Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Bonnie Fuller: Zach Sobiech: You Were a Huge Inspiration in Your…
When A Tornado Strikes, Should Schools Evacuate?
Women-Only Swim Hour for Muslims Makes Waves on Campus
Filed under: In The News, Religion & Spirituality
Credit: Matt Roth, Getty Images
In an attempt to be inclusive to all religious traditions on campus, last week George Washington University started "Sisters' Splash," a ladies-only swim hour, according to the university newspaper, The GW Hatchet. The school's Lerner Health and Wellness Center closed the pool to men and covered the glass door with a dark tarp, giving female Muslim students the chance to swim at their leisure, while honoring the basic tenets of their religion.
Everything was going swimmingly, and coeds shed their head and body gear and rocked swimsuits, at least until scores of critics began hurling heated comments that continue to pour in on various blogs and news reports, according to the journal Inside Higher Education.
"Should a minuscule minority force the overwhelming majority to abide by their rules or should it be the other way around?" is one of the Internet comments about the female-only swim, the journal reports.
Others include: "Come on, folks. An hour a week -- what's the big deal?" "It's not an unreasonable request. 'Women' is like *half* the population."
Because George Washington is a private university, there should be no constitutional issues with the swim hour, Ayesha N. Khan, legal director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, tells Inside Higher Education.
"Should a similar program start up at a public university, the presence of church-state issues would depend on the many facts of the situation, such as whether access is religion-specific," Khan tells the journal.
Aliya Karim, social chair of the Muslim Students' Association (MSA) women's group, tells the student newspaper the organization made the effort to coordinate the swimming hour so fellow Muslims would feel comfortable in the pool.
"Personally, I would only want to go when just girls are there," Karim, who is also a Hatchet photographer, tells the newspaper.
Rahiba Noor, a junior who serves as the community service chair of the MSA, tells the newspaper that, prior to attending GW, swimming laps at a private pool was an important part of her health regimen. At school, however, Noor tells the student newspaper she's resigned herself to staying away from the water and using a treadmill.
"Religious values always define us," Noor tells the newspaper. "Although I wouldn't really mind, it would be satisfying to me religiously to swim only with girls."
For some Muslims, being in public without a hijab puts them at odds with fundamental aspects of Islam.
Valdez Williams, the operations manager of the gym, tells the newspaper the university helped the MSA coordinate the weekly swim hour because GW wanted to make the girls feel comfortable.
"At GW, we try to take care of all of our students," Williams tells the Hatchet. "As long as it's requested and works within our policies and procedures, we will generally accommodate them."
Williams says the university will try to schedule one hour each week for the female students to have private access.
"The girls should be able to swim here," Williams says. "We will not penalize them because of their religious beliefs."











ReaderComments (Page 5 of 10)
12-05-2010 @ 2:03PM
Connie said...I have no problem with setting aside an hour a week for 'women only' swimming. However, here's the thing that DOES scare the heck out of me: Any country or area of a country that is majority Muslim, Christians and Jews are discriminated against and treated VERY poorly. In many Muslim countries, Christians are being systematically killed or forced out of their homes. So why, or why are we allowing HUGE numbers of Muslims to immigrate to this country? Why allow them a foothold here, when they have such a horrendous record on human rights, womens rights, and religious freedom? They don't integrate, and they want to change OUR traditions and way of life to suit them. In a nutshell that's what's REALLY upsetting most Americans, and too many view this swimming thing as just the next demand, with many, many more to come.
11-11-2010 @ 9:18PM
JadeSnow said...Even if there were a miniscule amount of "difficulty" in setting aside this hour, would it ruin someone's life just to be nice about it? Why can't we treat each other with some respect and bend a little now then. Here's a thought: Treat others the way you would like to be treated. Oh, wait, we're Christians! We would NEVER want to do THAT!
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:17PM
gg said...We are not allowed to pray in public Our children are not allowed topray in school and yet we have special swimming time for Muslim women something is just not right about this whole thing. It is one thin to be taught about these religions in school it is a whole other story when it comes to practicing you religion in public.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 10:12PM
Alicia said...Your children can pray in school. They can read the bible in school. However, there shouldn't be designated prayer time where all children are forced to pray. Also, that's public schools. This is a private college.
