Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Cory Silverberg: Science and Storytelling in Sex Education
Carrie Smith: Building a Family: Is Going Into Debt for In Vitro or…
Big Brother Is Watching You, so Get Your Butt to Class
Filed under: Education: Tweens, Education: Teens
Any kid who has more than six unexcused absences has to carry a Global Positioning System device about the size of a cell phone. Credit: Getty Images
Welcome to George Orwell Junior High.
Big Brother is not the only one watching you. All sorts of adults can track your every movement, thanks to GPS technology. So don't try any funny business, kid.
The Orange County Register reports officials at the Anaheim Union School District thought it would be cool to track seventh and eighth graders like rogue bears on "Wild Kingdom."
That way, they could keep the little sneaks from cutting class.
Any kid who has more than six unexcused absences has to carry a Global Positioning System device about the size of a cell phone. Yes, it would be more fun to strap it on their ankles or clamp it on their ears, but some people say that's just not nice.
One of them is Miller Sylvan, the regional director of AIM Truancy Solutions, the firm helping with the GPS program. "We don't want to criminalize the kids or have them wear any bracelet or something around their ankle that would stigmatize them," he tells the Orange County Register.
Whatever. The important thing is that the kids can be monitored while adults drum their fingers and murmur, "Eeexcellent."
The whole thing is very science fiction-y. Every school day starts with a call from a computer (let's call him "Hal") who reminds the student to get to school on time.
Then, five times a day, the student must enter a code that allows adults to monitor him. He must enter a code when he leaves for school, arrives at school, eats lunch and goes home as well as a final check in at 8 p.m.
Failure to check in results in him being captured by a giant bubble and returned to the Village. Just kidding. That's another science fiction reference. School officials have not gone that far. Yet.
Students do get someone to watch over them, however. They get assigned an adult overlord (or "coach") who calls them three times a week to reportedly see how they're doing and help them find effective ways to get to class on time.
While there are no bubbles involved, the disobedient do risk a trip to juvie.
Hopefully, Sylvan tells the Register, it never comes to that. "The idea is for this not to feel like a punishment, but an intervention to help them develop better habits and get to school."
The GPS devices cost between $300 and $400 each. The Register reports the program is part of a six-week pilot program that costs the the district, overall, about $18,000. A state grant foots the bill.
Police tell the paper if tracking kids by GPS seems a little extreme, people should remember kids face extreme risks. Kids who cut class are prime candidates for joining street gangs, police say.
And schools lose about $35 per day every time student fails to show up.
Miller tells the Register similar programs in San Antonio and Baltimore resulted in school attendance by chronically absent kids jumping an average of 77 percent to 95 percent because of GPS tracking.
Some students were back to their old tricks after the devices were taken away, Miller tells the paper, but many learned new habits -- especially with the coaches continuing to talk with them for a year.
"This is their last chance at an intervention," Kristen Levitin, principal at Dale Junior High in Anaheim, tells the Register. "Anything that can help these kids get to class is a good thing."
Not all parents agree.
"I feel like they come at us too hard, and making kids carry around something that tracks them seems extreme," Raphael Garcia, the father of a sixth grader who has six unexcused absences, tells the paper.
"This makes us seem like common criminals," she adds.
Not really, police investigator Armando Pardo tells the paper. Parents are not being charged with a crime. However, they could be. Letting kids skip school without a valid reason is a crime, he says.
The kids could be sent to juvenile hall, and their parents could be slapped with a fine up to $2,000.
So here's looking at you, kid.
Want to get the latest ParentDish news and advice? Sign up for our newsletter!











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 2)
2-22-2011 @ 2:29PM
Duncan Max said...Big Brother, Indeed !! Seems to me that very soon we will have no privacy at all !!
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 4:14PM
Alicia said...@Charlchase- I hate your stance that all kids lie. It's a load of shit. If you raise your kids right and allow them to earn your trust and respect and honor that trust, they won't abuse it. God, I feel bad for your kids.
