Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Babble.com: 8 Parenting Lessons To Learn From 'Arrested Development'
Our Favorite Tweets From Parents This Week
Did Veganism and Alternative Medicine Kill Breast-Fed Baby?
Filed under: In The News, Breast-Feeding
An 11-month-old baby's death in France was blamed on breast-feeding and the mother's vegan diet. Credit: Getty Images
Just ask the French couple sentenced to five years in jail for refusing to take their sick and undernourished 11-month-old daughter to a hospital, and instead treating her with advice from a 35-year-old alternative medicine book, Time magazine reports.
The case, which has attracted considerable attention in Europe, serves as a reminder that homeopathic treatment alone is hardly the answer to every health woe, and, in some cases, may even be tantamount to child abuse, according to Time.
Joel and Sergine Le Moaligou were accused of "neglect or food deprivation" after their daughter died due to their failure to follow a doctor's advice. But they escaped actual jail time after their sentence was partly suspended, Time reports.
In 2008, two months before their baby Louise's death, the strict vegans brought their baby to a doctor. The doctor suspected pneumonia and directed the couple to get their daughter a chest X-ray. Instead, they returned home and followed recipes they found in books on natural medicine for mustard, garlic and clay poultices. The couple's alternative "bible" was "The Natural Guide to Childhood," written in 1972 by Jeanette Dextreit, Time reports.
Louise had been losing weight -- she wasn't even 13 pounds at nearly 1 year old, but her parents canceled an appointment with her doctor. She died about a week later. Prosecutors pointed to breast-feeding and the mother's vegan diet as the causes for the baby's death, Time reports.
The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends babies be nourished exclusively on breast milk for the first six months; solid foods are gradually introduced one by one after that. It would be highly unusual for an 11-month-old to be solely breast-fed, but even more so in France, where breast-feeding is the lowest of any Western nation, according to Time.











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 6)
4-07-2011 @ 2:35AM
francisdiaz7 said...Very true that major brands do give out samples on their products, search online for "123 Get Samples" we just got ours today. You wont need CC.
Reply
4-07-2011 @ 3:38PM
Jami said...You need to be especially careful of what you are giving your children. Http://www.pregnancyandnutritioninfoguide.info You baby needs as much natural nutrition as possible!
4-07-2011 @ 5:50PM
Sam said...VEGANS ARE SO NAIVE. BEING A VEGETARIAN ISN'T ALL ITS TRUMPED UP TO BE. THATS WHY IT TAKES 3 HEAPING DINNER PLATES OF GREENS FROM A SALAD BAR TO EQUAL THE NUTRIENTS OF 1 SMALL 5 - 6 OZ. STEAK !!!!
4-07-2011 @ 6:04PM
Sue said...What people don't understand is that humans are not designed to be vegetarian, much less vegan. While it's true that modern humans eat way too much meat, we do need the essential amino acids that are only available pretty much from meat (without swimming to the bottom of the ocean for some weird seaweed). Vegans need to carefully supplement their diets because a vegan diet is NOT natural for humans.
4-07-2011 @ 6:33PM
Alfred Schrader said...Ok, I thought people actually read my comments. I went vegan for a year. I ate nothing from animals. After about 6 weeks it was great. I felt fantastic best I ever had, lots of pep, free from the grease and fats. But after about a year I started passing out. I was in perfect health, and passing out. Turns out plants don't provide vitamin B12, only animals do.
My B12 got below fatal levels. Humans must eat meat. Those two pointed teeth in your upper jaw are not for rutabagas...Alfred-
4-07-2011 @ 11:35PM
C.S. said...AL, I love your comments on everything!
You are SO right! Some animals are herbivores, some are carnivores. The rest of us are omnivores. We have the teeth to masticate plants and animals because we are SUPPOSED to eat both, plants and animals.
Going vegan, to me, would be like second guessing G-d.
4-08-2011 @ 1:36AM
ethan said...sam and sue - you could not be MORE wrong. as a complete vegan, i can assure you that i, and others like me, are a lot healthier than you. you can't just assume things and speak about something you know nothing about - it makes you seem ignorant. being vegan and vegetarian is about making healthy choices and choosing to live and eat a certain, healthier way. there is protein, amino acids, vitamins, etc. in all kinds of food that doesn't involve eating meat. again, it's about being smart and healthy. that said, this little baby that is the subject of the article didn't make the choice for herself and her parents should have fed her and provided medical care for her. they deserve to starve to death themselves.
4-07-2011 @ 9:12AM
Leanne said...Had this baby's parents eaten decent quality meat, they may have had sufficient saturated fat content in their breastmilk to nourish this child properly. There are some infants/toddler who refuse soilds for many months after most other children opt to start exploring the world of solid foods and that's ok IF their breastmilk source (or it's substitute) is of good quality. I suspect this baby would have started solids much early if a) the breastmilk she ate was of decent enough quality to adequately nourish her so that she was strong enough and had a developed enough brain to achieve the mental/physiological skill of eating solid food and b) had her compounded illnesses not further weakened an already weakened immune system.
I know all kinds of breastfed babies and the ones that are the most robust and solid are the children of mothers who have diets high in good quality beef and lamb (that includes lots of saturated animal fats).
This death was entirely preventable.
