'Parentless Parents': Q&A With Author Allison Gilbert
Filed under: Amazing Parents, Books for Parents
"Parentless Parents" looks at the growing number of adults whose parents have died. Credit: Hyperion
It's a growing demographic, and one that's underexplored, says Allison Gilbert, author of "Parentless Parents: How the Loss of Our Mothers and Fathers Impacts the Way We Raise Our Children." A parentless parent herself, Gilbert says she was surprised no one was writing about the phenomenon or doing the requisite research.
So, Gilbert, who lives in New York with her husband, Mark, and her children, Jake, 10, and Lexi, 8, took it upon herself to explore this emergent population. ParentDish recently spoke with her about her new book. An edited version of the conversation follows.
ParentDish: What are some of the unique challenges for a parentless parent?
Allison Gilbert: I'll give an example from my own life. When my husband's parents talk about, "Oh, your dad used to do X, Y and Z when he was a kid," or, "I remember when your dad used to do that," my kids don't have that (from my side of the family). So, as their mom, I'm less complete to them because they can hear those stories about my husband from his parents and they get to see my husband being a son (but) they don't get to see me doing those things. I'm much more one-dimensional to them.
PD: That's tough. Are there positive aspects about being a parentless parent?
AG: There are so many things that are life affirming. If you approach this in a proactive way, there are so many things you can do to keep the memory of your parents alive in very fun, creative, age-appropriate ways. When you close that last page of my book, you're not sad that you've read this book. You're actually feeling empowered and supported and you come away with great ideas.
PD: So, it's not all doom and gloom?
AG: The most important takeaway I can give to anyone who is thinking about reading the book, (is that) there is so much empowering information in here. It's not doom and gloom, it's not "woe is me." But, more than that, your children can actually benefit because you've actually been through this experience; you've learned life lessons you can actually use for your own parenting and children.
PD: Such as?
AG: Parents who have been through this loss have a very fine appreciation for what's a small problem and what's a big problem. When your kids are going through ups and downs -- "You're going to get a bad grade. That boy is going to break up with you. You're not going to make the baseball team" -- I really think that going through this experience allows you to have perspective, and that can help you help your kids also gain perspective. A parent who has gone through some negative experiences can let kids pull back the curtain and see the other side perhaps more readily.
Author Allison Gilbert. Credit: Robert Tardio
PD: You wrote a chapter about keeping the memory of your parents alive. Any examples?
AG: My father was an architect and he was involved with building the corporate offices of the New York Giants. And my son is a huge football fan. I called the Giants corporate offices, explained who I was and what my dad did and asked if I could bring my kids on a tour of the corporate offices. We got one better and went to Giants Stadium before a game and got to be on the field during warm up. My son was in heaven.
PD: How old was he when you did this?
AG: Jake was 9 1/2. I guarantee you he knows his grandfather was an architect, he knows that one of his clients was the Giants, and, for the rest of his life, he will remember that it was his grandpa who paved the way for him to have this incredibly memorable and important experience. It made my father become more real to them.
PD: Wow. That's fantastic.
AG: My mom worked in a typical office, but I did the same thing with my kids for her. I wanted them to meet her coworkers. I wanted them to see the view outside Grandma's window. I think those kinds of trips and experiences are really possible. These types of field trips have the ability to make people more real, who perhaps your children have never met.
PD: What about introducing surrogate grandparents?
AG: One of the wonderful lessons that I have come away with is that there is such a thing as redefining family. That just because your immediate family is now different than what it once was, and that the two people who you would want most to share in your children's milestones and actually applaud at your child's dance recital or cheer at your son's basketball game, they are not ever going to be replaced. But you can develop relationships with people who can fill the gap. Certainly never completely, but you can move in that direction.
PD: How does one go about finding such surrogates?
AG: There's a matter of extending yourself and realizing that these relationships aren't going to just show up. You actually have to be proactive and seek them out and be receptive to them when they materialize, because people don't know if you want that from them. If you are open and receptive, these are relationships you can gain not just for yourself, but for your kids.
Watch the "Parentless Parents" book trailer.
Your<span>Voice</span>
Ask Us Anything About Parenting
Recently Asked
- Justin Bieber - Baby ft. Ludacris by JustinBieberVEVO 3 years ago 859,231,811 views
- Copyright court case litigation? the words spoken by attorney at trial ? in defense of a product or person(or as plaintiff or defendant))
- . two ways to lose property's selling or debt ( debt property is sold to pay debt) the debt has to be proved) court managing property?











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 2)
3-18-2011 @ 12:37PM
sayso said...No offense, but when women decide to wait until they are older to have children, then yes, you can run into this problem. I am not saying it is wrong to wait, but if it is important for your children to know your parents and how you lived as a child, then maybe you should think about that before you wait.
