is OKAY for you to cut her off and move on. Your mother is nothing like Joran's...Mrs Van der Sloot doted on that boy all his life, which is probably why he is in the mess he's in. An evil narcissist is what he is. No comparison, sorry.
Reply
6-25-2010 @ 4:09PM
CLM said...Um, I think she was using van der Sloot's comment as a point of departure to discuss a particular type of parental alienation. Unless I read this completely wrong, I don't believe the author was making a direct comparison between her mother and Mrs. van der Sloot.
6-25-2010 @ 6:52PM
Burr Robson said...Elaine, You are not understanding what she's saying. She is not presenting her conclusion unilaterally; she is saying sometimes there is too much repeated emotional battering to have a relationship remain viable. Read the article again - it was an important and well written piece.
6-25-2010 @ 3:51PM
seawitch12 said...Having a child makes you a mother, not a Mom!
Reply
6-25-2010 @ 4:06PM
Lisa said...I also had a mother who should not have had children. My sisters and I basically raised ourselves. My mother was and is selfish and narcissictic. It's always about her. I have two small children and while I am very involved in their lives but I fear I have inherited some of her parenting disabilities. I am not a hugger and prefer not to be touched. I am sure my kid's will end up in therapy someday complaining about how cold their mom was. I tell them and show them that I love them very much, just don't touch me.
6-25-2010 @ 5:26PM
luckylux said...have you had therapy?
Reply
6-25-2010 @ 11:34PM
Audrey A said...You can't base a relationship solely on the fact that you happen to be related to someone. Even if they're you parent, sometimes the best thing you can do is just end it. That’s what I did with my dad. With his it was like he was this big kid and I was the parent. The first time I remember thinking he was just an a-hole was when I was 12 and that never changed. The last straw was when I asked him to stop having alcoholic drinks when we’d go out together and he said ok. Then I found out he’d just drink before we’d go out and my pointing out how that was wrong resulted in him yelling at me in the restaurant about how I was the problem not him. Of course the drinking was just one of the problems I had with him. It took me about 2 years to get to the point where I felt like I knew he wasn’t going to change and I stopped all contact with him. Now it’s 3 years after that and I know I was right. I know I was right because he hasn’t even once contacted me to ask why, or called me for any reason and I'm his only child. I say any idiot can have a child but not many people know how to be parents.
Reply
6-25-2010 @ 10:58PM
Annette said...I am sorry about what you have been through, but a parent's love for a child needs to be unconditional. Joran's mother does not need to see him if it hurts her, but she should not abandon him no matter what he has done.
Reply
6-28-2010 @ 10:52PM
muppetsbabygirl said...Unconditional love or not any therapist will agree that at this stage, while still loving her son she is doing what she needs to do to remain as healthy as she can mentally and physically, that she may be there for her other children. There is such as a thing as too much is too much!
6-26-2010 @ 6:00AM
Jen said...Don't go to the hardware store for orange juice.
You will never get what you need from your mother--she's just not capable. Sounds like you have a full and well-earned grasp of the situation.
Good luck with whatever you choose to do.
Reply
6-26-2010 @ 10:21AM
abtru said...lisa i wish you hadn't disabled your reply button so i could let you know that not being a toucher is ok. My mother wasn't and I turned out fine and didn't need therapy. The worst that will happen is that they will not be touchers with their children. As long as you show them love and affection in the best way you can then they will be fine.
Reply
7-06-2010 @ 7:12AM
alan said...I can identify with your pain. I was (1) when my mother originally divorced and never was able to meet my real father. When I did search for him, I found he had died in 1996. My mother and I never got along very well and on her death bed, she told me I wasn't worth the rubber I was strained through and the biggest disappointment in her life. She had been married 9 years before I was born.
That comment has stayed with me all these years and I'm well passed 70 now. Like you, I never got into any trouble but turned out to be a loner and an only child. The good thing that came out of this is I have two sisters, neither of which I knew about because my father never mentioned me to them. It was through an obituary of my father that I found all this out.
Reply
6-27-2010 @ 7:17PM
Chaya said...Please do not fear the chance to be a parent because of what your mom is like. She sounds a lor like my mom was. My mom suffered fom Borderline Personality Disorder and may have had Bipolar Disorder. I was a good and obedient and respectful. I feared that if I had kids, I would behave horribly towrds tham because of my upbringing. In therapy I had the chance to learn who I am and wha t good things I can do. I have three kids and we enjoy a wondreful relationship. Stop taking on your mom's sickness. If ou know that what she did is wrong and that you are a good person, you will not repeat her behaviors toward your own kids.
