Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Find Out What Beyonce Will Name Baby No. 2!
Teen Who Died During Her First Solo Drive May Have Been Texting
Switzerland Debates Legalizing Incest
Filed under: Relatives, In The News, Sex
Will incest become legal in Switzerland? Credit: Fabrice Coffrini, AFP/Getty Images
Swiss parliament may be giving a new meaning to the term "brotherly love." They have drafted a law that would repeal incest laws so that family members could have sex, if they so pleased.
Some claim incest laws are obsolete because there have only been three cases in the past three decades, The Telegraph reports.
Daniel Visher, a Green Party MP, is in favor of the law. "Incest is a difficult moral question, but not one that is answered by penal law," he told The Telegraph. Pun intended? We're not sure.
The Protestant People's Party and The Christian People's Party of Switzerland are on the opposite side, claiming incest should remain punishable. Who ever said Switzerland was neutral?
A spokesperson for The Protestant People's Party points out the obvious, "Murder is also quite rare in Switzerland but no one suggests that we remove that as an office from the statutes."











ReaderComments (Page 2 of 3)
12-20-2010 @ 4:36PM
scottvtm said...Incest and pedaphilia will both be legal and acceptable in a generation or less. Both marrige and DADT will have to include these two alternative lifesyles. Don't believe it? I do.. I've seen it happen... and so have you.
Reply
1-19-2011 @ 1:11PM
Sanity said...Please tell us where and what you "have seen it happen"?
And please tell me how you bring this back to DADT?
And why do you conflate incest and homosexuality?
12-21-2010 @ 9:24PM
Hypocrisy said...Wait a second .. I get the impression that the great majority here deem incest to be unacceptable, while clearly the social trend is acceptance of an otherwise unnatural sexual appetite.
eg: Homosexuality as 'normal'
You cannot have it both ways~
Reply
1-11-2011 @ 3:34PM
Mike Smith said...You're confusing "normal" (a statistical evaluation) and "natural" (i.e. something that occurs in nature). Homosexuality is not "normal", but it *is* "natural"; it has been observed in nature, and outside the human species, as well. (Not that either of these criteria should have anything to do with whether it is legal or socially acceptable. It doesn't hurt anyone, as long as it's consensual, so I don't see the problem. The same goes for incest IMO - although I *personally* find the idea rather creepy, I don't see why it should be illegal - as long as coercion is not involved, or children who aren't ready or able to make such choices for themselves.)
12-22-2010 @ 3:33AM
CHERYL said...SWITZERLAND SHOULD REMOVE ITS CROSS FROM IT'S NATIONAL FLAG IF THEY PROMOTE INCEST RELATIONSHIPS. EVERYONE BOYCOTT SWITZERLAND AND REMOVE YOUR MONEY FROM SWISS BANKS ACCOUNTS....THE WHOLE WORLD SHOULD IGNORE THIS SICK COUNTRY
Reply
1-05-2011 @ 7:52PM
Tom said...Abhorrence of incest is a natural thing among humans and all primates. It is not about morals. It evolved by natural selection to avoid sexual inbreeding which causes disastrous physical abnormalities in offspring. Weakness is doomed in the struggle for survival. Brothers and sisters, raised apart may find each other years later and fall in love despite the instinctual taboo which would have been there had they been raised together. In fact there are non-siblings in Israel raised together in a kibbutz as close as siblings. Such kibbutz kids surprisingly do not marry each other as planned. Incest is instinctively taboo in primates and humans raised as siblings. Not to worry. Sibling marriage could usually only happen very rarely to brothers and sisters not raised together. They do not have the instinctive taboo though they might be told they should not consider marriage. Wouldn't it be up to them what to do especially in regard to the consequences of having offspring. The instinctual taboo among those raised as siblings would normally be to cause a sense of disgust at the very thought as illustrated here by many comments against incest. Nature's way of preventing feeble offspring. Never mind religion. Incest taboo predates religion. But without having offspring, one could argue that there is nothing physically harmful about love and sex between siblings. Socially would be a huge problem. Historically our families were often very tightly intermarried. There were indeed many genetic problems caused by cousins repeatedly marrying over generations within families. Regarding incestuous relations, we still have to protect against abusive domination in marriages such as marrying an under age child to an adult. A few societies do not acknowledge the rights of women and young girls in marriage. Sadly humans historically do what they think works best and then invent a religious authority to justify what they do. We humans seem to mollify our conscience by any moral excuse. For example, anyone can see that killing and eating a helpless creature is abhorrent to most of us. Would you personally dare to enter a slaughter house. Isn’t it a sad moment when the day comes you have to tell your modern child where chicken mac nuggets come from or hamburgers? We take the kids to church and proclaim that God made the animals for our pleasure. After all we wrote the Book, not the Cows. We then can kill living beings wantonly. It is slaughter true and true. Let's be honest. We usually do not face the reality of the steak in front of us. God made all things for us we believe. We kill, as in murder, as we may. Falling in love with a brother or sister is naturally very unlikely to ever happen. It is small stuff. Killing the calf child of a cow crying for mercy for her young happens by the hundreds of thousands every single day and makes no headlines. Not a stir. We have a wonderfully tender veal steak for our lunch. Ah humanity. We are evolving into a creature that will someday learn to weep as it says grace.
