Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Abbie Rumbach: The Confession That Blew My Daughter's Mind
PHOTO: Reese Witherspoon, Ryan Phillipe Reunite
Grade School Counselors Could Boost Student Performance, Study Finds
Filed under: Medical Conditions, In The News, Research Reveals: Big Kids, Research Reveals: Tweens
President Barack Obama walks with Anthony Black from Washington, DC., as he meets with the five children who were featured in the documentary "Waiting for Superman" in the Oval Office on Oct. 11, 2010. Credit: Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP
Providing the opportunity for grade school-aged students to meet with counselors is an experiment that could rapidly boost student performance, quell disruptive behavior and resuscitate schools, Randall Reback, an assistant professor of economics at Barnard College/Columbia University, tells ParentDish.
A former fifth grade teacher in East Palo Alto, Calif., Reback says he was inspired to research how mental health services could improve classroom conduct and boost the learning and emotional well-being of young children.
"I was teaching in a lower-income school and having significant problems with two students," Reback tells ParentDish. "At the time, the police department provided counseling at the school and within one week I was amazed at the transformation in these students and how less disruptive they were in class. We're (teachers and parents) so focused on grades, but we under-emphasize the powerful role mental health help can bring to our classrooms. What kids need most is one-on-ones with caring adults."
Reback says the research shows that at least one in five young children in the United States is impaired by mental disorders. Yet, he says, less than half of the states require school districts to employ mental health professionals at the elementary school level.
Schools where students have access to counseling show significantly less concerns with disruptive behaviors in the classroom and teachers worry less about students fighting, stealing, cutting class or using drugs, Reback says.
In schools where counseling is available, boys are more likely than girls to receive guidance, as are students who come from single-parent households or those whose parents are recently divorced, Reback says.
At the same time, Hispanic and Asian students are the least likely to receive access to counseling because "it is not strongly supported in their cultural traditions," Reback tells ParentDish.
"In 'Waiting for Superman,' obviously charter schools can be a great answer because students can be expelled if they don't meet behavioral standards," Reback says. "But, in public schools, we need to address behavioral issues in other ways. Teachers that can refer students for counseling report significant improvements in their classrooms."
Next on Reback's agenda: Studying the impact of early mental health intervention on crime and drug abuse among older students.










ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
10-20-2010 @ 10:44PM
GRACE2STAND said..."Next on Reback's agenda: Studying the impact of early mental health intervention on crime and drug abuse among older students."
How about intervening BEFORE these children's lives are ruined by the DRUG ABUSE of their parents??? How about blood or hair drug tests, instead of the "bring-in-someone-else's-pee" drug tests that we have now??? How about serious JAIL TIME foe selling your food stamps for drugs??? How about permanently losing your kids when it is proved that you USE THEM as a commodity? (Buying drugs with benefits paid for your children.)
My 11 year-old grandson is currently in a mental facility on SUICIDE WATCH, because a year ago he was molested, cut and threatened by a guy, in full view of his mother, who was too high from snorting Vocodin to realize or react.
This was his THIRD molestation. His first was his own father, whom his mother knew had molested his own neice and nephew. The second was the crack addict who lived with him and his mother for 3 1/2 years... CPS in our county is USELESS, and we have a stack of dead children to prove it.
Oh, and my grandson's guardian ad litem defended a PEDOPHILE all the way to the state supreme court, working in conjunction with another slimeball attorney who goes into court and demonstrates how the image of an adult body can be morphed to look like a child, so "you can't prove that this defendant's collection is REAL kiddie porn!"
SPECIAL PLACE IN HELL for EVERYONE involved in the betrayal of our children!!!
Yeah, counselors are fine, unless they don't know squat about Post Traumatic Stress Disorder in children, and most don't.
The kids get molested, 80-some percent NEVER tell ANYONE. Instead, they act out, then it's "you can't play with my kids, anymore; you can't ride our church bus anymore, you can't come to our school anymore..." Off you go to juvie... The kid thinks, "I was molested because I'm bad, I deserved it." They cut themselves, burn themselves with cigarettes, and many kill themselves...
All the while, there's NO accountability for the parents, the pervert judges let the molesters off... If you ever wonder how "a loving God" could send anyone to hell, you have never seen the suffering of a miolested child!
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 10:53PM
cinjim56 said...I completely agree with you. I've worked in a juvenile facility for 21 years, and it still breaks my heart to see how our children have no support. I've heard teachers make horrendous comments such as referring to new girls in the institution as prostitutes!!
10-21-2010 @ 2:08AM
addthea said...I agree with the accountability and think we should start with you. What kind of parent, or lack thereof, must you have been to have raised a child who allow such atrocities to your grandson?
