Do My Kids Have to Add Grandma and Uncle Joe to Their Facebook Page?
Dear AdviceMama,
My high schoolers have Facebook pages. We have relatives that have "friended" them who they have added so as not to hurt feelings. My kids and I are not happy that these relatives are using Facebook to find out things about their lives when they really don't interact with them otherwise. What to do?
Signed,
Seeking Privacy
Dear Privacy,
It really is a new world when it comes to sorting out cyber-relationships, and your question points to a particularly challenging aspect of this: When is it okay to pass on accepting a friend request, and are there other options if ignoring an invitation could be seen as hurtful or disrespectful?
Although this appears to be a Facebook issue, it strikes me as also being about the fact that your relatives show a "cyber" interest in your kids, without demonstrating one in the "real" world. I understand why it might feel annoying when they pursue connections with your kids online without making an effort to interact with them offline.
But I also know that many aunts, uncles, cousins and grandparents are sensitive to the fact that, typically, adolescents aren't terribly interested in long phone calls or visits with extended family members. Have your relatives gotten the sense that your kids want to get to know them better, or do your high schoolers come across as disinterested -- as teens so often do around distant relatives?
Many people have found Facebook a great way to show interest and connect with nieces, nephews and grandkids, while maintaining a respectful distance from them.
If you're convinced that your relatives are, however, deliberately snooping on your high schooler's pages for juicy tidbits, keep in mind that users can discriminate between who gets to read personal news (best reserved for genuine friends) and who receives the generic information -- like your favorite pizza topping. Your kids can put relatives into a group with limited privacy settings that will prevent them from having full access to the information that their closer "friends" can see.
And in the same way that we teach our kids to have healthy boundaries by not forcing them to hug someone who makes them uncomfortable, we also need to respect our youngsters' wishes if they don't want a relative in their Facebook world. It's easy to "unfriend" someone, and fair game to turn down an invitation if your kids doubt a relative's good intentions. You might even support them in sending a message, explaining that they feel more comfortable restricting their Facebook friends to those with whom they have regular contact offline.
The fact that your teens have generously included their relatives in their Facebook world suggests that you have raised them to be respectful and caring. It also tells me that, unlike many young people these days, your high schoolers aren't posting things too provocative or inappropriate for Aunt Edna to see, which is comforting.
Use privacy settings to support your youngsters in establishing boundaries for themselves. But if there's a possibility that your family members are tentatively trying to establish a relationship with your kids but are hiding behind Facebook because they're intimidated about reaching out, consider inviting them to join you for a real-world family game night or barbecue. Chances are, they'll greatly prefer getting to know your kids offline, if given the opportunity and the invitation.
Yours in parenting support,
AdviceMama
AdviceMama, Susan Stiffelman, is a licensed and practicing psychotherapist and marriage and family therapist. She holds a Bachelor of Arts in developmental psychology and a Master of Arts in clinical psychology. Her book, Parenting Without Power Struggles, is available onAmazon. Sign up to get Susan's free parenting newsletter.











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 5)
10-18-2010 @ 1:07PM
Bird said...I have 2 teenagers - a 15 year old in 10th grade and a 17 year old in college. My children have many aunts, uncles, grandparents, etc. They have sidestepped this problem by having 2 facebook pages. One for their friends and the other for the rest of the family. Everyone is happy and feels included The kids can post pictures and going-ons with their life for the family and still maintain their banter with their friends.
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 4:20PM
stacey said...Dear Bird. That is GREAT advice and nice of you to take the time to share. Are you sure your sons have not turned 16 and 18? My brother goes by "Bird" and the kids had a birthday when he fell asleep one night. Is this you?
10-18-2010 @ 1:46PM
Alicia said...I'm really glad my family doesn't snoop. I'm 20 and in college and tons of my friends have problems with distant relatives looking for gossip, often with malicious intent. I deleted all my relatives who pulled that and told them why.
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 4:12PM
Rachelvis said...just put the person in hiding, so you don't see them or what they have to say everyday...thats for us that are older and just don't want a certain family member preaching to us about this or that..so that takes care of the problem, they don't get their feelings hurt because you've added them and also they don't know you've hid them away so you don't have to see their face or what they have to say anymore..PROBLEM SOLVED...now don't confuse what i've said with blocking a person,,when you block they go away for good....but hiding a person means they are still there and you can retrieve them from that hiding spot anytime you like...so its great...
but they can see what your posting but again this is advice for those older, who have relatives that go on and on about the same ole same ole and all you've got to do is hide them..but you tweens have a different problem, so you might want to listen to what they are saying in this article....later...74012--place to be
10-20-2010 @ 5:15PM
Flojoe said...It is an unfortunate culture that considers grandparents as "distant relatives" who can be dismissed, discounted and disrespected on the whims of children.
Never mind the broken hearts and the pain caused. Perhaps ultra-personal things should be not posted on Facebook even for "real friends". Our culture should encourage building contact and communication between generations.
No one gives unconditional love like a grandparent.
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 4:00PM
MC said...It is easy - just don't use Facebook at all. Why anyone in their right minds would put all that stuff about themselves 'out there' for so many to see is beyond me. I have turned down EVERY invitation to join Facebook. Anybody I want to know anything about me I tell them personally. The rest don't need to know.
