Women-Only Swim Hour for Muslims Makes Waves on Campus
Filed under: In The News, Religion & Spirituality
Credit: Matt Roth, Getty Images
In an attempt to be inclusive to all religious traditions on campus, last week George Washington University started "Sisters' Splash," a ladies-only swim hour, according to the university newspaper, The GW Hatchet. The school's Lerner Health and Wellness Center closed the pool to men and covered the glass door with a dark tarp, giving female Muslim students the chance to swim at their leisure, while honoring the basic tenets of their religion.
Everything was going swimmingly, and coeds shed their head and body gear and rocked swimsuits, at least until scores of critics began hurling heated comments that continue to pour in on various blogs and news reports, according to the journal Inside Higher Education.
"Should a minuscule minority force the overwhelming majority to abide by their rules or should it be the other way around?" is one of the Internet comments about the female-only swim, the journal reports.
Others include: "Come on, folks. An hour a week -- what's the big deal?" "It's not an unreasonable request. 'Women' is like *half* the population."
Because George Washington is a private university, there should be no constitutional issues with the swim hour, Ayesha N. Khan, legal director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, tells Inside Higher Education.
"Should a similar program start up at a public university, the presence of church-state issues would depend on the many facts of the situation, such as whether access is religion-specific," Khan tells the journal.
Aliya Karim, social chair of the Muslim Students' Association (MSA) women's group, tells the student newspaper the organization made the effort to coordinate the swimming hour so fellow Muslims would feel comfortable in the pool.
"Personally, I would only want to go when just girls are there," Karim, who is also a Hatchet photographer, tells the newspaper.
Rahiba Noor, a junior who serves as the community service chair of the MSA, tells the newspaper that, prior to attending GW, swimming laps at a private pool was an important part of her health regimen. At school, however, Noor tells the student newspaper she's resigned herself to staying away from the water and using a treadmill.
"Religious values always define us," Noor tells the newspaper. "Although I wouldn't really mind, it would be satisfying to me religiously to swim only with girls."
For some Muslims, being in public without a hijab puts them at odds with fundamental aspects of Islam.
Valdez Williams, the operations manager of the gym, tells the newspaper the university helped the MSA coordinate the weekly swim hour because GW wanted to make the girls feel comfortable.
"At GW, we try to take care of all of our students," Williams tells the Hatchet. "As long as it's requested and works within our policies and procedures, we will generally accommodate them."
Williams says the university will try to schedule one hour each week for the female students to have private access.
"The girls should be able to swim here," Williams says. "We will not penalize them because of their religious beliefs."











ReaderComments (Page 4 of 10)
11-11-2010 @ 8:20PM
IvyLeaguer said...Mary Beth Sammons writes:
"the chance to swim at their leisure, while honoring the basic tenants of their religion."
Just curious, do these tenants have to pay much rent? Mary Beth, I hope writing is not your day job.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 8:20PM
John said...As long if any student and or the school is receiving financial aid from the US government by law they must obey eeo laws.Their cannot be any separation for church for even 5 minutes.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 8:23PM
sarahb said...I hope Alicia don't have any children in school because if she does, she should know that their religion is in no way protected nor allowed to be even talked about at school, but we should make exception for Muslim girls to sneak around from their Muslim Authorities and go swimming in a swim suit, which is against her Muslim (religion rules)???? And make everyone else honer their wishes for them to have the pool in privacy. That is absurd!!!!!!
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:04PM
Alicia said...1) Your grammar is appalling.
2) I'm 20. No I don't have children and I'm incredibly happy about that particular fact, since I'm far too busy racking up student loans to pay for them.
3) Considering I had classes on just about every religion throughout high school and college, I'd say you're misinformed. I went to a public school and we had all the major world religions taught to us as part of social studies, since they all contributed greatly to the laws and reactions of different areas around the world throughout history.
4) While it was a religious group that requested the hour be designated for women, it is not only Islamic women who can swim. Honestly, I prefer to workout with no men around, including swimming. I'm usually at the pool (when I have access to one) and the earliest or latest possible hour to avoid there being men (or anyone else) there, so this can benefit women who are just more comfortable working out when there are no men around.
11-11-2010 @ 8:24PM
bdogs80 said...Yeah, if you don't like our democracy, then move somewhere else where you live under the thumb of a tyrannt. They are not asking for Muslim only swimming, they are asking for women only. GW should make a men only swimming hour to even it out. But as one person already said, you are an idiot.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 8:34PM
J said...Here we go again, kowtowing to the muslims.......
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 8:50PM
Sara said...its an hour a week people plus its not only for the muslim women its for any woman who doesnt want to swim with men stareing at them.
but oh no because they did it for the muslim women to begin with it must be bad...yet we get easter break christmas break but not women only swim hour
so quit crying that for one hour a week you cant stare at the women swimming in theire bathing suits
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 8:59PM
sandy ainbinder said...What's the big deal. It's only an hour a week. I'll bet that if it were a different religion, there wouldn't be this flap. All Muslims don't want us dead. It's that tiny percentile that causes all the problems.