Reply
4-07-2011 @ 2:31PM
mike hylton said...but those mean old parents/ones with healthy kids/ were eating some poor animal, and we know how anti that the weirdo vegans are,
4-07-2011 @ 2:49PM
jenp said...The issue wasn't that the mom's breast milk was bad because she is a vegan. The issue is the child was ONLY being given breast milk for food at 11 months. That's not enough calories or nutrition for a baby that age.
4-07-2011 @ 4:11PM
Vinsmom99 said...Leanne, the baby's parentS did not breastfeed her. If she was breastfed at all, it was by her MOTHER. Please quit the P.C. B.S. While I am sure the dad was in on the decisions about how to raise and nourish the baby, he did NOT breastfeed.
4-07-2011 @ 9:08PM
bakulogic said...Well put. The third of my four sons (now all grown, healthy young men) was not terribly interested in solid food. Even at one year plus, he still got a lot of his nourishment from the breast. He was a happy, chubby little guy who grew into a thriving, strong, handsome child and man. You can experiment with your own health, but you can't take chances with your precious babies.
4-07-2011 @ 10:15PM
Rich said...Dumb and dumber. Anyone with half a brain knows a baby needs more nourishment than a vegan diet will provide.
Reply
4-07-2011 @ 2:26PM
BMG said...Leanne,
Your comments are clearly based on ignorance of veganism. A diet consisting of eating meat is not the most healthful diet. Eating meat has been shown to be riddled with medical problems, no matter how "quality" the meat is that you are ingesting. The diet of vegans has been demonstrated repeatedly to be less conflicted with visits to medical professionals, and to have the need for the need of medicines. Vegans are much healthier, and live longer. You should do your research on veganism, and the rates of death and illness as opposed to those who are meat eaters. The cause of this baby's death was not veganism, as the doctors claimed; it was the lack of medical care with regard to the pneumonia. Further, the reason for the low weight of this child was that she was being fully breast fed, rather than having been introduced to solid foods. So, although the medical community wants to use veganism as a convenient source of blame here to show how people need the services that will simply bring them more money, this simply was not the case. Much of what the medical promotes is the least healthy for us. Again, do your research, and you will find that this, in fact, the case.
Reply
4-07-2011 @ 3:08PM
orlenda said...Hehe-its true that medicine is mostly guesswork too, they have no clue what causes what most of the time. thus all teh conflicting advice out there....
although i do believe that huamns are omnivores and meant to eat meat......
i must say taht if vegans are indeed healthier, its probably because of the fact that they are more mindful of eating in a healthy way in general (not the lack of meat in their diet....you cant tell me a vegan who stuffs themselves with pottoe chips all day will be a healthy person, but if a person is CHOOSING to not eat meat, they are probabaly more likely to choose healthy foods as well.) Its more about what type of person they are than the actual food is my assumption. There is nothing wrong with nice lean meat.....BUT pepople who choose to eat meat, may not eactly be known for will power and choose to eat fatty meat....
4-07-2011 @ 4:17PM
Alice said...Statistics your are stating are generic, not specific. We are omnivores and we need protein. You can be a vegetarian/vegan if you compensate for it. But my son for instance can't eat soy products do to a kidney defect. Yet he is quite healthy and has exceeded growth expectations for a spontaneous birth defect. The kind of meat makes a differences as well as how much. I use natural remedies if at all possible as well, but I prefer the concept of integrated therapy and and there are many more doctors certified in this now thanks to Dr. Andrew Weil and Dr. Oz. Stay away from extremes and look for balance. These parents did not monitor the child's well being during treatment and were not giving enough nutrition for the child's age, as they should have had solids by then. Ignorant parents who have learned a heartbraking lesson.
4-09-2011 @ 7:14PM
nicolebauman6 said...Actually, its been proven that people who eat meat live longer and don't get sick as often as vegans and vegetarians. And vegans/vegetarians have a higer chance dying from brain anurisms. That is also, sadly, how Mr.Rogers died.
4-07-2011 @ 5:47PM
hank said...The parents should have gotten life. These vegan freaks KILLED their baby.
4-07-2011 @ 7:29PM
shawneen said...Just being vegan does not mean in any way that the mothers milk is insufficient for the baby's nutritional needs at 11 months old. Due to many food allergies I have had to become vegan, my son due to NEC cannot digest food on his own, with the exception of breast milk. He is nearly 3 years old and subsiding nearly entirely on breast milk. I eat a very healthy and proper diet, I can not eat soy, dairy, eggs, meat protein (or milk protein) rice or gluten. But I do consume 90 grams of protein a day (I am also pregnant and my baby is growing ahead of schedule) I eat a very health and balanced diet. Being vegan and smart about it can yeild a very healthy person and high calorie breast milk, the average ounce of breast milk provides 20 calories, mine was tested and provides 32 calories per ounce.
I think the big problem was their lack of allowing medical intervention when necessary and the mother likely did not adhere to a proper vegan diet, she was not passing enough calories to her daughter for her daughter to be so small. My son is 32 lbs and 38 in at 33 months old on pretty much straight brest milk.
4-07-2011 @ 7:45PM
George O said...Have you never read Genesis 9:3? "Everything that lives and moves about will be food for you. Just as I gave you the green plants, I now give you everything. "