10-20-2010 @ 4:18PM
cryan522 said...When you were a child your generations was free to have "kid time" with their peers. We now live in an age where predators are looking to attack children so it is safer for teens to play at home. This is their outlet to vent and tell jokes with peers. It is not ancestory.com, it is a social media network that was initiated for friendships.
Solution- Create a family "like page" on facebook- exclusively for your family. The members of the "like page" don't need to be fb friends to interact and send message and updates. You can still maintain a relationship through fb and they can have their privacy too. My family has done this for years. and it works. I have distant older cousins/aunts writing crazy things on my wall every day. Now that I'm in my mid-twenties I don't mind. I laugh about it wonder how we are genetically linked. I can understand the teens wanting privacy. At that age everything is embarassing and, not like we need a reminder, there are a lot of school bullys that could hassle your teens based upon what family members write on their wall.
10-20-2010 @ 5:06PM
jykathy said...You are so right, all my grandkids have me on, they invited me. Its great and i dont tell mamma anything they say.
10-20-2010 @ 3:18PM
Sean said...I do not have a facebook account anymore for this very reason. Once I graduated college, I said goodbye to facebook forever. Family members should NOT be your friends. This is why parenting is getting harder and harder nowadays, parents want to be friends with their kids. My parents wanted me to be friend with them on facebook when I was in college, I simply rejected them. Peoples feelings getting hurt?? Because of a social networking site? SERIOUSLY?! Come on...
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 4:00PM
Proud Mother said...I orginally went on facebook after my daughter wanted to show me something about my son. She actually gave me her password. Then she said why don't you get your own account. I was hesitant but did it and actually connected to another facebook account of a group of old friends from the 1970's through late 1990's and it was great. I have never friend requested anybody, however, my children, my friends, my children's friends have all friend requested me and I accepted. There are things that they post that I'm not crazy about so I pass by them; and there's posts that I comment on. My children comment to me and so do their friends. So, personally do not have a problem regarding friends and relatives being my friends on facebook.
10-20-2010 @ 7:03PM
candcathly said...Oh, you'd be surprised.
10-20-2010 @ 7:42PM
Lita said...I've got to agree with you, Sean. Also, there has been yet another screw-up regarding the privacy settings; it seems that advertisers were given access to all manner of things that were marked private. Also, when you delete things from facebook, they aren't deleted at all. You may not be able to access them, but some other folks can. I've had acquaintances suggest that I get on facebook. I tell them that I have been in the phone book for decades; if they wanted to be in contact with me, why the heck haven't they called me? Facebook? No thanks.
10-20-2010 @ 2:44PM
morekare said...I think people who are too tight with their genetic "family" are usually peculiar in social situations with people outside their family. It's like sharing sexual fantasies with your grandmother or your grandfather just isn't appropriate. Get a life!!!!
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 2:57PM
Wendi said...My Mother in Law requested friendship on Facebook and I simply ignored her request. I also have my privacy settings so that people I don't keep in contact with, like old high school friends, don't see everything. You never know what your old acquaintances are up to so better to be safe than sorry!
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 2:54PM
Heidi said...It saddens me that this is even an issue. How else can extended family keep in touch these days? Apparently this parent has no respect for family either if being Facebook friends with family is so bothersome. If you are afraid of Grandma finding out something bad on Facebook the solution is not to unfriend Grandma but to KEEP THE STUPID STUFF OFF FACEBOOK. Both of my teen daughters have not only friended anyone in our family with Facebook, but have also friended longtime family friends who had grown up with their Dad. Our family is out of state, so it's the easiest way to keep in touch.
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 9:34PM
mariday1 said...I agree. I have my kids, grandkids, nieces, their kids, brother-in-law and some very close friends that I consider family. We all live all over the country, and it is one way to just be aware of what is going on in their lives. I comment on some posts, and some I just read and say "oh, ok".
10-21-2010 @ 8:49PM
Lita said...And who are you to decide how much respect someone has for their family just because their view of the relationship between family and facebook is different from yours? Respect flows in all directions, not just young people having respect for their elders which, sadly, seems to be coming more and more rare. (Why should a child respect or share information with someone who, for instance, shows no interest them except maybe to criticize, or offer an unsolicited opinion? All adult opinions are no more valid than all young people's opinions are invalid.) If a teen wants to share all with family members, good for them. But should he/she be compelled to do so? No. As for posting something stupid in facebook? No one should upload stupid things onto the Internet, social networking or not. And mom and dad should remind them that once that "send" button is hit, it is out there somewhere, forever....
11-06-2010 @ 10:46PM
Gena said...Heidi,
I have to agree with you! And I believe that posters who don't seem to understand "adult" opinions must be very young. I often think (under those circumstances) that I'd like to be a fly on the wall when that person gets some age and experience on them. In the words of my sainted grandmother, they'll wind up "paying for their raising". Life is a sweet thing!
10-20-2010 @ 3:00PM
jodi said...I do not have family on my facebook nor do I try to add family. I have a 20 yr old son, If I want to know whats going on in his life I ask. I do not have him as a friend on facebook. Its not my business. As for other family, I do not because I use my FB for political networking and my family thinks differently then I do and I do not like to be lectured
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 3:00PM
kELLY said...If there are posts on ones facebook page that a relative can't view, then perhaps it should have been sent as a personal message that facebook offers! Facebook is a public domain and the banter should remain G rated!
Reply