Hot on HuffPost Parents:
27 Fantastic Books For Kids Of All Ages
Mike Ryan: Ben Affleck Bids Bill Hader & Fred Armisen A Fond Farewell
Tough Safety Standards For Cribs Going Into Effect
Filed under: In The News
This undated image provided by the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) shows a drop-side crib. Credit: AP
Ushering in one of the most significant changes in child safety in decades, the rule taking effect this week bans the manufacture, sale and resale of drop-side cribs. Drop-sides have a side rail that can be raised and lowered to allow parents to more easily place or lift a baby, but they have been blamed in the deaths of several dozen children.
Another significant part of the new federal standard mandates more rigorous safety tests for children's cribs before they hit the market. In the past, manufacturers were allowed to retighten screws and bolts on a crib in the middle of hardware testing meant to mimic how a child might rattle a crib - by jumping up and down or shaking a rail.
While the tests were intended to simulate a toddler in a crib, they don't mimic the reality of the parent. It's a rare parent who would know when to retighten obscure pieces of hardware on a crib during normal use by a child.
The retightening of screws and bolts during durability tests on cribs ends Tuesday, as part of the new rule approved last year by the Consumer Product Safety Commission. Stronger mattress support systems and crib slats are also a major part of the new testing.
"After 30 years of having outdated standards, CPSC delivered on its promise and created the toughest crib safety standards in the world," Commission Chairman Inez Tenenbaum told The Associated Press. "Parents can now shop for a crib with confidence."
New cribs on the market won't really look different other than the obvious absence of a movable side that drops down. Now, all four sides will be fixed and the cribs should be sturdier because of the tougher testing requirements.
Drop-side cribs have been around for decades. But they have increasingly come under scrutiny in recent years because of malfunctioning hardware, sometimes cheaper plastics, or assembly problems that can lead to the drop-side rail partially detaching. That can create a dangerous "V''-like gap with the mattress in which a baby can get caught and suffocate.
Drop-sides are blamed in the deaths of more than 30 infants and toddlers since 2000 and suspected in about a dozen other infant fatalities. Since 2007, more than 9 million drop-sides have been recalled including cribs from Evenflo and Pottery Barn Kids.
The end of drop-side cribs marks a long-awaited day for Susan Cirigliano, who lost her 6-month-old son, Bobby, when his drop-side slid off the tracks in 2004, trapping his head and neck between the mattress and the malfunctioning side rail. He suffocated.
"It's bittersweet. It is not going to change my life as far as what has already happened to us," said Cirigliano, who lives in North Bellmore on New York's Long Island. "But hopefully, it will save many more children. I am sure it will."
While drop-side cribs will no longer be made or sold, they are still being used in homes across the nation. The industry says drop-sides that haven't been recalled can be used safely as long as they are properly assembled and maintained to the manufacturer's instructions. Manufacturers do not recommend using cribs that are more than 10 years old.
Industry officials say a healthy supply of new cribs awaits shoppers.
"Our members are currently selling cribs that meet the new federal standard and parents will continue to enjoy a large selection of cribs in a range of price points," said Michael Dwyer, executive director of the Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association, a trade group that represents about 90 percent of the crib industry.
A new crib can cost from about $120 to more than $700, with about 2.4 million of them sold each year.
While manufacturers have been making cribs to the new standard for months, some retailers still have cribs in stock that will be banned on Tuesday. One estimate suggests more than 100,000 noncompliant cribs costing more than $30 million in lost sales.
The two Republican commissioners at the CPSC tried this month to secure an extension for dozens of retailers, many of them smaller ones, to allow them at least a few more months to sell their inventory.
"I would have liked to have seen a three-month grace period for retailers," Republican Commissioner Anne Northup said in an AP interview. "We should have staggered it so that if we allow manufacturers to deliver up until June 28th, we should have allowed retailers a certain amount of time for them to sell what was legal."
The three Democrats on the commission, however, blocked an extension.
The agency is allowing daycare centers, hotels and companies that rent cribs additional time to comply - until Dec. 28, 2012, before they need to purchase cribs that meet the new safety standards.
Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. The information contained in the AP news report may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or otherwise distributed without the prior written authority of The Associated Press. This article was written by Jennifer C. Kerr, Associated Press. All active hyperlinks have been inserted by AOL.
Want to get the latest ParentDish news and advice? Sign up for our newsletter!











ReaderComments (Page 1 of 2)
6-28-2011 @ 2:17PM
Rachel said...Wonder what the government is going to do when moms and dads start dropping babies on the floor because they couldn't get a firm grip with the side of the crib in the way?
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 2:58PM
Opion8ed said...I agree with you. I am short and can barely get my grandson to the mattress. Standing on a stool isn't very safe either. I wish they would think out these things before they pass legislation.
6-28-2011 @ 3:22PM
M. Wilson said...Why dont they tell the parents that if they bolt them solid where sides cant move they wouldnt have to discard and buy new.The manufacturers probably love this, look at all the new sales
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 3:31PM
Wendy said...Because an awful lot of parents (especially first-timers) don't want their "precious" in second-hand furniture. Also, the dropping side won't have enough wood in the area where it would have to join the reast of the crib to support enough hardware. Getting around it would probably be kludgy enough to turn off most buyers.
6-28-2011 @ 3:20PM
grandmama2three said...Is it just me or does anybody else wonder why civilization didn't stop eons ago? There are so many dangers and babies slept with parents when they out grew the only infant device which was a cradle. On and on we go. I had 3 and they were all tummy sleepers. Gasp! Why wasn't I told they might suffer from SIDS. I'm not making light of SIDS. It's a tragic loss but I don't think sleeping on it's tummy makes it stop breating. One of mine flailed his arms around and cried when I put him on his back. When they became about 3 months old, it didn't matter where I put them, they'd flip to their tummy's immediately.
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 4:25PM
ED said...We were all too stupid to realize how stupid we were. Thank God that the government figured out that they could create many agencies to help educate us and give their friends and relatives jobs at the same time.
6-28-2011 @ 8:43PM
AFWife807 said...How true! I was raised by my Grandmother, who also raised two children of her own and three adopted. The stuff she tells me about how children were raised, and the stuff I remember from my child hood..according to standards today none of us should be alive today! We were well taken care of, spoiled in many senses, and all alive today!
6-28-2011 @ 3:24PM
Wendy said...How typical. Greedy managers take shortcuts in manufacturing quality, and instead of weeding out the bad apples, they ban the whole design. Wait, not the whole design. The whole CONCEPT of drop-side cribs. There are lots of ways to design a drop-down crib, but because the most popular way is vulnerable to failure, they ban all types without letting manufactuers switch to a more resilient design.
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 4:26PM
chadwick said...how true
I raised 4 healthy bottle fed babies Used that plastic car seat, the very best (tee hee)
Did what most mothers do, Went by the skin of my teeth, they all grew up!!!!
6-29-2011 @ 2:43AM
Mitchell said...In a recent year, it was reported that 167 baby deaths occurrec when sleeping with parents and were suffocated. That same year, 2 deaths occurred in cribs. Government thinking is that the 2 deaths matter more because they can force a recall on a product.
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 5:33PM
HHF34 said...150 kids out of how many born during that time... How many were killed in car crashes... How many were killed because of being left alone in the tub... How many were killed from allergies... etc. etc. Personally, there is no way that I'm going to purchase another crib for baby #2, and I fully plan to use the drop down side option. For those who argue that the new ones are cheap, well, if you've got money laying around to use for that, go ahead, stimulate the economy. This ranks right up there with requiring more energy efficient lightbulbs that are more expensive, more harmful for the environment when they stop working or break than the good old incandescent lightbulbs which it is safe to throw in the trash, not so much for mercury bulbs..
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 5:15PM
rdc said...Ok some of you people are crazy. if everybody thought this way there would not be seatbelts in cars, testing for lead in childrens toys, higher saftey measures in factorys or even smoke detectors. Just because you were lucky to have children survive, there have been familys not so lucky! so because its not convenient for you to not have a drop side crib everybody should take their chances huh? Makes alot of sence to me!