Reply
1-19-2011 @ 1:11PM
Sanity said...So eating meat, which we have done since before religion, is worse than corrupting our genetic pool via incest? Get some perspective. I do not believe an invisible, omnipotent god created us and gave us dominion over animals but your anthropomorphism is wacky. I really love the "killing the calf child" line. Made my day. Makes me want some veal tonight. Oh, I worked in a slaughter house in college.
1-05-2011 @ 12:04PM
craftyflair said...Incest is a taboo for the reasons deemed. Yet, it is a moral dillema for a child to be molested by a father, brother or other relative. And, this is punishable by law in the U.S.
One must think of the long range consequences of this unlawful act by a predator upon a young child. I would consider tightening the laws against incest. Presently, those charged with such a crime are let off more easily then if the child was m olested by a stranger.
Must be Switzerland has been lax in applying such laws and the result is to legalize incest. Outrageous!
Reply
1-10-2011 @ 6:25PM
Deuce said...Wow!
Bestiality, pedophilia and polygamy can’t be far behind.
This world has lost its moral compass.
Natural selection and religious dogma are one thing but, this should not even be debated where Mans law is concerned.
Reply
1-07-2011 @ 1:41PM
Oji said...Does this proposed law tend to exonerate for example, a mother who has abused her son sexually when a child from the criminal offences she has committed? Does this law consider the resultant mental devastations that have been caused by the abuse? What a horror!
Reply
5-13-2011 @ 1:47PM
ar said...The Swiss banned construction of minarets last year. Now they're considering legalizing incest. What a messed up system of values. It's so fashionable to be valueless/anti religion/pc that we're going to end with a new generation of hedonistic, sociopathic deliquents. Oh wait, that's already started...
Reply
1-11-2011 @ 11:17AM
RM said...People are being extreme. They are not legalizing pedophilia, which is abuse of a child by an adult. They are talking about legalizing incest, sex between two consenting adults who are somehow related.
Reply
1-11-2011 @ 2:51PM
Sophie said...Wow... so many comments on how terrible this law would be for kids, even though it only applies to adults. People should read links before they launch into tirades against something which doesn't exist.
Adults. Sounds sick, but who cares? And for those raising religious arguments, you need to read the Bible, particularly Leviticus 18 and 20, and Deuteronomy. It allows, for example, for a man to marry his niece, his half sister on his mother's side, or (although it seems to be deemed undesirable) even his own daughter. Lot's daughters get their dad drunk and have children by him (Genesis 19), yet they all seem to have God's approval.
It's only about consenting adults. Get over it already.
Reply
2-17-2011 @ 2:34PM
sam said...Don't try to spew biblical wisdom when it's not. If you'll recall, Lot was the guy who had to be dragged out of SODOM AND GOMORRAH by angels. . . cuz he wouldn't leave! Remember, Lot is the same guy who offered HIS DAUGHTERS to the homosexuals when they demanded he give up his visitors. Remember, Lot is the guy whose wife loved that life so much she yearned to go back EVEN as it was being destroyed. . . All of them were consenting adults. It is hilarious that the term "consenting adults" automatically gives people permission to do all kinds of things to others with no regard for the fallout.
1-15-2011 @ 4:01PM
charles said...its nobodies buisness, esspecialy the governments what two concenting ppl do with eacthother. Im not allowed to tell anyone they cant be gay, i also cant tell anyone they cant have an incestual relationship. People lets all step out of out christian values world and start living in a free one. We can decide for ourselves what is right for ourselves
Reply
1-16-2011 @ 6:55PM
benjikid said...Are these lawmakers nuts?
Reply
1-16-2011 @ 3:58PM
nikki said...these people are crazy !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i was raped by my biological father till he died a week after kennedy !!!!!!!!!!!! it was a blessing but ruined my life. i am 54 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply
1-16-2011 @ 7:06PM
benjikid said...The mountains that surround the Swiss from the rest of the world makes me think these people haven't come out of the earths womb yet. But they are a cold people who have banks and great acocuntants. Especially hiding super rich people money. They took any jewels, gold and money while the nazis were devouring europe. Incest legal? Maybe the nuetral Swiss deserve this horrid law ...God forbid! Incest is immoral whether secular or religious. Incest is an abomination ...Is Switzerland a a BOMB in nation"?
Reply
1-20-2011 @ 9:24AM
ADCOW said...Look guys if a mother fancies a bit of her son or a daughter wants her father to deflower herest, as long as the ADULTS agree and I did say agree well so be it. at least they have each other.
I think that it is a perfectly acceptable thing to do, as regards the
Darwinian attitude that animals do not mate with their offspring
well we can use birth control
Reply
1-27-2011 @ 10:45AM
Swiss said...I'm from Switzerland and am Swiss and I never heard about this non-sense.
Reply