Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Karri-Leigh P. Mastrangelo: Pregnant or Not, I Don't Regret My…
How To Have A Stress-Free Blended Family Vacation
Can I Avoid Nicknames?
Filed under: Baby Names
I am due in December, and my husband and I like the name William. The problem is our last name, which ends in "ll" as well, rules out the nickname Will. We do not like any of the other popular nicknames for William. How reasonable is it to expect that little William will be called by his full name instead of having family and friends shortening it into a nickname that is either a tongue twister or a name we don't care for?
- No Will, No Way
If you aim for the full William, you won't be alone. More and more families are turning toward the formal today, filling playgrounds with the likes of James-not-Jim and Daniel-not-Dan. The standard nicknames just sound too ordinary for today's parents. After all, it was "every Tom, Dick and Harry" who stood for the everyman, not "every Thomas, Richard and Henry."
But as many Name Lady readers have told me, nicknames have a life of their own. Parental control only goes so far.
The biggest risk factor is length. The longer the name, the more tenacious nicknames are -- especially for boys. Cross the three-syllable boy barrier and shortening is hard to avoid. That's tough news for the mom of a Maximilian or Tobias, but bodes well for your William.
The second source of risk can be hard to imagine from the prenatal present. It's your son himself and his future buddies. At some point between the start of third grade and the senior year sports banquet, a marauding horde of boys is likely to transform your elegant William into a Will (or Billy, or Rocketman).
So, if your surname is truly abominable with Will (Will Call?) and you can't accept the slightest risk of it, William is not for you. Otherwise, make your peace with the possibility of future nicknames and go ahead and choose your favorite name. William is a classic, you and your husband both like it, and you, at least, will always be able to call your son by it.
How do you deal with nicknames? Share your experiences here. And if you have your own question to Ask the Name Lady, drop her a line!
- No Will, No Way
If you aim for the full William, you won't be alone. More and more families are turning toward the formal today, filling playgrounds with the likes of James-not-Jim and Daniel-not-Dan. The standard nicknames just sound too ordinary for today's parents. After all, it was "every Tom, Dick and Harry" who stood for the everyman, not "every Thomas, Richard and Henry."
But as many Name Lady readers have told me, nicknames have a life of their own. Parental control only goes so far.
The biggest risk factor is length. The longer the name, the more tenacious nicknames are -- especially for boys. Cross the three-syllable boy barrier and shortening is hard to avoid. That's tough news for the mom of a Maximilian or Tobias, but bodes well for your William.
The second source of risk can be hard to imagine from the prenatal present. It's your son himself and his future buddies. At some point between the start of third grade and the senior year sports banquet, a marauding horde of boys is likely to transform your elegant William into a Will (or Billy, or Rocketman).
So, if your surname is truly abominable with Will (Will Call?) and you can't accept the slightest risk of it, William is not for you. Otherwise, make your peace with the possibility of future nicknames and go ahead and choose your favorite name. William is a classic, you and your husband both like it, and you, at least, will always be able to call your son by it.
How do you deal with nicknames? Share your experiences here. And if you have your own question to Ask the Name Lady, drop her a line!











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 7)
12-06-2010 @ 6:43AM
rebecca said...I primarly like Parent dish, but this is the worst question I have read yet. No wonder no one has responded.
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 6:48AM
brinda said...3 kids, Sara became "sissy" Ian, for some strange reason is pronunced "an" and aaron will forever be known as "a" no complaints from any of them, and they are in their 30's!
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 1:19PM
Holly said...Just name you child William and if it sticks it sticks. If nicknames develop and your son is comfortable with them, what's the big deal? Some of my son's friends that date back to childhood are Andrew, Michael and Patrick. They've never been called by nicknames. I always wished there was a cute nickname for my name, Marilyn. No one ever came up with one. My mother, on occasion, would call me Mare. Like sure, Mom, I'm a female horse. In high school, a popular boy went by Snapper. His real name was something normal like, John, James or William but no one ever knew it until senior year when his graduation picture for the yearbook listed his real name. In high school, some kids were called by nicknames and others weren't. We had both Barb and Barbara, Margaret and Maggie, James and Jim, etc. It's pointless imagining what nicknames your kid may be called when you never know. We had a couple of kids in high school that for some reason, everyone just called by their last names.
12-06-2010 @ 7:01AM
Mom of 3 said...Our son is named William and we call him Will. After living in the south all of my life and listening to William pronounced "Weeyum" we decided to shorten it ourselves. Now if I can just get them to stop calling him "Willie"! :)
Reply
12-07-2010 @ 6:36AM
New York said...The childs name is the least thing you should worry about. People will call him whatever you call him. My grandson is named William. We call him William & guess what??? So does everyone else.