10-20-2010 @ 10:34PM
J. McDonald said...How about actually studying. I'm a high school teacher.
Reply
10-20-2010 @ 10:49PM
cinjim56 said...????Who are you referring to as far as studying, and what are you referring to in terms of studying?
10-20-2010 @ 11:00PM
Nancy said...Getting rid of the children born to illegal aliens from mexico (anchor babies) that are badly overcrowding and dumbing down American childrens education. Mexicans are very slow learners and very fast at overpopulating our schools and overworking our teqachers. American children are suffering due to mexican anchor babies.
Reply
10-21-2010 @ 12:14AM
Juls said...It is true that today in most PUBLIC SCHOOLS , Guidance Counselors only do the scheduling for the students.(I'm a teacher, so I get this first hand) Assistant Principals take care of of the so called "discipline", but beats me who offers my students and my own children any couseling. It saddens me that this is our future-ONE in FIVE children will become ADULTS with MENTAL DISORDERS. Really has gotten me thinking about the future of this country. On a side note, my own child(daughter) asked to go into counseling to "work out some issues" We were lucky enough to find help fairly cheaply and it has helped her immensly.
Reply
10-21-2010 @ 12:16AM
juls said...Try teaching them HOW and make a difference, for God's sake.
Reply
10-21-2010 @ 12:18AM
Darlene said...Make's a heck of a lot of sense. Talking it out. Instead of Acting it Out. C'mon why does everything have to be about race. . We see children acting out on all sides of the spectrum. In high schools and college .Student going on rampage killing in predominately white neighborhood. So who are they talking all students from every race and class. Who are they talking about all children who are troubled trying to live in a sometimes very disturbing world.
Reply
10-21-2010 @ 1:10AM
GRACE2STAND said...Signs and Symptoms of PTSD in Children (from National Center for PTSD)
School-Aged Children (6-11 years)
Feelings of responsibility and guilt
Repetitious, traumatic play
Feeling disturbed by reminders of the event
Nightmares, other sleep disturbances
Concerns about safety, preoccupation with danger
Aggressive behavior, angry outbursts
Fear of feelings, trauma reactions
Close attention to parent’s anxieties
School avoidance
Worry / concern for others
Behavior, mood, personality changes
Somatic symptoms (complaints about body aches and pains
Obvious anxiety / fearfulness
Withdrawal
Specific, trauma-related fears, general fearfulness
Separation anxiety
Loss of interest in activities
Confusion, inadequate understanding of traumatic events (more evident in play than in discussion)
Unclear understanding of causes of bad events
Giving magical explanations to fill in gaps in understanding
Loss of ability to concentrate at school, with lower performance
Spacey or distracted behavior
Signs and Symptoms of PTSD in Children (from National Center for PTSD)
Preadolescents and Adolescents (12-18 years)
Self-consciousness
Life-threatening re-enactment
Rebellion at home or at school
Abrupt shifts in relationships
Depression, social withdrawal
Decline in school performance
Trauma driven acting out, such as sexual activity and reckless risk-taking
Effort to distance self from feelings of shame, guilt humiliation
Excessive activity / involvement with others, or retreat from others in order to manage inner turmoil
Accident proneness
Wish for revenge, action-oriented responses to trauma
Increased self-focusing, withdrawal
Sleep / eating disturbances, including nightmares
Reply
10-21-2010 @ 2:10AM
a mom said...How about adding testing for ADD or ADHD? My son has ADD and was not achieving to the best of his ability. The teachers were giving him low grades, he wouldn't score high on a test, yet I would be studying with him for a few nights in a row before the test and he would still get a D or a C-. The guidance counselor at school couldn't figure out why my son's teachers said he seems bright, we just don't know why he isn't performing well. My husband's a doctor and once he said to me, "Maybe he has ADD." That went in one ear and out the other. It wasn't until my son reached 9th grade, last year, that he came home and told us he thought he had ADD. He had the same symptoms as his friend and his friend was now on medication and was getting A's, when he was failing before. Well, my son has been on the medication ever since we took him to the pediatrician and he was diagnosed with ADD. The hardest part has been finding the right dosage and medication as the stimulants effect their sleep, their appetite and makes them irritable. However, we cut the dose in 1/2 and he is doing much better.
Reply
10-21-2010 @ 1:52PM
Alicia said...I wouldn't be so quick to herald the beauty of school counselors. My grade school counselor nearly ruined my life when she tried to "help" me through my parents divorce. She tried to force me to open up and when I refused, tried to suggest to my mother that I was suffering from depression and possibly other mental disorders. I've never had any of the other counselors and therapists I've seen since (none related to the divorce) say I needed medication or suggest I be diagnosed. She just couldn't accept that I didn't like or trust her enough to talk to her about an issue I really didn't, in the long run, have a problem with.
As for high school counselors, some of them are wonderful, but some of them (the ones who help you get into college, at least) tend to be incompetent.
Reply