Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Bonnie Fuller: Zach Sobiech: You Were a Huge Inspiration in Your…
When A Tornado Strikes, Should Schools Evacuate?

Message to Teachers in Wisconsin: Leave the Governor's Kids Out of It!
Filed under: Opinions
On February 15th, more than a thousand protesters gathered outside of the Wauwatosa, Wis., home of Governor Scott Walker to protest his proposed state budget bill. But Scott Walker doesn't live there, and the teachers in that community know that.
Walker lives at the governor's residence in Madison. His Wauwautosa house is home to his wife, Tonette, who is living there while their teenage boys finish out the school year. Having your home surrounded by a thousand chanting protesters in the post-Gabby Giffords era is frightening. For high schoolers, it can also be, well, embarrassing!
Back in Madison, where the protests in the Captiol rotunda continue in full force, some protesters couldn't resist the urge to make it personal. In addition to signs depicting Governor Walker as Hitler and comparing him to deposed dictator Hosni Mubarkek, several teachers held up these homemade signs:
"Scott, your son is in my class. I teach him, I protect him, I inspire him."
"Scott, I taught your son algebra. My son just turned 5. Does he deserve a good education?"
Is this really necessary, or professional, for that matter? Can't these educators see the hypocrisy in claiming to "protect" a child that they're simultaneously using as a pawn for political gain? Surely I'm not the only parent appalled by this violation of trust in the student-teacher relationship.
Regardless of where you stand on the issue of unions, collective bargaining rights, government spending or billion dollar deficits, we are all called to use our common sense and decency in our political expression. It shouldn't be hard for teachers to imagine that it's probably tough being the governor's teenage sons during these contentious times in Wisconsin. Teachers and their unions ought to publicly denounce these tactics that so clearly undermine their claims that these protests are all about "the kids."
Whether it's the Obama girls or the Walker boys, politicians' kids deserve to be off limits. It's a good civic rule of thumb -- one our public school teachers shouldn't need to be schooled on.
Want to get the latest ParentDish news and advice? Sign up for our newsletter!











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 3)
2-25-2011 @ 1:00PM
Ann M said...I found it very ironic that the teacher was holding up a sign about how she teaches his son - during school hours, on a day that was *supposed* to be a school day. I guess she teaches, protects and inspires him when she wants to - but not that day...
Reply
3-02-2011 @ 9:33PM
Maria said...Aren't teachers allowed to take a day off for personal reasons? Secondly, how were the governor's children impacted by the protest if it was a school day? Weren't they in school?
3-08-2011 @ 12:31PM
Kim said...If unions- and their supporters- are truly about "the children" (which they are not, of course- they're for gaining as much as they can for their dues-paying members- in this case, public school teachers), they'll leave children's homes and personal information out of these debates.
3-11-2011 @ 12:55PM
ck said...Look up the defintion of 'ironic' before you use it, genius. Right-wingers are such useless pieces of anti-American trash.
3-18-2011 @ 11:19AM
s. hoskins said...I would interpret the sign as a threat that the teacher was prepared to disclose what she/he knows about the governor's kid and his record. I am a teacher and know that children are off limits in adult issues. This teacher would be the first I would let go, no, fire, if I had the power. "Protect,"..... what a sad joke.
3-22-2011 @ 3:59PM
Sue said...You taunted protesters by laughing and video taping while having dinner with Scott walker. Respect that the state is desperate.
Please! Scott walkers kids won't have to worry once he's ousted.
2-25-2011 @ 1:24PM
Elizabeth said...You couldn't be more wrong. It is completely appropriate for protestors to make this personal. The bill is a personal attack on public workers, including those teachers who work in the Wauwatosa schools, teaching Walker’s sons.
Walker doesn't have little kids who might be scared; he has teenagers who should know that their father is a political whore who is willing to sell out his soul and the workers of Wisconsin to some billionaires who bought him the governor's mansion. There has been absolutely no indication that any of the protestors are the least bit violent or malicious. (At least, there wasn’t until Walker admitted that he considered planting violent troublemakers in the otherwise completely appropriately-behaving crowd, putting his own citizens, including children, and the police that works to protect them, at risk.)
Those teachers who have taught Walker’s kids have every right to hold up signs asking why their own kids don’t deserve a great education, too. Based on the completely un-Constitutional vote in the WI assembly this morning, comparisons to Hitler and Mubarkek are valid and fair.
If there’s anything these boys should be embarrassed by, it’s their father and his political pandering. If I were his kids or wife, I’d be out protesting with the workers.
Reply
2-25-2011 @ 1:45PM
Sarah said...Hitler? Really. Let me know when Walker mercilessly slaughters millions of people. Then such comparisons are valid and fair. Until then, try focusing more on history and less on histrionics.
