Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Christie O. Tate: I Love and Welcome My Daugther's Rage
Rob Watson: A Gay Dad's Open Letter to the Parents Who Are Seeking to…
Women-Only Swim Hour for Muslims Makes Waves on Campus
Filed under: In The News, Religion & Spirituality
Credit: Matt Roth, Getty Images
In an attempt to be inclusive to all religious traditions on campus, last week George Washington University started "Sisters' Splash," a ladies-only swim hour, according to the university newspaper, The GW Hatchet. The school's Lerner Health and Wellness Center closed the pool to men and covered the glass door with a dark tarp, giving female Muslim students the chance to swim at their leisure, while honoring the basic tenets of their religion.
Everything was going swimmingly, and coeds shed their head and body gear and rocked swimsuits, at least until scores of critics began hurling heated comments that continue to pour in on various blogs and news reports, according to the journal Inside Higher Education.
"Should a minuscule minority force the overwhelming majority to abide by their rules or should it be the other way around?" is one of the Internet comments about the female-only swim, the journal reports.
Others include: "Come on, folks. An hour a week -- what's the big deal?" "It's not an unreasonable request. 'Women' is like *half* the population."
Because George Washington is a private university, there should be no constitutional issues with the swim hour, Ayesha N. Khan, legal director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, tells Inside Higher Education.
"Should a similar program start up at a public university, the presence of church-state issues would depend on the many facts of the situation, such as whether access is religion-specific," Khan tells the journal.
Aliya Karim, social chair of the Muslim Students' Association (MSA) women's group, tells the student newspaper the organization made the effort to coordinate the swimming hour so fellow Muslims would feel comfortable in the pool.
"Personally, I would only want to go when just girls are there," Karim, who is also a Hatchet photographer, tells the newspaper.
Rahiba Noor, a junior who serves as the community service chair of the MSA, tells the newspaper that, prior to attending GW, swimming laps at a private pool was an important part of her health regimen. At school, however, Noor tells the student newspaper she's resigned herself to staying away from the water and using a treadmill.
"Religious values always define us," Noor tells the newspaper. "Although I wouldn't really mind, it would be satisfying to me religiously to swim only with girls."
For some Muslims, being in public without a hijab puts them at odds with fundamental aspects of Islam.
Valdez Williams, the operations manager of the gym, tells the newspaper the university helped the MSA coordinate the weekly swim hour because GW wanted to make the girls feel comfortable.
"At GW, we try to take care of all of our students," Williams tells the Hatchet. "As long as it's requested and works within our policies and procedures, we will generally accommodate them."
Williams says the university will try to schedule one hour each week for the female students to have private access.
"The girls should be able to swim here," Williams says. "We will not penalize them because of their religious beliefs."











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 10)
11-10-2010 @ 6:29PM
Alicia said...I don't see the point of the anger here. It's an hour a week. If it's that big of a deal, offer a men only hour on a different night. These women are trying to follow their belief system and I find it ironic that, at a time when I hear the word "godless" thrown around constantly, there's such criticism of people attempting to be godly. Or is it because they're the wrong religion?
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 7:28PM
deedee said...You took the words right out of my mouth. There's way too much hatred in this country. If the hour a week had been started for a different reason there would be no uproar.
11-11-2010 @ 8:25PM
Times a wastin' said..."We will not penalize them because of their religious beliefs."
If their religious beliefs penalize them for being in a country that has traditions that differ with theirs..........they are FREE to relocate to another country.
11-11-2010 @ 8:42PM
Alicia said...Last time I checked, America had a tradition of religious freedom and tolerance and acceptance of other cultures, including Islam and Middle Eastern culture. This isn't hurting anyone, it's not excluding anyone who isn't Muslim and there can just as easily be a men's hour if there are guys who feel uncomfortable swimming in front of the ladies. The outrage this has caused is completely ridiculous.
11-12-2010 @ 2:03AM
RaqRaq said...It's not a big deal. I like co-ed swimming but admit that I would also attend a women's only hour. I'm sure the college would do a men's hour, but that would just bring out the homophobes.
11-11-2010 @ 10:46PM
Ed said...It's high time the tail stopped wagging the dog.