Reply
6-28-2010 @ 6:07PM
ang said...Hi, I thought I was the only one with such a situation. My mom died about ten years ago. You are a little better off than me. My mother would not even permit men around me and she did her very best to destroy my marriage. She wanted me to remain alone and without children. And besides this I expierenced the same situation as you. Why they are doing this? It is not out of hatred but it is out of too too much love combined with a lot of disappointments. And most of the time, mentally they are not able to cope with this situation. The result is being evil and wicked against their daughters and not their sons. Especially if, despite everything, as they see us accomplishing our destiny.
In my case I had the moms of my friends. I could speak my situation to my aunts and uncles.
If you permit me, please receive this piece of advice: continue to respect her and love her no matter what, continue with your life/destiny, enjoy the love and care and favour of those around you and please bear your kids and be the mom that you are destined to be. You know how it should not to be done.
After all you are responsible and accountanble for your own life.
Be strenghtened
Reply
6-29-2010 @ 12:46PM
Mercedes said...Wow...and I thought I was alone in the world! I completely empathize with you and others who have had the same misfortune. I am very grateful for my genes, though, and have wonderful family through her, and also a wonderful father.
When people feel sorry for me and ask me if I miss having a mother, I simply respond that you can't miss something you never had. I cherish my real friendships and family that are there, which more than makes up for the lack of a mother.
For many years I attempted to kindle a relationship, thinking that once I was a grown woman we could relate and she would respect me as an adult. It has never happened and she is an extremely toxic human being to be around. Finally others on her side of the family have witnessed, experienced and recognized this behavior, too, at her own father's funeral. In my case, I can not have respect for someone that deliberately destroys me or anyone else, and is cruel and hateful intentionally.
I have not had children in life, but not because I have not wanted to, but because it has not happened, but I would have loved to be a mother! I think that if we are aware of what NOT to do and be from personal experience that the chances of repeating are slim to none.
I wish you much peace and happiness!
Reply
6-30-2010 @ 6:26AM
ker said...The Van der Sloot syndrome?
Parente clearly had a very difficult time as a child and continues to struggle with her relationship with her mother, and I feel her story and insights are important to share.
But it has absolutely NOTHING to do with Mama Van der Sloot. Joran is hardly the poor child of a cold unfeeling mother who had to struggle on and make his way in the world without her loving influence.
The reason Mama Van der sloot is distancing herself from Joran has nothing to do with her personal short comings and everything to do with Joran's unacceptable and dangerous behaviors. She has two other children to care for, She cannot fix Joran, and she should no longer blindly protect him. Her allowing Joran to face the music in Peru without her to soften the blow is a VERY GOOD THING.
Parente should never have linked her experiences with the Van der sloot mess.
Reply
7-06-2010 @ 7:46AM
Lynne said...This was painful to read. As a divorce lawyer of 34 years, I have seen similar situations but it is obvious to me that this "mother" is mentally ill. As I often say to clients, you can't get upset about the way she treats you; she treats everyone the same way and its not personal. Unfortunately, she's the only mother you have. Despite that, it sounds like you turned out pretty terrific. Kudos to your grandparents!
Reply
7-06-2010 @ 9:48AM
TruthBeTold said...Very touching article--thank you. I also suspect that I was raised by a mentally ill mother who just refused to be diagnosed. I also have a younger sister. My mother was very hard on me and very strict as well, which would not have been an issue had she treated me sister the same way. Instead, she focused on disciplining me and allowed my sister to do whatever. I dealt with days of alienation growing up if I confronted her about how she had hurt my feelings; this was not permitted. Thank goodness, my father was nothing liker her.
I'm now almost 40 and nothing has changed. My sister grew up to do a whole lot of nothing with her life, and I'm a college grad with a very successful career and marriage. I also feel that I'm a good mother--am nothing like my own mother. I have removed myself from my family for the most part, and when I move away the removal will be permanent. Do I have emotional scars? Yes. The pain I feel will never subside. However, opening myself for more pain is certainly going to do more harm than good. Sometimes, you just have to cut all ties.
Reply