Hot on HuffPost Parents:
WATCH: 12-Year-Old Piano Prodigy Uses His Music As Medicine
Breaking The Paternity Leave Barrier: The Rest Of The Story
Opinion: Kids Feeling Peer Pressure? Sorry, Your One-Liners Aren't Going to Help
Filed under: Opinions
Forget being individuals. Kids just want to belong. Illustration by Dori Hartley
Take, for example, the classic and beloved, "Because I said so." No room for argument there. Or, every kid's favorite, "Don't talk back." Another classic: "I'm going to count to three."
As parents, we employ these powerful word constructs as often as required to both console and control.
But, ask yourself this: In the history of the world, have any of these one-liners ever actually worked?
No. In fact, kids can't stand it when they hear this stuff.
Of course, every parent is bound to experience a day when our child leaves school all gloomy and dejected-looking. You know the scene: You've just picked up your precious bundle and she slumps way down into the car seat next to you. Between her deflated body language and pouty puss, you dare to ask, "Hey, what's up?"
After a series of mouth twists and moody little gestures, you finally glean that she experienced something hurtful and she admits someone made fun of her or expressed some sort of public disapproval in front of her peers.
Usually, kids come down on other kids because of appearance, but peer pressure's nasty spokesperson could just as easily condemn and ridicule something as mundane as the contents of a lunchbox. As a parent, all you know is your baby is hurting, and you don't like it one little bit.
So, what do you do? Why, you pull out "The Advanced Parental Bag of Indisputable One-Liners: Peer Pressure Edition" and hit her with the big one: "Who cares what those kids think?" It's a line that pairs well with, "It only matters what you think" or "They're probably just jealous, anyway."
But why stop there, when, "Don't let them get to you, kid" nicely tidies up the entire self-esteem package?
Sure, the intention behind the words may soothe, but aren't these cliché catchphrases really just a vehicle for your love and concern? As rich in truth as these words of wisdom may be, they're void of meaning unless whomever they're meant for is some exalted being who can instantly assimilate the wisdom and turn it into action. Not. Happening.
The truth is, our kids do care what other kids think. They don't relate to being objects of jealousy (because they don't believe it) and they do let the words and opinions of other children get to them. Kids fall prey to peer pressure and no amount of pep-talking one-liners can organically move children from point A to point B without them processing it on their own, first.
Now, I've always been a freaky individualist. But that doesn't mean my child is willing to fly her freak flag right up there beside mine. She's already let me know she is not comforted when I tell her to be proud of her individuality -- because she wants to be part of the group.
For her and her fellow 12-year-olds, it's cool to be yourself, as long as you don't stick out too much. For kids, being different equals being isolated, and, at this stage in their social progress, isolation isn't part of the deal. Kids don't want to be special amongst their peers; they want to belong.
So, when my child fights for her right to blend in, why should I feel it's my duty to sway her into believing she's better off being an isolated individual? Must excellence always come by means of parental pressure? Between trying to fit in with their peers and the constant push at home to excel, be proud and stand tall, what kids really need is half a minute to figure some of it out on their own.
Can we not assume for one moment that, just as they eventually accepted the toilet over the diaper, excellence and individuality may be something kids will come to know on their own terms, and at the right time?
So, when my daughter gets in the car with the sad-puppy face and tells me so-and-so hates her, or that she doesn't feel pretty enough, I resist the urge to hit her with my one-liner, "Oh honey, who cares what they say?"
Instead, with consideration and respect for her feelings, I console her by saying, "Hmm, yeah. Well, hopefully that'll work itself out soon, right?" Her feelings are validated and the message I'm sending is, "Yeah, I hear ya," as opposed to, "Get over yourself and see things my way."
We want our kids to be perfect living examples of self-esteem, courage, intelligence and beauty. But ask kids what they want to be, and, more than likely, they'll tell you they just want to be kids.
Just like the other kids.
Remember, children are not short 40-year-olds. They haven't figured out yet that their individuality is inevitable. We can't force them into accepting their uniqueness by using quick, positive one-liners only adults can relate to. The only way they'll ever know what it's like to break away from the pack is by knowing what a pack is, in the first place.
And how do I know this is true? Because I said so.
Want to get the latest ParentDish news and advice? Sign up for our newsletter!











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
1-22-2011 @ 7:11AM
zap said...Follow The Crowd To Nowhere. Set Your Own Pace. Follow Your Gut Instints, And The Most Important. If Your Going To Be STUPID, You Better Be Tough.
Reply
1-22-2011 @ 9:48AM
Harry Hurt said...If I had a kid who was mistreated by the other kids, I would first ask "but what did you do to them?" If I determined that it was the other kid's fault, I would hunt down that kid and make him rue the day. Then, if this happened at school, I would bang my fist on the principal's desk and demand where school authorities were at the time. Teachers are sometimes very poor disciplinarians. Schools need to grab the bull by the horns and put a stop to bullying. Come down on the bully's parents. Too frequently, the child in the wrong gets away with things scott free, when what they need is a swift paddle to their asses.
