Hot on HuffPost Parents:
WATCH: 12-Year-Old Piano Prodigy Uses His Music As Medicine
Breaking The Paternity Leave Barrier: The Rest Of The Story

Toxic Christmas? Nope
"Children don't ask Santa for a dose of lead in their stockings," begins this article in USA Today, "but consumer advocates say that lead, a potent neurotoxin, is present in a surprising number of everyday products, including Christmas decorations."
Yikes! So our kids are going to get lead poisoning from the decorations now -- not just from gnawing the toys from China?
The article talks about Christmas lights, artificial trees and candles, suggesting they could cause little things like, oh, brain damage. Which is weird because most Americans celebrate Christmas, and (if you don't count Congress) their brains are still working. So let's tackle the "toxins" one by one:
1. Christmas tree lights: The wires of these lights are insulated by plastic and that plastic contains polyvinyl chloride (PVC), which has some lead in it. The article suggests that "families who aren't able to buy new [hard-to-find, rare, non-PVC] lights should wear gloves when handling their old lights."
Gloves? As if it's not impossible to untangle Christmas lights already?
Gloves might make sense if the plastic is crumbling, and you planned to rub it on your fingers and then furiously suck on them. (Mmm!) But otherwise the danger is nil, says Terri Bowers, a scientist at the environmental consulting firm Gradient, where her specialty is lead. Lead does not enter the body through the skin, so you have to eat it for it to have any effect.
P.S. By the time your wire is crumbling, those lights are dangerous for another reason. Think.
2. Artificial Christmas trees: Fake trees are also rife with PVC, which, once again, poses no threat to kids unless they plan to chomp those spiky needles. "PVC is completely safe. It has been tested for over 50 years and there's no evidence that it is harmful," says Elizabeth Whelan, founder of the American Council on Science and Health, who holds a Doctor of Science from Harvard.
3. Candles: "Lead can also show up in candles, such as those with stiff metal wicks," according to USA Today. "Lighting candles can allow lead to vaporize, so that people breathe it in ... Lead is toxic to a baby's brain at any dose ..." The article suggests that if you MUST buy candles, buy the pure beeswax ones.
Can it be true that candles -- humankind's light source for thousands of years -- mangle the mind?
"People burn candles in their homes every day," says Christie Sayes, a professor of toxicology at Texas A&M University. Candles are just one of the myriad pollutants we're exposed to daily. To suddenly single them out as a danger doesn't make much sense.
For her part, Sayes has an artificial tree at home -- and second graders. Is she, a toxicologist, worried about them getting lead poisoning?
"It didn't even cross my mind."
Does she light candles when her kids are around?
"Yes."
And while she doesn't happen to string up Christmas lights, she says, "if I would, I wouldn't use gloves."
Me neither. Have a safe and non-toxic Christmas!
(Which looks exactly like all your old, non-toxic Christmases, complete with fake tree, lights and candles.)
Yikes! So our kids are going to get lead poisoning from the decorations now -- not just from gnawing the toys from China?
The article talks about Christmas lights, artificial trees and candles, suggesting they could cause little things like, oh, brain damage. Which is weird because most Americans celebrate Christmas, and (if you don't count Congress) their brains are still working. So let's tackle the "toxins" one by one:
1. Christmas tree lights: The wires of these lights are insulated by plastic and that plastic contains polyvinyl chloride (PVC), which has some lead in it. The article suggests that "families who aren't able to buy new [hard-to-find, rare, non-PVC] lights should wear gloves when handling their old lights."
Gloves? As if it's not impossible to untangle Christmas lights already?
Gloves might make sense if the plastic is crumbling, and you planned to rub it on your fingers and then furiously suck on them. (Mmm!) But otherwise the danger is nil, says Terri Bowers, a scientist at the environmental consulting firm Gradient, where her specialty is lead. Lead does not enter the body through the skin, so you have to eat it for it to have any effect.
P.S. By the time your wire is crumbling, those lights are dangerous for another reason. Think.
2. Artificial Christmas trees: Fake trees are also rife with PVC, which, once again, poses no threat to kids unless they plan to chomp those spiky needles. "PVC is completely safe. It has been tested for over 50 years and there's no evidence that it is harmful," says Elizabeth Whelan, founder of the American Council on Science and Health, who holds a Doctor of Science from Harvard.
3. Candles: "Lead can also show up in candles, such as those with stiff metal wicks," according to USA Today. "Lighting candles can allow lead to vaporize, so that people breathe it in ... Lead is toxic to a baby's brain at any dose ..." The article suggests that if you MUST buy candles, buy the pure beeswax ones.
Can it be true that candles -- humankind's light source for thousands of years -- mangle the mind?
"People burn candles in their homes every day," says Christie Sayes, a professor of toxicology at Texas A&M University. Candles are just one of the myriad pollutants we're exposed to daily. To suddenly single them out as a danger doesn't make much sense.
For her part, Sayes has an artificial tree at home -- and second graders. Is she, a toxicologist, worried about them getting lead poisoning?
"It didn't even cross my mind."
Does she light candles when her kids are around?
"Yes."
And while she doesn't happen to string up Christmas lights, she says, "if I would, I wouldn't use gloves."
Me neither. Have a safe and non-toxic Christmas!
(Which looks exactly like all your old, non-toxic Christmases, complete with fake tree, lights and candles.)











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
12-20-2010 @ 2:18PM
Alicia said...USA Today must be desperate for headlines and panic, if they're publishing shite like that.
Reply
12-20-2010 @ 4:23PM
Arjen Lentz said...And a happy winter solstice to you too, today!
I don't like PVC for another reason though: when discarded it's essentially chemical waste that doesn't decompose easily; and when it does, the chlorine causes trouble in the environment. It's also unnecessary to use these days as there are good (bio-degradable) alternatives like PP and PE and other options.
I'm not fussed if my daughter handles something that contains PVC. I just tend to avoid buying stuff that has it, but for the above reason not for fear of her chewing it!
Reply
12-20-2010 @ 5:49PM
brainfan said...""PVC is completely safe. It has been tested for over 50 years and there's no evidence that it is harmful," says Elizabeth Whelan, founder of the American Council on Science and Health, who holds a Doctor of Science from Harvard."
Elizabeth Whelan's idea of "testing for 50 years" is "because we've been using it for 50 years that means it's okay." They used to think the same thing about radioactive substances: people used to drink it because they thought it was healthy.
Then in steps science, catching up with technology. Science exposes these products as dangerous, but companies are used to the profits and they don't want to lose them, never mind risk asbestos style lawsuits (did I say asbestos? Elizabeth Whelan opposed removing asbestos from schools.).
So what do these profit-seeking companies do? In steps Elizabeth Whelan and her American Council on Science and Health. For a fee, (yes, her organization is funding by the companies that manufacture things like PVC) her organization will give you a clean bill of health. No, she's not a medical doctor, but she hired one! -- after he got out of jail for fraud.
As for you toxicologist friend, I can't help you. There are plenty who have taken a look at the health problems that are ravaging our country and realizing that it is their field that has dropped the ball.
Go ahead and listen to Elizabeth, who makes over $300,000 a year to say the things she says. If you care about your children, you may want to investigate what the other side has to say.
Reply