Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Bonnie Fuller: Zach Sobiech: You Were a Huge Inspiration in Your…
When A Tornado Strikes, Should Schools Evacuate?
Study: Working Mothers Have One More Reason to Feel Guilty
Filed under: Work Life, In The News
The children of working mothers are apparently at greater risk of health problems. Credit: Corbis
This just in: Working mothers are the leading cause of male pattern baldness.
No, not really.
But they might as well be. It seems they are responsible for just about every ill that besets humanity. They can't catch a break. Just this month, ParentDish reported on how working mothers supposedly have more fat kids.
Now a new study is adding another leg to the guilt trip. The children of working mothers are apparently at greater risk of health problems.
The Kansas City Star reports researchers from North Carolina State University just had to bum working mothers out by finding that their kids have a 200 percent greater risk of overnight hospital stays, asthma episodes, injuries and poisonings.
"Maternal employment imposes a burden on a mother's time and may result in the poorer supervision or care of her children," writes Dr. Melinda Morrill, the North Carolina economics professor who led the study. "A child's health is at least partially a function of time-intensive activities such as healthy meal preparation and house cleaning."
Another risk: Increasing smugness among stay-at-home moms.
Morrill acknowledges that, telling the Kansas City Star she worries about toxic smug levels and warns people not to make sweeping generalizations about working mothers.
And we all know working mothers don't sweep all that much. Oops. Sorry, generalization.
Morrill and her team looked at 89,000 kids ages 7 to 17 and examined 20 years of data from the federal National Health Interview Survey.
The Star reports that her conclusions fly in the face of previous studies, which concluded that the children of working mothers are actually healthier because their families have more money for health care and because their moms feel good about themselves.
Well, they did until Morrill's study came along anyway.
Morrill tells the Kansas City Star the previous studies confused causes with effects. They overlooked the fact that some mothers can't work outside the home because their kids have special needs or chronic health problems, she says.
She adds that decisions to work or stay home are based on complex sets of variables. Only one thing is certain. Working mothers are evil -- eeeeevil!
Actually, Morrill tells the Star, that's the wrong message to take away from the study.
"A mother's decision to work could reflect underlying (and unobserved) ability, skills or preferences, so that a mother that works may be different in important ways from a mother that does not work," she writes in the study.
Want to get the latest ParentDish news and advice? Sign up for our newsletter!











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 3)
2-18-2011 @ 2:19PM
abbyj said...Just a kind reminder: women who have children work "in" the home or "out" of the home, but all women with children work. EVERY mother is a working woman. When I hear people say,"My mother never worked, I want to howl at the moon." It's the hardest work any human being will ever do.
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 2:40PM
Susan said...Oh you said exactly what I was thinking. A mother ALWAYS works......and it isn't easy. And a mother who works outside the home works twice as hard as any man, if that man doesn't help with household chores and child rearing.
Another point, I think, most women who do work outside the home do it because of the need for extra income.
2-18-2011 @ 11:13PM
Lia said...After my first child was born I really didn't want to go back to work and have my baby spend a good part of her day in day care. The problem was that we needed my income to pay the bills. I kept looking for a way out until a friend of mine told me that she found a way a to make a nice income from home . She told me that she found out about it at this website ( HttP://bit.LY/MomsHomeIncome ) I was very skeptical but I figured that I had nothing to lose by checking it out. I ended up getting a great work-at-home situation and I not only make good money now but I get to spend most of my day doing what I love… being a mommy!
2-18-2011 @ 5:30PM
Robin9600 said...Could it be that working mothers are more likely to have private insurance, hence more likely to take their children to seek medical help? Could it be that these children with private insurance, and in some cases double coverage thanks to two working parents, will more likely be admitted because medical professionals will be confident that most any treatment they administer will be payed for? Just a thought.
2-18-2011 @ 6:39PM
Kookie said...Well said. Mothers who stay home have no lunch breaks, no one to gossip with, no pat on the back. Their work is never done.
2-18-2011 @ 6:40PM
david said...I was a single dad for 5 years before remarrying. it is very hard and it is natural that our kids would suffer compared to normal families. but please don't think women are the only ones doing this. i worked 65 hours a week in contruction and took care of my home. very few women come close to that.
2-18-2011 @ 11:55PM
Cognitogrrl said...I agree, it seems ridiculous to say "Working Mother" in this day and age AND economic times.
Gotta wonder, who funded this study at the U of North Carolina ECONOMICS dept? I'd tend to believe it if a psychology dept or medical school did such a study, but this REEKS of some elitist group saying, "Here's $$$ so you can go find data that says what we want it to." Article said they took "20 years of data" from federal National Health Interview Survey. Never heard of that in my life, and wonder who's behind it?
I went thru all the formats when my children were small -- full time job outside the home, stay home mom for 2 years, and then part time job outside home. NEVER had a kid spend an overnight stay in hospital until our older child was in junior high.
2-18-2011 @ 2:25PM
laxauntsc said...who coes up with nonsense?? I mean really! By the way, where the heck are the dads? why is burden of child care the only responsability of mothers? don't both parents make the kid in the first place? AOL you make me sick with all you mother and woman bashing this is why women are so stressed out and are kept opressed. It is articles like this and all the judgments and reqirements placed on women from both sides of the fence I say to all go JUMP OFF A CLIFF they only thing that has destroyed our kids is all the media crap and Dr. spock's book of taking the rights of parents wasy to punish thier kids. Oh so just because mom was working johny broke his arm from climbing in the tree OH PALEEESSSEE maybe all the moms who stay home are responsible for the out of control obesity in our kids casue the never let them go outside and play they tell them to watch tv and play video or computer games so to all moms your damned if you do and damned if you do so do what is right for you and your family
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 3:40PM
Lauren Brown said...I agree with you. A stay at home mom can easily be to blame for unhealthy or smothered kids. I can't believe this article has any kind of support behind it. Complete nonsense. A working mother can raise healthy children just as a stay at home mother, it depends on the values of the family.
