Hot on HuffPost Parents:
Lauren Boggi: Bouncing Forward: The Post-Natal Recovery Experience Of…
Measles Surges In UK Years After Vaccine Scare

My Little One Was So Excited About Being a Big Brother ... But Not Anymore!
Filed under: Opinions, Expert Advice: Family Time
Dear AdviceMama,
During my pregnancy, my 3-year old could not have been more excited about having a little brother or sister. He told everyone he was going to be a big brother and couldn't wait for "his" little baby to be born. He was OK for the first few weeks, but now he is misbehaving in ways he never did before, having meltdowns at home and even at preschool -- a place he loves. What should I do?
From,
Pregnant
Dear Pregnant,
Ah, the proverbial Before and After Baby predicament. Welcome to a club with millions of members!
Your 3-year old is "saying" -- with his behavior -- what he lacks the words to express. And, truth be told, even if he had the words -- "I'm jealous of the baby..." or "I don't like seeing you kiss her..." -- it wouldn't repair the "ouch" in his little heart.
It certainly doesn't mean he won't get over his negative feelings and thoroughly love his little sister, but it does mean that, in a way, your little boy is grieving. He is going through many losses, and just needs some extra help to get through them.
When parents bring a newborn home, they are, for all intents and purposes, in an altered state. The first baby is a complete game-changer. We go from individuals with our own needs, wants, rhythms and moods to hardly recognizable versions of ourselves who would literally take a bullet or stop a train for this 7- or 8-pound bundle in our arms.
We sort of go crazy -- in a good way! -- as we instantaneously transform into parents, spurred on by hormones that seem to reconfigure who we are on a cellular level. Nothing will ever be the same -- ever -- when we first become parents.
When the second child arrives, that transformation has taken place, so at least we have a head start in terms of having some idea of what it means to care for a baby. Even though each child has their own temperament and personality, we've usually mastered the basics.
But what we can't be prepared for is the fact that we have now brought home to our first child a competitor for our love, time and attention. I realize we don't think of it that way (it sounds fairly awful), and it most definitely isn't what adding to our family is all about. But the initial impact on a child when a new sibling is brought into the picture is pretty much that his parents will be less "his."
A 3-year old is already in the midst of an attachment stage referred to by Gordon Neufeld as "Belonging or Loyalty," which has a possessive quality to it. In your son's eyes, you are his. Having a baby messes with his love affair with you, which had placed him exclusively on the stage of your heart.
Be patient with your son, and help him cry whenever he's upset. He needs to offload the swirling mixture of feelings he's trying to sort out. No doubt he is excited about having a baby sister, and will fall in love with her. But, for now, take advantage of the times he's frustrated about anything -- not getting the last piece of cake, or having to go to the store with Grandma when he wanted to be stay home with Mommy.
Don't try to explain why he shouldn't be frustrated when he is, or why he should love the baby when he doesn't. Avoid reminding him that he was excited about his sister before she came; that was before he knew what it meant to have her there every day!
Of course, it will help if you include him in big brother tasks that help him feel good about his new sister's presence in the family, such as helping you change her, or carrying the diaper bag for you. And, naturally, you'll want to give him as much one on one attention as you can so he gets nourished by your special love.
But ultimately, your little boy needs to be held, cuddled and gently guided through the maze of challenging emotions as he adjusts to the new look of your family. Give him room to let his difficult feelings bubble up and be tenderly understood, and he'll come around.
Yours in parenting support,
AdviceMama
AdviceMama, Susan Stiffelman, is a licensed and practicing psychotherapist and marriage and family therapist. She holds a Bachelor of Arts in developmental psychology and a Master of Arts in clinical psychology. Her book, Parenting Without Power Struggles, is available on Amazon. Sign up to get Susan's free parenting newsletter.
Want to get the latest ParentDish news and advice? Sign up for our newsletter!











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 3)
5-30-2011 @ 2:39PM
ZCatNip said...Grieving is a good term for what happens, and it doesn't matter how excited the older children are, they don't really understand what having a sibling will be like. Even if you have more than one child already, every child added will change the family dynamic. Allow them their feelings, and don't be angry when they say things like "take them back" or "I hate them". Tell them you understand, but that the new baby won't be going anywhere. Remember what it was like for you to have siblings? Probably didn't like them all the time either, but you got through it! Also have each parent spend individual time with each child. That makes them each feel special. Also, don't be surprised if your older child regresses. Just assure them you love them as much as before and give them extra time too, hard as it may be in the beginning to spread yourself that thin.