I know that sometimes it isn't a matter of your choice to wait for children, or maybe your parents have already passed on, but if your parents are still alive why don't you go ahead and maybe video tape them talking about thier lives, what they did as kids, ect. I have done this with my grandparents so my children will get to hear thier great-grandparents voice and know them.
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 2:24PM
saannie said...That is a neat idea, thanks for sharing that. I am thankful that both of my parents were still alive when my children were born and were able to get to know them. My dad passed away from cancer when my daughter was just 10 yrs old, and my nephew made a video of him talking about his life. I am so thankful for having the video, Even though it has been almost 16 yrs since he has passed, I will always tresure the video. As I now have grandchildren, reading your post has made me realize that maybe, I need to start making a video for my grandchildren, so when I pass they will have something to remember me by. Thank you for posting your comment.
3-22-2011 @ 4:03PM
Theresa said...not every has the choice as to when they have children. I was married at 23 yet was not able to have my first child until 27 and my second child at 35. We are very lucky to have them. Also, I come from a large family and being one of the youngest your parents are going to be older. Secondly, my husband was only 55 when he passed away.
3-22-2011 @ 2:19PM
Enough Already said...I was not an "older" mother when I had my children, but you cannot predict the health of your parents as they age. My youngest is 13 and my oldest is 25. They were old enough when my parents passed away to remember and keep dear memories of them. It is difficult to see the children go through different phases of their lives and not have their material grandparents there to celebrate.
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 2:37PM
charlotte7224 said...I'm sorry; but this is pathetic. Why do Americans think they're
"entitled" to the "perfect life" The 2.3 kids, dog, grandparents;
perfect house, 2 cars, vacations, aunts; uncles & grandparents,
for that all important "family" holiday picture round the food laden table
smiles in place.
That is what may be ASPIRED TO...not necessarily reality.
In the movies, & personal dreams; as we go through life planning
our perfect future; yes I'm sure we all dream of this....but lets
get real here; its not reality for everyone, in facy; probably not the majority.
Our "family" maybe anything from a single parent & kids; to a multi generational household, whatever it is;
embrace it & quit whining about what you Don't have. whether they are absent by death, or by choice; that is your reality;
You do your children a disservice by not addressing reality; surrogate grandparents!?! Come on, be honest; tell them the
truth; & then let them know; you still have parents, there are children who have no-one at all; "its not an entitlement"
I was told something years ago; as I FELT SORRY FOR MYSELF; (being one of those particular kids) & I have kept it
ever since; "THERE WILL ALWAYS BE PEOPLE BETTER OFF THAN YOU--- BUT YOU WILL ALSO BE BETTER OFF
THAN ALOT OF OTHER PEOPLE" I have used this through out my life, & used it to raise my 2 children; who also grew up
with no extended family. I suggest that when you feel either yourself; or your children to be hard done by, you think of this;
& take it to heart.
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 4:47PM
bunsbestgirl said...Charlotte,
THANK YOU! I could not have said it any better than you. Just because your parents may be gone, how does that make someone "one dimensional"? Even tho my father died at 51 years of age (of a heart attack) and my kids were real small, they know him through pictures and stories. People are always finding things to complain about. How about be glad that YOU'RE STILL HERE TO TAKE CARE OF YOUR CHILDREN! That must mean something.
3-22-2011 @ 5:06PM
Matthew said...Charlotte no one is claiming they deserve a perfect life. People are talking about their experiences and how you deal with them. You have gone through this and if you can shrug it off then good for you. You said someone told you there are people better off than you. I worked at a hospital for a while when I was in college. In a 5 day time period on feb my father had a horrible car wreck and broke his hip in many places and was in icu and might not make it. 3 days later my mother had a heart attack crashed on the table and had a 4 way bypass. They werent sure she would make it. 2 days after that my birth defects brother died at my aunts house. I had to wait for doctors to give my parents valium then go into each room and telll them what happened. I passed out when I got the call about my brother. I thought they are all going to die in one week. I had a boss that had the nerve to say to me"Well someone has it worse off than you" I couldnt believe I was sitting there going through all that and she had the nerve to say it. I wasnt thinking" Oh I deserve better than this, oh woe is me" I was scared! This isnt about what people think they deserve its what we go through in life. I would wish you had a little more compassion for others. Maybe you havent dealth with this as well as you think you have!
3-22-2011 @ 6:04PM
joyceand said...I disagree with you. My father died when my son was 12 and my mother died recently (my son is now 15). We are fortunate to have some elders in our circle of friends; they have been delighted to come to my son's ball games, graduations, etc. It doesn't replace his grandprents but everyone enjoys it.
3-22-2011 @ 6:25PM
Susan said...To Matthew: Very well said. To Charlotte: You sound like a windbag, loving the sound of you're own bitter voice. The topic is keeping loving memories green, a right we all have. Perhaps that explains your bitterness, you might not have such memories to embrace, which many families enjoyed and pass on to their children and grandchildren.
