Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Franne Golde and Syd Fox: Love More, Fear Less: A Mother and Her…
Dr. Peggy Drexler: The Breadwinner Complex: Are Women Apologizing For…

Do We Really Need a Breast-Feeding Cookie?
Filed under: Weird But True, Opinions
MilkMakers, Milkin' Cookies -- these are two new-ish cookies created for breast-feeding moms. They're made from, among other things, oatmeal, yeast and flax seed, all long held to help boost milk production, and anecdotal evidence (well, people posting on breast-feeding blogs) seems to indicate they work. So more power to these little teats!
Er ... treats. That being said, I do have a couple of reservations:
First off, my cookie of choice while breast-feeding did not cost $44 for 30 of them, as do the MilkMakers. It was called the "Oreo," and it was available pretty much everywhere.
Furthermore, the blogs about the breast milk-boosting cookies are filled with chipper endorsements like, "And my husband loves them, too!"
Short response: Ew!
Long response: "I'm sure a more mature woman would feel totally comfortable with a male enjoying an all-natural cookie whose ingredients just happen to help lactating females develop more milk but -- ACK ACK ACK!"
The larger issue is the idea that lactating women suddenly need their own line of foods. As with Gymboree classes hinting that our kids would never learn to clap and sing without some professional help, the growth of specialty foods for moms hints that without us taking all sorts of new (sometimes pricey) precautions/supplements/classes, our kids are going to suffer. And, of course, it's all our fault.
So here's another, absolutely free and age-old way to make more milk: Listen to Shakespeare.
While I can't entirely vouch for this working for human moms, a team of researchers in England discovered that cows listening to Shakespeare produced 4 percent more milk. Which means that soon some other entrepreneur, perhaps locked out of the lactation cookie market, will probably set about rewriting the bard's biggest hits for a bovine audience. So I asked readers of a contest I run in The Week magazine: What will some of these plays be called? The winners:
"Romeo and Mooliet," "The Dairy Wives of Windsor," "King Steer," "A Midsummer's Light Cream," and, my husband's favorite, "MacBessie."
If you want to cheer up a breast-feeding mom who's having a hard time of it, here are some more: "The Tipping of the Shrew," "Such a Moo About Nothing," "Julius Cheeser," "Richard the Curd," "Othello: The Moo-er of Venice," "A Comedy of Udders," "The Merchant of Angus," "Two Gentlemen of Velveeta" and "Four Stomachs of Verona."
There's even one that's eerily appropriate: "As You Lactate."
Good luck to all breast-feeders (human and otherwise) out there!
Related: The Real Reason Your In-Laws Don't Want You (and Your Baby) to Visit
Your<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- Why should anyone listen to a _____, what makes her an expert? Harpo is jus an actress, all she does is sit on her tush & claim she knows it all. ...
- (department of defense)? hey can you build me a super duper all protector? yea what you want on it $$$$$
- Divorce reasons wife does not want IVF, Donor Sperm











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
7-27-2010 @ 12:17PM
Becca said...I agree way over the top!!! yes moms sometimes need help producing but there are cheaper ways and this is just feeding off people's worry and doubt. If you have trouble lacating a bowl of steel cut oats every morning will help and be a lot cheaper mix in the flax and some berries. If you really want to cut loose and go wild a half beer will have you gushing.
Reply
7-27-2010 @ 3:47PM
Hannah said...If someone really is having trouble with milk supply, they can save their money and just try oatmeal or oatmeal cookies, drinking plenty of water, pumping after feeding, etc. If that doesn't help, see a lactation consultant with the money you saved not buying the expensive cookies.
Reply
7-28-2010 @ 6:42AM
freejack444 said...Or maybe just make the cookies yourself out of their listed ingredients
Reply
7-28-2010 @ 7:11AM
A.D. said...They need something to make them feel special, giving bottle fed babies and their mothers self-righteous eye rolls just isn't enough anymore.