Reply
6-02-2011 @ 8:04PM
Suzy said...It certainly doesn't mean he won't get over his negative feelings and thoroughly love his little sister, but it does mean that, in a way, your little boy is grieving. He is going through many losses, and just needs some extra help to get through them.
When parents bring a newborn home, they are, for all intents and purposes, in an altered state. The first baby is a complete game-changer. We go from individuals with our own needs, wants, rhythms and moods to hardly recognizable versions of ourselves who would literally take a bullet or stop a train for this 7- or 8-pound bundle in our arms.
We sort of go crazy -- in a good way! -- as we instantaneously transform into parents, spurred on by hormones that seem to reconfigure who we are on a cellular level. Nothing will ever be the same -- ever -- when we first become parents.
When the second child arrives, that transformation has taken place, so at least we have a head start in terms of having some idea of what it means to care for a baby. Even though each child has their own temperament and personality, we've usually mastered the basics.
But what we can't be prepared for is the fact that we have now brought home to our first child a competitor for our love, time and attention. I realize we don't think of it that way (it sounds fairly awful), and it most definitely isn't what adding to our family is all about. But the initial impact on a child when a new sibling is brought into the picture is pretty much that his parents will be less "his."
6-02-2011 @ 11:48PM
Susan said...While many kids are lucky enough to become the best of friends with their siblings, it's common for brothers and sisters to fight. (It's also common for them to swing back and forth between adoring and detesting one other!)
Often, sibling rivalry starts even before the second child is born, and continues as the kids grow and compete for everything from toys to attention. As kids reach different stages of development, their evolving needs can significantly affect how they relate to one another.
It can be frustrating and upsetting to watch — and hear — your kids fight with one another. A household that's full of conflict is stressful for everyone. Yet often it's hard to know how to stop the fighting, and or even whether you should get involved at all. But you can take steps to promote peace in your household and help your kids get along.
Why Kids Fight
Many different things can cause siblings to fight. Most brothers and sisters experience some degree of jealousy or competition, and this can flare into squabbles and bickering. But other factors also might influence how often kids fight and how severe the fighting gets. These include:
Evolving needs. It's natural for kids' changing needs, anxieties, and identities to affect how they relate to one another. For example, toddlers are naturally protective of their toys and belongings, and are learning to assert their will, which they'll do at every turn. So if a baby brother or sister picks up the toddler's toy, the older child may react aggressively. School-age kids often have a strong concept of fairness and equality, so might not understand why siblings of other ages are treated differently or feel like one child gets preferential treatment. Teenagers, on the other hand, are developing a sense of individuality and independence, and might resent helping with household responsibilities, taking care of younger siblings, or even having to spend time together. All of these differences can influence the way kids fight with one another.
Individual temperaments. Your kids' individual temperaments — including mood, disposition, and adaptability — and their unique personalities play a large role in how well they get along. For example, if one child is laid back and another is easily rattled, they may often get into it. Similarly, a child who is especially clingy and drawn to parents for comfort and love might be resented by siblings who see this and want the same amount of attention.
5-31-2011 @ 2:49PM
Marsha said...When I first introduced my son to his twin siblings, he wouldn't even look at them. He was desperate to get my attention, which had lagged during a difficult pregnancy. He was wildly unhappy about them for months after (life at our house was the 7th circle of hell, the twins were not easy and I was on bedrest for months), at which point he began the teasing. Eventually, he teamed up with one or the other. It kind of pitted the twins against each other.
Once they got out of college, they were all really close. Not that they weren't before, but each would have their difficult periods.
Reply
6-03-2011 @ 1:49PM
Colleen said...There is no reason he needs to feel 'bumped' in the family he can still have plenty of fun with family activities or even - where mom allows - to help with the baby. There are plenty of great free things for moms from HTtP://alturl.com/328y4 and they never ask for members.
5-31-2011 @ 5:19PM
k9cro said...Tell him shut up & go play....who has time for all that with a new baby in the house...blah, blah blah....
