School Officials Often React Poorly to Student Suicides, Experts Say
Filed under: In The News, Research Reveals: Tweens, Social & Emotional Growth: Teens
The outpouring of grief over a suicide could be seen as glorifying the person who completed suicide, which may cause other teens to think they want all that attention. Credit: MTC
When a teenager commits suicide, schools usually become the nexus of information and counseling for the affected community.
However, in responding after a student's suicide, many school officials actually do or say things that send the wrong messages to students and may even make copycat suicides more likely, according to Paul Granello and Darcy Haag Granello, co-authors of "Suicide, Self-Injury and Violence in the Schools."
While school administrators operate under the best of intentions when reacting to a student's suicide, the best course of action is actually "counterintuitive to our cultural norms," say the authors.
"We naturally want to have ceremonies and memorials, flowers at the fence and burning candles," Paul Granello says in a news release. "But when you do this in the case of a suicide, it sends the wrong message to troubled youth who might also be contemplating suicide."
This outpouring of grief could be seen as glorifying the person who completed suicide, which may cause other teens to think they want all that attention, he says. For this reason, schools should also avoid holding memorials or cancelling classes, and should only hold discussions about mental health or suicide in small classroom groups, not large assemblies.
Adults can also send the wrong message when they talk about a suicide; for example, when they say the student killed himself to "end the pain."
"What a dangerous message that is for young people," Darcy Granello says. "It tells them that suicide is the way to end pain. But suicide is never that simple. There is never a direct line from some bad things happening to someone to a choice to complete suicide."
Adults should instead convey to students that "suicide only transfers the pain from the person who killed him or herself to a whole community who is now in pain," she says.
School officials should also refrain from discussing specific details of the suicide, Paul Granello says.
"Instead of focusing on the suicide itself, focus on what help if available and how people are responding to the grief. The focus should be on the community response," he says.
But adults shouldn't be afraid to talk to teens about suicide, or even ask troubled students if they are thinking about suicide, according to Darcy Granello.
"There's a lot of research that shows that talking about suicide appropriately actually reduces the risk -– it doesn't increase it," she concludes.
Here are some other steps schools should take after the suicide of a student:
- Compile a list of students who may be at risk for suicide and remind staff about the risk factors and warning signs.
- Contact community support services, such as local mental health agencies, other school counselors, community crisis hotline agencies and clergy members.
- Arrange a meeting with parents.
- Provide them with warning signs for adolescents who may be suicidal.
- Provide information about supportive services available to students at the school and in the community.
- Provide information about how to respond to students' questions about suicide.
- Meet with students in small groups in the classroom.
- Make sure teachers announce the death of the student during their first class of the day.
- Describe the deceased as "having died by suicide" rather than as "a suicide" or having "committed suicide."
- Disclose all relevant facts, but do not provide morbid details like method or exact location of the suicide.
- Allow students an opportunity to express their feelings. "What are your feelings and how can I help?" should be the mantra behind the structure of discussion.
- Inform students of the available support services in the school (and outside the school) and encourage them to use the services.
- Establish support stations or counseling rooms in the school.
- Reschedule any immediate stressful academic exercises or tests if at all possible.
- Avoid flying the school flag at half-mast in order to avoid glamorizing the death.
- Follow up with students who are identified as at-risk and provide ongoing assessment and monitoring of these students (follow-up should be maintained as long as possible).
For a more complete list and additional information on youth suicide prevention in schools, view the Youth Suicide Prevention School-Based Guide posted online by the Florida Mental Health Institute.
Want to get the latest ParentDish news and advice? Sign up for our newsletter!
Your<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- What's the penalty for falsley claiming relation to a person does it have to be for monetary gain or proven not just a social gesture
- (department of defense)? hey can you build me a super duper all protector? yea what you want on it $$$$$
- If i own all or most of the property in dc think the mayor already knows. president and others including Embassies. on my property for 20 +years











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 1)
2-25-2011 @ 2:41PM
Alicia said...I agree with nixing "suicide ends pain" chatter and offering preventive help for students, but frankly, the rest of this is bull. I lost a friend and former classmate to suicide in October 2009 and was not able to attend his funeral because I go to school so far away from home. It made it that much harder to get over his death because I never had the opportunity to say goodbye, converse with and support people who knew him and be supported by them. The internet made it possible to speak with them, but we all needed physical contact and I couldn't have that. Memorials are vital to the healing of survivors, especially after a suicide and especially for a community like a school. Don't take that healing away from kids. Instead, focus on changing how suicide is talked about; the language we use to discuss suicide is inappropriate. Even more so are comments like, "if I don't get my way, I'll kill myself" or "I'd rather kill myself than do such-and-such." It makes light of suicide and kids who already think they have nothing to live for will lack that sense of social taboo that might forbid it. It's easy to change language, but you'll do more harm than good changing the process of mourning.
Reply
2-28-2011 @ 3:36PM
Lauren said...I'll admit that at first, I thought this article was crazy. But towards the end I found that I agree with this. There was a student death at my high school, drunk-driving related, that seemed a bit glorified to me. He got a personal and permanent plaque at the school and got everyone "excited" about getting safe drivers for their parties. Lesson learned right? Not quite...see, he WAS the safe driver that night. But one that didn't do his job for whatever reason. So it seemed ridiculous to say his death means we should have more safe drivers. How about just not drinking AT ALL? It also seemed sad that he got a permanent plaque when other students who died later on didn't. That didn't seem fair either. Glorify all or none.
Reply
3-10-2011 @ 10:53AM
Silver Fang said...Teens commit suicide because our culture has reduced them from young adults with responsibilities to overgrown children who are forced to sit idle until they're finished with indoctrinat... school. Let teens take on adults responsibilities at an earlier age than 18 and the suicides will be greatly reduced.
Reply
3-13-2011 @ 4:18PM
Elba said...My daughter Jessica took her life seven years ago. The pain I feel is something you cant explain. Every day I miss her and wish she was here. I think that as a parent i forgot that she was a child, we tend to think that our kids are grown bu there not. I thought i gave her everything,material wise how ever I know think the signs were there I just did not pay attention the guilt I feel is horrible my depression is worse. Parrenst please listen when they want to talk take time to listen, I wish I did.
Reply