Reply
11-12-2010 @ 5:00AM
Laura Miller said...Ah, that may be true that only a few casue the trouble but how many of the majority have stood up around the world including those in this country to condemn their terrorist acts? uhm.....NONE. These people still believe in stoning, beheading, women can't be heard or seen and they must walk behind their man. They can not get medical treatment because no other man may touch them. Disgusting religious ways!
11-11-2010 @ 8:59PM
debbie said...I really don't understand why this should be an issue. There are many different religions in this country and every American has the right to practice the religion of their choice...whether people from other religions approve or not. Muslim women have a right to swim too and I can see no reason why it should be a problem for an hour a week to be set aside for "women" only so that Muslim women can be comfortable in the pool.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:00PM
endorph said...years ago when I was working for our community swim program we had one hour a week set aside for the Old Apostolic Lutheran women to swim. Not only were they by themselves - all the lifeguards had to be female and there could be no men in the building - which also housed a gym - while they were there incase they ran into someone coming and going to the locker room. The men from the church swam for an hour after the women. We could have female lifeguards for them as well as male! So beofer you jump on Muslims keep in mind there are many Christian denominations out there that require segreation of the sexes for things like swimming as well. It's one hour a week - get over it. And if others wnat a segregated time let them petition the school for the same thing.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:00PM
tweb142 said...An all female swim hour to appease the ragheads. Can you say "DISCRIMINATION." Do they have an ALL MALE SWIM HOUR?
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:35PM
L.A.G. said...The Muslim girls have a great idea. There is a reason there are all women gyms in this country. It's called modesty. Putting on a bathing suit can be difficult and embarrassing for women of all sizes. This is not spring break in Cancun where the women want to flaunt their bodies. That women want to exercise without men around is nothing new and certainly an hour a week shouldn't be an issue.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:39PM
sdf said...Really the Muslim women have a good idea, how about the Muslim men? Are there ideas that we women are merely property, they can divorce us and we have no say so, but we can't divorce them, we have to cover our heads and bodies in 100 plus weather, or kids can treat us like property too, we can't walk outside without a male with us who is a relative, no drinking, no smoking, heck no freedoms! You really like the way they think? Get real.
11-11-2010 @ 10:09PM
Alicia said...@sdf- An there are Christians who believe women shouldn't be educated, allowed to vote, allowed outside the home, that marital rape should be legal, that a woman should submit to her husband and he has the right to beat her when she doesn't and that women belong to men as property. However, the majority of Christians know that's bullsh*t. Yes, Muslim women are asked to cover their hair and dress modestly, but most followers of Islam are far more moderate than you give them credit for. Never judge a culture by its extremists.
11-11-2010 @ 9:02PM
Dan said...Fck that! Set up a time for them to swim with alligators, sharks, and pirahna!
Reply
11-13-2010 @ 2:48PM
mhung said...how old r u .. 13? .. what you wrote was so f*kn UNEXPECTED .. i was Shocked by the image that popped into my mind: my old hi sch pool with sunrays pouring in thru the huge windows onto laughing giggling teenage girls splashing in the water when suddenly‼
i know you're an adult; but the solution you offer relates to my own mindset at 13 or so .. and it was That mhung that cracked up when he read your post .. so out of step with all the other pro and con posters .. slap-stick comedy at its best. thanks for the laugh between the serious and the angry perplexed .. just like a zen strawberry ! (aaah)
11-11-2010 @ 9:10PM
gg said...Well good Ole America we just keep believing that this is part of our constitution. Yet the very people we are trying to accomodate don't BELIEVE in Our Constitution and in some states are trying to have the laws changed to Sharia law were women are treated no better thtn cattle. So just keep giving in and pretty soon you will have these idiot Muslim men trying to tell you how to treat your wife and children. Just remember They do not believe in Jesus the Son of God . However Jesus said in his word that unless we first know Him we CAN NOT know the Father.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:23PM
pcintampa58 said...When are American's going to wake up. We are at war with the Muslims. Granted, there are some who are just as America loving as I am. But those are the ones that should be standing up and saying that what the terrorists are doing is wrong. Unless, deep in their heart they believe and condone all that has been done to the western world in the name of Allah. And don't come back with this crap that we are not at war with all Muslims. How many terrorists have there been that were of any other religion? Look at some of the nations in Europe. They are slowely being taken over by the Muslims who have been given haven there. Maybe in some years in the future you will look back and realize that the Muslims are like a spreading plague. I lived among these people for a full year and know that they have no feelings whatsoever for "infidels", meaning ANYONE who is not a Muslim. Again I say wake up America before it is too late.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 11:39PM
Lishalu said...Oh, I don't know, how about these Christianity-based domestic terrorists...
1. Army of God
2. Aryan Nations
3. The Covenant, The Sword, and the Arm of the Lord
4. KKK
5. Phineas Priesthood
Do I really need to keep going? Don't judge an entire population on the actions of a few.