3-22-2011 @ 2:42PM
kacbk said...I am an older parent whose parents passed before my first was born. I've never felt less complete in my children’s eyes then their farther because of childhood stories from his parents. I, my self, kept a reminder with stories of my own childhood and always had pictures of my parents from different stages of my young life. I never once felt I was less of an individual then my spouse to my children. As I am aging now I realize there is something I have missed out on, and that is how to be a grandparent. I have come to the realization I have had no one in my life as a roll model to follow. This is where I really feel some what lost and inadequate.
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 2:56PM
Becky said...31 years I haven't had my parents-a 21 year marriage and 3 kids later-trust me there are moments I have missed them so much. I look forward to reading this book :0)
Reply
3-24-2011 @ 9:35PM
Julymoon said...Just can't wait for the day when graduation is full of 100 yr old mom's I don't care I think we women shouldn't have children pass 40 and then those are change of life babies. Now on the other hand of you can hire nannies round the clock you can have them real late in life because your not taking care of them anyway or getting up all hours of the nite ...
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 4:19PM
Matthew said...Im 39 and by the time I was 36 all of my family had passed away. I do have a few siblings but they will not talk to me and havent since I was about 20. Its a depressing thing but I wouldnt and cannot change who I am. If I had kids which I dont and wouldnt have them if you paid me I would teach them family is very important. You love your family no matter what. You do not put if's ands or buts on that love. Its unconditional! Life is what it is. This happens to many. I have friends that have become my family and Im glad for that.
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 5:20PM
salome said...ooooooooooooooomygawd,I can't believe that THIS IS some kind of an issue or CATASTROPHE,but then again we're OBVIOUSLY dealing with yuptards and of course IT'S ALL ABOUT THEM and NOW their ultimate possession-- A CHILD ! or 2. 3 ? they're up for canonization.
what would they do,how would they cope if they were the first generation out here and their parents were thousands of miles away ? and neither your family or the grands could fly back and forth except every 5 years or so ????oooh the humanity ! LOL.
3-22-2011 @ 4:49PM
Gina said...Geeze Louise! I never even thought about this. I decided to have my children when I decided to have my children (all in my 40s, and my last one at 47.) Our parents on both sides, mine and my husbands are gone. Hmmm!
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 5:23PM
salome said..............Mat ? don't know WHY this(first post ) wound up as a reply to you as obviouly it hsn't a thing to do with you--
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 5:37PM
Angiebaby said...Just tell your kids stories about when you were a kid that involve your parents, and stories about your parents. It would help if you have a few photos of them around the house, too. Me? I didn't really know my father, and stories I would have to tell about our few times together aren't very good. My mother is still alive, thank goodness, because I don't have any good stories from growing up with her, neither. Whatcha' gonna' do? Besides, I don't think this problem is limited to older parents because so many families are fractured today and don't see or speak to one another. It's not uncommon for a mother or father to have 8 brothers and sisters, but their kids only know one or two aunts or uncles. Same with grandparents.
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 8:39PM
Sarah88 said...Angiebaby, thank you for stating it that way. Though I'm still rather young, I have no children of my own, and my parents are still alive. Perhaps I can give a slightly different perspective on all of this; perhaps more of the "grandparentless grandkid" perspective. My father's parents are still alive, but it's been a bit of a rough and shut-out relationship with them, so I don't know them very well with things like their childhood. But I do know about my dad's childhood because I'd ask him and he'd tell me. My mother's parents passed away when I was younger, but even when they were alive I only got the chance to really know my grandmother because my grandfather had a series of severe strokes when I was just born. Though I could go and see him and talk to him, he could never talk back to me. But that didn't mean I had any less of a connection with him, because what he couldn't tell me, my mother and grandmother told me. I can understand the hardship of a parentless parent, but end the end I think it's up to the parents to take the reins and tell their children about their childhood and their family if their own parents aren't around.
3-22-2011 @ 5:39PM
Joanne said...I lost my Mom when I was 31. My boys were 4 and 1. My daughter is named for my Mom. I lost my Dad when my daughter was 5. My in-laws were lousy grandparents...ok, so life isn't fair, but that has not kept us from keeping them alive in our hearts. I will be 50 this year and I still think my parents would be proud of me, my husband and our kids. My folks have missed a lot--but it doesn't stop us from living a happy life. We choose happiness.
Reply
3-22-2011 @ 6:33PM
kim said...I am both without parents, and without children of my own. ( I am 49)... One of the things I have learned is that family is not always the people related to you by blood. Two of my happiest recent moments... my " nephew", a close friend's son, thanking me in front of his family and other guests, for having traveled half way around the world to share a happy occasion with him. And having another, younger, friend refer to me as her surrogate big sister. And by the way, as she is expecting her first child, I will be "auntie" again. You always honor those who are gone, by remembering them and telling their stories, whether to your own children or to those you borrow.
Reply