Mean Girls Mellow With Age (Except on TV)
Filed under: Tween Culture, Teen Culture
A high school mean girl can become a decent adult. Credit: Michael Gibson, AP Photo/Paramount Pictures
Turns out in real life, queen bees who thrived on belittling and tormenting their wannabe peers in high school can grow up to be decent human beings, according to the Washington Post.
Of course that's if they're not tapping into their inner mean girl to act like an immature high schooler on TV, or acting like a nihilistic cheerleader and running for public office, Rosalind Wiseman, author of "Queen Bees and Wannabes" and an expert on teen and young adult behavior. Wiseman's book was the basis for the 2004 movie "Mean Girls," Newsweek reports.
"In our culture," Wiseman tells Newsweek, "we get rewarded for mean-girl behavior, so we see adults behaving in ways that we typically assign to teens ... Getting attention is the most important thing."
But, in real-life mean girls do mature and chill out eventually, according to the Post.
In fact, to assume that all women exhibit mean girl behavior is the meanest cut of all, Jess Weiner, author and columnist for Seventeen magazine, tells the Post, saying she knows firsthand.
Weiner says that, as a large girl in middle school, she was bullied repeatedly. But at age 28, when she appeared on "Oprah" for her book, "A Very Hungry Girl," she received an e-mail from her former tormenter apologizing. The woman wrote that her parents were divorcing at the time and that her mother's boyfriend was molesting her, Weiner tells the Post.
"Her apology freed me to realize that we all suffer in those adolescent years," Weiner tells the Post. "No one leaves that period of time unscathed. But we can learn and grow from it and move on to lead engaged, loving, productive lives."
Evidence that mean girls mellow with age also can be found in a new study, which finds that the percentage of girls who bullied declines from grades 9 through 12, according to the latest Youth Risk Behavior survey, which was published in 2009 by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Same thing happens in college, according to researcher Rebecca Goldberg, an assistant professor of clinical mental health counseling at Mississippi State University. In 2008, she interviewed 202 female undergraduates on what is called "relational aggression." She reports in her dissertation that freshmen were the most aggressive, seniors the least. Several seniors, she tells the Post, "looked back four years and said, 'Oh, I was a terrible brat back then.' "
Want to get the latest ParentDish news and advice? Sign up for our newsletter!











ReaderComments (Page 2 of 2)
2-18-2011 @ 5:53PM
Patricia said...Whats sad is why they ever got to be that way in the first place.. Where were the parents? I remember there was a girl like that in high school...She ended up getting her butt kick...She wasn't so mean after that...hummmm
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 6:22PM
sparrow said...Okay, confession time. There was a girl in my grade school who I picked on all the time. I was very mean to her, and I have regretted it for years. I was beastly to her and I am very sorry for it. If I knew where she is today I would apologize to her. I sincerely hope that my behavior did not have any lasting effects on her. I am an adult now and I am far from mean. Kids can be rotten. I don't think I'm the only one, and I would guess that if you all examined your childhoods closely, many of you would come up with you own examples of mean behavior.
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 6:56PM
Alicia said...I kind of agree with you. I was always the picked on because I was a bookworm as young as first grade, but my third grade bully became my eighth grade friend. People do grow up. However, I think high school and college girls often stay mean girls. I haven't seen any improvement in some of the girls I run into that I graduated HS with and it's been three years.
2-20-2011 @ 3:27PM
Elizabeth Bennett said...I am glad to see someone express remorse over abusing their peers. However, I can assure you that these girls grow worse. They are more subtle in how they abuse each other as adults. Some DO outgrow it but some do NOT. Psychology is highly subjective and not one shoe fits all.
I am glad to see you speak out. I wish more reformed bullies did the same thing....
2-18-2011 @ 6:27PM
jana said...Mean girls simply become mean women. The girls who bullied my daughter have mothers who behave the same way. The majority of people really do not change that much - some do, but most do not.
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 6:46PM
Jabawaba said...Once a bitch, always a bitch !!!
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 7:37PM
melaina said...After teaching secondary school for over 20 years & my own occasional run-ins with bullies (male & female) in school-Ive learned that there is a percentage of "mean" people in our population. I was never mean in school & often felt sorry for the underdogs-I'm still the same as an adult & teacher. I tell my students the truth-there are just some people who are mean-you will always encounter them-we must learn to deal with them-whether they are 12 or 80! I'm sorry but too many people cut slack for a mean kid-don't- Ive spent hours in classrooms with these types-luckily only 1-2 a year-I see them as people who are very uncool and "betcha" they will be 20 years from now too!
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 7:40PM
beadlady said...Mean girls are in the corporate offices as well. They bulldoze male co-workers under the cover of being an "assertive Type A" employee. Female co-workers either become subservient or destroyed. Mean girls don't change.
Reply
2-19-2011 @ 8:07AM
jojo said...Some people never grow-up, therefore, they never grow out of it!
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 7:59PM
LAB said...I agree that Sarah Palin is a prime example of what a "mean girl" is. She exhibits the same attitude and vindictiveness that they did as kids. What causes that is beyond comprehension except maybe for a weakness of their moral character. SP shows nothing to be proud of. GW had the same mean spirit as a spoiled rich kid would have had. I knew many of them in school.
Reply
2-21-2011 @ 1:21PM
Terresa Portal said...I know first hand that some mean girls mellow with age but others just get worse. It's not only girls behaving like attention seeking brats. Men do it too. I have been the target of workplace bullying for months and it's both men and women doing it to me. I am seeking legal counsell to take action and make it stop.
Reply