2-22-2011 @ 4:18PM
Godiva said...And I feel bad for YOUR kids, Alicia.
Oh! That's right!
You don't have kids. You are single, you are not a parent, you don't plan to ever have kids yet day after day you come to Parentdish and post critical comments to other posters.
Why is that? Why does a single woman with no children come to parentdish and criticize those who do?
2-22-2011 @ 4:42PM
Alicia said...Why does a mean-spirited woman constantly hunt me down, hound and misquote me every time I post. If you ever took the time to read any of my posts, Godiva, you'd notice I said if I decide to have kids, I intend to adopt. Never have I said I never intended to have kids, just never intended to have my own. I've also told you at least three times why I come on this site. As for Charlchase's comment, I criticize because it is horrible to not trust teens and treat them all like they're criminals.
2-22-2011 @ 7:33PM
Rick said...Alicia you are so blind and oblivious to what is going on around you. I am not a parent either but it doesn't take a fool to see what is going on in the world around us. Today's kids are out of control. They are rude to people who are older then they are. They are mouthy and disrespectful to anyone in authority. They feel like they are entitled to the world without putting any work into it. They will lie in a heartbeat to get what they want and to try to get out of any trouble they get into. They will steal anything they can get their grubby little hands on. They will cheat to try to get ahead instead of putting in the effort to get what they want. They will throw their best friend under the wheels of the bus and won't own up to anything they do wrong and blame it on anyone else but themselves. I am not saying every kid is bad but a good majority of them are. The saying it takes a village to raise a child has long gone out the window. When I was growing up if we did something wrong we got out butts whooped. If we back talked we got backhanded across the face. If we got bad grades in school or stayed out past curfew we got grounded. We had to do chores and help with the house. If we didn't do something right we were made to do it over till we did. If we did something wrong at a friends house we got our butts whooped by that parent then by the time we got home our own parents would know what we did and we got it again from our parents. Now in today's world if a friends parent even thinks of raising their voice or disciplining someone else's child all hell will break loose. If a parent spanks their child it is now called child abuse. If things got back to the way they were when I was growing up I personally think this world would be a whole better place. Oh and I forgot to mention that kids today a lazy. All they want to do now is sit on their butts all day and play video games and chat online with their friends and update their facebook status. God forbid they got off their butts and went out to play and hang out with their friends and use their imaginations to entertain themselves like we did when I was a kid. We went to school. We hung out with our friends. When we weren't in school we did our homework, did our chores and entertained ourselves and were home by curfew. Today's kids just don't know how easy they have it. Oh geeze now I sound like my parents who walked up hill to and from school both ways 10 miles in subzero temps with no shoes and had no books for school and the whole class had to share one pencil to do their schoolwork. LOL I think you better wake before you adopt or pop out those kids if and when you decide to have them or else your gonna be in a whole world of trouble.
2-23-2011 @ 3:00PM
Alicia said...How often do you actually spend with kids? Because I can tell you, I know quite a few teenagers and quite a few young kids and I know that the majority of kids are like the majority of adults: good people. Yes there are bad apples and that's what we see in the news, but most people are good people at heart. If anything, teenagers today are more aware of world events than their parents were and many are already trying to get involved to change the ill in this world. You sound like a bunch of old geezers: "Kids these days...The world is going to pot, I tell you!" I see evidence to the contrary every single day. I can't wait to finish college and get out in the world and start actively fixing what you lot have ruined and when my generation slips up, the generation after us will pop up and fix what we screwed. That's how it works. Don't blame kids for living in a different world than you did. They have to respond differently because there are different stimuli, but in the end, kids are kids who still love their friends and have big dreams they want to achieve. Maybe if you had a little hope for them, more of them would achieve them.
2-22-2011 @ 2:42PM
Mike said...I can understand school officials wanting to know where the kids are during school hours, but what business is it of theirs where a kid is on his own time? School officials are there to educate kids, not control their lives. My grand daughter was once suspended for a comment she made to another kid while at her gymnastics class, miles from the school. She was back in school the next day, along with her grandfather, and his lawyer.