Reply
1-22-2011 @ 12:45PM
SunbirdSE said...AMEN Harry! I wholeheartedly agree with you! I was bullied as a kid and my father was a teacher! He didn't do 1 thing to stop the bullying, and it continued until I finally got out of that freaking school. He was a pathetic excuse for a parent.
1-22-2011 @ 2:09PM
Tom Kelly said...Bravo to you, Harry, for sticking up for your child. I think that's the very best way to show your kid that he or she lives in a world of safety and strength. I was with my neice at a McDonald's Playland area (okay, okay...an occasional treat). A big bully in the ball area kept thowing balls at her...hard! When I saw that, I shot out of my seat, told him to knock it off, and then marched into the store, got the manager, dragged him out there and pointed out the kid like a rabid storm trooper. The kid, according to the sign, was way too big to be in there anyway. I cared not a whit what anyone thought of me.
What stunned me was my niece's reaction. She looked into space for a moment (what she did when processing something), then turned to me, spread her arms wide and said in a strong voice," I'm the strongest girl in the whole, wide world!"
"Stunned" is not a strong enough word for the happiness and love I felt at that glorious moment. That she knew I had her back was the best therapy "in the whole, wide world."
Of course, if My Little Darling had been the little bully, my reaction would have been quite different...of course!
1-22-2011 @ 1:20PM
Annbee said...Hi HealthScience.com:
Thank you for sharing the info on "Opinion: Kids feeling peer pressure."
It was a great learning tool for me. I will use this info in my daily life in the future with one change.
I want to use your suggestions for myself as a person who is female, 56 years of age, was a C student in school. Managed to work for 32 years for a bank before economy issues began and I was eliminated from the bank which led to unemployment. I have been able to gain employment once again.
The issues I face: Learning by reading. I seem to understand better by visual aide. When my manager is speaking to me, I seem to digest and retain the info better by closing my eyes and allowing my hearing to take over. Trying to remember is tough. It is so important for me to take notes.
My greatest asset is "I refuse to give up" I will work on an issue till I get it right. But deep in side my self, I struggle with self worth and self satisfaction.
I look forward to any positive suggestions you can give me.
Sincerely,
Ann
Reply
1-22-2011 @ 12:45PM
Glenn Posner said...Simply don't have children in the first place...problem solved.
Reply
1-23-2011 @ 12:08AM
isisreptiles said...This is actually one of my many reasons for opting to not have children. Living through this stuff as a child/teen was horrible. I had no desire to re-live it through a child I might have.
1-22-2011 @ 12:46PM
WendyC said...I got seriously sick of snappy little one liners by the time I was 10, and I'm now 40 and working on a novel about how stupid one liners are. I honesly thought adults and older teens were retarded when they gave me those snappy little platitudes. How lazy and helpless can you be?? Get real! Give "the long answer!" That means, really delve into the problem and talk about it, explain the possible motivations of the other kids, and certainly condemn the hurtful behavior. Say "how dare they" or "what rotten kids" or show a little outrage sometimes, huhn? And I at least partly agree with what Harry Hurt says above.
Reply
1-22-2011 @ 3:14PM
isisreptiles said...Giving some stupid platitude to a hurting child is the worst thing you can do. It invalidates the child's feelings. Same with asking the child what s/he did to cause the behavior. That's blaming the victim. I know from experience as I was bullied and tormented all through school. I either got the stupid platitudes or was blamed for what had been done to me. The only thing that did was to make me feel even worse, and made me very angry to have my feelings so trivialized.
What I really wanted was to have my feelings acknowledged and validated, and to have the bullies' actions condemned as wrong. It wouldn't have changed the situation but I would have at least felt supported.
And then parents wonder why their kids won't open up to them...
1-22-2011 @ 3:21PM
colleen said...I agree with the "long answer" and speaking authentically to your children. To the writer I have to ask you, honestly???? If your daughter says she "doesn't feel pretty enough" your reply would be "yeah, hmmm, I hope that works itself out soon" ??? Really?? I would rather hear my mom tell me that I was the most beautiful girl in the world and to forget what others think. At least with that line I always knew that my mom was in my corner and my #1 champion. Even if I didn't think she saw me quite as clearly as others did. God Bless my mother!
1-23-2011 @ 1:30AM
Alicia said...Hahaha I just pretty much said the same thing to my best friend, specifically about "because I said so."
"I swear to god, if I ever magically have kids and I pull that "because I said so" crap in front of you, beat me with a fire iron and take the children out for ice cream because that is still the most patronizing pile of steaming emu shit ever spoken"
1-29-2011 @ 7:42AM
Harry Hurt said...Steaming emu shit? HA HA HA HA!!!!! Alicia, you're an original!
Reply