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 5:43PM
Squiggles said...I had two different models of drop-side cribs. Fortunately none of them ever caused problems for my children. I am still left wondering about how the new type works. Can the mattress be raised or lowered for ease of putting the baby in? I would hate a design that had the mattress all the way down with no way of raising it. And lastly, can these new cribs be converted into toddler beds?
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 8:30PM
Kristen W said...Well, I already knew this and faced the music when purchasing a crib for my second Daughter who was born in October of 2010. I had the drop side for my first born and it was very convenient considering I stand at 5'0 on a good day. When I got pregnant the second time I figured "heh just go to the store and get one similar to the first" since I had given the first to a friend in need years before. Imagine my surprise when I looked all over Northern California for a drop side, only to be told they were no longer allowed to be sold.
I ended up purchasing a beautiful crib, that looks fantastic in her nursery. However, it is not a drop side and I face a struggle every time trying to get her in and out of it. The side of it comes up to my armpit level, so reaching into this thing is difficult to say the least. I end up standing on my tip toes and straining to get baby out.
There could have been safety precautions and a re-vamp of the drop side crib to accommodate mothers such as myself who are not pushing 6'0.
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 6:05PM
fatlady said...We should go back to the days when we had a METAL rod in the drop side instead of PLASTIC. They never came off the track then. I used them before and will use them in the future. This expensive crap they are dcoming out with is just a gimmick to get your money.
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 6:31PM
Amanda said...I agree wholeheartedly! Drop-side cribs have been around for GENERATIONS, but the problems didn't start until they started manufacturing parts out of cheap plastic instead of the metal of old. Instead of increasing safety and manufacturing standards, they're just banning them outright with no regard for those who are of short stature, recovering from C-sections, or anything like that. I'm only 5'3", and if I had had to use a fixed-side crib instead of a drop-side crib, I'd have found it impossible to get my kids out, especially right after childbirth! Instead of applying common sense, the Safety Police are shooting off a cannon to kill a flea! Stupid.
6-28-2011 @ 6:26PM
bryan said...never had a problem with my drop side crib i know hao to use it and keep all the bolts tight i will keep using it don't care what they say its great
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 6:49PM
Vicki said...I agree with HHF34 above. Millions and millions of kids were raised safely in drop-side cribs. The problem with them began when cribs started being imported from China. Their knock-offs have ruined lots of previously-quality items. Because the imports weren't well-made and a few unfortunate babies sadly got stuck, now everyone has to suffer with breaking their backs over those stationary sides. Yes, the standards should have been raised so the accidents were prevented. Instead, the government has once again stuck its nose into consumers' choices. At present, I cannot think of one area of our lives where our government hasn't implemented rules and regulations......it has happened gradually, but do people realize it is now endemic? America: the land of the free? The only thing free about it is for the 51% of the population who lives off it.
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 8:57PM
Dave said...I agree with Vicki's comment about cheap cribs being made in China I get E-mails from CPSC almost every day and most of the recalls are products made in China. It's time to bring the jobs back to the USA where we have more control of the products.
Reply
6-28-2011 @ 7:48PM
sherry said...Another thing that the government has to take control over..... what happen to the right for us to make our choice in the matter. I am educated enough to make a decision without the government to mandate it for me. My kids are grown and all was raised in drop down cribs.... I have grand kids now, and all 4 have slept in the drop down cribs. What happened to the parents checking on the kids during the night ??? I still check on my grown kids while they sleep during the night and my grand kids. Guess I was raised in the generation that was brought up that was what we was suppose to do. Our youngest grandson is 22 months old and my husband and I both enjoy just watching him as he sleeps. The joy the kids and grand kids have brought to us is more than words can describe. We camp and boat with our kids and grand kids and also do that safely too. I am 47 years old, and my mother still can not believe all the new gadgets out there now for new mothers and babies. She raised 3 of us, and there was no car seat then. She held us on her lap. My youngest son is 21 years old, and I still can not believe some of the new items that is out there for the new mothers and babies. Please tell me how there is any of us around with all the NO NO's that we did as mom's back when we raised our children !!!
Reply