
Barbara Walters' Question on 'The View' Gave Me a Pregnant Pause
Filed under: Opinions, Celeb News & Interviews
My husband, now known as Congressman-Elect Sean Duffy, Barbara Walters, Baby Maria Victoria and me behind the scenes this week at The View.
It was a provocative question, especially since baby #6 was sitting on my lap at the time. I simply responded, "Being a mom is the best job in the world!"
Politico called the answer "diplomatic," and National Review's Kathryn Lopez tweeted that it was "graceful," but I couldn't help being disappointed with my response. Not that it wasn't true -– being a mom is the best job in the world - but I felt that a question as culturally loaded as this one deserved a better answer, especially from someone who has written countless columns and an entire book on the subject of at-home motherhood and the sad fact that our culture does little to applaud or elevate this noble calling.
So, if I had it to do over again, what would I say to Barbara? I'd say, "Barbara, I consider it a privilege and a blessing to have six kids and watch them grow up. As fun as it is to be here with you all (and it is!) I wouldn't trade the precious and fleeting time I have home with my kids for anything."
The truth is, I honestly hold nothing against Barbara for asking the question. Come on, it's "The View!" We expect conversation-starters and brutally blunt discussion. More importantly, I understood full well what Barbara was trying to say. She's a smart woman and a mom herself, so she knows that raising children, especially six, involves not only professional sacrifices, but also many daily personal sacrifices. From Barbara's perch, I can see why my decision to choose at-home motherhood in rural Wisconsin over a "budding career" as she called it, seems perplexing.
What I failed to articulate in that moment on behalf of all the other at-home moms watching is that amid the daily diapers, dishes and tedium, there is also a certain kind of happiness that one can only derive from service to others – especially our children. In our me-first culture, that is a very counterintuitive notion, but one that recent scientific studies into the field of "happiness" are confirming. People who serve others are happier, regardless of their income or personal circumstances.
But setting aside service for a moment, perhaps the most under-examined aspect of mothering is pleasure -– yes, pleasure! Despite the hard work, an increasing number are choosing to do it full-time because they derive real pleasure and a deep sense of satisfaction from doing it well.
Being an at-home parent does not make me a better parent. What it does afford me are more opportunities to become the best parent I can be. That's as satisfying a feeling as any daytime Emmy -- and it won't wear off when the headlines fade.
Time spent with my kids permits me to better understand their personalities and needs. Like any other profession or sport, I improve my skills and techniques the more time I spend doing it. Becoming a better player in the parenting game means more moments to enjoy the game -– or in this case, delight in my children. Would I trade that for anything? Not a chance. Not even for a career as illustrious and historic as Barbara Walters'.
Your<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- Government agent under oath washington dc civil filing?
- Alot of .gov when submitting a program or proposal for government agency (be sure you personally can provide for the agency)
- Copyright court case litigation? the words spoken by attorney at trial ? in defense of a product or person(or as plaintiff or defendant))











ReaderComments (Page 3 of 5)
12-17-2010 @ 8:41AM
Spot said...Ditto Sandyone.
Being a full time mom/homemaker is my career. I absolutely love what I do, I cannot fathom doing anything else right now and I am blessed to have the opportunity to be at home.
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 11:13AM
Karen said...alicia, I havent and nver wanted any children from the get-go..I kinda knew what it would take & NOW being 55 yrs know for sure I would not have been capable of being a good mother..It's a career in itself and many have NO idea of the HUGE undertaking theyre taking..I practiced b/control, then finally got my tubes tied round 30...Best thing i had ever done for myself and an unwanted child..
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 8:47AM
Tere said...Thank you for making a stay at home mom sound so good...I did it for seven years before I decided to go back to work and that was only decided because the kids were becoming older and were starting their own lives...now I have the opportunity to watch my daughter be a stay at home mom and raise her daughter, my advice to her has been to cherish the moments..especially the little ones..to enjoy her daughter because they grow up so soon...being a parent is the hardest job their can be and much harder for women who decide to stay home.... but to all those who make the decision to stay at home with their children I applaud you!!!!!
Reply
12-20-2010 @ 7:40PM
jennifer Delgado said...Let's see if the next time BW inteviews a man, she says, " Now, are you sure you wouldn't rather have 6 kids and stay home from work to raise them?" At that point, we have reached equality. I know a wonderful man who adopted 4 alone, and does just that. Let BW be egaltarian, not demand it of her guests.
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 9:06AM
SteelCityMagnolia said...I am 40, childless, and work 1 full-time job and 2 part-time jobs. I work to fill my time, not because I I have bills to pay. I work because I love all three of my jobs dearly and enjoy the time I spend at them. Yet I would give them all up in a heartbeat for just one child. Society looks at childless women quite differently. Somehow it's odd that a woman my age doesn't have kids. I get asked quite frequently "Don't you LIKE kids???" and then get a rambling-on spiel about how wonderful kids are. I love kids. I'd love to have a baby, but it just isn't possible. My reproductive organs are nobody else's business, yet because I am childless, people seem to make them their business. "Oh, you're just not trying hard enough." (on the contrary, I've tried VERY hard!) "God will bless you some day." (well, he better hurry up, he gave me this biological clock and I can only hit snooze for so long!) "Well, you can always adopt." (true, if I had an extra $50K laying around and could find an adoption agency that doesn't look at single women like pedophiles!) Those are the things I hear on nearly a daily basis, all while being looked at like I am some sort of freak. I've accepted my life for what it is and the way it is. Why can't everyone else????