11-11-2010 @ 11:03PM
debbie said...deedee,the muslam culture hides a hitler regime behind a fake religion--i hope you dont have little children,for they will reap what you have allowed to be sown
11-11-2010 @ 11:04PM
porkforubabe said...I want so see some of these muslim chicks in bikinis. Lets see what it is all about.
11-11-2010 @ 11:14PM
marilyn said...Many women besides Muslim are modest and would like women only swim time. Unfortunately in this day and age modesty does not count - Muslim does. Therefore I applaud an hour that modest women could swim in.
11-11-2010 @ 11:25PM
Debbie said...I agree 100% with Alicia. I'm slightly older and a little on the heavier side. I'm self-conscious in a bathing suit and would love a "womens only swim" I don't care what your religious beliefs are. And men can have equal time as well....
11-12-2010 @ 9:08AM
mg said..."They are free to move"???? Yesterday was veterans day. Our men and women have died to give us freedom including religian. Though I am not muslim it is their right in our country. 1 hour a week while how many Christian holidays do we place on others.
11-13-2010 @ 9:35PM
Doug said..."while honoring the basic tenants of their religion." ??
The word is 'tenets': a principle, belief, or doctrine generally held to be true; especially : one held in common by members of an organization, movement, or profession.
I'm going to make you look up the word 'tenants'.
If you're going to be a 'journalist', at least look like one.
11-18-2010 @ 2:42PM
Havildar said...This is Bogus. So women get an hour to themselves so what? Who lost anything or was hurt by it? It seems like the stupid that listen to the brain dead Fox talk shows are the ones complaining. Get a Life.
11-24-2010 @ 12:29PM
Vince said...Join the YWCA instead
12-05-2010 @ 6:47PM
billy said...This is only the beginning for the Muslims. I would have a better
feeling if the same Muslims stood up and spoke out against the terrorists or the burning of the American flag and Death to America.
But they don't - they are silent as always. Muslims will never be accepted in this country unless they become Americans first instead of Muslims first!!!
12-16-2010 @ 12:41PM
naql said...Hey, it's ok. Look they have one of those "pool cams", so we can just undress them with our eyes remotely. No problem.
1-05-2011 @ 1:20PM
iteration2 said...The same people throwing "godless" around, as if it were an insult, are probably not the same people who criticize this decision being made on religious grounds.
I'm an atheist, which means I haven't chosen or been handed a set of arbitrary beliefs and superstitions. And while I feel sorry for those who do feel like they need to fit their lives into a framework of arbitrary rules, I don't think it's right for them to expect or demand anyone else to bend to their beliefs. And if someone argues that their religion is NOT a choice, then I think that alone speaks volumes about the ethical vacuum their religious background thrives in.
That said, I still agree with the policy of having certain times designated for restricted access. It's a fair request that there be some time set aside for women, and some for men, and some for adults (probably not an issue at a university pool). Nothing wrong with offering special accommodation to people who want it, so long as the majority of time is spent catering to those WITHOUT self-imposed special needs. The only issue is when it becomes a matter of religious entitlement. People are free to have whatever belief system they want, but it should never entitle them to special treatment.
11-11-2010 @ 7:07PM
LON CURTIS said...IF THIS BE THE CASE THEN I WANT A CATHOLIC NIGHT 1 HR BABTIST NIGHT 1 HOUR JEWISH NIGHT 1 HOUR INDIAN NIGHT 1 HOUR BLACK NIGHT 1 HOUR WHITE NIGHT 1 HOUR ATHIEST NIGHT 1 HOUR SEVENTH DAY ADVENTIST NIGHT 1 HOUR ONLY TO BE FAIR TO ALL. I OULD GO ON AND ON BUT THIS IS WHAT IS HAPPENING TO OUR SOCIETY WE ARE ALWAYS BENDING OVER TO THE MINORITY SIDE IT SUCKS LITERALLY. IF YOU MUST USE THE POOL THEN DO AS OTHERS DO PUT ON YOUR SUIT AND DIVE IN ALA WILL SAVE YOU I HOPE.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:18PM
PaulTHirth said...This is LADIES swim hour, not a MUSLIM swim hour.
11-12-2010 @ 2:12PM
rob said...I know where you're coming from, we are always bending over backwards for them, yet they won't move a stupid mosque!!