2-19-2011 @ 1:05PM
Melissa said...I kinda thought the writer of this article was making fun of the study. Maybe I read it wrong. But I did stay home and had an in-house day care so I could stay home with my kids and bring in an income. They actually blossomed with this arrangement because they had other kids to play with but still had Mom around. I eventually had to go to work to help pay the bills but I hated it. Now I'm a Realtor so I can stay home when needed and work when my husband is home. Of course, my kids are older now but I think they appreciate that someone is always around if needed.
2-18-2011 @ 2:32PM
lively said...Ok, so let me get this straight. Because I work, and my husband, who is disabled, stays home with the "kids" (two teenagers who don't need 24/7 supervision), my kids are going to be fat, unhealthy under achievers? How does that work?
And, by the way, Melinda Morrell better not have any kids, since she's a full time working college instructor...and if she doesn't have any kids, how can she even BEGIN to judge?
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 2:42PM
Sean said...Ooops, here comes the Female denial cries, guess what, as a working mom you are not a goddess, your are not being picked on and most of all you sure as hell are not better than anyone else! I was a single dad of a newborn till my son was 11 years old when I found another, and what I did was what I had to do, Raise my son the best I could, I am not special, I am no better that anyone else, I made mistakes, but I get the job done. I did however get to see what single parenting is all about, and you ladies think you are the shit and think there should be special attention given to you because you are a single parent, let me tell you something....BULLSHIT! I had it worse cause this country is set-up to give you ladies all the breaks you need. for me I got crap..And I did just fine... So shut up, and get off your high horse..and deal with it..your not special. do your job..and quit your crying.
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 3:17PM
just saying said...LOL, I am a 25 year old single mother to an 8 year old. Things are harder than anything I could imagine and I 100% agree with your comment. As women and men it is our choice to make the children and it is our responsibiity to take care of these children to the best of our abilities regardless of these "facts" stated above. In this society we have to thrive in order to allow our children to thrive. If you have to work or stay at home to ensure that then that is YOUR choice because YOU are trying to do what YOU think is best for YOUR child. If you believe you need praise for doing what you should be doing then maybe you are doing what you are doing not so much for your children but more for yourself. Which makes you the opposite of a good parent.
2-18-2011 @ 3:12PM
kristih333 said...I believe that stay at home moms are extremely valuable. My mother stayed at home, and we had a wonderful upbringing. However, I am sorry it is not work. My wife and I work variable schedules where one of us has to be home with the children for several days alone. It is a blessing and very rewarding. I would rather be at home any day than at work. Yes, it can be hard and lonely at times, but it is not work. Work is much more stressful. I do both, so this is just my opinion.
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 5:00PM
Pam J said...My mother did not work until my brother and I were in school, and then her work schedule had her home when we got home. We were lucky in that way and I wouldn't have traded it for anything. Part of the problem is that, in a two-parent home, they think they have to have a big house and two cars. So, of course, both parents have to work. Maybe in this economy that's not the norm. But if you have children, they are your responsibility. Whether it is the mother or the father who stays home, I think it is worth it's weight in gold. So I applaud you and your husband for working it out.
2-18-2011 @ 6:46PM
ginny said...I have "worked" at home and outside the home. If you do not believe being at home is work, you are clearly not running a household. I used to leave my three children off at school and sigh a deep sigh of relief. I would find solice in having a lunch hour and using the toilet by myself. I worked in an accounting office in a job that was routine and enjoyable. I decided to stay home with my three children (one of which is autistic). Best and hardest decision I had to make. I love my children immensly, but being home with them and volunteering in various capacities is far harder than my full time job could ever be. I feel that both types of working mothers contribute greatly to their families and society as a whole. Every mother works hard in the pursuit of a happy and healthy family. Every family has a unique set of needs and options. Stop this insane vitriol and begin having respect for all types of mothers.
3-14-2011 @ 3:41PM
kmomto4 said...Oh my goodness. I rarely get bent out of shape over comments but this one just hurts. Managing a household is so stressful and is definitely work. Granted, I homeschool 2 of my children so that adds a whole other dimension. However, managing a household and managing it well is very demanding. Intellectually stimulating, unfortunately no, but man does it feel like work! I don't have free time and I'm 'on the clock' from the moment I wake up. I have a daily struggle with feeling crushed under the weight of all I do and feeling like it is deemed worthless in our society.
2-18-2011 @ 2:49PM
Susan said...Melinda just dumped GRANT money down the bowl. Maybe we should applied for a Grant to prove her wrong. And I don't allow anyone to judge me. That is left to God only.
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 2:53PM
Katie said...I have been a working mom and a stay at home mom. We felt our children were responding better to my staying at home, so I stopped working outside the home for good. I work hard everyday and don't appreciate the tone of the article. I am in no way "smug" about staying at home. There are great working moms and crappy working moms. There are great stay at home moms and crappy stay at home moms. We need to band together as moms period and support one another rather than pick over the differences.
Reply
2-18-2011 @ 2:54PM
Susan said...WOW, I applaud you. Good for you and your child. But, I must say, I didn't see any women ranting here or on a high horse. Just stating some opinions. Also, didn't see any single women commenting. I myself was married 37 years and raised 5 children, who had children and they in turn have children. So, please calm down.....And again, you did a fine job. Keep up the good work.
Reply