2-25-2011 @ 9:03PM
Allys said...Are you a public school teacher? I'm guessing you are either a product of producer of public education. The lack of logic and common sense in your response leads me to that conclusion. Collective bargaining issues and salary while they impact people personally are not personal attacks. The comparison of a state governor who is forced due to the lack of fiscal restraint by prior administrations to genocidal maniacs and dictators stretches the goodwill and civility of public discourse and actually diminishes the real atrocities committed by horrors such as Hitler. Does a teacher having to pay $200 per month for health insurance and having limited collective bargaining rights really warrant a comparison to the deaths of millions in concentration camps due to their race? Honestly. I can see why over a third of public school teachers in Wisconsin have their kids in private schools.
2-25-2011 @ 11:08PM
Suz said...So you would think it fine if teachers showed up protesting to your kids on your front lawn if they didn't like what you did at work? Really you would be fine with that? My guess is you would be the first to call the police to complain and go on talk shows telling how emotionally scarred your kids are.
2-25-2011 @ 11:19PM
Rose P said...I agree 100% with you Elizabeth. The writer is probably a republican who sides with Scott anyways! I'd like to see the amount of people commenting actually FROM WI (like me!) Scott should be ashamed of himself but hey- wait he's actually getting more money by passing this bill!
2-26-2011 @ 9:30AM
traci said...You are right, they do have the right. But what about social graces and civility? These people are setting a poor example by teaching their children and ours that it is okay to act in this manner when you don't like an outcome.
2-26-2011 @ 10:43AM
paul said...Sarah, really?? So you had no problem with Hitlers policies until he approved the final solution. Or are you captivated by a dictators power? He ruled Germany from 1932 until 1939 and hadn't started a war, but surely showed his true colors from the beginning! Open your eyes and ears and reread your history. Alot of Republicans supported Hitler until he invaded Poland.
2-27-2011 @ 12:37PM
Bryan said...Elizabeth, it is you who couldn't be more wrong. These teachers and every other union member across the country need to realize that they need to make the same concessions as the rest of us in these times. The majority of Americans are facing pay cuts and layoffs, yet the unions seem to think they're immune to that. The teachers need to realize that soon they won't have a need for a union as there won't be enough tax payers left to fund a public school system. As Americans, we're ALL in this together. Paying union dues doesn't make you recession exempt.
3-10-2011 @ 5:11PM
slept said...I'm surprised nobody has taken his kids as political prisoners with a no compromise no negotiations attitude. There was a time when Americans stood determined and unwilling to be the victim. It may be tea party time in America lately but wait til the youth SIP the New nescafe that's bubbled in the Mideast. They drank it in Egypt, Tunisia, lybia, and soon Kuwait. A liberal billionaire met a chemist who knew some bloggers who knew a country fed up with the powers that be. The new LSD is going to fundamentally change America when the time is right. When wikileaks drops documents on BANK OF AMERICA then you will know that its the beginning of something real big.
2-25-2011 @ 2:18PM
Matt said...The role of teacher, protector, and inspirer is the father and mother, and not the government worker. The twisting of roles in today's society is contributing greatly to the breakdown of society. The tremendous upsurge in the homeschooling movement is a result of this...parents are starting to get the message. Government run schools are fundamentally flawed.
Reply
2-25-2011 @ 8:20PM
Marcus said...I agree with you. Unfortunately society has dumped this responsibility on the teachers. A lot of parents are not involved in their child's education and have no idea what's going on. And when the student is not achieving, we dump all the blame on the teacher and none on the parent.
2-25-2011 @ 2:40PM
jackie said...You need to understand--people need to fight for what they believe in. You want a quality education for your child? Read this! "The Myth of Charter Schools; the New York Review of Books" and see that Finland, a country showing the greatest success in teaching children, have teachers in unions (OMG) and they are SUCCESSFUL because, basically, they don't do the tests, and they teach students for a successful future--(OMG--no state mandated tests????). They work with parents--and have a minimal poverty rate. Wow--teachers factor in as POSITIVE, RESPECTED personnel...imagine that! You can also find what else Finland does right by doing a google search.
Reply
2-25-2011 @ 4:13PM
Rachel said...I think that unless the references toward his children were offensive or derogatory in some way, there is nothing wrong with them. The references that you quoted seem to ask Gov. Walker to reflect and rethink some things which he was clearly unable to do. Politics are personal. We usually only care about it when it directly affects us. I think the people of Wisconsin, those who voted for him, those who he represents, those who hold up those signs are only trying to show him how many people this bill will affect, even if it doesn't affect him.
They put him in office.
He should become a better listener.
Reply
2-27-2011 @ 10:44AM
Alan Ostlund said...I think you are right. Not only should they be allowed to protest at Walker's home, though he isn't there. We should all get protesters to the White House and the Obama girls school so we can protest what is being taken away from us. I feel he is responsible for my underemployment.
When it involves a Republican, it's the end justifies the means. If it involves a Democrat, why can't people be more caring.
I had to end up home schooling my son, because the teachers couldn't teach him to read. With the help of Sylven's Learning Center, I was able to get him up from 3rd grade level, to 10th grade level, from February to Sept. Just in time for him to start a failing high school attempt.
We should be protesting in front of the School Teachers Union President's home. Those people fail us more than most
Governors do.