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 2:42PM
K5 Learning said...This is truly disheartening. The money, effort and technology gobbled up by this GPS system could have been used in so many more productive ways.
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 4:12PM
Alicia said...Agreed. Also, how is this not going to make kids feel like they're being punished?
2-22-2011 @ 8:39PM
Christina said...I feel children have right's also unless, they are abused. If my child had a problem with skipping class or school then by all means. We are responsible for their safety and education. When you put them on the bus or drop them at the door they should be required to attend set classes and the school should be held accountable for such.
In my opinion, under no circumstance should a child without a problem be monitored.
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 3:22PM
sstines said...Really!?! Where are the parents in this truancy problem? It is their responsibility to get their children to school not the school's and not the child's. Given a choice would they go, NO. Given a choice would an adult go to work, NO! Instead of tracking the children like criminals--make the parents do their job!!!
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 8:33PM
mom2alex said...How? I wish that there was a way to make people do what is right. But, given the cost of putting kids in jail I think that the cost is justified. Also, funding is based on attendance. Why should my kid not get a good education because someone else is not doing their job? I say send the cops to their homes and take the kids to school! This might work better than getting rid of tenure or paying teachers on "merit".
2-22-2011 @ 4:13PM
Sandra-A1 said...What happened to parents being responsible for their children?
If the child is truant then make the parents serve detention with their child and have to deal with the GPS!
Seems to me that these children have parents that need training just as much as their child!
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 4:38PM
bkwormsjv said...Interesting. My initial thoughts are that despite its invasive nature, they seem to have good reasons behind their actions.
1. School, until age 18, is mandatory by law. If students are skipping, the state is well within their rights to find out where they are and to try and get them back.
2. Since parents can be held liable when they don't try and track down their kids, this just helps them do the job they should be doing (and may be unsuccessfully trying to do) already.
3. There seems to have been a great deal of success, not just in the short term but also on a longer-term basis. This is a much healthier outcome for the students- or so I assume- which would make this an investment in our future rather than an empty expense.
4. I know from experience that teenagers will lie to parents about their whereabouts. If this helps cut through the smoke and mirrors, I have a hard time seeing the disadvantage.
As long as the GPS data is secure, I don't see a problem at first blush. Yes, it may seem intrusive. But I have to ask myself if it is warranted (see drop-out and failure rates), justifiable (legally, minors do not have the right to skip school), and proportionate to the problem (with the exception of the 8PM check in, all others occur during school hours). I don't see a major difficulty in any of these areas.
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 4:53PM
Tom said...All invasions of individual rights start as good intentions...
2-22-2011 @ 4:26PM
MIKE said...in my little neck of the woods, if a student has more then 5 unexcused absenses, the fines start to roll in. i remember back when i went to school, just one year, i missed 30 days, just didnt feel like going. after the fine my parents recieved and the ass kicking i recieved, i didn't miss a day of school for the next 3 years. by law, parents can be punished if their minor child, does something wrong, if parents think that this gps device will work, i say continue using it, as for those commenting who have no children, just mind your own business
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 5:52PM
Jim said...I can see using the device as an "alarm clock" to get the kids to school on time, and I can see tracking them during regular class hours, but once the kids leave the school yard after normal hours it's invasion of privacy. 8 PM? Sorry, but schools been long out and they have no business tracking anyone once they're off school grounds.
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 4:43PM
Tom said...NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO...NOT NOW...NOT EVER!!!
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 5:03PM
Great said...Wow great except one thing....its illegal for this public school to do this. They might want to have a lawyer explain this to them.
Reply
2-22-2011 @ 5:32PM
mike hylton said...how dare the school do this to these precious little kids?? my gosh dont you know they arent allowed to tell a kid,hey you are doing wrong, you are disobeying rules, you are on the wrong track, you are setting your self up for failure,, ha, and my gosh to tell this to a parent of one of these misbehaving kids is even worse,, cant tell them thetruth this may damage their precious little self esteem,,,ha
Reply