12-06-2010 @ 7:26AM
Sunny-Hawaii said...Good luck with trying to control how others use his name. You will be doomed to frustration. It's not only others, but the child themselves that will rename himself. Princess Diana had William, but she renamed him Wills because he was willful. I have a 3-syllable ethnic name. Talk about name hell. #1 most people can't pronounce it #2 I spend an ungodly time correcting people and spelling it over and over (thanks mom!) #3 people shorten it anyway. They use the first 2 syllables, the last 2, and in=between! And interestingly, none of them repeat the same nick name! Early on in my life I gave myself an "American" name because I wanted to be like 'everyone else'. So at all my different work places, I'm known by a different name! Only my last job did everyone pronounce my full name all the time. Prior to that it was always a new short cut. So good luck with everyone calling Wm. by his full name. I can hear Bill, Billy, Will, Willy, and even Wii now. At least it's not Richard!!
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 7:40AM
John F.C. Taylor said...You fear the possible nicknames? Never use them when speaking to the child in private or in public. If other people and their children hear you use William all the time they will be less likely to use a nickname when they talk to him.
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 7:57AM
Madonna said...easy way to correct shortined names my dad did it to mine someone called and asked for me by nick name and my dad said sorry no on by that name lives here and hung up sane with knocks at doors etc.. he told me that is not your name and would not accept it and never did so my friends accepted it and always usedmy full name end of problem
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 12:43PM
Meg said...That was what my great-grandmother did to my grandma... Her name was Margaret, and her friends wanted to call her Peg, Peggy, Marge, Maggie, etc, but her mom put her foot down and said "no" to nicknames. My grandma was Margaret until the day she passed.
12-06-2010 @ 2:18PM
george22552 said...I taught in a H.S. for 20 yrs. and I've run in to my fair share of names that, at times, I had to look twice at to confirm what I was reading. One mild, introverted, and foreign born male 7th grader's name was pronounced "Nee-shee" BUT it was spelled N-I-S-H-I-T .
I would hyothetically cringe if and when some substitute,perhaps, would be taking attendance and maybe raise raise their eyebrows but say Nishit's name incorrectly anyway. Suggestion: if and when you choose ANY name for your offspring just examine the initials or nickname posibilities before you cross any similar pobbibilities.
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 12:53PM
Jack said...Same thing happened to me with a 3rd grade student whose name was pronounced Shee-Toll but the spelling was Shital. I hate to think what they called him in HS when kids think they are clever over something that clearly isn't funny. I wonder how the poor little Shit - al is doing these days.
12-06-2010 @ 1:40PM
Holly said...This reminds me of when one of my distant relatives came through Ellis Island and his last name was Shitlovich. Fortunately, someone at the immigration service had the sense to shorten it so that when he became a citizen the "shit" was formally gone.
12-06-2010 @ 8:21AM
Darla said...My son's name is William. We have always called him by his full name, but by the time he started high school, most people were calling him Will, especially kids on his baseball team. It does not bother me, but I still call him William. PLEASE do not give your child a name that you already know will cause issues. You cannot control who will call him by his full name and those that will shorten it. Why would you give your son a name that you know could cause you and him grief?
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 8:39AM
Bardowl said...This may be off the point a bit, but I used to be a college teacher, and one of my colleagues who had to fill in for another teacher came to me with a situation. She showed me a list of names, one of which was a surname that could be pronounced in a very embarrassing manner, and asked me what to do when she called the roll. I suggested that she pass around a sheet of paper and ask students to sign it. Problem solved.
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 8:41AM
scales60 said...why can't you call him willy...or willie........that is another nickname for William.
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 10:26PM
Matthew said...Really Scales? You want them tom call the kid Willie? Why dont you just shoot him now before he goes to jr high and high school!
12-06-2010 @ 8:43AM
stacy said...My younger sister is named Gabrielle. My step mother was very adamant about her only being called Gabrielle, not Gabby not Gab not Elle GABRIELLE. When people would try to call her something else they were politely reprimanded "Excuse me, her name is Gabrielle not Gabby." It worked, when she was old enough she started telling people herself what her name was and besides children teasing her no-one has ever referred to her as anything other than Gabrielle. Now if you think this is a fluke I have to tell you I also have a younger sister named Francesca...not Fran not Franny... FRANCESCA. She is also old enough to now tell people what her name is when they make the mistake of calling her anything else. If you feel strongly about a name you can make sure that the everyday people in your child's life call them by their name and not a nickname. We work hard with the struggle of picking the perfect name for our children it is not unreasonable for us to want them to be called by that name and it should not be considered rude or impossible to expect otherwise.
Reply
12-06-2010 @ 9:52AM
cpm said...Feel free to be didactic out the name, but the end result is that most people aren't going to bother with anyone who is that uptight to begin with.
BTW--"Gabrielle" can be pronounced as ending in "-ell" or "-ella". Do you slap people who add or omit the last syllable?
12-06-2010 @ 6:01PM
Tonic said...Well, here's a point you may have missed: parents who insist their children be called by the full name are considered pests. I had a friend, Linda Lee, and people constantly shortened her name to Linda. When the mother jumped right in to correct them, everyone rolled their eyes. If you don't care about that, go ahead and insist on never allowing shortened or nick names.
12-06-2010 @ 8:49AM
John said...When someone called my daughter "Al" or "Allie" instead of Allison, we (or she) would simply say, "I prefer Allison." And, my co-worker James, would never let anyone call him "Jim." IF you don't want the nickname, just say so if someone starts to use one.
Reply