Students Cruising Through College With Little Asked of Them, Little Learned, Book Says
Filed under: In The News, Research Reveals: Teens
That diploma won't mean much if your college student skips on the studying. Credit: Getty
For a long time, educators have focused on the crisis of overcrowded classrooms and unmotivated kids in primary and secondary schools, but now, author Richard Arum argues in "Academically Adrift: Limited Learning on College Campuses," the downward trend in learning is rampant in colleges and universities, too, Salon.com reports.
Arum, a sociology and education professor at New York University, co-authored the book with University of Virginia sociology professor Josipa Roksa.
Growing numbers of undergraduates are moving through college without working particularly hard, and without key learning skills, such as complex reasoning and critical thinking, Arum tells Salon.com. He says his research is based on the Collegiate Learning Assessment, a standardized test, as well as transcripts and self-reports from students.
The data is supported across the board at universities, research institutions, liberal arts colleges and even highly selective schools, and, Arum tells the site, although colleges and universities are doing lots of great things today, they're not focused on educating students.
"We also argue that large numbers of students today are moving through college and university academically adrift," he tells Salon.com. "They end up with college degrees that have too little substance to them, because they've been able to identify pathways through college that have asked very little of them academically."
Fueling the trend, Arum tells the site, is a long-standing tradition of some students going through college with little asked of them and little learned.
"Nothing is new about that," he says. "However, there is significant evidence out there that something has changed in terms of the academic rigor and student workload."
Full-time college students spend 50 percent less time studying than they did several decades ago, Arum tells Salon.com.
"We also know that, in terms of grades, students expect to receive higher grades and do receive higher grades in spite of less effort," he adds.
The consequences? College graduates will not have developed the "higher order" skills -- critical thinking, complex reasoning and the ability to communicate in writing -- skills needed in today's labor market, Arum tells Salon.com.
"If you haven't, you're going to be at a lifelong disadvantage in the economy," he tells the site. "Equally or more troubling, if you're graduating large numbers of kids that have not developed critical thinking and complex reasoning, how are they going to function as democratic citizens?"
Want to get the latest ParentDish news and advice? Sign up for our newsletter!
Your<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS AS TO THE ANSWER BY DEFENDANTS ______________________________. Plaintiff, ________________________ h...
- Alot of .gov when submitting a program or proposal for government agency (be sure you personally can provide for the agency)
- What is the TFI ORGANIZATION IN KS?











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
2-10-2011 @ 5:09PM
Alicia said...I'll agree with that. My college tries to promote these skills, but the classes and programs they have in place are worthless unless you have a fantastic teacher that challenges students (I have been lucky enough to have been blessed with many such. The work is more difficult, but I actively seek them out because it's worthwhile). Even so, I just got back from studying abroad and after a challenging, fulfilling semester in Ireland in lecture and discussion-based courses that put my ability to analyze and make an informed argument to the test, I'm bored. Of my six courses, only half are of any interest and only one is actually challenging, but it's a self-marketing and portfolio-building course meant to give us professional experience rather than a class meant to teach us facts. Bored students will party instead of work because, hey, what motivation have I to work if it's valueless? Its disappointing and a waste of money and I hope for a better selection of classes next semester and the following, because if I spend another year like I'm sending this semester, I will have wasted my money to get a piece of paper that, yeah, may mean something to my future employer but it means shit to me.
Reply
2-10-2011 @ 6:55PM
Coop said...Not to mention that many so-called "universities" and "colleges" are really nothing more than degree mills. Pay your money for 4 years and they'll give you a very nice, suitable-for-framing that isn't worth the paper (not even sheepskin) it's printed on. Brought to you by the No Child Left Behind program which assumes that every child is capable of entering and completing a meaningful post-secondary educational course of study. Since not every child actually does have the brainpower to pull that off, at least some colleges have had to water things down a bit.
Reply
2-16-2011 @ 11:33AM
mary said...Too many college professors today are not teachers. They either don't know how or just don't want to bother. They are the ones who brag about how hard and "rigorous" their classes are when they are just loading on busy work (i.e. calculus classes that require 150 problems each night, or the Econ prof who makes an intro class so hard that econ majors have difficulty passing, or the math prof who fails 98% of the class). Those people are just pushing their egos. They need to be reviewed. At the same time students need to have goals, employment goals and learning goals.
Reply