Reply
7-28-2010 @ 4:40PM
Silver Fang said...King Steer? *dies laughing*
Reply
7-28-2010 @ 4:46PM
MarfMom said...I HATE products like these. They perpetuate the idea that breastfeeding is some super-hard, complicated thing that requires a lot of time and money. All you need is a baby and your breast, and a lactation consultant if you're having trouble...possibly a pump if you're going to go that route. Products like these just psych women out from even trying out breastfeeding I think.
Reply
7-28-2010 @ 4:47PM
De said...I'm currently breastfeeding, and when I experienced supply drop after going back to work, I saw a recipe on epicurious for lactation cookies, and made my own. Do I think they helped? No. Was it worth a try? Yes. Would I make them again? Heck yeah; I bake cookies all the time! I've started adding ground flax, brewers yeast, oat powder (whiz oatmeal in my spice grinder), and powdered fenugreek (because I have it anyway) to other baked goods whenever I can. It can't hurt, and all those ingredients are healthy in their own right.
Would I spend $40 on specialty cookies? No. But I also don't spend money on any other specialty baby product.
Reply
7-28-2010 @ 5:01PM
Luschka said...I wouldn't spend that much on them either, but I do make my own. I have tons of milk - so whether that's related or not, who can say. There is a recipe for lactation biscuits on www. diaryofafirstchild . com though if you want to try.
In the end, to each their own - struggling with milk supply is no fun, so anything that can help is worth trying. (but not at any cost!)
Reply
7-29-2010 @ 3:53PM
Dana said...Here's the greatest thing about coming up with a product like this: you'll get rave reviews on blogs about how much they "work" from moms who don't realize that nursing generally works to increase milk supply. Especially nursing with a nutritious snack and a glass of milk, regardless of the price or brand name attached to the snack.
Reply
7-29-2010 @ 6:46PM
drummeyd said...Agree it's over the top, tho' I *struggled* to get adequate milk production. Back then, I might've tried out of frustration!
Reply
8-02-2010 @ 11:24PM
Leslie Garrett said...Oh darn, I wish Dickens worked, too (maybe he does!). A Tale of Two Titties, anyone??
Reply
8-02-2010 @ 10:50PM
Jacquie @ Wild Mother Arts said...You can easily make your own... there are lots of recipes floating around the net. Google "lactation cookie recipe"! Some are really yummy!
Reply
8-19-2010 @ 11:58AM
juliea said...So - let me just say it makes sense that there would be food out there just for lactating mothers....it's very based around nutrition.
Another aspect of this is that many women have issues with supply. I work for a lactation consultant in a breastfeeding/maternity/baby boutique and a woman came in recently talking about them. I became intrigued and started doing some research online - which is how I found this article. I have made these cookies based off of a recipe I found online and they are amazing! I do not think it's gross that men or other people use them because I know that the only thing different that is in them (other than what you would already find in an oatmeal chocolate chip cookie) is brewers yeast (which is VERY good for you) - and if the man has ever had a beer in his life he's already had that...the other would be flax seed meal...which I already added to many of our recipes without even knowing it was good for my production. So, that being said - this is really just a healthy cookie. Good for everyone, really good for the lactating mother who is concerned with keeping up a healthy supply of life's greatest baby food - breast milk.
I for one have a REALLY hard time remembering to take supplements....I've never in my life forgotten to eat a cookie.
Reply
8-19-2010 @ 11:58AM
juliea said...Forgot to add that $44 for 30 cookies IS absolutely ridiculous though. I am a doula who has a line of nursing accessories and plan on possibly incorporating these cookies into what I sell - but they would be soooooooo much cheaper. I don't believe in making things unaffordable for the people who need it.
Reply
2-10-2011 @ 7:56PM
Hero said...You can make them yourself, I guess. And what's the harm with oatmeal cookies? Oatmeal's good for you and oatmeal cookies are tasty.
So what if you have to add a shit ton of butter. ;P
Reply