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 9:26AM
peleroja said...How well said! I am like you (single and childless, and slightly older - mid 40's). I too have had people say that to me often about having children... and believe me I wanted a "typical" family, but it didn't work out that way. I am a teacher (so I obviously like kids) but I'd give it up to have had my own, but time and Mother Nature dictate that isn't likely. So, like you, life continues on and you make the best of it - but I agree, single childless women ARE judged differently and more so the older they get.
12-17-2010 @ 9:11AM
beachlover said...I just stumbled upon this article. I don't get it - the stay at home mom has written a book and dozens of columns. Who is watching the six children while she is doing all this work? She may be a mom that stays at home - but clearly she is doing something else but changing diapers and doing the dishes to derive some type of emotional and educational satisifaction.
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 9:30AM
Dee said...I have never been clear on why so many people admire Barbara Walters. She asks questions which are none of her business or anyone else's. Years ago she asked former NYC mayor Ed Koch if he was gay. He essentially told her that the question had no bearing on their discussion. He said that he did not question her about her sexuality and that she should not be asking him. Amen!
Just because it's a talk show does not mean it's open season on any subject.
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 8:43PM
sarahb said...Too bad some of those thousands Barbara hass spent on face lifts to make her face crooked a stiff looking couldn't have been used to enhance her brain.. Money can't put a brain where there is none and obviously can't do much for a face as ugly as Barbra Walters..
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 9:50AM
Carolyn said...I take issue with women who claim they've made "sacrifices" in raising kids. When having children is what you choose, you haven't sacrificed; you've gotten what you want. Do working women without children claim they've "sacrificed" to go to work? They shouldn't. They, too, have gotten exactly what they want.
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 10:10AM
bbimley said...THE WORLD'S GREATEST PROFESSION IS BEING A 'MOM'.....I TOTALLY RAISED MINE,,,,(GOOD HUSBAND WORKED ALL TIME TO SUPPORT US) BEST THING I EVER DID ...@49 & 46 THEY ARE MY BEST FRIENDS & CONFIDANTS......
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 10:21AM
Dave said...I guess a question like that is to be expected from someone like Barbara Walters... and the 'ladies' on the View... I liked your response; don't feel bad. Where her son/daughter(???), will remember mommy was on TV and bought me everything, your children will remember all the time and love you gave them
when they were young... Keep up the good work!
Merry Christmas! :)
Dave, father of six
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 1:02PM
Diane said...Rachel, just like my mother who gave up a career to raise me and my sister, you are a real hero. Being completely honest about it while society is not, women like you and my mother are special. Truly you are better mothers than your counterparts, who are actually part-time moms. You should've asked Ms. Walters if she regrets sacrificing the job of being a mother to have a career. That's at least as fair a question.
P.S. I have a career and no children, but if I did become a mother I'd not be a part-time one, if financially possible.
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 12:26PM
gnomei said...First time commenter. Just wanted to say that this was a very good article and I'm happy to have come across it.
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 10:31AM
ProudArmyMom said...Your original response was fine: short and inspirational. I chose to stay home for 15 years to raise four kids. During the 80s, women who chose to stay home were considered lazy and a sale-out to the women's cause. As I told everyone that TRIED to make the statement, "Who better to raise my kids than their parents!" It was a joy then. Helping to raise grandkids is a joy now. Even more thrilling is when my kids tell me things I did with them that I thought at the time was nutty and they loved. More, I get choked up when they thank me for choosing a career at home with them over a career elsewhere for me.
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 10:46AM
Toni said...Barbara's question frustrates me a bit. Just because you stay home with your kids and parent them doesn't mean you don't have a career! Being a stay-at-home mom is a more-than-forty-hours-a-week job. Shame on Barbara for failing to recognize this!
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 10:48AM
chasesea said...To Alicia: Good for you...you don't want kids and aren't afraid to say so. And certainly smart enough not to have kids at 20. People need to mind their own f*****g business. It's a personal choice. I absolutely love babies but never wanted to be a mother either. At least I was honest as well, which is more than I can say for a lot of women who have them and then treat them badly, neglect or abuse them or even murder them (because it's hard work and have decided they don't want them anymore...Casey Anthony is a perfect example, and I hope she fries). I applaud mothers, but I knew it was not for me either, and whoever doesn't like my decision can bite me. It's not for everyone (like marriage....look at the divorce rate).
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 10:59AM
Nunzie said...I hope Rachel Duffy gets a chance to see my comment..........Yes you are SO lucky to have the opprtunity to stay home and have the hardest job raising your six children. I am a working mother of two with a carrer that most would look at to be so "exciting" and I have NO choice but to work due to my financial situation which was no fault but ours. I long everyday wishing that I could be home with my girls especially on a day like to today when I had to drop them off at daycare and give my caregiver a nebulizer to care for my baby. I hate every moment being away from them..... so YOU GO GIRL and enjoy the moments with your kids that you could never enjoy if you were working a "career" they approve of. Those catty bitches have nannies and are miserable regardless. By the way they hate the GOP. They demean women with that horrible show of old hens!
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 12:34PM
Dawn said...LOVED this article. Found it posted on someone else's blog. I am a mommy to 8 children and I wouldn't trade it for all the money, big career, etc. I take great pleasure in raising our children. Getting to know their personalities, being there for them when they need you, making meals for them, spending a lot of time with them. It isn't perfect. A lot of times it is messy- really messy! There is nothing I would rather do.
I think a lot of women would love it if they weren't almost bullied into careers because they "should" positions. I think deep down there are many times women just think "oh I could never do that" because it is truly hard work. I also know though from personal experience that the more you let yourself enjoy it. Kick the world's viewpoint out of your mind. The more you really love it.
Thank you for this post. :)
Reply
12-17-2010 @ 12:39PM
rick howard said...What WAWA meant was "validate what I chose".
Reply