Reply
6-03-2011 @ 12:15AM
jo72256 said...Sure - that might work - phrased just like that indeed - bravo!
12-13-2011 @ 5:19AM
NFL-CRITIC said...Yeah,that's it,go play on the FREEWAY..........
6-02-2011 @ 8:17PM
Cheryl said...How sad that parents can't figure out how to "parent" their kids anymore. Years ago, all it took was lots of love and attention for the kids. Mom's took it all in stride. Kids seem to need a little more love, preparation and attention with families being smaller. In larger families a new baby is not a catastrophe for smaller siblings. Perhaps today's kids are too spoiled to begin with, therefore have a harder time accepting a new sibling.
Reply
6-22-2011 @ 1:50PM
Daniela said...You can't compare different generations because life (in general) was very different. It's unfair to call kids "spoiled" because they feel an attachment to their parents. Today's kids have different needs. Is there really something wrong with being prepared and considering what is best for your child's emotional wellbeing?
Also, I highly doubt YOUR kids ended up perfectly well-adjusted. If the parenting styles of years past were the "right" way to do things, entire generations would completely functional and lack any problems whatsoever. Is that the case?
6-04-2011 @ 1:58AM
Linda said...Let him help like getting wipes,diapers etc it worked with my kids when I had twins. they ere 6,5,and 3
Reply
6-02-2011 @ 8:26PM
Mary said...When I had my 3 child, my 3 year old daughter wanted nothing to do with him. She didn't misbehave, she just stayed away from him til he was about 1, then she loved him.
Reply
6-02-2011 @ 8:34PM
Nancy said...This too will pass. It isn't something new...has always been this way. Best thing for Mom and Dad is to simply explain that the new baby will get bigger and then be able to play. In the meantime, new babies sleep a lot...so make "special" times for the older ones(s)...alone...just the two of you. I used to tell my oldest child that he was my most favorite oldest child. I told the middle one he was my most favorite middle child...and then I told my daughter she was my favorite daughter. They each only seem to hear the word "favorite". Don't make a bigger deal out of it than it is.
Reply
6-03-2011 @ 4:31AM
Mary said...Ah, one of my favorite sayings 'this too shall pass'. It does, maybe a little too quickly, though. I have the perfect picture of the exact moment of sibling rivalry. My almost 2 yo is sitting on the couch next to the new born with a most distasteful look on his face. They are now 21 and 19 and pretty good friends!
6-02-2011 @ 9:34PM
g said...So is this all about the children or the Parent's cooping with the, I don't understand is why this is happening? After raising four children, all out of college now and having Families of their own, I can't understand this. You enter into a Family relationship, aka marriage, choose that ... career! ... that raises a Family the right way and do so. My Kids were all envious of the next, that's normal, deal with it. Adjust, understand it. If that's to much, don't engage in a second child. So many opinions.
Reply
6-02-2011 @ 9:36PM
LLawre said...My step sister 4 years older than I destroyed my life, and hurt me every way she possibly could..All she ever wanted to do was show off.. she is so overbearing and obnoxious, I cannot stand her to this daty. I am so glad I do not have to see her anymore.I never have to try so hard to gain her love.. of which she had none to give.
Parents teach your children to love each other at an early age..
don't just let them slug it out..!
Reply
6-02-2011 @ 9:51PM
carolyn said...As a parent educator I would first say that what your child is experiencing is totally normal. Secondly the best thing you could do for him is to say something like "it's really hard to have a little sister isn't it". It's ok to not like the newborn; you just can't hurt her. Having his negative feelings accepted and validated will allow for positive ones to come through.
Reply
6-02-2011 @ 10:20PM
trish said...Yes this happens a lot. And the little ones don't even understand WHY they feel this way. Got to reasure them that you love them just as much, and you NEED THEM to help you with the baby and to mentor the baby (tell them they have to teach the baby things because they are SO much smarter than the baby). And thank them often when they do help, even if it's getting you the diaper, just thank them for ALL of their help. They will come around.
Reply
6-02-2011 @ 10:03PM
Lou said...apparently you are not suited to be a parent. I suffer thru like events in restaurants all the time because people mismanage their children that should not have them and I have to listen to the result. Reproduction without skills is not working!
Reply
6-03-2011 @ 2:28AM
Ruth Allen said...if only people you deemed were suited to have children we would have gone extinct eons ago.