11-11-2010 @ 11:47PM
Lee said...You can pray in public, you just can't do it over a bullhorn and disturb other. No one has ever stopped a student from praying in school (before a test or a meal for example) but the public schools aren't allowed to orchestrate it or demand it.
Get your facts straight. Perhaps you could pray for clarity.
11-11-2010 @ 9:19PM
Bill said...If! If! If! Everything associated with the Islamic religion in western society starts with an 'IF'! If Jews and Christians want to swim in Islamic countries with mixed swims, would Muslim's allow it? "IF' hell freezes over first!
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:26PM
Thomas J. Burke said...I went to the University in Germany back in the 50s & 60s. There were many Moslem foreign students there. They all adapted to the local customs while at the University. Drinking beer is of course one of the customs at a German U. They said that when at a foreign U that it was permissable to do as they do. Has the rules for Moslems changed or are these people trying to create a scene. They may be younger than the post graduate students that I knew in Germany and many immature kids like to make a scene just to be noticed.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:20PM
crabby said...People are actinh hateful petty and intolerant.Get a grip...face reality and grow the hell up. Sometimes in the real world you have to be flexible and accept things.Why is it difficult to understand a cultural tradition of modesty for females?
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:25PM
Craig said........basic "tenants" of their religion?
Please.....
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:34PM
Thomas J. Burke said...Before coming to America they should understand the "Melting Pot" tradition of America. It is not now, never has been, and should not be that we have to understand and put up with their traditions. What ever happened to the "When In Rome Do As the Romans". In Moslem countries you are expected to live in accordance with their tradition. They do not allow American women to wear shorts or miniskirts in their country.
11-11-2010 @ 10:15PM
Alicia said...And we know their country is flawed. That is why they left, to move to a country where we tolerate other cultures and encourage them to engage. Oh wait. That's right. If you're not rich, white, male and Christian in America, you're screwed. I almost forgot why I left the flea-bitten place to begin with. Too bad I have to come back.
11-11-2010 @ 10:22PM
Alicia said...*countries are
Aye, the stupid is catching. I'm starting to sound as ignorant as you lot.
11-11-2010 @ 9:30PM
Bob Sherman said...This is a bunch of bull. I wonder if there country would give our AMERICAN girls that same privilege
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:52PM
SHEILA said...While this particular incident should not be overblown, some Americans, including myself, are often bewildered by Muslim persons who wish to have our society conform to their sexist upbringing. These women are chattel in their own society and should not expect our society to change to always accommodate their beliefs. Also, Non-Muslims would not be given the same
freedoms to do co-ed activities in their homeland in respect to our
beliefs. Many Muslims come here because it is America and the
freedoms we have are desirable and unattainable in the religion or
society. Let the Mosques who are so stringent in their control of their chattel build their own pools and there will be no complaints.
The one hour is not the problem; the insistance of following their
tenets is the problem. God Bless America, Land of the Free, where swimming at a particular hour is a form of discrimination; this is an example of reverse discrimination to men and our system of freedom.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:30PM
Coop said...If there's anyone in this country who is more against muslims wearing their traditional garb in public, it's me - and even I don't see a problem with GW having a women's hour at the pool once a week. I would imagine there are some fairly devout christian women who will also take advantage of this opportunity. And, while I certainly appreciate (read: "love to ogle") a well-shaped female body in a swimming suit, I admire women who exhibit a little modesty.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 9:31PM
qq4lbfm said...Would I be correct in assuming that there is at least an hour set aside each week for men to swim sans women?
Reply
12-10-2010 @ 2:23PM
Jodi said...I'm sure there would be if the men wanted it.
11-11-2010 @ 9:34PM
sdf said...I agree with Lon, this bending over backwards for every small faction of our society has got to stop. They are here in our country they need to conform to our rule or leave. Do you think for one minute that any Muslim country would permit our women to wear a bikini in public or to walk around without covering their heads? No, they would force us to put on the veil and covering or we would get beaten on the streets or taken away to jail where we might or might not be seen again.
Reply
11-11-2010 @ 10:20PM
Alicia said...Like white people conformed to Native American culture? Oh...that's right...
11-11-2010 @ 9:39PM
lola said...There have been WOMEN only swims and gyms for orthodox Jewish women for years why is this different? OH OH I remember, because AMERICAN CONSERVATIVES are looking at ALL MUSLIMS and their religion like the NAZIS looked at JEWS 60 years ago. Should we start building the ovens now?
RACIST BIGOTTS
Reply